That’s is basically what Eurofed actually said, when you strip away all the layers.
That's what Eurofed basically says about the victory of Napoleon or Kaiser Bill, not Hitler or Stalin.
Well a TL evolving a hegemonic Kaiser Bill or non-Nazi Germany wouldn’t be objectionable, but Eurofed picks the Axis, comes up with contorted leaps of logic to hand-wave the Nazi’s only 100% consist feature (I.E batshit homicidal insanity).
That's a gross distortion of what I've written. In my Axis victory TL, Nazi genocidal drives get fulfilled to the hilt. As a matter of fact, the Lebensraum gets expanded to the Arab world. I just assumed that they would soon become somewhat smart killers (i.e. they don't kill the Slav/Arab slaves till they have the Aryan settlers to replace them), out of sheer economic necessity.
The TL does not whitewash victorious Nazism by stripping away their genocidal urges, although over time they become much more the expression of imperialist ruthlessness carried to far-end extremes (i.e. we murder you to steal your land and resources for all time, dead people don't rebel or come back to reconquer what they lost) and much less the expression of the racist batshit insanity that drove the genocide of the Jews (i.e. we murder you because we think you are talking rabid dogs).
It is true that ITTL other batshit insane aspects of Nazifascism (e.g. the pseudoscience) get discarded over time, but they were relatively peripheral to the ideology and the ruling circles of the regime, and much less important to both than the Lebensraum.
Then presents to outcome as a bit messy but compared to OTL almost a tie.
That's the product of my historical observation that over time, totalitarian regimes tend to mellow, and the North Koreas seem to be the exception, not the rule, and my reasoning that the Nazi would have had no really valid reason to be radically different. I mean, Maoism had doses of batshit insanity wholly comparable to Nazism (ask Pol Pot), yet its main expression has managed to evolve into a fairly sensible and relatively "soft" version of authoritarianism.
I have applied the same standard to my TL's fascist Europe. The genocidal urges get more or less fulfilled, but they were never aimed to "Aryan" Western Europe (unless you happen to be saddled with a major genetic disorder or incurable major disability, then your survival chances in TTL Europe approach zero, until biotechnologies develop enough to be a feasible alternative).
Over time, the world is indeed left to deal with a superpower that may be sane enough to heed MAD constraints throughout Cold War and in the end mellow enough to give up direct colonial control of Africa and western Asia and allow some serious detente, but built its cities over the mass graves of European, North African, and Middle Eastern Jews, Slavs, and Arabs, and is unrepentant about it. And there is not much that the rest of the world may do about it, since (post-)fascist Europe is a frigging nuclear superpower. In this regard, the evil guys won.
Apart from that, ITTL North America and Oceania basically achieve a tie with OTL, Latin America does rather better, India achieves a tie, Africa is somewhat worse than OTL but basically the usual screw-up in the end (since the Nazi don't get to enact Lebensraum there, it would have been hard even for them to make things much worse than OTL after they pull out, although they were terribly harsh slavemasters while they stay), China moderately worse (the Japanese were very harsh slavemasters but it is hard even for them to make things much worse than Mao, and eventually they pull out, so China has a chance to recover, but not yet to OTL levels), SE Asia rather worse, Western Europe and Japan may or may not be a basic tie with OTL depending on what you look at and value more, Eastern Europe and the Arab world are screwed into oblivion and replaced with an extension of Western Europe, Siberia, Central Asia, and Persia are rather worse than OTL.
In other Nazi victory TL‘s; such as CalBear’s. Nazi Europe is presented has the horrific dytopia it invariably would be (in fact I think CalBear was a bit optimistic). In Eurofed’s case Nazi Europe is presented as being only slightly dysfunctional in some areas but generally a good place to live. It is presented in fact as a somewhat desirable outcome.
My TL was purposefully written to be the polar opposite outcome of Calbear's (within reason, of course). Calbear's Nazi empire is a rather typical but well-reasoned example of "wicked, lucky, and dumb" Nazi, which somewhat luck their way into winning WWII, but fatally shot themselves into foot soon afterwards with dumb batshit insanity.
My TL is meant to be a well-reasoned example of "wicked, lucky, and smart" Nazi, which keep all of their basic homicidal urges, get enough luck to win WWII, but gradually evolve out of dumb batshit insanity, become sufficiently efficient at running an empire, and evolve in a direction much like Maoist China or Soviet Russia. Fascist Europe eventually grows to be a place which is more or less as good or bad to live in as modern China or Late/Post Soviet Russia (with a more efficient economy), out of the pressures of reality clashing with ideology. They went and built their continental superstate on the mass graves of Slavs and Arabs, although sheer imperial overstretch exhaustion, resources limitation, and unconscious collective satiety at mass murder made them eventually give up further expansion of Lebensraum in Asia and Africa. It is however anyone's guess what availability of increasingly powerful biotechnologies may do to their collective psyche in the 21st century.
As I see it, both TLs are examples of possible outcomes for the same basic scenario.
This is either a result of Eurofed’s own ideological sympathies or an impressively elaborate display of trolling.
Actually, this is the result of trying to write a best case scenario for the Axis. Calbear has been already writing a well-written TL where the Nazi build a continental WarPact/North Korea hybrid and dumbly make themselves sitting ducks for the heroic Yanquis comeback that saves Europe by destroying it soon afterwards the apparent victory of the Nazis. I meant to do something quite different and much more akin to a real Cold War between Fascism and Democracy. This required to manage butterflies so that the fascist block becomes efficient enough to be a credible long-term opponent to the Western block.
About the last bit of unwarranted attack, I knew there was a good reason why I had put you in my ignore list.
But other, nicer people had expressed interest on a comment of mine about the argument UF made, so here it is. I'm not however much interested on derailing CB's fine TL thread with a lengthy and in all likelihood flamey discussion of my TL's merits, or lack thereof, especially with a guy I've already put in my ignore list.
The Nazis put all their pseudo-science Deutsche Physik bollocks behind them, even though it had just "won them the war", in their eyes at least,
Since when in my TL, or in any non-ASB Axis victory TL for that matter, the Nazi won by using Vril-powered death rays and Atlantean spells ??? Victory in WWII by usual, real-world means is not going to convince guys like Goering, Speer, Manstein, and Rommel that the pseudoscience crap peddled by Himmler's occultist flunkies has any merit.
Moreover, Nazi committment to pseudoscience is often overblown beyond reality. Hitler and the rest of Nazi bigwigs had little ideological trouble establishing a nuclear research program, so Nazi dislike of "Jewish Science" had definite limits even IOTL.
and Nazi disregard for petty morality and ethics meant that genetic sciences were decades ahead of OTL, despite the fact that many capable scientists would have been killed, there would have probably been a distinct lack of investment, and that many senior Nazis were into all kinds of unscientific bullshit
I remember that one, it was ASB, there were assumptions that technology would be developed in the 50's that was somehow decades ahead of early 21st century technology. I dunno where such logic came from. Simply allowing uninhibited human testing does not guarantee drastically faster results.
Actually my intention in that thread was to define how much TTL
early 21st century biotechnologies might become more advanced than OTL thanks to Nazi disregard of medical ethic and enthusiasm for eugenetics. I never meant that they would become available in the 1950s, far from it.
Even so, my initial assumptions about the issue were admittedly a tad optimistic, but that was the effect of my fanboy enthusiasm for genetic engineering. I have long since restricted myself to follow the productive and reasoned advice of a TL commentor who seems to have real-world experience with the field and a constructive attitude to the scenario, and which already helped me settle some thorny demographic issues about the extent of Lebensraum colonization.
By the way, those Nazi bigwigs heavily invested into pseudoscience were essentially Himmler, and my expectation is that in the most likely case, he suffers a Beria or Jiang Qing fate as soon as Hitler dies soon after the war. The guy was loathed by most other Nazi bigwigs, and the army hated his guts.