To be fair to the man, the B-36s status in the winter of 1950/51 was still more theoretical than real. The bugs were massively crippling and even leaving aside the problems with the plane in particular, overall SAC was still in the process of shaking off the issues that had plagued it. By '53, though, it was a fairly mature technology... but then so was the legion of Soviet of MiG-15s and 17s which could counter it.Did Turtledove ever say how he managed to forget the existence of the B-36?
I don't disagree, ultimately, that the book's research makes a very poor presentation of how a Third World War in the winter of '50/'51. The Red Army is far less successful than it actually would have been while Soviet strategic nuclear forces are far more successful than they ever could have been at the time. Not to mention the deus ex machina uprising of Eastern Europe, which was not at all organized in the early-50s to launch a major ruprising movement and would have massive Soviet reinforcments constantly streaming through it toward the frontlines on hand to crush any such attempt...
Last edited: