Sir John Valentine Carden Survives. Part 2.

24 December 1941. Singapore.
24 December 1941. Singapore.

The first DM (Durban-Malaya) convoy had arrived with a heavy escort. The RAF Buffaloes and Fleet Air Arm Sea Hurricanes provided an umbrella over the troopships and Motor Transport freighters. The activity in the harbour was best described as frenetic. The first priority was to get the men of 18th Infantry Divisional Troops off the ships and into their holding areas. The Divisional HQ; Intelligence Corps; three field regiments, anti-tank regiment and light AA regiment of the Royal Artillery; three Royal Engineers Field Companies and Field Park Company; the Royal Signals; RASC; RAOC; RAMC; MPs; a machine gun battalion; The RAC’s 18th Reconnaissance Battalion. As well as the divisional troops, 53rd Infantry Brigade was on board: it was a lot of men to be sorted and moved.

The other two Infantry Brigades (54th and 55th) with their own support units were on the next part of the convoy. A full Infantry Division contained over 17000 men, but the convoy had also carried 7th Bn RTR (58 Matilda II) and an extra Royal Artillery Medium Regiment and Heavy AA Regiment, along with various RN, Army and RAF replacements, almost 20000 men altogether. All these men carried off the ships just their own duffel bag and personal weapons. All the weapons and equipment that made the men into the fighting force, including over 4000 vehicles, needed to be unloaded and that would take time.

The crated Tomahawks for the RAF were being prioritised. The RAF had learned from the arrival of the Buffaloes earlier in the year that it would take time to uncrate the aircraft, put them together, test fly them and train the pilots on them. All this would come to naught if they were destroyed on the ground by Japanese air raids. The crates would be taken to a number of different locations where the work could be carried out in some semblance of safety.

HMS Ark Royal was currently on a run between Ceylon and Port Sudan to pick up RAF Hurricanes to be flown off directly to Singapore. HMS Formidable sailing from the Mediterranean would join her, they expected to arrive with almost 100 Hurricanes between them at by the middle of January. HMS Formidable would return to the Mediterranean fleet after ferrying the Hurricanes. HMS Illustrious had started her journey from North America but was in a collision with HMS Indomitable while sailing together. They would both sail for the UK for repairs, with both carriers eventually joining the Eastern Fleet. HMS Indomitable was supposed to replace HMS Ark Royal in Gibraltar, but HMS Furious would do so after her refit in America.

Ships carrying crated Martlet IIs (G-36Bs with folding wings) sailed in August 1941, with 36 shipped to the UK and 54 shipped to the Far East. At Ceylon these aircraft were being prepared and Fleet Air Arm pilots training on them, to become the fighter squadrons on HMS Ark Royal and to defend Ceylon. HMS Illustrious and Indomitable would also have those Martlets shipped to the UK as their fighter squadrons when they sailed for Ceylon after repairs.

Admiral Phillips was waiting for more reinforcements including HMS Warspite coming from Alexandria to replace HMS Barham. Four R Class battleships, Ramillies, Resolution, Revenge and Royal Sovereign along with HMS Hermes, which was at Durban being refitted, were all expected in Ceylon around March, for all the good Admiral Phillips thought they would do. HMS Repulse was in the dry dock in Singapore having emergency repairs, she was expected to sail with the empty merchant ships when they left Singapore. The battlecruiser was likely to need a longer time for repairs, which would probably mean sailing to the United States.

Major-General Merton Beckwith-Smith (GOC 18th Infantry Division) was glad to get off the ship and onto dry land. With his senior staff they went for an immediate meeting with Lieutenant-Generals Percival and Mackay, who were to be his Commanding Officer and Corps Commander respectively. Mackay had been responsible for the planning for the men of 18th Division coming off the ships, the Australians had learned a lot from the arrival of their own 9th Division.

Since he’d sailed from Durban two weeks earlier, Beckwith-Smith hadn’t had much in the way of news of how things were going with the Japanese. The situation in Hong Kong was terrible, Percival thought that the end would come in a day or two at most. Percival’s senior intelligence officer gave a briefing of the current situation in Malaya and Borneo. Mackay laid out his plan for 8th and 9th Australian and 18th Division. The two Australian Divisions had been working hard on training and preparing defences to protect Johore. He wanted Beckwith-Smith’s men to have time to regain their fitness, and then have some jungle training and exercises so that they’d be in the best possible shape for the fight to come. To enable this 18th Division would stay on Singapore island in the first instance. There were some defensive preparations they would have to make. Should there be a failure to hold Johore having 18th Division prepared to defend the island, it would give the Australians, and whatever was left of the Indian Corps, somewhere to fall back to.

Mackay believed that if the Indians could continue to bleed the Japanese as they had been doing, by the time the Australians were on the front line, the Japanese would have shot their bolt. Then 18th Division would be Mackay’s choice to begin the counter-attack, pushing the Japanese back up the Malaya peninsula. Beckwith-Smith had some questions, but was generally happy with the plan. He had been training his men since July 1940, training and hard work was something they were well used to. Having a clear role to prepare for, both defensively and offensively, gave the Major General a chance to show how far his Second Line Territorial Army Division had come and just exactly what they would be able to do.
 
58 more Matilda IIs (on top of everything else)? The Japanese are suffering already, that's just going to put the cap on it.
 
Last edited:
honestly the matildas are probably the most important part of the convoy . Could be sent to help indians even if they are used to guranatee retreats and stuff and be rather used up in that role.

Still think maybe sending the current churchill tank brigade with maybe another matilda brigade maybe from the uk would still be a good idea. Especially if the pom-poms are reequipped for like half of them maybe ?
 
Mackay isn't wrong we would have to see an IJA perspective but given what I know the IJA is getting the shit kicked out of it with minimal resupply in a situation were the pressure isn't coming off any time soon with no real ability short of heavy guns which they can't make a lot of to deal with the Matilda's due to an even more messed up supply situation back in the home islands.

It isn't a good day to be a Japanese conscripts, NCO or Officer. They are very fast getting spent trying to beat a brick wall bloody.
 
58 more Matilda IIs (on top of everything else)? The Japanese are suffering already, that's just going to put the cap on it.
9th Australian Division are there, I just noticed.
The Imperial Japanese... well this is the Australian division they're facing which held Tobruk for months on end against the Axis in the original timeline, and played a big part, as I understand it, in sucking in and breaking the Axis reserves in the north at second El Alamein.
I don't have the words (or at least not ones which are compatible with forum rules) at the moment to describe adequately how much trouble the Imperial Japanese are in if they have their original timeline objectives and only their original timeline forces.
 
yes thats why i suspect that some things might get sucked into the malaya theater rather than extensive adventures in the pacific to try take singapore is my thought considering the somewhat limited pod .
 
I don't have the words (or at least not ones which are compatible with forum rules) at the moment to describe adequately how much trouble the Imperial Japanese are in if they have their original timeline objectives and only their original timeline forces.
There's another factor as well. The Government of Siam must be starting to wonder if they've backed the wrong horse with the attack on Malaya bogging down and the likely behaviour of their Japanese allies towards the Siamese population. It won't be the Japanese that are clearing the ledge and they won't be gentle encouraging the locals to do it.
 
Last edited:
24 December 1941. Singapore.

The first DM (Durban-Malaya) convoy had arrived with a heavy escort. The RAF Buffaloes and Fleet Air Arm Sea Hurricanes provided an umbrella over the troopships and Motor Transport freighters. The activity in the harbour was best described as frenetic. The first priority was to get the men of 18th Infantry Divisional Troops off the ships and into their holding areas. The Divisional HQ; Intelligence Corps; three field regiments, anti-tank regiment and light AA regiment of the Royal Artillery; three Royal Engineers Field Companies and Field Park Company; the Royal Signals; RASC; RAOC; RAMC; MPs; a machine gun battalion; The RAC’s 18th Reconnaissance Battalion. As well as the divisional troops, 53rd Infantry Brigade was on board: it was a lot of men to be sorted and moved.

The other two Infantry Brigades (54th and 55th) with their own support units were on the next part of the convoy. A full Infantry Division contained over 17000 men, but the convoy had also carried 7th Bn RTR (58 Matilda II) and an extra Royal Artillery Medium Regiment and Heavy AA Regiment, along with various RN, Army and RAF replacements, almost 20000 men altogether. All these men carried off the ships just their own duffel bag and personal weapons. All the weapons and equipment that made the men into the fighting force, including over 4000 vehicles, needed to be unloaded and that would take time.

The crated Tomahawks for the RAF were being prioritised. The RAF had learned from the arrival of the Buffaloes earlier in the year that it would take time to uncrate the aircraft, put them together, test fly them and train the pilots on them. All this would come to naught if they were destroyed on the ground by Japanese air raids. The crates would be taken to a number of different locations where the work could be carried out in some semblance of safety.

HMS Ark Royal was currently on a run between Ceylon and Port Sudan to pick up RAF Hurricanes to be flown off directly to Singapore. HMS Formidable sailing from the Mediterranean would join her, they expected to arrive with almost 100 Hurricanes between them at by the middle of January. HMS Formidable would return to the Mediterranean fleet after ferrying the Hurricanes. HMS Illustrious had started her journey from North America but was in a collision with HMS Indomitable while sailing together. They would both sail for the UK for repairs, with both carriers eventually joining the Eastern Fleet. HMS Indomitable was supposed to replace HMS Ark Royal in Gibraltar, but HMS Furious would do so after her refit in America.

Ships carrying crated Martlet IIs (G-36Bs with folding wings) sailed in August 1941, with 36 shipped to the UK and 54 shipped to the Far East. At Ceylon these aircraft were being prepared and Fleet Air Arm pilots training on them, to become the fighter squadrons on HMS Ark Royal and to defend Ceylon. HMS Illustrious and Indomitable would also have those Martlets shipped to the UK as their fighter squadrons when they sailed for Ceylon after repairs.

Admiral Phillips was waiting for more reinforcements including HMS Warspite coming from Alexandria to replace HMS Barham. Four R Class battleships, Ramillies, Resolution, Revenge and Royal Sovereign along with HMS Hermes, which was at Durban being refitted, were all expected in Ceylon around March, for all the good Admiral Phillips thought they would do. HMS Repulse was in the dry dock in Singapore having emergency repairs, she was expected to sail with the empty merchant ships when they left Singapore. The battlecruiser was likely to need a longer time for repairs, which would probably mean sailing to the United States.

Major-General Merton Beckwith-Smith (GOC 18th Infantry Division) was glad to get off the ship and onto dry land. With his senior staff they went for an immediate meeting with Lieutenant-Generals Percival and Mackay, who were to be his Commanding Officer and Corps Commander respectively. Mackay had been responsible for the planning for the men of 18th Division coming off the ships, the Australians had learned a lot from the arrival of their own 9th Division.

Since he’d sailed from Durban two weeks earlier, Beckwith-Smith hadn’t had much in the way of news of how things were going with the Japanese. The situation in Hong Kong was terrible, Percival thought that the end would come in a day or two at most. Percival’s senior intelligence officer gave a briefing of the current situation in Malaya and Borneo. Mackay laid out his plan for 8th and 9th Australian and 18th Division. The two Australian Divisions had been working hard on training and preparing defences to protect Johore. He wanted Beckwith-Smith’s men to have time to regain their fitness, and then have some jungle training and exercises so that they’d be in the best possible shape for the fight to come. To enable this 18th Division would stay on Singapore island in the first instance. There were some defensive preparations they would have to make. Should there be a failure to hold Johore having 18th Division prepared to defend the island, it would give the Australians, and whatever was left of the Indian Corps, somewhere to fall back to.

Mackay believed that if the Indians could continue to bleed the Japanese as they had been doing, by the time the Australians were on the front line, the Japanese would have shot their bolt. Then 18th Division would be Mackay’s choice to begin the counter-attack, pushing the Japanese back up the Malaya peninsula. Beckwith-Smith had some questions, but was generally happy with the plan. He had been training his men since July 1940, training and hard work was something they were well used to. Having a clear role to prepare for, both defensively and offensively, gave the Major General a chance to show how far his Second Line Territorial Army Division had come and just exactly what they would be able to do.
This is a very good focused TL.
Keep up the good work old chap.
Also Threadmark!
 

Ramp-Rat

Monthly Donor
And that is the principal advantage that the British have, a fully functional major port, through which they can stream resources and men. And the ability to draw on other areas for the resources and men that they require. Once the Japanese invasion has stalled, the advantages will always be with the British, who have a depth of resources and men, that while minor in comparison to that which the Americans have, is basically gigantic in comparison to those available to the Japanese.

RR.
 
That's lot of reinforcements. OTL, the bulk of the 18th division didn't arrived until early February, just in time to get enveloped in the final disaster on Singapore Island. It's not looking good for the Japanese 25th Army, who now have a full-strength Corps waiting for them when/if they manage to batter their way through the Indian divisions holding north Malaya.

Interesting that the British are still planning to establish their second defence line on Johore. That would mean withdrawing from most of the peninsula - including Penang, Kuala Lumpur and Kuantan as well as most of the tin and rubber-producing areas - rather than send their fresh units north. It's a decent strategy if the IJA can be relied to come charging south and then wreck themselves against a prepared defence line, but what if they dig in in front of Johore and settle down to siege/starve the defenders out? That's a lot of people in Singapore dependent on the convoys continuing to get through.
 
Interesting that the British are still planning to establish their second defence line on Johore
It's good training and helps acclimatise the new arrivals to local conditions. They probably won't need it now but it's better to have and not need than need and not have.
 
The IJA only got as far as they did from the supplies they got from the British, supplies they will not be getting now.
 

Ramp-Rat

Monthly Donor
So the Japanese invasion of the Island of Borneo is encountering more resistance and more successful resistance, than it did IOTL. Will this enable the Dutch and British to prevent a successful invasion, that is a decision that’s up to the author. I personally believe that given the present situation and the strain that both the Dutch and British are under, the priorities that they have, and the lack of infrastructure and resources, the Japanese will eventually succeed. However this will be at a much higher cost than it was IOTL, and allow both the Dutch and British to carry out a far more effective policy of destruction of the oil industry in Borneo. And providing that Malaya, Singapore, Java and Sumatra, remain in British and Dutch hands, Borneo will become a bleeding sore, of Anglo-Dutch directed insurgency, in the next few years. And the more that the Japanese try to suppress it, with their normal strong arm methods, the greater the resistance will become. This invasion is without doubt going to add more grit into the Japanese war effort, for in the end little to no return. The Japanese IOTL didn’t gain a great bonanza of resources from Borneo, as they didn’t have the resources themselves to exploit it fully. And ITTL I would expect that it’s going to cost them far more than they ever benefit. The basic problem for the Japanese is the same as the basic problem was for the Germans, they allowed themselves to project on to their enemy, their belief of how they would respond to their situation. Hitler and his gang believed that Britain would after the fall of France, make peace with Germany, as being morally, weak money grabbers controlled by secret Jewish bankers, they would make a deal. In the same way the Japanese establishment, believing that they were morally superior to the decedent western powers, whose people didn’t have the fortitude of the Japanese. Would quickly sue for peace, despite the historical record of the two nations. Britain could have easily gotten a peace treaty with Napoleon or the Kaiser, but chose to fight on at great cost financially and in WWI personally, until finally victory. President Lincoln, could have brokered a peace treaty with the Confederates, and was under some pressure to do so, but chose to continue the fight, in what turned out to be the most costly war on a personal level, that American has ever fought. And now they are truly stuck to a very, in the case of the British upset nation, and in the case of the Americans enraged nation, tar baby.

RR.
 
24 December 1941. Singapore.
Missing Threadmark.
There's another factor as well. The Government of Siam must be starting to wonder if they've backed the wrong horse with the attack on Malaya bogging down and the likely behaviour of their Japanese allies towards the Siamese population. It won't be the Japanese that are clearing the ledge and they won't be gentle encouraging the locals to do it.
Theydo have the advantage that they were invaded. Somehow, I doubt they will be declaring war on the Allies this time around.
 
There's also a second major port in the region, that being Batavia (Jakarta today), which should also be able to operate a fairly submarine force.
 
@allanpcameron

Given the air attacks on Force Z, will the British be undertaking emergency refit of ships (especially the R-Class) with additional light AAA? Obviously the TTL world you've created is very different than OTL and so leaders will have different choices to make based on different availability.

Cheers, Matthew. 🍻
 
Top