"Our Struggle": What If Hitler Had Been a Communist?

20201210-183555.jpg
I am sorry, but I laughed out loud when I saw your picture. The man in the picture is Józef Piłsudski. Literally, the father of the Second Polish Republic. He fought against the Soviets during the Polish-Soviet War. I am not aware if he had any special animosity towards Communists, but he most certainly would be horrified by the idea of a German/Soviet Alliance. An Alliance that would have Poland enclosed by two powerful enemies with historical and current animosity towards Poland. In fact, in real life, he had spent most of his later life preparing for war against either Germany or the Soviet Union.

In fact, he should still alive in 1934, but he will soon be dead in less than a year. Interestingly, RL Hitler had considerable respect for Józef Piłsudski. Hitler would often claim that the invasion of Poland would have been unnecessary if Piłsudski had lived. And Hitler had tried to reach out to him to establish an alliance against the USSR, which Piłsudski always refused. In fact, after the invasion of Poland, Hitler had german guards placed to protect Piłsudski's tomb.

I would imagine that Red Hitler would not be fond of Piłsudski and he would be already planning the division of Poland with Stalin. While Piłsudski would be deeply worried for his nation's future as now Poland has two powerful enemies to contend with. Red Germany on the Western Border and the Soviet Union on the Eastern Border.

 
Last edited:
The world is changing. Who now has the strength to stand against the armies of Germany and Russia, to stand against the might of Stalin and Hitler in the union of the Red Banners. Together, General Secretary, we shall conquer this continent of Europe. The old world will burn in the fires of industry. Their palaces will fall. A new order will rise, we will drive the machine of war with the sword and the bayonet and the iron fist of the proletariat!
1607627222905.png
(one would need to edit the German flag a bit)
 
Chapter CXXV
From great inequality of fortunes and conditions, from the vast variety of passions and of talents, of useless and pernicious arts, of vain sciences, would arise a multitude of prejudices equally contrary to reason, happiness and virtue. We should see the magistrates fomenting everything that might weaken men united in society, by promoting dissension among them; everything that might sow in it the seeds of actual division, while it gave society the air of harmony; everything that might inspire the different ranks of people with mutual hatred and distrust, by setting the rights and interests of one against those of another, and so strengthen the power which comprehended them all.


~ Jean Jacques Rousseau, On the Origin of the Inequality of Mankind










download.jpeg









Santa Palomba transmitter, Rome; Shortly after





“As we have seen, the fascist aggression can only be met with the same violence they would inflict on the German worker. Their attacks across the border began again last night, we have been returning fire since 2 AM. From now on bullet will be met with bullet, shell will be met with shell-”



The Crown Prince Wilhelm, head of the House of Hohenzollern, took another sip of his coffee and smiled. Hitler had developed his ability to broadcast vitriol over the airwaves for over a decade, he had no doubt this new act of defiance being broadcast across Europe was scripted to time with the sudden outbreak of skirmishes across the Italian border. He had underestimated the man as an adversary beforehand but no longer.


This news had come alongside similar reports of firefights in France, Hungary and Poland. Scattered on their own but together, enough to paint a picture of Germany under siege.

In regards to the news of shooting in the vicinity of the Brenner Pass, Mussolini was yet to respond with his usual bombast, casting doubt on Hitler’s aspersions about a coordinated fascist offensive. The Crown Prince had no doubt the Duce was currently just trying to figure out what was going on before responding.

The increasingly confused activities of the United Front were perplexing to many and the Crown Prince would not have begrudged Mussolini’s confusion. Indeed, he held the Italian dictator in high regard, with him having been a generous host in accommodating the Hohenzollern family after the Third Reich debacle had forced their flight from Germany. Since then their lands and fortune had been expropriated by the United Front. They had few means but Mussolini had provided them with a luxurious existence at the expense of the Italian state, with an easy line of credit. It was charity which the Crown Prince aimed to repay one day.

To this end he had looked to establish a government-in-exile after von Seeckt’s assurances that he must lay low seemed to be leading to little practical action on behalf of German patriots. Von Seeckt himself and many other potential followers of the Crown Prince’s cause had left Europe altogether for the opportunities offered by the new world but he refused to leave his empire behind and as such he had looked into seeking recognition for himself as the true leader of Germany. Mussolini hadn’t been willing to go this far with his support, however he had been decent enough to send his son-in-law Ciano, now Head of the Government Press Office, to meet with the Crown Prince once more.

Ciano had explained that the breaking-off of all diplomatic relations with Berlin was not advisable. If he was ever to become Kaiser through Italian help then Italy would need to be strong and that strength was only enabled by the German trade which helped to grow the Italian economy.

The Crown Prince had been frustrated by having his dedication to duty be tempered by such clerical matters but it seemed the recent events in France and subsequently in Germany had allowed for a change of tact on behalf of his Italian hosts. It appeared that the republic was about to fall entirely to Bolshevism much as he had warned before and his request to make an appeal to German patriots to resist such a direction was now given the green light.

It was for this reason that he was now sitting leisurely in the waiting room of one of Europe’s most powerful radio transmitters, used by Italian state radio, to deliver a broadcast in German. Ciano had welcomed him there himself, having assured the Crown Prince that they were going to great lengths to ensure his broadcast would be heard by as many in Germany as possible. The script he had been given was more measured than the one he would ideally have liked to broadcast but it was a start. Where Mussolini dithered, the Crown Prince intended to show once again why leadership was in his breeding.

Hitler continued to outline the details of his outrage from the waiting room’s radio, elaborating on a conspiracy in which treacherous royals were mentioned more than once. The rhetoric made Hohenzollern smile further, Hitler wasn’t the only one who could utilise this technology and he would soon find that out when the Crown Prince himself took to the airwaves to set the record straight.

He saw Ciano arrive at the door, the Italian glancing awkwardly at his choice of programming, Hohenzollern turned it off for his benefit.



“Important to know what the Bolsheviks are up to if we’re to beat them at their own game. Wouldn’t you agree?”

“Quite, excellency. They’re ready for you now.” Ciano replied with an awkward deference.


“Wonderful, then let us shed some light at last!”


He was, of course, not entirely blind to how some of his future subjects viewed him. There were those who had tried to vote to expropriate his families lands even before the civil war and amongst his own supposed adherents there had been those like von Schleicher, who saw him as fit only to be a useless bauble to lend legitimacy to a regime whose power lay elsewhere. Since the events of the Third Reich had required him to flee he had been branded a pretty tyrant by the left and a feckless criminal by many on the right. It was enough to stoke a fire inside anyone but he knew that such impressions were temporary, he had been a prince across the water in worse circumstances. Now he had a chance to show he could lead once more.



Or, at the very least, he could cause a little chaos of his own.






---


The painting is Wanderer above the Sea of Fog by Caspar David Friedrich
 
Interestingly, this isn't a 1:1 parallel of Russia - while the Romanovs were terrible, they weren't fascists and were conceding more and more power to the forces of indirect democracy by the end of their reign, so the survival of Tsarist rule would have at least lacked some of the shortcomings of the USSR.
Enjoy your pogroms and crushing poverty I guess.
 
Enjoy your pogroms and crushing poverty I guess.

And kangaroo courts designed to sate the Tsar's blood libel conspiracy boner
I think he was just saying that an authoritarian regime that's more just vanilla conservative wouldn't do the exact same terrible things as one motivated by ideological extremism, which gives it a tiny step up. The government-directed ethnic oppression is aimed at Jews instead of Ukrainians, and the kangaroo courts are aimed at everyone but aristocrats as opposed to everyone but (certain) socialists. Again, not a big improvement, but there was at least the promise of glacial-slow reform and it was preferable if you were Ukrainian or an aristocrat.
 
The government-directed ethnic oppression is aimed at Jews instead of Ukrainians, and the kangaroo courts are aimed at everyone but aristocrats as opposed to everyone but (certain) socialists. Again, not a big improvement, but there was at least the promise of glacial-slow reform and it was preferable if you were Ukrainian or an aristocrat.
English is not my first language and I am a bit tired, but this part sounds like since it is only jews who are persecuted it is somehow not as bad
 
English is not my first language and I am a bit tired, but this part sounds like since it is only jews who are persecuted it is somehow not as bad
It's my tongue-in-cheek way of comparing Tsarist and Stalinist Russia being different flavours of awful. Persecution of Jews is terrible, but preferable to persecution of Ukrainians if you're Ukrainian.
 
It's my tongue-in-cheek way of comparing Tsarist and Stalinist Russia being different flavours of awful. Persecution of Jews is terrible, but preferable to persecution of Ukrainians if you're Ukrainian.
Stalinist Russia was terrible, but that's no excuse for Tsarist Russia being terrible. And the Tsarists didn't "only" persecute Jews, though even if that was true, it would be hardly a defence—or does it stand in praise of OTL Hitler's regime that "only" Jews, gypsies, homosexuals etc were attacked, while other Germans had "the trains run on time"? Everybody who wasn't an aristocrat was systematically disadvantaged, and that's not just a pretty word; when you think about famine and sickness it means loss of lives. Just look at what happened to life expectancy under the Soviets compared to the Romanov emperors and it tells you a lot. It's difficult for the human mind to comprehend how many serfs died pointless, easily avoidable deaths from lack of food or lack of medical treatment while the highborn relaxed in their dachas, in the crushing poverty and oppression of a regime that regarded people who weren't aristocrats as less than human.

Stalin does not deserve to be defended, so I won't defend him. He was a monster. No buts. Communism in Russia has millions of deaths at its door. That said, it is wide of the mark to suggest that Tsarist Russia was equally bad as the Soviet Union, let alone to suggest that it was better. Factually, as measured in numbers, considering the life of Joe Average in the two eras, the Tsarists were vastly worse. (I emphasise, this doesn't exonerate Stalin. If you're a mad axe-murderer and you can point to another mad axe-murderer who's killed more people than you, this doesn't make you not a mad axe-murderer.) But the Tsarists' sins were quiet and systematic and undramatic and the communists' sins were dramatic and direct and spectacular, so people don't talk about it very much.
 
Stalinist Russia was terrible, but that's no excuse for Tsarist Russia being terrible. And the Tsarists didn't "only" persecute Jews, though even if that was true, it would be hardly a defence—or does it stand in praise of OTL Hitler's regime that "only" Jews, gypsies, homosexuals etc were attacked, while other Germans had "the trains run on time"? Everybody who wasn't an aristocrat was systematically disadvantaged, and that's not just a pretty word; when you think about famine and sickness it means loss of lives. Just look at what happened to life expectancy under the Soviets compared to the Romanov emperors and it tells you a lot. It's difficult for the human mind to comprehend how many serfs died pointless, easily avoidable deaths from lack of food or lack of medical treatment while the highborn relaxed in their dachas, in the crushing poverty and oppression of a regime that regarded people who weren't aristocrats as less than human.

Stalin does not deserve to be defended, so I won't defend him. He was a monster. No buts. Communism in Russia has millions of deaths at its door. That said, it is wide of the mark to suggest that Tsarist Russia was equally bad as the Soviet Union, let alone to suggest that it was better. Factually, as measured in numbers, considering the life of Joe Average in the two eras, the Tsarists were vastly worse. (I emphasise, this doesn't exonerate Stalin. If you're a mad axe-murderer and you can point to another mad axe-murderer who's killed more people than you, this doesn't make you not a mad axe-murderer.) But the Tsarists' sins were quiet and systematic and undramatic and the communists' sins were dramatic and direct and spectacular, so people don't talk about it very much.
Reminds me of the Twain's writing on the French revolution:

Why, it was like reading about France and the French, before the ever memorable and blessed Revolution, which swept a thousand years of such villany away in one swift tidal-wave of blood--one: a settlement of that hoary debt in the proportion of half a drop of blood for each hogshead of it that had been pressed by slow tortures out of that people in the weary stretch of ten centuries of wrong and shame and misery the like of which was not to be mated but in hell.

There were two 'Reigns of Terror,' if we would but remember it and consider it; the one wrought murder in hot passion, the other in heartless cold blood; the one lasted mere months, the other had lasted a thousand years; the one inflicted death upon ten thousand persons, the other upon a hundred millions; but our shudders are all for the 'horrors' of the minor Terror, the momentary Terror, so to speak; whereas, what is the horror of swift death by the axe, compared with lifelong death from hunger, cold, insult, cruelty, and heart-break?

What is swift death by lightning compared with death by slow fire at the stake? A city cemetery could contain the coffins filled by that brief Terror which we have all been so diligently taught to shiver at and mourn over; but all France could hardly contain the coffins filled by that older and real Terror--that unspeakably bitter and awful Terror which none of us has been taught to see in its vastness or pity as it deserves.
 
I think he was just saying that an authoritarian regime that's more just vanilla conservative wouldn't do the exact same terrible things as one motivated by ideological extremism, which gives it a tiny step up. The government-directed ethnic oppression is aimed at Jews instead of Ukrainians, and the kangaroo courts are aimed at everyone but aristocrats as opposed to everyone but (certain) socialists. Again, not a big improvement, but there was at least the promise of glacial-slow reform and it was preferable if you were Ukrainian or an aristocrat.

And I'm saying it isn't a step up because the "vanilla conservatives" had their own massive hate boners. Swapping one group to hate on for another isn't an improvement unless you're antisemite.

It was also crushingly poor and without a plan to fix it.

Joining WW1 and getting a large chunk of the country killed over it was the cherry on top.
 
Allow me to reiterate my argument so that people don't accuse me of anti-semitism: I think that the Tsarist regime and the one that replaced it were both bloody and hateful, with the key differences being which minorities the state decided to persecute. From a standpoint of said minorities, you could understandably prefer the government that targets your people less, even if it doesn't make them any less morally reprehensible.

There is a poetic justice in a blood-soaked regime being washed away in a tide of blood, but I don't think massacring bad guys necessarily makes you a good guy. If Lenin and his successors had gone on to successfully build a worker's paradise without killing vast amounts of said workers, it'd certainly make their crimes they committed near the start much easier to forgive. As it was, instead of a true revolution, Russia only got a changing of the guard.
 
Last edited:
Chapter CXXVI
What is important is that the worker can say of the land in which he was born: It is my country, in which I can lead a free and happy life. It is important that in such a country the worker together with other workers exercise power, not the bourgeoisie that lives by exploiting the workers. The question of fatherland always was and is a class question. The worker’s fatherland cannot be a country where the last exploiting class on the planet lives, where the monopolists control the factories and slaughterhouses, the land, the army, the police, the courts, the press, radio, and television. The fatherland of the workers, farmers, and productive people is where he is free of exploitation and slavery, where the working people rule, united under the leadership of the working class and its revolutionary party. It is where the government serves the good of the people and the happiness of mankind. Only such a fatherland is worthy to be defended.


~ Heinz Hoffman, The Meaning of Being a Soldier






1608052207636.png









Luftstreitkräfte Flugplatz, Stolp; July 1934






Johann rubbed his eyes wearily in contemplating the maps he had laid out in front of him. The entire country was preparing itself for the worst and it seemed the Luftstreitkräfte might end up being on active duty far sooner than he thought. It was important to be ready.



There was a certain anticipation to the prospect of going up in the air into combat once more. The crackle of gunfire which could occasionally be heard from the Polish border had already given the airfield a sense of impending conflict in the preceding days. It left everyone on the base on-edge, a feeling those belonging to the new German air force had hoped to be free from with the revelation of their existence, only for events to leave Europe teetering on the edge of a cliff.


He liked to think Germany having an air force had made the fascists more apprehensive about an all-out attack, hence why the aggression had been limited to skirmishes so far, but there was a creeping fear that they were only waiting for certain stars to align. The sudden reappearance of the Crown Prince had felt like such a moment. His message over the airwaves to the German people, vaguely calling for them to stand in opposition to what he had claimed was a Bolshevik coup, could easily have been an activation order to the groups Hitler had spent the last few weeks warning everyone about. Chaotic figures similar to the strange creature he had witnessed in a Berlin cell. There had already been rumours of sabotage going on within Germany over the last few days, only adding to the tension on the base. There were former Reichswehr personnel amongst them after all.

His room onbase was still in the warm night all the same, Johann’s role as flight group leader was not quite as prestigious as the one he might have had within the Citizens Defence Council but this had been his goal ever since his days in the Ruhr Red Army and should Germany be thrown into the conflagration of another war he was glad to be at the front, in the air. He cast his eye dreamily to the science fiction novel lying on his bunk, The Shape of Things To Come, before turning his eyes back to the maps of Polish targets that would be first to face the anger of the Luftstreitkräfte. It was hard not to think of his Polish counterparts doing the same to German targets at this moment, let alone the French and Italians. The French crew who had opposed him with so much defiant bravado over the skies of Russia, only to be sent to their deaths, came to mind. Perhaps friends of theirs were planning the same fate for him just now.

A blaring sound of alarm came from the base’s speaker system, calling on all stationed to assemble in the parade grounds at once. It was a means of collectively informing them all that something was wrong. Johann was disorientated from the noise after being taken out of his thoughts but he composed himself quickly. If this was it then there was no point in panicking. He casually threw on his staff jacket and walked out his quarters, the younger pilots under his care already filling the corridor, gossiping about what the alarm could mean whilst waiting for Johann to lead them out.

It was not an unpleasant night to be outside, the breeze from the Baltic sea broke up the humidity although those who had been forced to climb out of their beds shivered all the same. Perhaps some were struggling more than others to not look terrified. Johann remained blank faced; up in the air he was truly alone, there he could scream.

He drew his men to attention as their superior, Colonel Blaas, strode on to the parade ground. The base commander nodded with satisfaction before putting them at ease.


“Kamerdan, you may know that in these last few days our Fatherland has been the target of probing attacks across our borders. What you will likely not know is that less than an hour ago Polish troops began to march into East Prussia.”

Blaas let the news hang in the air, but there was no audible reaction from the well drilled pilots and ground crew. Johann tried to count in his head how many among them he knew were from East Prussia, and how many had family there.

“Our comrades on the border are resisting but have been forced to fall back. It seems the Poles have had help, either from infiltrators, or from traitors, to help them find weaknesses in our line. Plan Kolberg is now in effect. We must clear our runways at once and prepare for attack.”

With that the orders of mobilisation were barked out, there was no time, no place for any words of comfort. Johann and his men moved to change into their flight suits even whilst the runway was cleared for their expected arrivals.

The gossip was more alarmed now,

“It’s the middle of the night!”

“Oh no, did the Defence Council forget to consult you again?”

The back and forth between his men made Johann consider that it would have been good to have been on Citizens Defence Council at this moment. It would have been good to know what was truly going on.

Kolberg was a dread phrase for it was the name given to the hypothetical worst case scenario. It meant that in short order Germany was expected to come under attack from three fronts simultaneously and as such the thinly spread forces of the People’s Guard were being gathered to defend the interior. It had been predicted that such an offensive might start with a diversionary attack in the Polish corridor and so the plan called for sacrificing East Prussia in the process of not being caught short elsewhere.

The Luftstreitkräfte’s immediate role in this was the evacuation of its East Prussian assets to bases inside Germany proper. Given the suddenness of the Polish attack, Stolp would be expected to bear the burden of this. At night of all things. Every light on the base slowly came on, punctuated by the loud clicking of the flak gun’s searchlights, illuminating them on the horizon and with luck, thousands of feet in the air.

They were sitting ducks, even as they helped to roll their new Heinkel He-50 fighters into the turf surrounding the base to help make extra room. It was a physically demanding task, even when not in a flight suit and amidst the strain it had been possible to miss the first droning noise from up above.

The searchlights jerked towards the place in the sky the noise was coming from and the assorted pilots stopped pushing and pulling for a moment to see the shapes illuminated in the dark, heading towards the base.

Johann recognised the familiar buzz and silhouette and realised he had been holding his breath. He exhaled as the He-16 came into land. The German upgrade to the Soviet Polikarpov he had flown against the French was the first to make it to safety it seemed, the pilot quickly exiting the aircraft before joining in with the efforts to make room.

More fighters landed, taking precedence due to their lack of flight time and ease with which they could be moved to make way for the bulkier transports and bombers. The searchlights focused on the larger planes now circling above, waiting their turn. The way they swung back and forth was an uncomfortable watch, making it easier to focus on the task at hand. One misstep out of the light and a collision could become inevitable.


The sight made Johann’s stomach turn. He couldn’t help but think of those in Berlin, going through the same focus. With not only their own lives on the line but those of the country as a whole.



He was glad he couldn’t see the nation going through similar motions.






---





The painting is Internationale Blatt II by Arno Rink
 
In the map of germany in 1936 we saw east prussia being seperated from germany and labelled german reich.
Maybe the fascists win a short series of border skirmishes and manage to establish the kaiser as a puppet ruler in Königsberg
 
Top