The North Star is Red: a Wallace Presidency, KMT Victory, Alternate Cold War TL

Well that escalated quickly.

So...MacArthur for President? I mean we've already seen another TL with Patton as President, so this would be the hat-trick now. (if you count OTL with Eisenhower.)
 
Regarding the chaos in Argentina and Brazil what is Chile doing? In 1955-1958 the populist Carlos Ibañez was still president and he was really close to Peron.
Per%C3%B3n_Iba%C3%B1ez.jpg

(This Photo is from 1953 and also this song
)
Also he had far more loyalty in his own armed forces. From Wikipedia:
"In this area, Ibáñez was closely linked to the Argentine government of Juan Domingo Perón. In Buenos Aires on July 8, 1953, both Perón and Ibáñez signed the Treaty of Argentine-Chilean Economic Union. Ibáñez participated in the founding of Villa Eva Perón and both shared the same ideals; In addition, Perón urged him to take a new dictatorship. [citation needed] As a result of this, the group La Línea Recta, a group composed of officers and NCOs of the Army and Carabineros, was formed. Its purpose was to be ready to take power as soon as possible. President Ibáñez arranged it."
 
Regarding the chaos in Argentina and Brazil what is Chile doing? In 1955-1958 the populist Carlos Ibañez was still president and he was really close to Peron.
Per%C3%B3n_Iba%C3%B1ez.jpg

(This Photo is from 1953 and also this song
)
Also he had far more loyalty in his own armed forces. From Wikipedia:
"In this area, Ibáñez was closely linked to the Argentine government of Juan Domingo Perón. In Buenos Aires on July 8, 1953, both Perón and Ibáñez signed the Treaty of Argentine-Chilean Economic Union. Ibáñez participated in the founding of Villa Eva Perón and both shared the same ideals; In addition, Perón urged him to take a new dictatorship. [citation needed] As a result of this, the group La Línea Recta, a group composed of officers and NCOs of the Army and Carabineros, was formed. Its purpose was to be ready to take power as soon as possible. President Ibáñez arranged it."

Yay another poppie for my list :D

There is also at this timeline Jimenez in Venezuela and Odria in Peru.
 
Chapter 61 - Poland Is Not Yet Lost
Poland Is Not Yet Lost

The 5th Army reached Poland shockingly late, giving the Polish forces significant time to build up their forces. Notably, elements of the 5th Army were deployed from East Asia, began deploying back after the beginning of the Korean War, and then began deploying back again to Poland after the end of the Korean War. When they arrived in Poland to reinforce Communist Polish and Czechoslovak forces, it was months after they expected to arrive.

The rebel forces were concentrated primarily in Warsaw, Krakow, Gdansnk, Wroclaw, Poznan, and Lodz. Due to overwhelming air superiority, armored, artillery, and infantry superiority, the Polish rebels were no match for the crack troops of the Red Army, which handled every city except Krakow (close to Czechoslovakia). The Commander of the 5th Army, Aleksandr Vasilevsky, was deeply horrified by some of the stories he had heard from Finland and Yugoslavia and was determined to crush the rebellion with...somewhat less collateral damage. Most notably, Vasilevsky was one of the few Soviet military commanders to both know of Stalin's survival and have Stalin's confidence, giving him latitude to act with more lenience. In general, Vasilevsky used his armor and aerial assets to slowly chase Polish rebels out of any exposed spaces with no cover, slowly sheperding them into small areas that could be encircled, at which point he would demand a surrender and slowly apply pressure to the pockets. In general, the plan was successful, albeit very slow, and still came with some collateral damage (especially in public plazas, parks, and roads) - though still less than in Yugoslavia or Finland. The primary resistance to Soviet forces came in Gdansk, which had too much industrial factories for this strategy to work. Instead, Soviet forces engaged in close-quarters combat with Polish rebels, with both sides taking nasty losses. Much of Gdansk's industrial base was destroyed in the frenetic fighting that quickly reminded Vasilevsky of the fighting in the factories of Stalingrad...except this time he was the invader. Most worryingly for the Soviet Union, as the battle turned against the rebels, most of the rebels refused to surrender, instead launching a dramatic breakout attempt that overran Soviet forces near the port, commandeering ships, and then fleeing into Swedish-controlled waters, before spontaneously breaking out in widespread singing of the Polish national anthem, Poland Is Not Yet Lost.

In contrast, Czechoslovakia, having just undergone brutal "anti-Titoist" purges under the orders of Stalin, had leaders who deeply feared that any display of softness might give the Soviet Union an excuse to purge them as well. The People's Republic of Poland had similar sentiments, especially as they knew they were on thin ice after allowing the Revolution to happen. As a result, the Czechoslovak People's Army (CSLA) and the Polish People's Army (LWP) was ordered by its commanders to crush the rebels in the most dramatic fashion ever, which led to the Battle of Krakow, where the CSLA and LWP began their assault with artillery carpet strikes against the city. Anti-Communist sentiment was stronger in the West than East, so Krakow was also home to some of the most determined defenders in Poland, especially as they understood that the two Eastern bloc armies were still somewhat inferior to the Red Army (especially in aerial and armored assets) and could in theory be defeated. Polish defenders fought CSLA-LWP troops on every block of the city, leading to horrific losses on both sides that caused outrage in Czechoslovakia itself. The most dramatic moment of the Battle of Krakow was the last stand of over a thousand Polish rebels, who refused to surrender and holed up in the famous Wawel complex.

Soviet commander Vasilevsky sent over a telegram indicating that the destruction of the Wawel Complex (including the famous Wawel Castle and St. Mary's Basilica) was politically unacceptable and that CSLA-LWP forces ought to starve out the rebels. However, in the paranoid post-purge environment, CSLA-LWP leaders took this order as a "trap" meant to test their commitment to the Communist cause - and instead, they interpreted the order as demanding that they go "up and beyond" by securing the complex without artillery strikes. Firefights broke out between Polish rebels and CSLA-LWP troops in the famous churches and castles of Wawel, as a determined Polish resistance tried to turn every piece of historical architecture into a new way to ambush their attackers. After a week of constant attacks, both sides had taken horrible losses, but the Polish troops ultimately ran out of ammo. The leftover Polish soldiers, around 300, still refused to surrender, raiding the castle museum for medieval weapons to continue to fend off the CSLA-LWP soldiers. The morale of CSLA-LWP soldiers was so low due to the symbolic nature of the Wawel complex, that the next Communist assault was actually routed when rebel soldiers counter-charged them, wielding medieval halberds, swords, and spears. In one case, a squad of Polish troops had donned entire suits of plate armor, and a CSLA-LWP squad simply fled from them, unaware that their guns would actually penetrate plate armor. When the leaders of Communist Czechoslovakia and Poland heard that some of their troops had literally been routed by medieval weapons, perhaps the ultimate humiliation, they fired and purged the leadership of their respective armies, replacing them with political toadies with significantly less competence. Ordering mass human wave assaults into the most cramped corners of Wawel Castle itself, the new commanders more or less threw away their massive advantage of actually having guns. The Polish rebels were quickly able to engage in fierce close-quarter combat, although due to the numerical disparity, they were eventually almost all killed. At the end of the battle, out of around 1300 Polish defenders, only 37 all survived (troops too wounded to fight in the final last stand - many of those men would soon die of their wounds).

The Polish Revolution of 1956 had been crushed, but at a tremendous cost, both to Poland's Communists and the rest of the Eastern Bloc. In addition, the crushing of the Polish revolution sent a powerful course towards America's large Polish-American population, who quickly became some of the most fervently anti-Communist voters in America. Stories of the last stand in Wawel and dramatic escape of Gdansk circulated across Polish newspapers in America, causing many Polish voters (traditionally a solid Democratic bloc) to rethink their loyalty to the "do-nothing" President Russell.
 
You know, this war may be an equivalent for Stalin and Stalinism of Mao's Cultural Revolution, a supossed success to them while they were still alive, but a violent disaster so big to everybody else that Deng and most of the party had no other choice but to get ride of the maoist gang and start big reforms. Khruschev may be able to get ride of the old stalinist guard and fully implement the liberman-kosygin reform and continue financing the OGAS.
Also if Tito's Yugoslavia survives it may replace the Soviet Union as a beacon of socialistic anti-imperialism (after this war the USSR will have problems presenting itself as a trustworthy ally to many third world nations). Yugoslavia could become the european prima donna of american economic and military aid (like Korea and Taiwan in otl Asia) and become a similar success story.
All of this could contribute to a stronger and more relevant non-alligned movement. More nationalistic and mixed economy-oriented governments in the third world.
 
Chapter 62 - The Spring of Rage and the Tokyo Wall
The Spring of Rage and the Tokyo Wall
The Korean War backfired horrifically on one individual who hadn't even vocally supported it, Prime Minister Hatoyama of Japan. His failure to explicitly prohibit the war outraged much of the Japanese center and left, which remained still staunchly anti-war. Even though the Communists were thoroughly chased from respectable politics having been officially banned, this simply caused many Communists members to infiltrate the still-legal Japan Socialist Party, which commanded the allegiance of most of Japan's publicly unionized workers, such as the teacher's unions. The Siege of Seoul and stories of civilian deaths sparked massive antiwar protests that overran Kyoto, Osaka, Hiroshima, Fukuoka, and Tokyo (at least the South Japanese parts). In addition, although Japan was not directly involved in the war outside of shipping assistance, it was a primary military exporter (of steel, gears, widgets, and what not) to South Korea, and industrial Japanese workers regularly engaged in the sabotage of factories perceived to be producing war material. Finally, most worryingly to the government, 4/5ths of Japan's Korean population was affiliated with the North (as opposed to the South).[1] This was interestingly not based on ideology, but rather the geographic origin of Korean-Japanese.

The protests in Tokyo were estimated to be the largest mass protest in Japanese history, with over half a million marchers, even larger than the previous Communist general strike during the US occupation. The protesters included both radical Communists and more conventional, but still radical socialists, but the pictures of hammer and sickles especially alarmed the South Japanese government, which was further put on edge by the mobilization of the Soviet Army in North Japan to the border. Some also theorized that some people just went to the protests because it coincided perfectly with cherry blossom season, causing the protest movement to largely adopt cherry blossoms as their motif. Cherry blossoms however, have been associated also with the fleeting nature of life ever since the famous invocation of cherry blossoms in the Tale of Heike, an ill omen that was to shortly come true. Acting under orders of the Kim Il-Sung government, North Korean-aligned Korean-Japanese provocateurs launched attacks on Japanese police during the Tokyo Protests. A terrified local police force acting under the orders of former National Police Force commander Takushiro Hattori, operating without Hatoyama's direct orders, immediately responded with force.

Tokyo exploded in rage, soon followed by Kyoto, the city in Japan with the most former Communists. The students immediately became the most radical, attacking police officers on sights with Molotov cocktails and other improvised weapons. Massive streetbrawls exploded, especially as construction workers on Tokyo's increasingly intricate subway system (privately unionized workers were a bastion of support for Hatoyama) went off work on their own initiative to fight both students and members of the Japan's railway unions (a well-known Communist bastion of support).[2] The construction unions generally had close relations with Tokyo's Yakuza groups, which caused many Yakuza members to join in the violence. Very quickly, Tokyo's subway system had to be shut down in order to curb the violence, but this didn't stop agitators on both sides from using the metros tunnels as ways to ambush their enemies. Corpses notably began to pile up in the Ginza and Marunouchi Lines, which would have to be eventually removed to re-open the subways. However, the anti-war protestors had their own advantages. Much to the consternation of Japanese police, protestors could sneak into the Communist sector of Tokyo (namely, Tokyo east of the Arakawa River.) In addition, most of Japan's teachers went on strike just before the start of the school year on April 1st, causing a nationwide school stoppage that further polarized the nation. The radical nature of university students caused most colleges in the country to similarly shut down.

Hatoyama was horrified by the violence, a direct challenge to his dream of a liberal, united, egalitarian society. Instead of responding nationally, Hatoyama decided to hunker down. He told worried comrades in his Social Nationalist Party (SNP) that the best way to not further divide Japanese society was to remain neutral in both the war and protests, wait for the South Koreans to triumph, and watch as the protest movement ebbed away. Hatoyama felt very confident about this approach up until the point the People's Liberation Army entered the war and destroyed almost the entire South Korean Army in roughly a month and half.

The news of the ROK Army's destruction basically doomed Hatoyama's premiership, as his allies on the political right indicated that they no longer had confidence in Hatoyama's ability to continue. The Social Democratic wing of the Social Nationalist Party under Suehiro Nishio, Jotaro Kawakami, and Tetsu Katayama supported Hatoyama, but he had lost the support of the liberals under Hitoshi Ashida and Tanzan Ishibashi, as well as the conservatives under Nobusuke Kishi and Mamoru Shigemitsu. Hatoyama immediately resigned and retired from politics, confident that he would be succeeded by either Ishibashi or Shigemitsu, both of whom promptly became too ill to run for election. In a shock to all parties involved, Nobusuke Kishi won the leadership election on a platform of clamping down on the Communist rioters with force.

Police forces were marshaled from outside of Tokyo, often staffed by far more politically conservative rural police forces who were in a mood to crack heads. Kishi genuinely considered the option of going to war, but ultimately decided against it after realizing he didn't have the support in his own party to do so. However, he was sick of Communist rioters dodging across the border to East Tokyo where South Japanese police could not pursue, and then coming back later far-better armed. Working with his allies in various Yakuza groups, Kishi came across a simple solution: building a giant wall to isolate East Tokyo. Kishi-aligned construction workers immediately began constructing what would become known as the Tokyo Wall, quickly putting an end to this trend. In addition, Kishi quickly became best friends with President Richard Russell, greatly deepening the US relationship. The two of them began hammering out a possible mutual defense treaty between the country, something only put on hold due to Russell's challenging re-election campaign.

Due to much harsher repression, the death toll rapidly climbed, destroying much of Tokyo's shopping centers due to mass brawling, looting, and gunfire. Protestors rapidly stepped up the degree of violence, often ambushing police officers and soldiers to deadly effect. However, after the declaration of a ceasefire in the Korean War, the anti-war protesters quickly began to disperse, having made their point and feeling emboldened over preventing Japanese intervention in the Korean War. Schools and subways and shops began reopening. However, images of street violence, including pictures of police officers gunning down student protesters, quickly became seared into the minds of Japanese popular culture. Kishi quickly became known as the "Showa Devil" for his harsh repression, which eroded much of his support outside of the right-wing of the Social Nationalist Party. The Spring of Rage, referred to by left-leaning Japanese as the Tokyo Massacre, is estimated by some to have claimed somewhere between 10,000-20,000 lives, including around 500 Japanese soldiers and police officers.
---
[1] OTL, this was 2/3rds, but with a more southern border that puts Seoul in the North, this is 4/5ths.
[2] This is OTL - they once famously launched a Communist terror campaign against private railroad executives once.
 
Japan may move closer to the US but its reputation is now as a fault line rather than a bulwhark of stability as IOTL.

Isolating East Tokyo sounds to me like it is going to render it a very unpleasant little enclave of misery. I guess the new Tokyo wall could theoretically give the West a sort of counterbalance to the East Berlin situation, though in reality, this more likely means that calls to liberate West Berlin would now look far more hypocritical. As for those in East Tokyo, who knows what the government has in store for them. If it is generous, it should allow most of them to leave the area for North Japan proper and leave East Tokyo as a potemkin city manned by a skeleton crew. Allowing it to potentially become an isolated slum is terrible for their legitimacy.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 63 - The 1956 Presidential Debate
The 1956 Presidential Debate
Although several had floated the possibility of presidential debates before, the 1956 elections was the first to turn it into a reality. The 1956 Democratic Primary notably featured a debate between the seasoned debater Richard Russell and the young Hubert Humphrey, where Russell was generally thought to have won. In August 1956, immediately after the end of the party conventions, University of Maryland student Fred E. Kahn sent a letter to the Russell, MacArthur, and McCarthy campaigns to visit the University of Maryland, where they would take questions from students. The Russell campaign immediately accepted. The McCarthy campaign, upon hearing of the Russell campaign's acceptance, also accepted with the caveat that the presidential forum be televised, a condition the Russell campaign accepted. The Russell campaign was confident in their candidate besting the two Republicans, while the McCarthy campaign wanted to do anything for more exposure. Upon hearing the two campaigns accept, the Big Three media networks immediately muscled their way into the process, immediately advertising the presidential forum as a "debate between President Russell and Senator McCarthy." The MacArthur campaign immediately saw the debate as a trap and refused to attend, but when the networks decided to continue holding the debate, they realized that they would get even more bad press by simply not attending. Eventually, the MacArthur campaign folded, and decided to attend.

The first televised presidential debate was held on October 1, 1956, a Monday. Although it was technically billed as a presidential forum with students asking pre-prepared (and pre-cleared with the Big Three networks) questions, in actuality, it was essentially a presidential debate. It quickly became one of the most watched broadcasts in American history - the 1956 Presidential Debate would be consistently listed by Americans, especially by Americans too young to remember Pearl Harbor, as one of the most memorable events in their life.

The three candidates immediately went off on each other. McCarthy went on the attack against both other candidates immediately, lambasting them as crypto-Communists who were intentionally allowing the Soviet Union to rampage against the Free World. MacArthur responded angrily, citing his long military service as a reason as to why it was absurd to impugn his patriotism - and how as a military general, he understood the costs of war, moving into a short lecture about how he would repulse Soviet influence without resorting to war, unlike President Russell, who he claimed might blunder America into a war.

President Russell, by far the most seasoned debater, generally dominated the night, parrying accusations of Communism from McCarthy and parrying accusations of racism and violation of the constitutional order from MacArthur. The audience, although quite confused at the end, generally concluded Russell won. However in practice, President Russell would eventually have the worst night of all three. Relatively late into the night for Russell, while he was describing in length as why his administration's policies would both 1) not lead to war as suggested by MacArthur and 2) not fail to repulse Communism as suggested by McCarthy, several of his aides crawled up onto the stage against the direction of the networks to talk directly to Russell. Russell immediately ceased speaking, gathered his papers, and wordlessly left the stage and the entire campus to a rather confused audience.

The broadcast continued running for a few minutes as the confused audience chattered, before each of NBC, ABC, and CBS cut their broadcast in order to interrupt with a completely different broadcast. Each of their anchors calmly announced to their respective audiences what they knew: the United States had been attacked and that President Russell had called a Joint Session of Congress to meet ASAP (next morning). Then less calmly, they announced what they most ominously didn't know: the full extent of American losses, largely because every successive report every few minutes was worse than the last.
 
Not sure what the heck just happened or where, but I do hope this TL doesn't suddenly go all AANW on us. I've been really enjoying the subtle intrigue and world building...
 
Last edited:
No I don't think it will become WW3 (or least I hope not)
Well, if you mean the USSR attacking the US, then yeah, maybe not. I mean, considering that the USSR itself is focused on achieving its initial goal of throwing out Tito, has repeatedly showed a strong desire to avoid opening new fronts (with the exception of Finland), that it has only just started to catch up in nuclear weapons and its next generation strategic bombers, slbms etc are still largely in the pipeline, it's really hard to see any scenario where it decides on attacking the USA directly, assuming it even can. A big if.

On the other hand, there is a cornucopia of militant, radical people in this world who could and might do something very unexpected. And I have a suspicion that somewhere, somehow, some proverbial shit just hit a fan.
 
Well, if you mean the USSR attacking the US, then yeah, maybe not. I mean, considering that the USSR itself is focused on achieving its initial goal of throwing out Tito, has repeatedly showed a strong desire to avoid opening new fronts (with the exception of Finland), that it has only just started to catch up in nuclear weapons and its next generation strategic bombers, slbms etc are still largely in the pipeline, it's really hard to see any scenario where it decides on attacking the USA directly, assuming it even can. A big if.

On the other hand, there is a cornucopia of militant, radical people in this world who could and might do something very unexpected. And I have a suspicion that somewhere, somehow, some proverbial shit just hit a fan.

First person to guess where shit completely hit the fan wins an imaginary cookie. :) Personally, I think there are three obvious places to guess (one of them is right).

As weird as it sounds, I actually think I'm a pretty fluffy, optimistic writer, despite the fact that almost every update is about something awful something happening somewhere, just OTL probably had on net average, even more awful things happening.
 
Will we get updates in Africa, especially with the newly independent sub-Saharan states and the Algerian independence movement?

"Will we get xxx" questions are a lot like Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle, because asking the question tends to change the answer (from a no to a yes). And I mean that in a good way, because I often do wonder "hmm, I wonder if I'm forgetting an update for something I shouldn't be forgetting" and then a helpful reader reminds me! So yes!

I am surprised North Japan didn't try to expand during the Spring of Rage.

North Japan doesn't really have a combined arms army. They have a large militia infantry army (like Finland), but they rely on the Soviet garrison for aerial and armored support, so they've really got to run any war plan through with the Soviets, as seen below.

Historical Soviet Response to North Japanese War Proposal (Colorized)
cdc.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top