In this update, the presidential debates between John Glenn and Paul Laxalt occur, as well as the vice presidential debate between Lloyd Bentsen and Bob Dole; the New York Mets make a run at the World Series, two years earlier than OTL (1986); President Reagan promises to meet Soviet premier Gorbachev before he leaves office, with a summit in Reykjavik scheduled for December, and more Starfleet Intelligence episodes. The only article in this update is going to be the Reagan-Gorbachev announcement. The rest will be written as a narrative.
Doc Gooden in 1984, winning the National League Rookie of the Year
Recollections from the New York Mets postseason run in 1984:
Frank Cashen (Mets general manager): We acquired Gary Carter from the Montreal Expos at the trade deadline because for the first time in a decade, we were contenders for the National League East. Carter immediately galvanized the team, and pranked a few of his teammates in the process with the Spock ears. He hit 10 home runs and drove in 42 runs in August and September, and we made up a six game deficit on the Chicago Cubs. We got the pennant race to the last day of the season, where we were tied with the Cubs. We were losing 5-4 in the ninth inning, and the Cubs were winning, so we needed a moment of magic. The Expos had Jeff Reardon, one of baseball's best relievers, out there to end our season. Keith Hernandez singled with two outs in the ninth. Then Carter hit a towering home run to center field, and our pennant dreams stayed alive. We won 6-5, and forced a one game playoff against the Cubs at Shea Stadium. The team carried the momentum from there, all the way to the World Series.
Dwight "Doc" Gooden: I was the best pitcher in baseball in 1984, as a rookie. Nobody could hit my curveball. I almost felt helpless when we were losing to the Expos on the final Sunday of the season, but when we took the lead on Carter's home run, Davey Johnson, my manager, sent me out there to pitch the bottom of the ninth. I gave up a single but struck out two and we won that game. Then I was scheduled to start the one game playoff against the Cubs. They had an imposing lineup. Ryne Sandberg was the MVP of the league, and Gary Matthews could intimidate a young pitcher. But I was fearless. Having the home crowd behind you is such a rush. They give you an extra two to three miles on your fastball. I struck out Bob Dernier, Sandberg, and Matthews in the first inning. The crowd was roaring on every pitch. There's nothing like a playoff crowd in New York in October. Keith homered in the first inning and said, "You've got your run." Darryl Strawberry homered later on and told me, "this game is over." We won 2-0, and I struck out fifteen Cubs. The back page headlines called me "the next Tom Seaver," and even Vin Scully called me that on the TV broadcast.
Darryl Strawberry: We then faced the Padres in the league championship series. We thought, "this is going to be easy, a sweep. All they have is old Steve Garvey and Goose Gossage, and Tony Gwynn is a singles hitter." But the Padres blew us out in Game 1, 10-3. Gwynn hit 2 home runs. We had to get our act together for Game 2, and Sid Fernandez, another great young pitcher, shut the Padres down. I hit 2 home runs in that game, and we won 8-2. Then we traveled to San Diego, and we had to win two games out of three there to go to the World Series. Ed Whitson was a pitcher who could be rattled pretty easily. Keith and I wagged our bats at him to intimidate him. He lost his control in the first inning. Then Carter smashed a 3 run HR and we cruised, 7-1. Game 4 was the only close game in the series. Doc was pitching and the Padres couldn't touch him, but we couldn't hit Tim Lollar either, which was a surprise. In the 8th inning Goose Gossage came on, and I was up with two outs. It was 1-1. Goose was aging but could still throw a fastball. I hit one of his fastballs about 450 feet down the right field line. The only question was if it would stay fair. It hit the foul pole, and we were up 2-1. Then it was down to Doc. Except for a Tony Gwynn double in the 9th, Doc struck out the rest of the Padres and we were in the World Series. I was NLCS MVP.
Davey Johnson (Mets manager): The Detroit Tigers were almost unstoppable in 1984. They were led by Kirk Gibson, the hometown hero from Michigan who had a career year. But we split the first two games at Shea Stadium. Sid Fernandez was once again outstanding in Game 1, striking out 10 and leading us to a 5-3 victory. We lost Game 2 in heartbreaking fashion, and I think that was the turning point of the series. We led 3-2 in the top of the 9th. Doc once again pitched his heart out. But Gibson hit a home run in the top of the 9th to tie it at 3. We eventually lost, 4-3, in the 12th inning. Detroit then blew us out 9-2 and 6-1 in Games 3 and 4 to take a 3 games to 1 lead. Sid wouldn't let us die though. He threw a stunning three hit shutout to deny the Tigers at Tiger Stadium, 3-0. We thought the series was winnable with the last two games at Shea. We took a 3-0 lead in Game 6 behind Hernandez and Carter once again. But Doc's arm was tiring. He never threw that many innings in his life. A guy who would eventually become a major part of our future success, Howard Johnson, hit a 3 run home run off Doc in the 5th inning, and Lou Whitaker homered in the 6th inning to make it 5-3 Detroit. We had our chances, but Willie Hernandez, their MVP and Cy Young winning reliever, was too tough, and the Tigers celebrated the World Series on our home field with a 5-4 win, and a 4 games to 2 series win. But the crowd at Shea didn't leave. They wanted to give us an ovation for getting to the World Series. After the Tigers left the field to open the champagne, we returned to the field and our fans applauded us for a half hour. We made a vow to ourselves that we would never lose a playoff series again while I was manager, and we never did. We also swore to bring home the World Series in 1985, which we did. In fact, we became a dynasty. Three titles in four years. The Yankees played second fiddle to us in the 80s.
Keith Hernandez: The first time Carter put the Spock ears in my locker, I said, "Don't you ever put those things in my locker! Who knows where they've been!" But we eventually loved the Spock ears. If Carter put them in someone's locker, that player had to make a big play. Usually, it worked out that way. It definitely worked out that way from 1984 to 1988. Four World Series appearances and three wins. One time, Lenny Dykstra tried to throw the Spock ears in the garbage in 1986, and Darryl started a fight with him so it wouldn't happen. Baseball players have weird rituals, and that was one of ours.
THE GLENN-LAXALT DEBATES (PLUS BENTSEN VS. DOLE)
Two presidential debates and one vice-presidential debate were held during October 1984. The first debate was held on October 7, 1984, with ABC's Barbara Walters moderating.
Walters: Vice President Laxalt, you're currently trailing in the polls and your message doesn't seem to be resonating. What do you think you have to do to turn this around?
Laxalt: I think we've made a nice comeback, thank you. We were 17 points down in August and we've cut the deficit to 9. I'm not worried about the polls. We'll have this thing as a dead heat by Election Day.
Glenn: I'm not worried about the polls either (crowd laughs).
Walters: The economy had its ups and downs under eight years of the Reagan administration. What would each of you do to set the economy on a more stable path? We've had periods of growth, but two recessions during the Reagan presidency.
Laxalt: Democratic obstruction in Congress led to the two recessions. Senator Glenn's more liberal colleagues led the effort to stop the President from passing more vigorous tax relief for Americans. When I'm president, I'm getting that major tax bill passed with a Republican Congress. The Democrats in Congress have ruined this economy by not following along with what President Reagan wants.
Glenn: Voodoo economics didn't work in 1977, and it doesn't work now. I support a targeted tax cut for the working class, but my good friend from Nevada wants all the money flowing up towards the business class. That type of economic model doesn't work.
Laxalt: John Glenn's boring, dull leadership style inspires nobody. He would simply be a placeholder President, and he'd be controlled by the liberal interests in Congress. Voting for Glenn is basically voting for Ted Kennedy and Elizabeth Holtzman, the two most liberal senators in the Democratic caucus.
Glenn: Excuse me, Mr. Vice President? I'm my own man, thank you. I'm the first American to orbit the Earth. To call me boring and dull is astonishing, even for you. I resent that remark.
Most of the 80 million television viewers considered the first debate to be a win for Laxalt, and he closed to within five points of Glenn in the polls before the second debate. One Gallup poll even had Glenn and Laxalt in a statistical dead heat, with 49% for Glenn and 46% for Laxalt. It would be up to Glenn's running mate, Lloyd Bentsen, to stanch the bleeding in the vice presidential debate, and he largely did the job. Sander Vanocur of CBS News moderated the vice presidential debate.
Vanocur: What do you make of the accusation that your ticket is boring and uninspiring, Senator Bentsen?
Bentsen: Well I'm inspiring enough to be elected senator from Texas three times. That isn't inspiring to you? You've got to have a strong personality to win statewide races in Texas.
Dole: John Glenn and Lloyd Bentsen couldn't inspire a single voter in the Democratic base to vote. Most of the Democratic voters are far to their left.
Bentsen: Left, center, right, conservative, liberal, it doesn't matter. John and I will govern the country how it needs to be governed. You and Laxalt will govern the country out of dogmatic ideology that doesn't work.
Vanocur: Traveling across America, I sense that this election is not as inspiring to the average American as those in the past. We don't have a charismatic figure running, like Kennedy or Reagan. Why has this election been all about policy and not about charisma?
Dole: Nobody is as charismatic as President Reagan, Sander. If we tried, we'd look like fakes. I'm not going to be a fake.
Bentsen: I think President Reagan caused that situation, Sander. If he actually allowed a Republican primary to occur instead of anointing my old friend John Tower for the GOP, we might have a more charismatic individual in the race.
Dole: I think Vice President Laxalt is pretty charismatic. He's not Jack Kennedy, but he can charm people pretty well.
Bentsen: Senator Dole, I knew Jack Kennedy. No politician in my lifetime was like Jack Kennedy.
Dole: President Reagan is.
Bentsen: I repeat my point. Nobody is like Jack Kennedy.
The 60 million viewers gave Bentsen the edge over Dole. Glenn held a seven point lead, 51% to 44%, in the polls when the second presidential debate aired on October 21, 1984. Edwin Newman of the Paramount Television Network moderated the final debate.
Newman: Vice President Laxalt, aside from tax cuts, what is your economic plan? You've campaigned largely on social issues, but we haven't heard anything else from you on the economy.
Laxalt: I want a larger tax break for families. The more children you have, the larger a tax break you get. I think my opponent can support that.
Glenn: I would agree with that proposal, but I feel that we're penalizing young adults who haven't started a family yet. If you design a large family tax credit, you should design a college education tax credit as well.
Laxalt: I am firmly opposed to a college education tax credit. That is a giveaway to young people who haven't paid their dues yet.
Glenn: I don't think young Americans are going to like that response very much, Mr. Vice President.
Laxalt: We can't just spend and spend for everyone in the country, Senator. We only have so many dollars in the economy. Americans understand that, but Democrats don't.
Glenn: Young Americans still don't understand what you just said, Mr. Vice President.
Newman: As our final question, tell us something that the American people don't know about you, that makes you more relatable to them. There's been a relatability problem in this campaign, according to polls.
Laxalt: I go skiing at Lake Tahoe whenever I can. I don't often get back to Nevada, but Lake Tahoe is one of the most beautiful places in the world. Everyone should go there once before they die.
Glenn: I watch Star Trek every week.
According to snap polls, sixty percent of American voters thought Glenn won the final debate. Once again, the senator from Ohio held a nine point lead, 53% to 44%, and time was running out. Vice President Laxalt seemed to accept the inevitable at a campaign stop in California after the final debate. "The only poll that matters is on Election Day," Laxalt said. "None of the polls had Truman winning in 48 but he won. I'll pull a Harry Truman." However, the polls didn't budge, even after a late October surprise claimed that Glenn had sexual relations with a woman other than his wife, Annie. Americans just weren't buying what Lee Atwater was selling.
REAGAN, GORBACHEV BREAK DEADLOCK
REYKJAVIK SUMMIT SCHEDULED FOR DECEMBER
October 22, 1984
President Reagan and Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev finally broke the ice, after Gorbachev swore earlier in the year he would not meet his counterpart from Washington. The two leaders will meet in Reykjavik, Iceland, two weeks before Christmas. Arms control will be on the table, as both leaders seek a reduction of intermediate-range nuclear missiles. "I'm glad we're holding this summit," Secretary of State Henry Kissinger said. "I wonder what could have been if the President were allowed to serve another term and improved his relationship with Mr. Gorbachev. We could have made some real progress, but most of the negotiations with Gorbachev will be left to the next White House." Experts believe it is unlikely that an arms control treaty will be signed, but are holding out for a breakthrough. "Gorbachev's hardliners don't want him to sign a nuclear arms deal yet, so most of the holdup is on his side," a source at the State Department said. "President Reagan wanted arms control ever since 1982, but he was never getting it with Andropov, and the Warsaw Pact war games earlier this year in response to NATO's Able Archer held up matters." The surprise summit announcement also caused some Washington officials to change their opinion of Gorbachev. "I think Gorbachev is willing to buck his hardliners and make his own policy," Secretary of Defense Caspar Weinberger said. "The question is, if Gorbachev comes home with an arms control deal, will his position as Soviet leader be in danger? The hardliners still hold a lot of sway in the Kremlin after Brezhnev and Andropov's rule."
STARFLEET INTELLIGENCE EPISODES
Hat tip to
@Ogrebear
EPISODE 51: ULTERIOR MOTIVES (Air date: October 2, 1984). President Roth opens up dialogue with Romulan Praetor Vespasian (played by Lorne Greene) regarding weapons of mass destruction. While the talks are occurring, Admiral Fitzpatrick receives a communication from Uhura stating that the Romulans stole poisoned darts from Gamma Trianguli and are planning to develop a chemical weapon. Roth breaks off the talks and Uhura's team are sent after the Tal Shiar. Fortunately for Uhura and company, the Romulans haven't been able to synthesize the chemical compound in the darts for industrial production. Uhura's team steals back the darts, and the Tal Shiar offer chase. Chekov and Nerva discover that the Romulans weren't there to develop a chemical weapon after all; there was a plague on Romulus killing 5% of the infected population and they had no cure for the virus. Uhura is against helping the Romulans but Chekov convinces her that it is the right thing to do, and could bring peace between the two empires. Uhura gives her consent; Chekov and Nerva develop the cure, along with a female Romulan scientist, Rivak. President Roth discovers the reason the Romulans stole the darts; he and Praetor Vespasian agree to arms control talks.
EPISODE 52: BACK TO MIRI (Airdate: October 9, 1984). Lt. Janice Rand (Grace Lee Whitney) contacts Uhura regarding the ongoing project on Earth 2 (from Miri). She has heard from a contact there that 'foreigners' have been sniffing around trying to learn the secrets of the Life prolongation project' - Marx is sent with Orion operative Neras (Kimberly L. Ryusaki) to pose as outsiders and investigate. Earth 2 has been much cleaned up (still looks like the 60's-cheap sets) and a UFP presence is obvious. Marx and Neras find there are still some children about, but also some are now adults and want off the planet who are willing to hand over secrets for passage off-world. Miri herself (Kim Darby) helps them break up the ring and expose the Orions behind it.
EPISODE 53: DIVIDING THE EMPIRE (Airdate: October 16, 1984). On one of the UFP Klingon worlds, Karlax is part of a crew delivering supplies. He says a few things about 'not having to be reliant on the Federation' which gets little traction from the other Klingons (smooth and ridged headed) some of which berate him for being 'behind the times'. At a bar, Karlax is approached by Valkris (Cathie Shirriff) who offers him a chance to 'gain honor against the UFP.' the two hit it off. It becomes clear Valkris is also a Starfleet operative trying to get close to a terrorist leader. After briefing him, Karlax is brought further into an organization trying to drive the UFP off the worlds and return them to the Empire 'the sheep who like the luxury, be damned' who are led by Torg (Stephen Liska) on behalf of a bigger leader- the name of which is Valkris' true target. Karlax suspects the leader to be Kruge but does not know it yet.
EPISODE 54: GENOCIDE ON BETA POLARIS (Airdate: October 23, 1984). We discover that Karlax and Valkris are after Kruge, whose home planet is Beta Polaris, the Klingon colony given free world status by the Intergalactic Council of Peace. Kruge returns to Beta Polaris with several Birds of Prey. He divides the population between those loyal to him and those loyal to the Federation. Starfleet Intelligence detects that Kruge is planning a massacre, and Uhura's team is brought in to investigate. Unfortunately for Uhura, her decision to release Kruge is wrong, and Kruge massacres over a thousand Klingon colonists deemed disloyal to the Empire before Uhura has a chance to capture him. Uhura feels guilty for allowing the massacre and offers to resign her commission to Admiral Fitzpatrick, but Admiral Kirk intervenes and persuades his former communications officer to stay in Starfleet. Uhura has a dream where she kills Kruge in cold blood, and screams out in anguish. She talks to Karlax and asks why Klingons like Kruge behave in that manner. Karlax says that there is nothing Uhura can do about Klingon customs, and that the massacre is not her fault; massacres like Beta Polaris occur regularly within Klingon territory. Kruge is placed on a Federation most wanted list, and Admiral Fitzpatrick sends a mission to Orion space to find him...only for the ships to disappear, never to return. Meanwhile, Kruge cultivates another contact at Regula One...
Vignettes: Genocide on Beta Polaris would be nominated for an Emmy Award in 1985 for Outstanding Writing in a Drama Series and Outstanding Directing in a Drama Series. Harve Bennett said of the episode, "it was the most emotional we ever produced. Seeing Kruge commit genocide against his own people was not only a shocking moment for television, but raised the stakes for Star Trek III," which premiered on November 8, 1984.