Pick your poison:


  • Total voters
    329
  • Poll closed .
They would use nukes to stop it, but if the Russians reach close to Moscow it would still be a very clear sign of weakness.

Thinking about it, if the Russians succeed in recovering their land after the fall of the Nazi Empire, they are going to have a massive national liberation narrative. Something in the lines of "not even nuclear fire managed to stop us". But if the Germans keep hitting them with nukes they may well run out of men to fight, considering their population is really down. At least they are recovering a little bit of land so their population should have at least some plus to compensate for the minus.
We aren't talking about tactical nukes, the Germans will turn everything from Kazan to Vladivostok into a radioactive wasteland before accepting a loss to the Russians. And considering it's Generalplan Ost we are talking about, they won't have much of a population to liberate.

One other thing, the younger generation, even of slavs, who grow in Moscowien, is being raised to not see themselves as Russians. Artificial identities based around old principalities and cultures are being shoved downthroat by the German-controlled education system. Even if they still learn the Russian language, there are very accentuated differences through dialects being artificially inflated. The SSK has been attempting to implement Stockholm Syndrome in a continental scale over the last 20 years while turning the ethnic groups in hatred of one another in the way their camp system work in a divide and conquer tactic.
 
We aren't talking about tactical nukes, the Germans will turn everything from Kazan to Vladivostok into a radioactive wasteland before accepting a loss to the Russians. And considering it's Generalplan Ost we are talking about, they won't have much of a population to liberate.

One other thing, the younger generation, even of slavs, who grow in Moscowien, is being raised to not see themselves as Russians. Artificial identities based around old principalities and cultures are being shoved downthroat by the German-controlled education system. Even if they still learn the Russian language, there are very accentuated differences through dialects being artificially inflated. The SSK has been attempting to implement Stockholm Syndrome in a continental scale over the last 20 years while turning the ethnic groups in hatred of one another in the way their camp system work in a divide and conquer tactic.
Do you intent on making Germany win at the end? Or you are merely saying that Germany will have to collapse from the inside before the Russians can recover their land?
 
I wouldn't put that much credit on the Russians being able to launch such ambitious operations. Yes they are getting stronger but so are the Germans, especially without Wegener and Heydrich driving an interservice war between the Waffen SS and the Wehrmacht. The German army still is overall the most powerful military force in the world and everything had to go wrong for yhe Wehrmacht's initial offensive to fail. I wouldn't bet on them going far beyond the Volga because after that it's attacking German Territory.
I am not suggesting going beyond the Volga but along it. Samarra is already on the banks of the Volga, so I was just saying that they can possibly reach the river in the south as well all the way to the Caspian Sea. I am not suggesting that they cross the river, which would be like putting your hand into a shark's mouth.
As for Iran, they are allied with Damascus, but as you may expect the Indians are not very eager to allow the Shah and Hess to continue their push after taking Iraq. If the two had their way, the world's biggest suppliers of oil would be under Germania's control, there is an incredible amount of soft power the two powers can project and Kuwait is part of the Greater Syria plan. India and Israel have a shared enemy, but the Indians can only go so far in supporting the Jews without alienating their own Muslim population (as you may expect, an unpartitioned India has to take care to not push against Islam too hard to not cause an explosion in sectarian violence). India's greatest hindrance here isn't the "Red Raj" (Nehru wouldn't be stupid enough to follow the Soviet model after Stalin crashed and burned in the most spectacular fashion), but to keep the fine thread of opposing growing Arab and Islamic movements without alienating their own substantial population.
But the Gulf States while technically being the protectorates of UK are economically integrated into India with them using the Indian currency. The OTL GCC countries are significant trade partners of India of the time and would likely soon host large Indian populations. India need not justify taking action to the Indian Muslims as it can be easily portrayed as protecting their fellow Muslims from the Nazi inspired states. And as far as Indian Muslims are concerned most can likely fall behind that line of reasoning. Imperial Iran in spite of being Nazi aligned would likely still have far better relations with India, who is their direct neighbour and Nehru and others made efforts to have good relations with them.

Militarily intervening without an attack on the Gulf States or India itself is not politically feasible but if the War spills over it becomes very likely that the Indians will intervene. As the British are more and more concerned with the European Matters, especially as the Royal Navy needs to fend off against the ever growing Kreigsmarine, it is very likely that the military protection duties of the Gulf States will be inherited by India, when coupled with the fact that they are economically tied to India, it will be very hard for India to not get involved when the Gulf is under threat. The threat of German submarines in Goa has been averted but if it instead mans that they would come from the Persian Gulf one day, it doesn't make it any better. Iran, being bordered by both Russia and India and even economically and diplomatically tied to them to some extent wil likely not allow U-boats based from its territory but on the other hand Syria hosting U-boats in Basra will probably warrant a military response preemptively to close down the Shatt al Arab or at the very least the concentration of the Indian Naval and Air assets in the Gulf but fortunately for the Allies large Oil Producers such as Venezuela, Malaysia and Indonesia are far away from the reach of Linz Pakt and by building long pipelines, the oil in the OTL GCC nations can be accessed too. With Italy nearly breaking off with Germany, Syria remains the last place from which Germany can dare to threaten Asia.
Right now, Kaufmann has a good chance of becoming the leader if Hess dies (or even if he doesn't die and the leadership just collectively decides to put him in a mental hospice). But Speer and Goebbels are the big players for now. Speer has an edge on Goebbels in the back of the big players, but Goebbels is THE public face of the Reich, a far better public speaker, and the population is quite on the edge for the moment so the sooner Hess is out, the more momentum Goebbels has.
That's all good but who will now take over as the new Reichfuhrer-SS?
Mussolini is close to death so you will have to discuss that with the new Duce.
Only Mussolini can be Duce and calling yourself that is disrespecting the Duce like Hess was a disgrace to the title of Fuhrer. Stick to Prime Minister. 🙃

As far as Italy cutting ties is concerned, I guess that Greece and Albania are firmly in the Italian Sphere of Influence and as far as Ustase Croatia is concerned, it was like a joint puppet with both Germany and Italy occupying it, so in whose sphere would they fall. Hungary and Serbia would be firmly within the German camp, well Hungary may hove some inclinations towards the Italians as they helped them get Transylvania, the same reason which would make the Romanians hate the Italians. The animosity between the Bulgarians and the Romanians likely mean that the Bulgarians can also possibly remain in the Italian bloc. The biggest coup would be if the French begin to play a game of balance between Italy and Germany.

Do the Hungarian Jews protected by Admiral Horthy still exist as there was no invasion by the Reich?

The Asian powers have collaborated on a joint military invasion, so is there any chance of them collaborating on bigger things like a regional organisation on the line of the Organisation for African Unity OTL and possibly even a joint Nuclear Weapon program to shield themselves?
 
Absolutley loved the Update! My favorite was probably the Duel between von Manstein and Schörner. Also nice to see that the Monster in Uniform has met his deserved end. The guy sent 1000s of Soldiers of the Wehrmacht needlessly to their death, so him getting killed by a Soldier of said Army is kind of poetic...
 
i just hope this doesnt grow into the vastly overdone "Germany goes the way of the soviet Union" scenarios like 99% of these scenarios do. For Italy i wonder who will succeed Mussolini
 
i just hope this doesnt grow into the vastly overdone "Germany goes the way of the soviet Union" scenarios like 99% of these scenarios do. For Italy i wonder who will succeed Mussolini
Wegener's demise cut that from it's roots, otherwise it is likely that Germany would be ruled by a corrupt and decentralized party bureaucracy that grows more decadent and arbitrary by the year (I mean, most of the Gauleiters were already like that, but they won't be even more empowered). Speer wants a stronger centralized and active state in cooperation with industrial sectors, while Goebbels want a more active and personalistic regime centered around charisma, neither of these are like the Soviets and the Nazis can be far more flexible on macroeconomics than the USSR was.
 
I am not suggesting going beyond the Volga but along it. Samarra is already on the banks of the Volga, so I was just saying that they can possibly reach the river in the south as well all the way to the Caspian Sea. I am not suggesting that they cross the river, which would be like putting your hand into a shark's mouth.

But the Gulf States while technically being the protectorates of UK are economically integrated into India with them using the Indian currency. The OTL GCC countries are significant trade partners of India of the time and would likely soon host large Indian populations. India need not justify taking action to the Indian Muslims as it can be easily portrayed as protecting their fellow Muslims from the Nazi inspired states. And as far as Indian Muslims are concerned most can likely fall behind that line of reasoning. Imperial Iran in spite of being Nazi aligned would likely still have far better relations with India, who is their direct neighbour and Nehru and others made efforts to have good relations with them.

Militarily intervening without an attack on the Gulf States or India itself is not politically feasible but if the War spills over it becomes very likely that the Indians will intervene. As the British are more and more concerned with the European Matters, especially as the Royal Navy needs to fend off against the ever growing Kreigsmarine, it is very likely that the military protection duties of the Gulf States will be inherited by India, when coupled with the fact that they are economically tied to India, it will be very hard for India to not get involved when the Gulf is under threat. The threat of German submarines in Goa has been averted but if it instead mans that they would come from the Persian Gulf one day, it doesn't make it any better. Iran, being bordered by both Russia and India and even economically and diplomatically tied to them to some extent wil likely not allow U-boats based from its territory but on the other hand Syria hosting U-boats in Basra will probably warrant a military response preemptively to close down the Shatt al Arab or at the very least the concentration of the Indian Naval and Air assets in the Gulf but fortunately for the Allies large Oil Producers such as Venezuela, Malaysia and Indonesia are far away from the reach of Linz Pakt and by building long pipelines, the oil in the OTL GCC nations can be accessed too. With Italy nearly breaking off with Germany, Syria remains the last place from which Germany can dare to threaten Asia.

That's all good but who will now take over as the new Reichfuhrer-SS?

Only Mussolini can be Duce and calling yourself that is disrespecting the Duce like Hess was a disgrace to the title of Fuhrer. Stick to Prime Minister. 🙃

As far as Italy cutting ties is concerned, I guess that Greece and Albania are firmly in the Italian Sphere of Influence and as far as Ustase Croatia is concerned, it was like a joint puppet with both Germany and Italy occupying it, so in whose sphere would they fall. Hungary and Serbia would be firmly within the German camp, well Hungary may hove some inclinations towards the Italians as they helped them get Transylvania, the same reason which would make the Romanians hate the Italians. The animosity between the Bulgarians and the Romanians likely mean that the Bulgarians can also possibly remain in the Italian bloc. The biggest coup would be if the French begin to play a game of balance between Italy and Germany.

Do the Hungarian Jews protected by Admiral Horthy still exist as there was no invasion by the Reich?

The Asian powers have collaborated on a joint military invasion, so is there any chance of them collaborating on bigger things like a regional organisation on the line of the Organisation for African Unity OTL and possibly even a joint Nuclear Weapon program to shield themselves?
The SSK will not stay as powerful as it is, Heydrich centralized too many functions in himself that made him dangerous. As for who it will be, that will be whoever can slip a paper in Ruddy's room and get his signature.

More likely that the Fascists get rid of Umberto before calling themselves Prime Ministers again.

I am afraid what happened in the Balkans prevents this from materializing, after the War Hitler made sure to make all the countries tow the line, he did not need any more pragmatic alliances with local strongmen like Horthy and Antonescu, the Arrow Cross and Iron Guard rule these countries under firm control of Germany, the only one who could get away was Simeon in Bulgaria because his regency was commanded by Lukov and so is his current government. Why that was done? Exactly for the kind of reason you may expect, after destroying the Soviets, Hitler sped up the Final Solution as he considered the Jews as the only threat to the Reich, when the governments refused to turn over their Jewish populations they were overthrown. Sure, most of those who realized there was no more hope of an allied return left Europe after the Treaty of London, like Anne Frank's Family, but those who remained were not protected by their local rulers because they did not last long.

You know we are still talking about Maoist China, right? The same ones who sponsored a proxy war in Korea for much of the decade and are an inch away from invading Mongolia? India and China are not going to make a joint nuclear program because that is a very good way to make sure Long and the West will want nothing to do with you, American companies have very harsh penalties for engaging in commerce with "Unfriendly Nations" due to the American Protection Act, making a shared nuclear program and organization with their Number 2 (or Number 1 to some yankees) enemies is a good way to make sure all those foreign investors will jump at the first ship to not have their assets seized by Washington.
 
Wow. A truly impressive chapter. A lot happened.
Speer himself subtly admitted during a meeting of the two that he was sabotaging the Reich's effort in the Ostkrie
Seems a bit odd he'd just out and say this, even subtly.
Yes, the Youth was the key, they were the torchbearers once and had to be again, a new revolution to rid the party of it's impurity and weakness, he had seen them in action when destroying the foreign structure of the Catholic Church
This has real Cultural Revolution energy
After he was taken away, nobody had ever come to see Paul Wegener again, much like Heinrich Himmler and other high-ranking figures he would disappear, with the claim that he had escaped only to be treacherously killed by "Zionist agents
Seems like they could have just said he was guilty and executed him?
Heydrich did not die immediately, in fact he crawled out of the car and attempted to fire back at the assassins as he could swear one of them shouted "Nakam", the Jewish word of vengeance, and as the adrenaline came down he realized his chest was bleeding.
HA! Couldn't have happened to a nicer Nazi.
 
Wow. A truly impressive chapter. A lot happened.

Seems a bit odd he'd just out and say this, even subtly.

This has real Cultural Revolution energy

Seems like they could have just said he was guilty and executed him?

HA! Couldn't have happened to a nicer Nazi.
That was Goebbels' point of view in the Chapter, Speer is the kind of man who can say anything to be on the winning side so Goebbels took that and it led to him thinking that Speer was on his side from the start.

Yes, Goebbels is the one who comes the closest to being a Maoist here.

A lengthy trial of a powerful political figure who could get many allies to stand with him is not something the putschists want, besides they don't need a trial, Hess declared him guilty and the Führer's word has a weight above any law for German jurists. And nobody needs his corpse as a martyr, he was sent to a Camp, or that is what the Senate was told, but the whole process was prepared by Heydrich.

Makes you think, were they really Jewish agents or did they only speak that to spite Heydrich in his last moments? Or perhaps it wasn't even the Mossad, Heydrich had plenty of enemies and a lax security, his assassins were never caught and there would be benefit if any onlookers just thought they were Jews, it certainly helps the leadership to ramp up the people's paranoia.
 
Just a recommendation, trying to completely understand the organization and competences of all the German Intelligence, Police, Secret Police and Paramilitary agencies is not good for your migraine.
 
I would want that, but I have another question: how much of Iraq was annexed by the Syrians when they invaded in the last chapter? And how much of Iraq was given over to the Iranians?
Iran did not annex much territory, but they critically took a large part of the Iraqi Kurdistan including Mosul. The Syrians have taken Basra which is critical for commerce considering how Nasser controls the Suez.
 
Albert Speer represents to the Reich a "rationalization" from the current predicament, contrasting with Wegener and the Party's efforts and with Goebbels' populistic approach. The Elites within the German state, from bureaucrats, ministers, industrials, corporative leaders and economists have their favorite in the Architect, a man who achieved great power by approaching Hitler as a friend, an appreciator of the arts and a man who made his visions into reality. The Volkshalle, the Führermuseum, the renovation of cities like Berlin and Hamburg, the project of Linz and of several eastern settlements, the expansion of the railroad network, all of that is credited to him. He is good at taking credit and the benefits of others' ideas, but the man himself is not without intelligence, showing the personality of a pragmatic and intelligent leader. However this all hides the true nature of his powers, he is the man responsible for the German Economy as both Minister of Economy and Minister of Production, alongside his contacts achieved thanks to the influence these ministeries gave him. He is the man responsible for the "Foreign Worker's Program", initially made as a wartime measure that consolidated itself into a trap, where millions were forced to work at low wages, treated like slaves through long work hours in terrible conditions. Poles, Ukrainians, Russians, Belarussians, all the conquered peoples and even those attracted by it's false promises in the Reich's satellite states, they are used as tools by the almighty Minister, who diverts them like numbers in return for favors to some of the largest companies in the world. His partnership with the SS long allowed him to use the labor of the concentration camps to his advantage, with enough loopholes those people could be used as little more than slaves by the Reich. No doubt a victory of Speer in this coming struggle was something he has been awaiting for years, resisting Wegener's push for partification, Heydrich's security state and now Goebbels and his masses, he will prevail just as he outlasted the others, ensuring that the Reich of a Thousand Years will divert to a more rational and streamlined path on the world stage.

Joseph Goebbels is hardly the man that the Reich's propaganda praises as the greatest race of them all, a man from the Rhineland who grew up to be a doctor in literature and now ended up as the voice of the most feared regime on Earth. Goebbels has been the voice and face of the party for years, something that only intensified as Hitler began to avoid the public due to his deteriorating physical health, and Hess did the same over his mental health. Goebbels, a true "Social Nationalist" from the beginning, is the living hypocrisy that goes against many of the values of the Reich even faithfulness. But nobody denies that he is a man true to his obsession with Hitler and his Legacy, and the people love him for it, they see him as the spokesman, an outsider to the corrupt bureaucracy that had taken over Germania, stagnating the economy and plunging Germany into a war that risks the conquests so hardly acquired by Hitler. A victory for Goebbels means a victory of this Hitlerist vision that he has in his mind, it means the victory of the German Volk against the shackles of it's enemies, a return to the dynamism and fervor of the early party days when the SA marched on the streets with brown shirts and enacted the Führer's will. A victory of Goebbels means a return to this old way, to use the fire that once burned the enemies of Germany to do so again from within, cleaning it from the vile kleptocracy and oligarchy, from the party elitism and from the whims of a weak leader.
 
Top