Status
Not open for further replies.
Wouldn't have the gold run across the whole flag. The white fimbrations for the red stripe is taken directly from the Kenyan flag, while the gold fimbrations for the black stripe are taken directly from the 1961-1964 Tanganyikan independence flag. The entire flag is done on the same principle as the Flag of Tanzania which merged the patterns of the Tanganyikan flag and the Zanzibari flag. So if the gold ran across the whole flag then component formed from Kenya's flag would be too far reduced I think to have been plausibly acceptable to Kenya in 1963. For the same reason, the green and blue are the shades that they are (though they would probably be darkened in truth when the flag was being prepared or perhaps a year or two after). Mirroring the gold on the shield though....hmmm...I like that..

So like so?
Better.
Still looks a bit half and half than a proper union.
 
A super simple flag design proposal for the Alabama state flag. The blue bars stand both for the Tombigee and Chatahoochee Rivers on the eastern and western edges of the state, as well as the South in general (s. the historic Bonnie Blue flag of West Florida). The camellia in the center is of course the state flower of Alabama.

I like it better than the current one.
 
I've got a flag for a commie East Prussia (it's a scenario where Russia doesn't force the Germans out of Kaliningrad and instead has East Prussia become a Soviet puppet.
View attachment 373875
The red stands for the socialist revolution, while black and white have been associated with the area historically. It also uses a modified East German coat of arms and the writing is German for "solidarity, equality, bread"

If the East Prussians (you) are going to have a slogan in German on the flag, it should probably be in Fraktur.
 
I prefer option 2. The vertical white line on the shield of option 1 is distracting. Geometrically you have an X over three horizontal stripes, which is fine, but then a vertical line on top of that which doesn't really flow into anything. Both look good, but it's hard to unsee that line. On the second option, the white mimics the spear shape, which make the shield and spears complimentary and not just a random object placed in front.

I propose to remove the implied line between the two ovaloids altogether--simply make them a solid white.

Have the gold run across the whole flag else mirror it on the shield, and darken the green and blue a tad.

Better.
Still looks a bit half and half than a proper union.

Okay, played around with them a bit more, and taking into account all of these suggestions and notes, I darkened the green to a shade between that of Kenya's green and Tanganyika's green and had the gold run across the whole of the flag at the top, while having the white run across the whole of the flag at the bottom. I kept the ovaloid shapes in the shield in one version and had them solid white (as per Suvareshkin's suggestion) in another. Here are the results:


Flag A

tanzanikenya or rump east africa minus uganda flag X resized.png



Flag B

tanzanikenya or rump east africa minus uganda flag XI resized.png
 
Still has the half and half problem.
What's needed is a striped flag that a non kenyan coloured shield can be placed over.
Otherwise it looks bipartite, like Austria-Hungary, rather than a union of several countries.
Using the same stripe pattern I'd say the colours should be blue white green white red (or v.v.) with the shield green black and gold.
 
flag_of_new_afrika_by_federalrepublic-dc5dp7j.png


Seems like I'm currently going through a flag phase again. This is my own version of a flag for New Afrika or an equivalent state. The broken shackles stand for Black liberation, the colors are of course Pan-African. Pretty straight-forward.
 
Last edited:
Nice work, but i have noticed that you used the Imperial flag of Germany on a Communist German flag; so i recommend you change it to either a new design or the Black, Red and Yellow of the Federal Republic of Germany
 
Nice work, but i have noticed that you used the Imperial flag of Germany on a Communist German flag; so i recommend you change it to either a new design or the Black, Red and Yellow of the Federal Republic of Germany

That would just be OTL east germany. The “imperial” flag makes sense as it’s the Prussian and Hanseatic colors combined
 
Per a scenario described in the map thread, here's two flags I cooked up:

9OMXwpk.png

Flag of the German Democratic Republic

N7HU5l9.png

Flag of the Danubian People's Republic

Nice work, but i have noticed that you used the Imperial flag of Germany on a Communist German flag; so i recommend you change it to either a new design or the Black, Red and Yellow of the Federal Republic of Germany

As pretty as the Communist German flag is, @Atlantisa Guard is right. Reusing the imperial flag would not fly for the communists.

That said, here's your regularly scheduled DDR.

 
Nice work, but i have noticed that you used the Imperial flag of Germany on a Communist German flag; so i recommend you change it to either a new design or the Black, Red and Yellow of the Federal Republic of Germany

If you had an early enough POD you could have the black white red tricolour as the German flag and thus a communist flag might use it. This would have to be in the early 19th century though.
 
Yeah - using items reminiscent of the Austro-Hungarian flag also wouldn't work theoretically for a communist regime, but admittedly the map/flags and scenario are more "semi-plausible rule of cool" material than anything else. I think the red/white/black combination being not welcome has to do more with the Nazi flag's use of the colors rather than the original German Imperial flag - again, which was little more than a combination of the Hanseatic and Prussian colors.
 
I'm trying to think of a post-PRC flag for China. The yellow stars orbiting the star of the Communist Party is problematic, but I'm not sure of a good way to get rid of it - a single white star is underwhelming.

VpbyvdB.png


vJo2TLr.png


Two proposed flags for the Federal Republic of China
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top