I Am Not A Crook
Watergate and the wiretapping never occurs. As such, Nixon is never forced to resign
37(first term): Richard Nixon/Spiro Agnew(1969-1973)
-Election of 1972: Richard Nixon/Spiro Agnew(Republican) vs Hubert Humphrey/Edmund Muskie(Democrat)[1]
37(second term): Richard Nixon(1973-1977)/Spiro Agnew(1973)[2], Gerald Ford(1973-1977)
-Election of 1976: Ronald Reagan/John Connally(Republican) vs Henry M Jackson/Carl Albert(Democrat)
38(first term): Ronald Reagan/John Connally(1977-1981)
-Election of 1980: Ronald Reagan/John Connally(Republican) vs Ted Kennedy/Frank Church(Democrat)
39(first term): Ted Kennedy/Frank Church(1981-1985)[3]
-Election of 1984: Ted Kennedy/Jesse Jackson(Democrat) vs George HW Bush/John B Anderson(Republican)
39(second term): Ted Kennedy/Jesse Jackson(1985-1989)
-Election of 1988: Jesse Jackson/Bill Clinton(Democrat) vs George HW Bush/Dan Quayle(Repulican)
40(first term): Jesse Jackson/Bill Clinton(1989-1993)
-Election of 1992: Jesse Jackson/Bill Clinton(Democrat) vs Paul Laxalt/George W Bush(Republican)
41(first term): Paul Laxalt/George W Bush[4](1993-1997)
-Election of 1996: Paul Laxalt/Steve Forbes(Republican) vs Al Gore/Paul Tsongas(Democrat) vs Donald Trump/Pat Buchanan(Independent)
41(second term): Paul Laxalt/Steve Forbes(1997-2001)
Abridged guide
* Died, ** Assassinated, *** Resigned
[1] Consequence of no wiretapping or Watergate, but Arthur Bremer still shooting Wallace
[2] Agnew's scandal originates from before his vice presidency, so he still resigns. The difference being that his scandal gets a bit more attention
[3] Church died during his vice presidency
[4] Dubya got bored of the vice presidency and went against being renominated
37: Richard Nixon(1969-1977)/Spiro Agnew***(1969-1973), Gerald Ford(1973-1977)
38: Ronald Reagan/John Connally(1977-1981)
39: Ted Kennedy/Jesse Jackson(1981-1989)
40: Jesse Jackson/Bill Clinton(1989-1993)
41: Paul Laxalt(1993-2001)/George W Bush(1993-1997), Steve Forbes(1997-2001)
Who Watches The Watchmen
A stab at the elections in the Watchmen Universe. Presumably the first two are the same, as RFK was still assassinated in this universe and the impetus for the Watergate scandal occurred, though the Comedian stopped people from finding out. And Gerald Ford is apparently still Nixon's VP. Minor Doomsday Clock spoilers
37(second term): Richard Nixon/Spiro Agnew(1973-1977)
-Election of 1976: Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(Republican) vs Ronald Reagan/Jimmy Carter(Democrat)
37(third term): Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(1977-1981)
-Election of 1980: Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(Republican) vs Jerry Brown/Lyndon LaRouche(Democrat)
37(fourth term): Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(1981-1985)
-Election of 1984: Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(Republican) vs Geraldine Ferraro/Jesse Jackson(Democrat)
37(fifth term): Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford(1985-1989)[2]
-Election of 1988: Robert Redford/Donald Trump(Republican)[3] vs Ronald Reagan/George W Bush(Democrat)[4]
38(first term): Robert Redford/Donald Trump(1989-199X)[5]
-Election of 1992: Robert Redford/Donald Trump(Republican) vs Nancy Reagan/Bill Clinton(Democrat)[6]
Abridged list
[1] As a consequence of the differences in the Watchmen timeline, Reagan remains a Democrat. As per Watchmen canon, thanks to Edward Blake and Dr Manhattan. Agnew's scandal doesn't occur/is covered up, but Nixon still drops him as he was tempted to IOTL 1972.
[2] Without Dr Manhattan or the Comedian's influence, Nixon isn't able to run a sixth time.
[3] This is a nod to how in Doomsday Clock, Redford is a thinly veiled allegory of Donald Trump(clearly the DC writers aren't fond of him).
[4] George HW Bush is still a Republican here, but his son isn't. Reagan was apparently running for president in '88 in Watchmen. A cowboy actor and a cowboy
[5] Latest point in the Watchmen timeline is November 22 or 23 1992, his first term isn't over yet
[6] Nod to a First Lady Hillary Clinton running, using another Clinton as his running mate and an OTL First Lady, Nancy, being the nominee. Redford won, of course
- 37: Richard Nixon(1969-1989)/Spiro Agnew(1969-1977), Gerald Ford(1977-1989)
- 38: Robert Redford/Donald Trump(1989-199X)