List of Alternate Presidents and PMs II

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Northern Irish executive is required to include the largest Unionist and Nationalist Parties in it- so if Sinn Fein walk out the Executive collapses, they can't patch together a deal with the smaller nationalists even if they wanted to.
 
The Northern Irish executive is required to include the largest Unionist and Nationalist Parties in it- so if Sinn Fein walk out the Executive collapses, they can't patch together a deal with the smaller nationalists even if they wanted to.
Oh. Fuck. I misunderstood that then. Umm I might delete the list and start again.
 
V for Vendetta PM's

1979-82: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative)
1979: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative), James Callaghan (Labour), David Steel (Liberal), Harry West (UUP),
1982: Michael Foot (Labour coalition with Alliance and SNP)
1982: Michael Foot (Labour), Alliance (David Steel (Liberal), Roy Jenkins (SDP)), Margaret Thatcher (Conservative), Gordon Wilson (SNP), UUP (James Molyneaux), Ian Paisley (DUP)
1982-89: Roy Jenkins (National Government (Labour/SNP/Liberals/SDP)
1986: National Government (Roy Jenkins (SDP), Dennis Healey (National Labour), David Steel (Liberal), Gordon Wilson (SNP)), Michael Hesseltine (Conservative), Eric Heffer (Labour), Unionist Alliance (James Molyneaux/Ian Paisley)

1988- THE SHORT WAR. BRITAIN AND THE EU ESCAPE THE NUCLEAR EXCHANGE

1989-92: Nigel Lawson (National Government (Conservative/NDP/Liberals/UA/BNP))
1989: Nigel Lawson (Conservative), Robert Killroy-Silk (National Democratic Party), Tony Benn (Labour), Paddy Ashdown (Liberal), Unionist Alliance (James Molyneaux/Ian Paisley), Gordon Wilson (SDP), Dafydd Elis-Thomas (Plaid Cymru), John Tyndale (BNP)


1992: IRISH TERRORISM CREATES STATE OF EMERGENCY

1992-94: Nigel Lawson (Emergency Government backed by the Metropolitan Police)

1994: Comm. Susan leads a coup against Lawson, united the coalition under the name "Norsefire" and declares himself "Leader".

1994-98: Adam Susan (Norsefire)
1998: Peter Creedy (Norsefire)

1998: The "Do-As-You-Please" era begins under the Democratic Federation of Great Britain and Ireland.

Monarchs

Elizabeth II: 1952-92

1992: IRA set fire to Windsor Castle killing the entire royal family

Zara I: 1992-98

1998: DFGBI declared. Monarchy abolished.
 
Last edited:
To mix things up a bit...British PMs:

1964-1976: Harold Wilson (Labour) [1]
1976-1981: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative) [2]
1981-1985: Denis Healey (Labour) [3]
1985-1994: Jeremy Corbyn (Labour) [4]

1994-1997: Gordon Brown (Labour) [5]
1997-2006: Michael Howard (Conservative) [6]
2006-2009: David Cameron (Conservative) [7]

2009-2016: Ben Bradshaw (Labour) [8]
2016-2017: Liz Kendall (Labour) [9]

2017-present: Alexander Johnson (Conservative) [10]

[1] From an upper middle-class intellectual left-wing background, Harold Wilson is regarded as having overseen a golden era of stability and economic growth, during which time the UK joined the EEC without too much fuss. He does, however, have his critics, including those who believe that he didn't advance liberal social reforms to a sufficient extent and those who complain that he made little attempt to connect with the working-classes. The electorate decided it was time for a change in 1976, and Wilson enjoyed a long and high-profile period as a respected elder statesman.
[2] An affable politician from an aristocratic Tory family, Thatcher was a protege of the likes of Harold Macmillan and Rab Butler on the 'One Nation' wing of her party. Despite her initial wide popularity as the first female PM, she soon found herself failing to deal with the economic problems of the late 1970s. In particular, her government's handling of the 'Winter of Discontent' of 1979 is infamous for its incompetence, utterly failing to deal with the more militant tendencies of the trades unions. The government's heavy defeat in the 1981 general election is often credited to (or blamed upon) Arthur Scargill. Thatcher herself is now largely airbrushed out of Tory history.
[3] A favourite of the middle-class left, Denis Healey is fondly remembered for his politeness towards opponents at the dispatch box, as well as for his government's achievements on social and constitutional matters; his government oversaw a change in the electoral system to Australian-style AV, a reduction in the size of the Commons, fixed four-year term Parliaments and advances on female and gay equality. He was unable to face down critics on the right of his party, however, who complained that he simply didn't grasp the need for liberal economic reforms and a winding-down of the post-war mixed economy. His health failing, he resigned in 1985 and passed away in 1988.

[4] The youngest and most controversial prime minister of the post-war period, Jeremy Corbyn is either the great saviour of the country or the unprincipled, power-hungry brute who sold out his party's principles for electoral gain. He made the notable achievement of becoming PM after just four years in Parliament, having won the seat of South Shields in 1981 and soon building a high public profile as a backbench critic of the Healey government. A fierce and sometimes outright obnoxious public speaker and debater, his government implemented a programme of 'Corbynonomics' - which saw the privatisation of various industries, significant cuts in income tax combined with a rise in VAT, the introduction of tuition fees and free schools, and the so-called Northern Powerhouse. His premiership was also one of the most electorally volatile periods in British history, with various new parties emerging, most notably the 'New Labour Party' - led by David Blunkett - a left-wing breakaway which swept away many hundreds of Labour councillors in its traditional Scottish, Welsh, Northern and Midlands strongholds, although it never quite made the same breakthrough in a general election. Corbyn also gained a reputation as a staunch Europhile, and by the end of his premiership was seen on the continent as a key leader of the European integration project.
[5] A highly charismatic and colourful personality, Brown was elected Labour leader and prime minister as a 'soft left' alternative to the Corbynite right's choice of John McDonnell. Lacking in economic knowledge, he disappointed his left-wing supporters by largely continuing the Corbynite consensus. His premiership was stable enough, although not much was seen to have happened. Brown now enjoys a career as a regular panelist of various comedy television programmes and even briefly had his own late-night chat show.

[6] A moderniser of the libertarian left wing of the Conservative Party, Michael Howard and his close friend and ally Ann Widdecombe (who served as his Chancellor) represented a new wave of Conservative Party thinking that eventually overthrew the old Thatcher-era One Nationers and forced the party to accept the new liberal economic and social consensus. Becoming PM after a narrow Tory victory in 1997, Howard pursued further electoral reform, the introduction of a minimum wage, community service as a valid alternative to prison and the adoption of the European single currency. His fortunes declined after the controversial invasion of Iraq in 2003, although he achieved an increased Tory majority in the 2001 election and only a slightly reduced majority in 2005.
[7] From a working-class Scottish coal-mining background, David Cameron was initially seen as a continuation of Howardism. This notion was ended soon after he took office, as a major economic crisis took hold. The partial nationalization of several major banks in 2007/2008 led many to accuse him of ending the 'New Tory' project, allow for many in the country the government did not go far enough on this front. His premiership doomed, the Tories suffered a landslide defeat in 2009.

[8] Previously an MP for the New Labour Party, Ben Bradshaw was among the vast majority of the NLP's 68 members of parliament who re-joined the Labour Party in the aftermath of the 2005 general election. Attacking the Howard and Cameron governments for their over-trusting of the economic experts, Bradshaw became a highly popular figure in Labour's old working-class strongholds and the party enjoyed record-breaking local and by-election successes in such areas in the final two years of the Cameron government. However, this was somewhat offset by declining support in London, which had been a big supporter of Corbynite Labour but largely stayed loyal to the Tories, mostly due to its economy holding up better than the rest of the country. Nonetheless, Bradshaw easily walked into No. 10 Downing Street in May 2009. The Scottish independence question was soon put to bed after a 'No' landslide of 69-31% in the 2010 referendum, the government oversaw the re-nationalization of the railways, the utilities and a significant reduction in tuition fees. Europe was the issue that undid Bradshaw, however. A longtime sceptic and a campaigner against membership of the Eurozone, Bradshaw decided to face down growing UKIP support by offering a referendum on membership in 2016. Against the expectations of many, Bradshaw decided to campaign for a 'Remain' vote, saying that Europe could be reformed via continuing membership in order to meet the needs of ordinary people. Unfortunately for him, the electorate voted 'Leave' by a narrow margin, and Bradshaw had no choice but to resign.
[9] Another former member of the NLP, Liz Kendall was one of eight cabinet members to campaign for Brexit in the 2016 referendum. Her heavyweight status was seen to have perhaps tipped the balance towards the Leave campaign, and she came to the leadership as the inevitable successor to Bradshaw and the obvious choice to implement Brexit. This couldn't be done prior to the next scheduled general election of 2017, and so Kendall largely remained as inoffensive as possible in the first (and, as it turned out, only) year in the premiership. Even after a general election campaign that included gaffes, a poorly-received manifesto and polls suggesting the public having cold feet about Brexit, Kendall's Labour were still expected to win a comfortable majority...then the nation watched with shock as the BBC's David Dimbleby read the exit poll results: "What we are saying is that the Conservatives are the largest party in a hung parliament." Kendall attempted, without even a grain of success, to negotiate a deal with the pro-EU Liberal Democrats. She resigned six days after the election after it had become clear that a coalition deal between the Tories and the Lib Dems had been reached.

[10] Former Greater Manchester mayor Alexander Boris de Pfeffel Johnson has been known as the 'grey man' of politics for some years, utterly lacking in personality but a very competent administrator. Drafted to the Tory leadership in 2009 largely against his own will, he continued the Tories' embrace of European integration and cemented its status as the most pro-European party in the country. His party staunchly opposed the idea of an in-out referendum in opposition, but Johnson took a leading role in the referendum campaign itself, with his calm trustworthiness shining through. Having achieved a shockingly good result in the 2017 general election, Johnson and his Tory-Lib Dem coalition government are now set to hold a second referendum on EU membership, with polls showing that the Remain side, this time, is likely to win.


 

Sideways

Donor
5th Past the Post

1979-1983: Jonathan Tyler (Ecology)
Def: National Front (John Tyndall), Communist Party of Great Britain (Gordon McLennan)


After the surprise dissolution of Labour, the Conservatives, and the Liberals, Jonathan Tyler's gamble of standing in as many seats as possible seemed to pay off. Ecology formed the first government of the new party system, and with a majority of 21, enough to push through their ideas. The only issue was that this was a young party with a very single issue at the fore of everyone's minds, and agreements on policy often broke down. The government made energy conservation, recycling, and agricultural self-reliance a priority, creating a mass of new jobs in co-operatively run, nationalised, industries. It also pushed forward devolution for Scotland and Wales, along with regional assemblies in England and a focus on the District council level of local government. Britain withdrew from defence agreements with the USA and began the process ofm unilatetral nuclear disarmament. Both policies put extra pressure on a military that was already seeing large cuts to funding. A Minister of Population was introduced for the first time, though for voters the party's polisy of cutting the UK population to 40 million in the next eighty years was sinister, and the post became viewed as a hot potato. Despite strong work done on sex education and abortion. The party was divided on many issues, and some motions on a less discriminatory immigration system and civil rights, only passed with the help of the CPGB's eleven MPs.

During this time, Malvinas was given to the Argentina, and the Chagos Islands were returned to their original inhabitants then occupied by Mauritius after a referendum. Vanuatu and Belize also gained independence. Hong Kong proved a sticking point for the UK government, as they tried to negotiate for China to recognise the New Territories as an area that would come under Hong Kong's independent control. The deal could not be reached, but typified the fears of many British people that Eco was not only isolating them on the world stage, but was also weak.

Increasingly, the government was riven by factional strife which made it hard for the cabinet to control legislation. In 1981 the NF managed to pass a Repatriation Bill, in 1982 they reversed Eco's disastrous cap on child benefit after the second child. By 1983, in a state of terminal decline and unable to pass a Queen's Speech, Tyler called for fresh elections.

1983-1987: Andrew Brons
1983-1985: National Front
1985-1986: Flag Group
1986-1987: Andrew Brons Political Action Task Force
Def: Ecology (Jonathon Porritt), BNP (John Tyndall), Communist Party of Great Britain (Gordon McLennan)

The National Front was elected with a historic landslide which was made even more impressive by the fact that they former leader John Tyndall formed a new party which won 24 seats and split the far-right vote. Problems started almost immediately, with one of Brons' new ministers giving a Nazi salute on entering Downing Street and Transport Secretary Nick Griffin getting accused of being in a sexual relationship with an older man while a teenager. The government courted controversy from the start by keeping the post of Minister of Population, although its focus was more on ensuring the white race had room to breed. Repatriation was expanded, businesses and assets belonging migrants (even ones who stayed) were redistributed. Attacks on ethnic and sexual minorities became common place and when these were protested against, the police came down hard on dissenters. America was granted bases in the UK once again and funnelled money into reversing disarmament.

During the early days of the NF government, football grounds, some breweries, and the Daily Mail spearheaded a recruitment and social reorganisation campaign on behalf of the government, winning them major business opportunities as long as Brons was in power but creating a legacy that has been very hard for them to shake off.

The NF's main problem was that it was made up of three distinct groups. The old style fascists, the left-wing Strasserites, and a rapidly growing and highly organised Political Soldier wing that wanted to take over the party and favoured Eco-style policies tinged with racialist mysticism. Cabinet's secularism and attempts to maintain some party discipline to prevent the overt use of Nazi imagery in parliament caused a rift between Brons and his back benchers and forced them towards the Political Soldier wing, however the older party members could not accept the Political Soldier wing and despite the three way schism of the party, Brons ust about managed to keep control, until his rump party declared bankrupcy and his government, now lacking any loyal back benchers at all, was forced to resign.

1987-1992: Gordon McLennan (CPGB)
Def: Jonathon Porritt (Green), Red Front (Frank Furedi), Brian Marshall (Moderate Labour)

The defeat of the National Front was so extreme that it caused a major power vacuum in British politics. While the Greens gained around 20 seats the big stir was the CPGB gaining 370 and winning the second landslide majority of the decade. Along with the Greens two other parties formed of former enemies of the state also entered parliament. The Red Front were more exteme in their violent attacks on fascists, the Moderate Labour Party had focused on non-violent opposition.

The new government pursued policies of disarmament, removing American forces (again), support for Soviet Union, wide scale nationalisation, industrialisation, and support for third world states. Hong Kong was handed over to China, officially marking the end of the British Empire, the House of Lords was abolished, along with the monarchy, which was seen as politically suspect. The new position of President was largely ceremonial and power remained with Parliament. Football and the popular press were nationalised and supporters of the old regime found themselve flung out of British political life.

While the government could effectively do what it liked, the public were uneasy with the changes they were witnessing and never again would the far-left have this degree of control in British political life.

1992-1997: Michael Meadowcroft (Liberal)
Def: Jean Lambert (Green), Geoffrey Clements (Natural Law), John Bates (SDP)

Meadowcroft's government narrowly defeated the Greens, and the Liberals became the first of the old parties to win mainstream political representation. They had a majority of just ten, but it was enough to push through a new Bill of Rights which included a law that constitutional changes would henceforth be made by referendums only. Post-fascist Britain was still trying to decide what it was in the world, and the period of Communist rule had only delayed this process. The government opened a truth and reconciliation panel and slowly deprivatised the media. Football was still seen as too dangerous, due to the propensity for mob violence with fan groups still dominated by fascists.

Sudden privatisation crossed with a poor world economic situation, the withdrawal of Soviet trade and the rapid terminal decline of the USSR (then the UK's biggest trading partner) caused massive problems for the Liberals. The final nail in the coffin came in 1995 when it was discovered that the Liberals had colluded with the National Front to arrest dissidents and many of the backers they had sold businesses to were in fact former fascists. This, coupled with the rise of a party that took their right wing vote, cost them dearly.

1997-2001: Alan Sked (UKIP)
James Goldsmith (Referendum), David Taylor (Green), Arthur Scargil (Socialist Labour), Michael Meadowcroft (Liberal)

The 1997 General election was won comfortably by parties that supported restoration of the monarchy and greater privatisation but feared the Liberal party's connection with fascism. The Greens, the only party to have consistently held their position in British life, were reduced to 46 seats, the Liberals to just one.

UKIP argued for wide scale privatisation, going so far as to include utilities and the rail services. Their big policy, however, was that they could restore the monarchy without a referendum. Their legislation on this matter was held up in the Supreme Court and, in 1999, by the newly elected President, Derek Wall. They finally passed a bill allowing them to hold a referendum in 2000. Even then, it was sent back from ratification when Derek Wall ruled that the question "Do you want to restore Great Britain as a proud, democratic country?" was deemed too biased. The referendum happened in 2001, by which time, public opposition to UKIP had solidified and the old queen in any case could hardly campaign well, particularly against a young and dynamic President Wall. The Republican side won with 50.6%. Following the referendum, the Opposition Referendum Party folded into UKIP, believing their last hope was to pursue restoration without another referendum.

2001-2010: Caroline Lucas (Green)
2001 Def: Jeffrey Titford (UKIP), Socialist Alliance, Arthur Scargil (Socialist Labour), Nick Griffin (BNP)
2005 Def: Roger Knapman (UKIP), Nick Griffin (BNP), Linda Smith (RESPECT), Robert Kilroy-Silk (Veritas)

The Greens built their landslide majority of the back of Derek Wall's success and their victory heralded the beginning of the end of monarchism as a major idea in the British political consciousness. The new government pushed for renewables and carbon neutrality, along with greater connections with the EU and a very progressive social liberal agenda that included gay marriage, pay equality, and a restoration of Equality legislation. Police forces came under increased scrutiny and many constabularies were broken down and brought under the control of District Councils. The new government engaged in some privatisation, but mostly wielded it as a weapon to get big corporations to make changes. Basic Income was introduced in 2007 to counter the effects of the global recession. However, the rapid worsening of the global economy had a huge impact on Britain's fragile economy.

2010-2015: Nick Griffin (BNP) Coalition with English Democrats
2010 Def: Malcolm Pearson (UKIP), Caroline Lucas (Green), Robin Tilbrook (English Democrat), Salma Yaqoob (RESPECT)

Nick Griffin finally clawed the far-right back into a position of power in 2010. The Greens were reduced to around 60 seats, while UKIP made large enough gains to stay roughly stable. The BNP attempted to run a slick media operation and represented a modernised nationalism, free from past associations with mysticism and the monarchy. But it didn't take long for this to start to crumble. A second Monarchy referendum took place in 2012 and saw 61.1% vote to continue the republic. This harmed the BNP's alliance with the English Democrats, a further blow to the Eng Dems was their failure to secure a unified English parliament in the 2014 referendum.

The BNP's biggest success was to join forces with UKIP to abolish the Supreme Court and the Bill of Rights at the end of 2012. This cleared the way for them to ban gay marriage and abolish all equality legislation. However it also cleared the way for UKIP, Eng Dem and BNP elements to push for restoration of the Monarchy without a referendum. The Bill to do so passed through parliament despite BNP opposition and, embarrassingly, was only stopped by President Jenny Jones.

2015-2017: Natalie Bennett (Green)
Def: Nick Clegg (Liberal Democrat), Dave Nellist (TUSC), Clive Peedell (National Health Action), George Calloway (RESPECT)

By 2015, UKIP were seen as utterly discredited for their monomania over the monarchy, and the BNP were worse than worthless. The Greens retook government, but the real shock was the return of an old party. The Liberals and the Old SDP had unified to form what was, in truth, a vehicle for TV presenter Nick Clegg to enter politics. He narrowly failed to form government and grew increasingly disenchanted with politics as the term continued, leading to the failure of his party and his return to presenting Have I Got News For You.

The Greens therefore had relatively little opposition as they set out to fundamentally change British life on a tiny majority. The Equality Act and Gay Marriage were reintroduced, but central to the project was the restoration of the Supreme Court and Bill of Rights. Parliament ruled that as this would enshrine the principle that constitutional changes require a referendum, it would require a referendum, which the Greens lost in 2016. Natalie Bennett announced her resignation the next day, but stayed on as an interim leader while the Greens elected a new leader.

2017-0000: Caroline Lucas & Jon Bartley (Green) Coalition with National Health Action
Def: David Nuttall (UKIP), Clive Peedell (National Health Action), Christian People's Alliance, BNP

While the Greens were hit hard by the referendum loss, the Liberal Democrats had lost their financial backing and had effectively dissolved, and no other party was in a position to challenge them. The Greens did not win a majority, but with the support of the NHA they essentially had a landslide as long as NHS funding rose steeply. This was easily agreed to, and the new "leadership team" used it to justify pulling support for Bennett's nationalisation schemes. The new government is planning to implement STV, a long standing Green party policy that has been impossible due to the need to hold referendums on constitutional changes. It is hoped that this policy will stop the seesaw of parties gaining enough votes to win hundreds of seats one year then disappearing the next, and will restore stability to British politics.
 
2020-2022: Emma Little-Pengelly (DUP)
I don't really think the DUP would oust Foster, unfortunately. She's been doing nothing but appealing to the hardliners and the party base. Pengelly might be alright in a few years but definitely not only two down the line. Also I doubt Fianna Fáil would even bother standing in Belfast, and I think it'd be Claire Hanna (who is steadfastly opposed to any deal with the Soldiers) as the candidate rather than the pretty past-it McDonnell.
 
Big Society

1920-1930: George Lansbury (Labour)
1920 (Majority) def. E.F.L. Wood (Conservative), Reginald McKenna (Liberal), Henry Page Croft (National Union), Ramsay MacDonald (Social Democrat)
1924 (Majority) def. Walter Guinness (Conservative), David Lloyd George (Liberal), Richard Cooper (National Union), Max Aitken (Imperial Union), Philip Snowden (Social Democrat)
1928 (Majority) def. William Joynson-Hicks (Conservative), David Lloyd-George (Liberal), Max Aitken (Imperial Union), Ramsay MacDonald (Social Democrat), Rajani Palme Dutt (Communist)

1930-1933: James Maxton (Labour majority)
1933-1939: Duff Cooper (Conservative)
1933 (Coalition with Liberals) def. James Maxton (Labour), Leslie Hore-Belisha (Liberal), Barry Domvile (Imperial Union), Ramsay MacDonald (Social Democrat), Rajani Palme Dutt (Communist)
1938 (Majority) def. Manny Shinwell (Labour), Margaret Bondfield (Social Democrat), Leslie Hore-Belisha (Liberal), Barry Domvile (Imperial Union)

1939-0000: Nancy Astor (Conservative)
1940 (Minority, with Imperial Union confidence and supply) def. Harry Pollitt (Labour), Margaret Bondfield (Social Democrat), Henry Maden (Liberal), Mary Richardson (Imperial Union), Rajani Palme Dutt (Communist)
 
Anyone got any potential Canadian POD's? People seem to like those.
-Dief never becomes Tory leader, with the SoCreds becoming the opposition in 1957 and becoming the major right-wing party.
-Chrétien calls a snap election in 2002 to silence Martinites, and with the opposition divided between the Alliance, Tories, and BQ, he wins a landslide majority.
-The NDP becomes the opposition in 1984 after Turner runs an even worse Liberal campaign.
-Robert Winters becomes Liberal leader instead of Trudeau.
-The PCs remain in the opposition in the 1993 election.
 
POD; Ross Perot decides not to run as an independent in 1992.

1989-1997; George Bush/Dan Quayle
1988; Michael Dukakis/Lloyd Bentsen
1992;
Bill Clinton/ Al Gore

1997-2005; Joe Biden/Bob Graham
1996; Pat Buchanan/Donald Rumsfeld, Steve Forbes/Bob Dornan (Coalition for America)
2000; Jack Kemp/Fred Thompson

2005-2013 Arne Carlson/Lindsey Graham
2004; Karen Thurman/Andrew Cuomo
2008; Mark Pryor/Chris Dodd

2013-2017; Paul Wellstone/Chellie Pingree
2012; Jeff Flake/Christine Whittman

2017-0000; Olympia Snowe/Todd Young
2016; Paul Wellstone/ Chellie Pingree

Essentially Ross Perot does not run which lets Bush I win a close election against Gov. Clinton. However the economy worsens under Bush even more so no major republican runs in 1996, causing a tough fight between Pat Buchanan and Steve Forbes who runs as a more moderate republican. Forbes fails to secure the nomination and forms the Coalition for America party. The election splits the vote and the party allowing progressive Joe Biden to win by a landslide in 1996, he also does well in 2000 with most moderate either voting for him or staying at home.

The republican party is divided into the conservative Buchanians and the moderate Forbes Republicans (Forbes reunited with the republicans after 1996 and became a leading moderate republican). Until 2005 the more conservative faction held power in the party, however the moderate Arne Carlson pulled an upset against Representative Newt Gingrich. The democrats nominated Governor Karen Thurman of Florida, the first woman nominated by a major party for the presidency, however the very moderate Carlson won in a tight race against Thurman. Carlson proved a very popular president and securing a large victory against the moderate Mark Pryror.

The more conservative wing of the republican party had their endings with Jeff Flake, the conservative-moderate who lost handily to the very progressive Paul Wellstone, however Wellstone clashed with congress in pursuing his agenda as president, and while popular when succeeded, the moderate republicans who controlled the senate for most of Wellstone's tenure made those victories few and far between. In 2017 the republicans again nominated a very moderate candidate. The bipartisan minded Olympia Snowe, the first woman president.

TL;DR the republicans become very moderate on most social issues while the democrats become Progressives economically and socially
 
Last edited:
-Dief never becomes Tory leader, with the SoCreds becoming the opposition in 1957 and becoming the major right-wing party.
-Chrétien calls a snap election in 2002 to silence Martinites, and with the opposition divided between the Alliance, Tories, and BQ, he wins a landslide majority.
-The NDP becomes the opposition in 1984 after Turner runs an even worse Liberal campaign.
-Robert Winters becomes Liberal leader instead of Trudeau.
-The PCs remain in the opposition in the 1993 election.
wowwww, so it’s like that now oppo
 
Let me explain again: Sinn Féin will NEVER be anything at Westminster. They don't recognize that Westminster has any right in the North or any other part of Ireland - and as you mentioned in your previous post they are an Irish party, not a British one. Of course I was referring to Stormont. I can see an alliance between Sinn Féin and the SDLP to take Stormont over, but there's no reason - at all - to do the same in relation to Westminster, as they have too different policies in that regard (SDLP of course recognize that Westminster is the ruler of the North).

If it's still too complicated to get, PM me and I'll be glad to explain for you :)

Sinn Fein don't have to take there seats to be the biggest Northern Irish party represented at westminster (they accept there pay so they are legally MP's all be it in abstention and rejecting the uks jurisdiction).

Sinn Fein offered a pact in OTL so I'm happy to say my pact is within the realms of possibility, the cognative disadence of such a pact vis a vis taking up seats doesn't rule it out.

We can agree to disagree but let's not fight.

Éire Fada Beo
Long Live Ireland
 
Last edited:
To mix things up a bit...British PMs:

1964-1976: Harold Wilson (Labour) [1]
1976-1981: Margaret Thatcher (Conservative) [2]
1981-1985: Denis Healey (Labour) [3]
1985-1994: Jeremy Corbyn (Labour) [4]

1994-1997: Gordon Brown (Labour) [5]
1997-2006: Michael Howard (Conservative) [6]
2006-2009: David Cameron (Conservative) [7]

2009-2016: Ben Bradshaw (Labour) [8]
2016-2017: Liz Kendall (Labour) [9]

2017-present: Alexander Johnson (Conservative) [10]

Interesting, what's the POD?
 
'Manchester Gorton, LIB DEM GAIN'

2016-2023: Theresa May (Conservative and Unionist)
2020 (Minority, with DUP confidence and supply) def. Tim Farron (Liberal Democrat), Chuka Umuna (Labour), Aaron Bastani (Democratic Socialists of Great Britain), Nicola Sturgeon (Scottish National), Arlene Foster (Democratic Unionist), Michelle O'Neill (Sinn Fein)
2023-2027: Tim Farron (Liberal Democrat)
2023 (Progressive Alliance with Labour) def. Theresa May (Conservative and Unionist), Aaron Bastani (Democratic Socialists of Great Britain), Ian Blackford (Scottish National), Emma Little-Pengelly (Democratic Unionist), Michelle O'Neill (Sinn Fein)
2027-2034: Ben Bradley (Conservative and Unionist)
2027 (Minority) def. Tim Farron (Liberal and Democratic Labour), Ash Sarkar (Democratic Socialists of Great Britain), Michelle O'Neill (Sinn Fein), Angela Constance (Scottish National), Emma Little-Pengelly (Democratic Unionist)
2029 (Minority) def. Ash Sarkar (Democratic Socialists of Great Britain), Layla Moran (Liberal and Democratic Labour), Michelle O'Neill (Sinn Fein), Emma Little-Pengelly (Democratic Unionist)

2034-2039: Liam Baker (Democratic Socialists of Great Britain)
2034 (Majority) def. Ben Bradley (Conservative), Layla Moran (Liberal and Democratic Labour), Michelle O'Neill (Sinn Fein)
 
Last edited:
Dwight D. Eisenhower/Alben Barkley (Nonpartisan/Democratic) 1949-1953
Def. Harry Truman/Alben Barkley (Democratic) [263] Tom Dewey/Earl Warren (Republican) [222] Strom Thurmond/Fielding J. Wright (Dixiecrat) [38] Dwight D. Eisienhower/Various (Faithless Electors) [4] Henry Wallace/Glen Taylor (Progressive) [4]

Basically, Henry Wallace actually campaigns, during this experience of actually running like a sane politician, he runs a populist campaign, and takes North Dakota by plurality. His actual campaigning leads to Dewey winning a few more states than otl, and the electoral college deadlocks, so Dewey makes a deal to receive Dixiecrat electors when the actual voting occurs. While it won't give him an electoral college majority, he hopes it can eliminate a popular third-party candidate from taking potential votes in the House (as Wallace did not have many allies in the house). However, electors in the Northeast don't take too kindly to selling your soul to racists, so 4 electors vote for Dwight D. Eisenhower. In the House election, Eisenhower's electors win the coin flip to get a chance to be voted in. After three stalled ballots, a coalition of Democrats and Republicans feel that they want a president to hold the office while they figure out a way to replace the broken electoral college system. So, almost the entire House votes for Eisenhower. Under president Eisenhower, a parliamentary system is created, with the first election to be held after Eisenhower's 4 year term would traditionally end. It was decided that the parliament would be as large as the House of Representatives. Eisenhower's popularity raises after working out the system, and helping American democracy, leading to the creation of the Unity! Party, which is basically a cult of personality around Dwight Eisenhower, except Eisenhower refused to be a member. However, Eisenhower's popularity drops after the conflict in Korea goes bad for America, he fires Douglas MacArthur for wanting to nuke North Korea[1], and he refuses to take a side on the issue of Civil Rights, hurting his popularity in the North and South. In fact the firing of MacArthur is so unpopular, the Republicans literally make him their parliamentary leader. Eventually, Eisenhower's term would end, and he would be replaced with another general.


Prime Ministers of the United States of America
Douglas MacArthur (Republican) 1953-1955
Bill Knowland (Republican) 1955-1956

Def. Averell Harriman (Democratic) George Aiken (Liberty)[2] James Eastland (State's Rights) Henry Wallace (Progressive) Estes Kefauver (People's)[3] Herbert Brownell (Unity!)
Bill Knowland/Benjamin T. Laney (Republican-State's Rights Coalition) 1956-1959
Def. Lyndon B. Johnson (Democratic) Bill Knowland (Republican) Benjamin T. Laney (State's Rights) Robert C. Hendrickson (Liberty) Glen Taylor (Progressive) Herbert Brownell (Unity!) Estes Kefauver (People's)
Wayne Morse[4] (Progressive-Liberty-People's-Unity! Coalition) 1959-1964
Def. Margret Chase Smith (Liberty) Lyndon B. Johnson (Democratic) Estes Kefauver (People's) Wayne Morse (Progressive) Bill Knowland (Republican) Benjamin T. Laney (State's Rights) Robert Anderson (Unity!) Barry Goldwater (Freedom)[5]
Hubert Humphrey (Democratic) 1964-1967
Def. Strom Thurmond (State's Rights) Margret Chase Smith (Liberty) Wayne Morse (Progressive) Richard Nixon (Republican) George Wallace[6] (People's) Barry Goldwater (Freedom) Robert Anderson (Unity!)
Nelson Rockefeller (Liberty-Unity! Alliance[7]) 1967-1968
Def. Hubert Humphrey (Democratic) George Wallace (People's) Richard Nixon (Republican) Wayne Morse (Progressive) Joe Foss ("Anti-California" Republican)[8] Ross Barnett (State's Rights) Barry Goldwater (Freedom) Don Edwards (Peace Democrat)[9]
John Connelly/Joe Foss (People's-Justice Coalition) 1968-1972
Def. John Connelly (People's) Nelson Rockefeller (Liberty-Unity! Alliance) Robert Kennedy (Democratic) Joe Foss (Justice) Eugene McCarthy (Progressive) Jim Rhodes (Republican) Barry Goldwater (Freedom) Orval Fabus (State's Rights)

I'm not doing anymore, because I'm not ready to write 300 more footnotes and more political parties

[1] No, this wasn't the only reason, and no, North Korea wasn't nuked under MacArthur
[2] The Liberty Party was formed by Liberal Republicans who felt that the Republicans had moved too far to the right
[3] Keef felt that he had been robbed of the Democratic leadership position, and decided to form his own political party
[4] While the Progressives did quite bad compared to the other parties in the coalition, Morse was the most popular out of any leader within the party
[5] Barry Goldwater left the State's Rights party because he felt that they were too focused on Racism, and not on the principles of state's rights. So he formed his own Libertarian-esc party.
[6] No, this is not racist Wallace. This version of Wallace won a seat in 1959 due to the unpopularity of the State's Rights-Republican coalition, and the way too long extension of the Korean War.
[7] Because they were collapsing, the Unity! Party formed an alliance with the Liberty Party. Rockefeller became leader due to popularity throughout the alliance.
[8] Joe Foss created a political party in opposition to the "California Establishment" that had ruled the Republican party for years. It changed it's name to the Justice Party to not seem connected to the Republicans
[9] After Hubert Humphrey declared war in Vietnam, fears of another unpopular Asian war spread across the Democratic Party. The Peace Democrats folded into the Democratic Party during the leadership of Robert Kennedy.
 
Last edited:
Unless Eisenhower was in the top three electoral vote winners he wouldn't go to the congressional vote, ergo Dewey or Truman would still likely win...
 
Unless Eisenhower was in the top three electoral vote winners he wouldn't go to the congressional vote, ergo Dewey or Truman would still likely win...
did I not mention that Dewey made the deal before the electoral college voted in order to take out a potential third party spoiler in the house election? That way, he revived the Dixiecrat electors, but didn’t get a majority
 
There was speculation on if the Bloc would not take their seats in parliament (so they don’t have to swear an oath to the Queen).

CanadianTory and I entered into the secret lair of Politicanucks to discuss this idea.

differences
-The PCs and Liberals do slightly better in Québec in 1997 because of people wanting a party that takes their seat.
-Preston Manning is seen as more of a Prime Minister by being LotO earlier, allowing him to stay on later and not change the name of Reform.
-The BQ abstaining on any confidence vote means that minority goverments fall earlier.
-With Layton dying earlier and Mulcair never joining the NDP, the BQ survives despite Fortin’s non-abstaining split.

1993-2003: Jean Chrétien (Liberal)
1993 (Majority): Lucien Bouchard (Bloc), Preston Manning (Reform), Audrey McLaughlin (NDP), Kim Campbell (PC)
1997 (Majority): Preston Manning (Reform), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Jean Charest (PC), Alexa McDonough (NDP)
2000 (Majority): Preston Manning (Reform), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Alexa McDonough (NDP), Joe Clark (PC)

2003-2004: Paul Martin (Liberal)
2004 (Minority): Stephen Harper (Conservative), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Jack Layton (NDP)
2004-2006: Stephen Harper (Conservative)
2005 (Minority): Paul Martin (Liberal), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Jack Layton (NDP)
2006-2014: Don Boudria (Liberal)
2006 (Minority): Stephen Harper (Conservative), Jack Layton (NDP), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Jim Harris (Green)
2009 (Majority): Peter MacKay (Conservative), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Bill Blaikie (NDP), Elizabeth May (Green)

2014-2017: Brian Pallister (Conservative)
2014 (Minority): Don Boudria (Liberal), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Peggy Nash (NDP), Elizabeth May (Green)
2017-Present: David Orchard (Liberal)
2017 (Minority): Brian Pallister (Conservative), Gilles Duceppe (Bloc), Paul Dewar (NDP), Jean-François Fortin (Pour le Québec: Ralliement Fortin), Elizabeth May (Green)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top