The West Wing presidential election 2006
I did a version of this before, but I didn't like it. Here's an updated version. This one is an altered version of the show with different characters, names, and stories. Let's say Sorkin stayed.
Season 5: Backstory
The Hoynes scandal is not written into the show as Sorkin is not leaving and doesn't want to write the "Speaker becomes President" story. In the Zoey Bartlet kidnapping crisis, Hoynes becomes Acting President. Just like in the real show, Zoey is recovered and the President resumes his duties. Season 5 has some different stories but nothing major happens. There is no replacing of the Vice President. As such, Will doesn't leave the West Wing to work for the Vice President. The real changes start at the end of season with the Gaza story. Fitzwallace doesn't die in the explosion but he is hospitalized for his severe injuries. The President does not fire Leo, instead, Leo has an unprompted heart attack, forcing him to leave his job. Josh becomes Acting Chief of Staff but he is clearly too distracted to do the job because of Donna. He recommends Senate Minority Leader Wendell Tripplehorn (Geoff Pierson, real character) to do the job. Tripplehorn is experienced, a good candidate, and was planning on retiring from the Senate soon. Plus, this gets Tripplehorn out of the 2006 race, as he was planning to challenge Hoynes. Tripplehorn accepts. Pierson joins the starring cast. C.J. stays as the Press Secretary so there is no Annabeth Schott introduced here and no Toby as the Press Secretary. The Santos character is never created. The election story begins in mid-season 6.
Season 6: The Primaries
At the start of a Christmas episode, Hoynes asks Josh to come run his campaign. Josh is hesitant to leave the White House and says he'll have a response later. When the president has an MS episode before an important meeting, the Vice President steps in to do the job and saves the whatever all by himself. Josh decides that Hoynes is the right man for the job and at the end of the episode and agrees to run his campaign. In the next episode, Josh tells the president he's leaving and formally resigns. Ed and Larry become the new Deputies. Josh asks Toby to come with him, but Toby doesn't think Hoynes is liberal enough. Dismayed, Josh leaves for New Hampshire without him, accompanied instead by Will. Although Josh and Hoynes expect an easy primary, Senator Ricky Rafferty (Mel Harris) challenges him from the left, with the help of her campaign manager Amy Gardner. The two campaigns clash bitterly after Rafferty has a series of surprising Super Tuesday victories. Josh eventually deduces that Rafferty's campaign is being advised by Toby. Ultimately Hoynes secures enough delegates and Rafferty drops out, but the Democratic platform has successfully been moved left and Toby accomplishes his real goal, moving Hoynes away from the center.
The final scene of the season's penultimate episode is the Hoynes team gaming out potential running mates. Josh says he only has one name in mind and the episode ends there. In the cold open of the finale, Josh goes to a house. He knocks on the door and a woman lets him in. She takes Josh to her husband and Josh asks him if he wants to be the next Vice President of the United States. The man is Admiral Fitzwallace. Roll credits. In the White House plot, there is no space shuttle leak. Instead, in the finale, the President is informed that the Sultan of Qumar has just been overthrown and executed by the military. This will replace the leak story and Kazakhstan in season 7. The remainder of the episode is dedicated to the Democratic and Republican conventions. Hoynes and Fitzwallace are nominated by the Democrats, while the Republicans nominate Senator Arnold Vinick of Texas. Vinick served in the Senate with Hoynes for many years and is his close personal friend. They are very close on the political spectrum as well. The Democrats wonder if they can really beat him. Vinick, a moderate, selects Senator Bob Russell (Gary Cole) of Alabama, a deep red conservative, as his running mate to balance the ticket and keep the base.
Season 7: The Election
Season 7 is very similar to the real show, except with the alternate candidates. There is a plot where a white cop shoots an unarmed black teenager in Dallas, similar to OTL's "Undecideds". Hoynes struggles with a proper response and gets into a fight with Fitzwallace about it. This plays into a deeper subplot when Fitzwallace accuses Hoynes of only picking him because of his race. Hoynes rejects and resents the accusation and Fitzwallace challenges him to prove it in his response to the shooting. Vinick gets into hot water when he tells a crowd of black people that they should do better at policing themselves. This blunder combined with a passionate speech from Hoynes puts the Hoynes campaign up in the polls. However, their bump is short lived after tabloids begin publishing rumors about an affair Hoynes had many years ago. Hoynes puts the story to rest by going on television with his wife (Teri Polo) and apologizing. Nevertheless, Hoynes is down in the polls again.
He and Vinick are neck and neck throughout the campaign as Josh grows increasingly frustrated trying to balance the left and center parts of the party. Vinick is leading the polls again thanks to stealing away moderate voters from the Democrats, putting several key states in play. Bruno continues to go for his 50 state strategy. Vinick's campaign eventually takes a hit with the nuclear incident, just like the real show. The White House plot, as mentioned before, is dominated by the civil war in Qumar. Ultimately President Bartlet decides to commit American troops to a UN peacekeeping force. Leo is heavily involved in this plot as the key to negotiations with other UN members trying to convince them to join the coalition. In the episode before the election, "Welcome to Wherever You Are", the President joins the Vice President on a campaign tour throughout the northeast, ending in New Hampshire. At the end of the night, before the President leaves for Washington, Josh expresses his doubt that they will win, but the President says he is confident in their victory.
On Election Night, the results coming in are inconclusive throughout the night. New Hampshire is called for Hoynes and the President asserts that it was his doing. It all comes down to Texas and Nevada. The first episode ends with Texas being called for Vinick. With Nevada exit polls favoring Vinick, Hoynes prepares to concede. The episode ends like the real one, with Leo being discovered passed out in his room. In the second episode, Leo is confirmed dead. The somber mood is interrupted by Nevada surprisingly being called for Hoynes, thus giving him 271 electoral votes and the victory. The last episodes focus on the transition. Josh puts together a staff consisting of Sam Seaborn as Deputy Chief of Staff, Will Bailey as Director of Communications, and Annabeth Schott (who was the campaign Press Secretary) as Press Secretary. Toby decides he will retire from politics to spend time with his children and write books. C.J. goes to do non-profit stuff like in the real show. There is no Speaker vote or search for a vice president, but some cabinet picks draw ire and create trouble for an administration that hasn't even started yet. The series finale is largely the same, only with John Hoynes being sworn in as the 44th President.
Main cast additions: Tim Matheson (season 6), Geoff Pierson (season 6), Alan Alda (season 7)
Bonus: John Hoynes presidential portrait