View attachment 801268
Quick little patch for the disputed area in the southern Andes between Argentina and Chile before 1902
Thanks! Many, many thanks! I have been searching for such a patch for quite a while!
Also, a little note by me because I'm often times prone to being really precise with language.
I would not use the word "disputed" in this case, since the treaties that defined the limits, caused the problem and later solved it were caused more due to ambiguities and lack of decent geographical knowledge rather than any proper ambition. And even the treaties acknowledged this. Both states considered for decades after these territories as almost worthless and barely needing mentioning in any international relations. I would honestly call these as "ambiguous limits" rather than "overlapping/disputed claims". I would not really use red lines for this then, but then again, this is my interpretation of this.
The interesting thing is that the treaties are weird because there's not just a situation in which an interpretation, any interpretation of them, causes them to be benefiting A over B or the reverse, but they are in a strange limbo in which they either benefit both or neither due to the way the treaties contradict themselves rather than contradicting other treaties, previous or of later date.
The greatest example of this is that you have things like the "Line of the Waters" (La Línea de Aguas) which separates the basins of the Atlantic and the Pacific-headed rivers and the highest summit of the Andes not corresponding to each other when both were used to create the limit at the same time for the same areas. And neither country claimed one interpretation as more valid than the other in any official position, but rather, a mixture, an arbitrary mixture which favoured them. That, that the definitions were arbitrary, was even acknowledged in the very documents of both states.
Well, I'm not really sure anyone is going to find much joy in trawling through historical treaties, but I have a friend who has while studying (Chilean) law and he has told me these things. On the other hand, I'm not really sure if anyone who uses this patch will really take such a close look at things.
I hope I haven't bored anyone and that this whole little asterisk on the limits wasn't felt as an exercise in being pedantic.