Independence and Counterrevolution - East Prussia after the Treaty of Versailles

Title
Independence and Counterrevolution - East Prussia after the Treaty of Versailles

- A short timeline in five chapters by Zurirch Adankar -

“Nationalism is an infantile disease. It is the measles of mankind”

Albert Einstein


iu

The city of Königsberg

Chapters:

Chapter I From Versailles to the “Provisional Government”
Chapter II The “Kapp-Putsch”
Chapter III Restauration ?
Chapter IV After the Polish-Soviet War
Chapter V Long Term Consequences
 
Chapter I
Chapter I: From Versailles to the “Provisional Government” January-August 1919

At the 29 January 1919, famous polish nationalist leader Roman Dmowski met with the Supreme War Council of the Allied powers to discuss the future borders of his country. In his presentation, he explained various polish claims which seemed necessary to him to create a powerful polish national state. While the treaty of Versailles included various polish claims and demands, Dmowski was still heavily disappointed. Since he was antisemitic, he believed, that a “Jewish Conspiracy” was responsible for the now unfavorable borders of Poland.

dmwoski2.png

Poland's borders as presented by Dmowski in Versailles. Lithuania should become a Polish puppet, while East Prussia should be independent under Polish influence.

But most historians agree, that the treaty of Versailles strengthened Poland.
In the following months, the European powers not only agreed that Poland should gain control over large parts of the former Prussian province of West Prussia, but also allowed the annexation of Masuria and the establishment of two “Free Cities”, Danzig and Königsberg under polish protection. An allied comission should oversee the establishment of polish control and the new boundaries.

The young German Republic was shocked when the demands became public. Adolf Tortilowicz von Batocki-Friebe, Oberpräsident (highest civil administrator) of the province of East Prussia developed a plan to prevent the annexation of the eastern provinces of Prussia.
Accoring to the so called “Oststaat-Plan” (eastern state plan), the eastern provinces should declare their temporary separation from Germany and organize an effective defense against Poland. Batockis Plan was popular among various government officials and military officers in Eastern Prussia, but the federal government rejected his ideas. They believed, that they had no choice but to accept the harsh peace under formal but ineffective protest. Armed resistance would only lead to total disaster.

425px-Batocki.JPG

Max Johann Otto Adolf Tortilowicz von Batocki-Friebe

When signing the peace treaty became unavoidable in June 1919, the provinces of Eastern Prussia and Western Prussia declared their provisional independence.
General von Below, who commanded the troops in the area declared his support and combined the army with various irregular troops, like the “Scharze Reichswehr”, various Freikorps, the “Grenzschutz Ost” and various local militias active in the region.

The leading administrators of the two provinces, and the mayors of Danzig and Königsberg meet in Königsberg to organize their “Provisional Government”. Von Below was appointed as commander of all armed forces in the two provinces. Königsberg became provisional capital. Danzig was far closer to Poland, and therefore in a far more dangerous position. They decided to use the black and white flag of East Prussia for their provisional government. Continued use of the black-white-red flag of the former empire and the black-red-yellow flag for the current republic was common, since they still understood themselves as part of Germany. The official proclamations of the “Provisional Government” emphasized, that they weren’t separatist, they saw themselves as a part of an indivisible German nation separated by an unjust peace from their motherland.

The German Government declared them rebels who committed treason in a time of greatest sacrifice. But the right wing public was far more favorable to this resistance to the treaty of Versailles.

Since February 1919 Poland was at war with Soviet Russia. While the Polish advanced in a successful offensive far into the east, only few polish forces where immediately available to attack the “Provisional Government”. It was possible to capture the Southern parts of Western Prussia and gain access to the Baltic Sea. But they encountered heavy resistance around Danzig. The Polish Government decided to wait until a successful armistice with Soviet Russia could be archived.

The “Provisional Government” still considered the republican Government in Berlin as legitimate. But with each day, reactionary forces gained more and more influence in Königsberg. They saw not only Versailles but the Republic and the Revolution of 1918 as highly illegitimate.




Edited (03.10.2018): Small corrections to the map. East Prussia is now "independent" under Polish influence.
 
Last edited:
Nice prussia shall live! Shame this will be short any hope you could continue this into ww2 and beyond?

Let's see what will happen.
I have five chapters written, which I could post in the next days. 3 small maps showing the evolution of borders (based on QBAM) are almost complete.
I think that the five chapters cover most of the interesting developments. I don't know what I want to do after that.

Restoration? Is that the monarchy if so then im subbed.
No comment. Let's see what will happen in the next posts. What is the meaning of restauration? At which point is a counterrevolution sucsessful?
 
. I don't know what I want to do after that.
Seeing how a independent german state deal with hitler rise in germany and desire to not be annexed by them. Siding with the allies or remaining neutral. Cold war with communist states all around and this state having to deal with this.
 
Chapter II
II. The “Kapp-Putsch” September-December 1919

The east Prussian banker Wolfgang Kapp was a central figure in the right wing circles of Königsberg. During the Great War, he became a member of various far right nationalist groups. The temporary independence of Eastern Prussia was from his perspective a chance to start the so much desired counterrevolution.
Various Freikorps where happy to gain his financially support.

Wolfgang_Kapp.jpeg

Wolfgang Kapp

The “provisional government” avoided interfering in the chaotic situation of the Baltic States, but claimed control over the Memel Territory, a region which should come under the control of the Entente according to the treaty of Versailles. Lithuania also claimed the region.

The Entente saw the “provisional government” as a highly illegitimate rebellion.
But there was hope, Poland could with some support defeat them. On of the main fears of the Entente was a right wing counterrevolution in the rest of Germany. They therefore pressured the German Government to avoid any support and isolate the East Prussian rebellion. That didn’t stop the conservative Reichswehr (the army of the young German republic) to give some support even against the direct orders of their government.

Kapp and his allies where finally ready to launch their coup. The Freikorps managed to arrest the “Provisional Government” in one of their meetings. Batocki tried to flew but was shot in the chaos of the coup. The city of Königsberg was now under their control. In their first proclamation they denounced the Weimar Republic as illegitimate and proclaimed, that East Prussia was still a loyal province of the German Empire. All loyal citizens should fight united against the revolution, against Poland and against Bolshevism. Now they called themselves “regency council” and Kapp claimed to be the new “Prussian Prime Minister”.

General von Below was not in Königsberg when the coup happened. He inspected some troops in Masuren. Since von Below was a reactionary, and didn’t want to fight a civil war, he agreed to cooperate with the coup leadership. In his mind, patriots should fight together in times of need. The city government of Danzig rejected the authority of the coup, and hoped that Kapp and his Freikorps would prove to be highly dysfunctional and would be quickly replaced by a responsible government.

But not everyone was happy about Kapp in Königsberg. KPD (communists), USPD (independent social democrats) and MSPD (majority social democrats) where still present in the city. And they didn’t want to accept a counterrevolutionary government. So red militias attacked the castle while a general strike was called. But this wasn’t a good day for the red flag. Freikorps attacked striking workers while the castle was successfully defended.
The “regency council” ordered the banning of all leftist parties and unions. After several violent days, most leftist left either to the Weimar Republic or to Soviet Russia. At the same time, many young reactionaries traveled to the East.

The city of Danzig feared complete isolation and agreed to cooperate with Kapp after Berlin denied them any support. They had no choice but to accept him.

Bundesarchiv_Bild_146-1971-091-20%2C_Kapp-Putsch%2C_Marine-Brigade_Erhardt.jpg

Freikorps supporting Kapp a few days after his coup
 
I won't post a chapter today, since I'm tired.
Also I need to improve some parts and informations to correctly include Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania into the timeline.

Whats the position of the monarchists here in prussia?
There are probably many reactionaries who want the monarchy back in this timeline and in OTL in East Prussia aswell as in Germany.
I guess the largest part of the population simply wants peace and a return to normality and dislikes the peace treaty of Versailles.
There are of course also many social democrats and communists who dislike the reactionary regime in East Prussia. (I read, that the Majority Social Democrats and Independent Social Democrats dominated the first elections in the city of Königsberg after the revolution).

Can we get Victoria Louise in power as the new monarch?
No comment. Let's see what will happen.

What is Hindenburg view and the rest of prussian junkars and people view of what the prussias are doing?
I guess most military officers and reactionaries think that it is a good thing. In their mind, finally someone is doing something against Versailles and the revolution. Not everyone would immediately join them, but you could probably expect large sympathies and passive support.

More pragmatic and realist conservatives would probably dissaprove, since the East Prussians could harm the reestablishment of peace. Probably people in the "Zentrum" (catholic moderate conservatives) would advocate for peaceful renegotiations.
 
Chapter III
III. Restauration ? January – September 1920

After several successes, the Polish Offensive against the Soviets failed, and a series of Russian victories brought Poland to the brink of defeat. Warsaw was in danger. Any planned offensives against East Prussia where canceled. Defending Warsaw was the main priority now.

Fearing the growing Soviet influence, the Entente accepted a temporary rouge East Prussia, but categorically denied any diplomatic acceptance. Poland convinced the Entente to gain more support. While Great Britain was more reluctant to support Poland, the French government became more and more convinced that a strong Poland would be necessary to prevent German or Soviet influence in the area.

This situation offered new possibilities for East Prussia and Kapp.
The “regency council” offered Emperor Wilhelm and his son Wilhelm prince of Prussia to return from the exile in the Netherlands to Prussia to regain the crown.

De facto various militias and Freikorps controlled East Prussia. Kapp realized, that his control over the Freikorps and various military formations was limited. He offered general Ludendorff to become regent until the Hohenzollern would return. A former leader of the Great War could give his government more legitimacy and respect. Erich Ludendorff was at that moment in Exil in Sweden. His dreams about germanizing parts of Eastern Europe, and his distaste for democracy made him perfect for the job. Arriving in Königsberg, Ludendorff tried to minimize Kapps power to become the new strong man in East Prussia. Most reactionaries supported him.

358px-Erich_Ludendorff.jpg

Erich Ludendorff, now "Regent" of "East Prussia"

The German Government feared, that the East Prussians would conspire with far right groups in Germany. They asked the Dutch government to keep a close look on the former Kaiser to prevent any plan from the pretender to leave the country. Several similar requests by the Entente arrived in the Netherlands. The Dutch government had no interest in creating an international crisis. But from the few reports which arrived in Doorn (the exile castle of Wilhelm II.) Wilhelm II. concluded that waiting to see what happened was a far better option than becoming a marionette of an instable “government” in East Prussia.

In Germany, the Government had to reduce the Reichswehr (the new far to reactionary military of the Republic) to comply with the treaty of Versailles. Various former soldiers and right wing militiamen decided to fight for their ideas in East Prussia. A famous example is the conservative writer Ernst Jünger, who wrote an autobiographical novel about his time in East Prussia, which became highly popular in the 20ies.

Kapp was unable to see, that he didn’t control the situation, and lost power with each day. His planning didn’t focus on the Baltic. Instead he favored a quick offensive into Pommerania, and a cooperation with reactionary groups inside the Reichswehr. The East Prussians and the Reichswehr should together launch a successful coup in Berlin to finally restore the Monarchy.
It was the final blow for his authority, when his “secret plans” appeared in the Vorwärts (the leading social democratic newspaper in Germany) under the titel “Reaktionäre Umsturzpläne aus Ostpreußen!” (reactionary coups planned from East Prussia). The German left feared a counterrevolution. Many groups armed themselves and prepared a general strike should the counterrevolution happen.

But it never happened. Most Freikorps had now different interests. They dreamed more about creating their reactionary paradise in the Baltic. Kapp tried to ignore the growing pressure on him, and didn’t even thought about resigning, until armed Freikorps visited his office. Ludendorff accepted his resignation and even offered him to become finance minister.
To appease the Freikorps, one of their generals, von der Goltz became new prime minister. This showed the dominance of military men in the “government” of East Prussia, and their Baltic ambitions.

Rüdiger von der Goltz was leader of the German forces and Freikorps in the Baltic after the armistice of 1918. Trying to establish a Baltic German dominance over the Baltic, his forces where almost defeated in the middle of 1919 by Estonia and Latvia. But the separation of East Prussia convinced him to continue fighting, and new volunteers arrived. The Kapp-”Government” provided logistical and military support. Goltz managed to defend Courland and assembled enough forces to start a counteroffensive at the beginning of 1920 with Riga as goal.

Ludendorff planned to appoint von der Goltz to incorporate the Baltics into East Prussia and to strengthen their support. Von der Goltz accepted his appointment to restore German dominance over the Baltics.East Prussia was de facto controlled by various Freikorps and militias. The government couldn’t do anything against them. Von der Goltz

The capture of Riga after a short siege was an important victory for the “government”, but Soviet Russia decided, that the new Prussian offensive showed the weakness of Estonia and Latvia and decided to invade again after their defeat in 1919. Estonian and Latvian nationalist failed to defend against the attack from two sides. Their governments fled to the islands of Dagö (Hiumaa) and Ösel (Saaremaa).
Prussian and Soviet troops meet each other in Northern Latvia and some fights erupted between them.
A small squadron of the British Royal Navy protected the two islands. Estonian politicians considered offering Britain to build a long term naval base on Saarema (Ösel) to gain a long term guarantee for their independence. Nationalist guerilla fought a desperate fight against Prussian and Soviet troops.

At this point, the East Prussian government considered reorganizing the occupied territories. But in Courland, Adolf Freidrich zu Mecklenburg, a german aristocrat, who was after the Great War once considered to become monarch of a Baltic puppet state, used the chaos to proclaim himself “Duke of Courland and Semgallia”. While he wasn’t that close to the Freikorps, Ludendorff accepted him. Establishing a traditional duchy could show their commitment to restore “order” and “tradition”. A german dominated city council gained leadership in Riga, and asked East Prussia for their “protection”. The rest of Prussian controlled Latvia was formally governed by a puppet government under Andrievs Niedra. The Russians established Soviet Republics in Estonia and Northern Latvia.

Poland urgently needed weapon supplies, but the Harbor of Danzig was still under East Prussian control. Therefore Poland requested France to pressure Germany into allowing military supplies trough the Harbor of Stettin.
Realizing that Poland was indeed in serious problems, France increased its support for Poland considerably.

Ludendorff realized that the survival of his state depended on foreign recognition. He opened secret contacts to Poland. But all offers for armistice failed. Poland categorically denied any recognition or negotiation with the “rebels”.Ludendorffs country was isolated without any chance of foreign recognition. Smaller incidents lead to constant tensions. At the same time, the economy of the isolated country collapsed almost completely, since trade was almost impossible.

Since it appeared, that no Hohenzollern would come to East Prussia for a long time, Adolf Friedrich zu Mecklenburg argued, that the “regency council” should elect a new king (maybe he himself would be a great candidate …). But most Freikorps where happy with Ludendorff (at the moment at least …) and didn’t cared for Adolf Friedrichs ambitions.

The regency council recognized the need for some long term political structures. Ludendorff renamed and reformed the “regency council” into a larger “crown council” who should develop a constitution (of course a constitution without all that leftist degenerate stuff like human rights). While it took far to much time to develop a constitution, the “Kingdom of East Prussia” was formally proclaimed in Königsberg in August 1920. The country should continue to exist, until the legitimate monarchy could be restored in Germany.
The Ludendorff-Government became highly unpopular among the ordinary population of East Prussia. Most people wanted stability and peace not war and military adventures. They suffered from economic collapse and oppression from various militias and Freikorps. The currency collapsed, while the food supply was limited.

Between Poland in the West and the Soviets in the East, East Prussia lacked real options for expansion for the power hungry Freikorps. Since various attacks against the Soviets in Northern Latvia failed, Lithuania became central to further Prussian ambitions.
Vilnius, de jure capital of Lithuania was changing control between Poland and the Soviets during heavy fighting in the Polish-Soviet war. The rest of the country was still weakened from the successful defense against the soviets.
Kaunas, “temporary capital” was much closer to East Prussia. A short offensive managed to capture the city and a puppent government was appointed by Ludendorff. Ludendorff ordered the Freikorps to start some of the Germanization projects he dreamed of. Various villages and farms where occupied, with the plan to distribute them among Freikorp veterans. Of course this happened with heavy human right violations. Antisemitism was common and widespread among the Freikorps and the higher officials of the Ludendorff-regime, including Ludendorff himself. This lead to various horrible acts of violence and widespread discrimination against the Jewish population.

The “crown council” legitimized the territorial gains. The “law on the provisional borders and territories of East Prussia” reorganized the administration of the small country, and divided it into various provinces. The various protectorates (Courland, Lithuania, Riga, Parts of Latvia) where futher integrated. But there was a large difference between the law and the chaotic practice in the unstable war torn provinces.

While the Entente continued to deny any recognition, the conservative part of the German public had a favorable view of the “heroes” in East Prussia. The old Field Marshal von Hindenburg wrote his warmest greetings and solidarity with East Prussia and encouraged “young patriots” to travel and volunteer there.

eastprussia2.png

The "Kingdom of East Prussia" according to the “law on the provisional borders and territories of East Prussia” while Poland tries to defend itself against the Soviets. Note that most borders in Eastern-Europe where not clearly defined at the moment, especially between Poland and the Soviets.

Edited (04.190.2018): Changed the administrative division of the Soviet Republics
 
Last edited:
Goddammit Wilhelm let a hohenzollern go there to represent and unit the monarchist, we need victoria or a hohenzollern on the throne.

Btw whats happened to the whites? Surely prussia can help them out?
 
Goddammit Wilhelm let a hohenzollern go there to represent and unit the monarchist, we need victoria or a hohenzollern on the throne.

Btw whats happened to the whites? Surely prussia can help them out?

1. Would you take a dangerous journey to an instable unrecognized country dominated by various competing warlords and military leaders, threatened by larger neighbours, just to become their puppet? It would be better to wait and see what will happen in the next months.
2. They are already occupied trying to conquer the Baltics and still threatened by Poland. As far as I understand the Russian civil war (I'm not an expert), while there are still various whites around in 1920, they are already loosing in 1920. East Prussia simply lacks manpower and the ressources to think about attacking the Soviets. There is probably a minority among the East Prussian leadership who even thinks about signing some treaty with the Soviets to secure their Eastern Borders, if the Soviets further advance into Poland (some form of alliance with the devil).
But giving some fleeing Whites asylum and recruiting some of them into the East Prussian military is a possibility.
 
1. Would you take a dangerous journey to an instable unrecognized country dominated by various competing warlords and military leaders, threatened by larger neighbours, just to become their puppet? It would be better to wait and see what will happen in the next months.
to save the monarchy then yes, they also dont have to take the mantle straight away but be their and represent the monarchy showing they are interested, also alot of these warlords and factions are pro monarch so they ave some assurance of support.

edit: Im surprised the baltic fell to the soviets estonia had a force of whites in their country.
 
to save the monarchy then yes, they also dont have to take the mantle straight away but be their and represent the monarchy showing they are interested, also alot of these warlords and factions are pro monarch so they ave some assurance of support.

edit: Im surprised the baltic fell to the soviets estonia had a force of whites in their country.

It is a change compared to OTL. In OTL and TTL the Soviets failed in 1919. But I think that the new attack from East Prussia and the Freikorps against Latvia in 1920 offers a new opportunity for Soviet Russia to attack Estonia again from the North-East. These two attacks could then probably lead to the collaps of organized resistance from Latvia and Estonia who closely cooperated in OTL to defend their independence.
 
Last edited:
Top