Hadrian's Consolidation - reboot

Hecatee

Donor
So an inversion of the comitatenses and limitanei formations? The heavy ones on the frontiers and the light ones for internal police duties?

Generally speaking one could.think so yet not really.

Firstly internal security force don't have an integrated multi effect force and are of very uneven strenght and quality depending on local ressources and political interest in security (they are raised by local officials) whereas the auxiliaries have a strong medium infantry + archers + cavalry composition and the legions have a very strong heavy infantry + archer + light mobile artillery + siege artillery composition.

The border security arrrangement often places the legions in heavy fortress on or close to the border while the auxiliaries usually are in fortresses on the border or atop communication nodes (mountain passes, river crossing,...) and provide manpower for the light surveillance infrastrucure (watchtowers) and most of the day to day patrolling (thanks to their large cavalry).

So not really the limitanei/comitatense division given that there are no centralized reaction armies, we are still in a principate type strategic disposition, rather aggressively oriented, but with higher mobility (thanks to cavalry), reactivity (optical telegraph lines) and combined arms approach, including a far greater (if rather unused) siege capacity maintained by regular exercises.
 
Generally speaking one could.think so yet not really.

Firstly internal security force don't have an integrated multi effect force and are of very uneven strenght and quality depending on local ressources and political interest in security (they are raised by local officials) whereas the auxiliaries have a strong medium infantry + archers + cavalry composition and the legions have a very strong heavy infantry + archer + light mobile artillery + siege artillery composition.

The border security arrrangement often places the legions in heavy fortress on or close to the border while the auxiliaries usually are in fortresses on the border or atop communication nodes (mountain passes, river crossing,...) and provide manpower for the light surveillance infrastrucure (watchtowers) and most of the day to day patrolling (thanks to their large cavalry).

So not really the limitanei/comitatense division given that there are no centralized reaction armies, we are still in a principate type strategic disposition, rather aggressively oriented, but with higher mobility (thanks to cavalry), reactivity (optical telegraph lines) and combined arms approach, including a far greater (if rather unused) siege capacity maintained by regular exercises.

The troops were described as "....a century of men from the praesidis forces..." That kind of implies that the governor has more than a century of personal troops which I would have thought would be unusual. I thought the usual method of policing involved detaching troops from the Legions or Auxiliaries. Isn't this slightly risky in terms of Governors having access to so many personally loyal troops?
 

Hecatee

Donor
The troops were described as "....a century of men from the praesidis forces..." That kind of implies that the governor has more than a century of personal troops which I would have thought would be unusual. I thought the usual method of policing involved detaching troops from the Legions or Auxiliaries. Isn't this slightly risky in terms of Governors having access to so many personally loyal troops?

You may recall a previous update where I described the system : those praesidis are not a governor's personal guard but a local militia raised in the cities of the empire and tasked with public order both in the city and in the surrounding area : you may want to re-read this post to see them in action and that post for the technical details. In short : each pagus has up to 3 centuries of men in its local defense force, and local provincial governors (which are no longer of senatorial rank but procurator centenarii due to the much smaller size of the provinces) can in case of internal emergency call on the militias of the pagi inside the province, but that would nest him between one to five cohors of not well equiped nor well trained infantry without artillery nor cavalry for the most densely populted pagi, so a rather negligible threat.

Also note that not all praesidis units are standing units (some are raised on a need to basis, or with a contubernalia on duty and the rest having a civil life, depending on local wealth and population), although some in the larger cities are indeed permanent units. They rose from the need for internal security due to almost all the legions being on the borders (one of the few exception is the legion based in Spain) along with most auxiliary units.

A new type of evergetism is to equip one's pagi troops with a new suit of armour, or some other form of necessary equipement (and it is a kind of act that the local notables like to do because it inject money in the local population and show their gift not only to their city but also to the whole area, improving their prestige at a larger level while not competing with the higher equestrian or senatorial level types of benefactions).
 
That is quite a sizeable force of trained men outside army command . I guess the question still stands - there could be a temptation for the militia to grow into private armies and even if they don't challenge the Empire they may get involved in local conflicts which escalate. I'm thinking of OTL examples like Palmyra where when Roman authority was weak, local authorities took matters into their own hands.
 
That is quite a sizeable force of trained men outside army command . I guess the question still stands - there could be a temptation for the militia to grow into private armies and even if they don't challenge the Empire they may get involved in local conflicts which escalate. I'm thinking of OTL examples like Palmyra where when Roman authority was weak, local authorities took matters into their own hands.

I agree, needs to be a unified command structure and/or something to prevent these forces from being used for iligitimate activities!
 

Hecatee

Donor
That is quite a sizeable force of trained men outside army command . I guess the question still stands - there could be a temptation for the militia to grow into private armies and even if they don't challenge the Empire they may get involved in local conflicts which escalate. I'm thinking of OTL examples like Palmyra where when Roman authority was weak, local authorities took matters into their own hands.

I agree, needs to be a unified command structure and/or something to prevent these forces from being used for iligitimate activities!

Yes it makes for large numbers overall, but widely spread : no more than 300 men for some 6 to 8000 km² (a large sized modern French departement), around 70 such divisions for the territory of modern day France, so a theoretical maximum of 21 000 men under the orders of 70 pagi leaders (there are 2 leaders in each pagus), themselves under the orders of at least 15 to 20 provincial governors, which means that no governor can have much more than 1500 men under his command for an area of some 125 to 200 000 km² (depending on whether you make a day on horseback 40 or 50 km). And above such provincial governor you still have the diocesian Vicarius' administration (1 for the area we take as example here) which can block attempts at rebellion (but not command any troops) and the praefectus' authority, here the Praefectus Occidentalis who resides in Lugdunum (Lyon) and who controls the British, Spanish and German legions and auxiliary units.

In fact a rebellion bellow the rank of Praefectus is almost certainly doomed to failure, but there are 4 praefecti and they are all spending a lot of time rather far from the units under their control because they are in a strategic position unless an external foes requires they take direct control of a large force, and they are of course under massive imperial supervision...

So you may have some local official using the local troops for some banditry, but that would not end well for him, and they would have little opportunities for much more than some briganding or bribe taking... Beside the troops being locals they would not like to move outside of their own local area so there are not that many chances of seing the praesitis follow an usurper...
 
Academia Militaria Tactica, Sarmizegetusa, Transisteria, diocesis of Dacia, April 247

Hecatee

Donor
Academia Militaria Tactica, Sarmizegetusa, Transisteria, diocesis of Dacia, April 247


Centurion Appius Aelius Candidinus pested once more against the unknown man who had thought examinations to be a good idea. He’d heard it was in fact a serican invention, brought back by one of the expedition ships going to the far empire every four years, but it was not one import for which he cared, not at all…

Aelius Candidinus had been promoted to the rank of centurion almost a year earlier, following the death from a bad cold of his predecessor. He’d then been sent to the Academia Militaria in the diocesis’ capital, Sarmizegetusa, to study about the arts of war and of administrations.

Discipline in the school was as severe as when he had been a young tiro. The staff, made of former centurions, knew all the tricks. Indeed Aelius Candidinus had learned a few new ones… There was only one liberty night every nundinae but that was not ressented too much by the trainees because they were mostly too tired for more : between the mandatory ceremony of honor to the emperor at the cock’s crow, the physical training that kept them at a peak strength, and the hours of theoretical lessons, wargames, trials simulations and other activities, they had not much time to fool around...

Now he was at the end of his year of schooling, and had to pass the examination… There was a lot of competition going on between the 25 trainees, and this was the culminating moment of this year of friendly rivalry. It was also important because while it was not mandatory to be good, it did help with promotion…

So he now had to answer a large question about the Empire’s administration, and another on the Empire’s army, and then he would have to play judge in a last mock trial before heading for a last boardgame battle competition…

So, the first question… “Describe the Empire’s institutions as best as you can”. Damn, what a broad and treacherous question ! And what of the second question ? “Describe the composition of the army, from the individual soldier to the Emperor, and the strength of each unit.” Ouch. Another broad question ! The headmaster probably wanted to make them pay for the damage they’d done during the last “symposion”, or rather drunken debauchery ! Fair enough, what had been supposed to be a moment to train them in the finer arts of eating with higher ranking officers had been turned into a boisterous drunken food battle… While giving as good as he got, the headmaster had not liked to be crowned with an eel’s head…

So, the structure of the empire’s institutions… Sighing, Aelius Candidinus took his feather, which he’d taken care to carefully sharpen the evening before, and plunged it in his ink pot, starting to scratch his answer.

“The Empire is one although made of what used to be many. Led by its Emperor with the help of the Senate, under the protection of its armies that prevent any external foe from disturbing the peace inside its borders, it is the oikumene and the place where civilization thrive. Its triumph is marked by its victories against its enemies and the greatness of its cities growing in the internal peace and of its monuments born from the genius of its architects and engineers and inventors.

The Emperor is the fount of all orders for both the civilians and the military. Succeeded by his designated heir, chosen by him and the Senate, he can command to all and gives the impetus for all laws as well as looking for their implementation. Taking command of the armies in time of need, the Emperor is a father for the nation, pater patriae, and also a guide for our souls as the high priest of all cults, pontifex maximus, first intermediary between men and the Gods.

His chosen heir has all the same power as the Emperor has, but under him, and none but the Emperor with approval from the Senate can dismiss the heir.

Under the Emperor are four high prefectures, that of Occidens, directed from Lugdunum, Illyria, directed from Serdica, Oriens, directed from Antiocheia, and Africa, directed from Carthage.

Deriving their imperium from the imperial favour, the four governors of prefectures are his voice in the province. They are the ultimate appeal in any judiciary procedure, except for those they decide to refer to the Emperor or those that the Emperor decides for himself to arbiter.

The governors, all former consuls of Rome and thus of the highest families of the Senate, may also take command of armies in time of external threat on the border of their area of imperium, until the Emperor decides to appoint another commander.

In charge of their prefecture for a duration of two years, they can only serve in areas where their families and those of their wifes don’t originate from, as the divine Marcus Aurelius did not want any local dynasty to feel empowered to take control of any region for its own purposes that could be contrary to those of the Empire.

Under them come the 18 vicarii, all former praetors of Rome, responsible for the proper running of the institutions in their diocesis for a duration of two years.

Helped by younger quaestor from the Senate, they look at the way justice is made in the provinces they are responsible for, and act as appeal court. They are also to look into the accounts of the officers in charge of the legions and auxiliary units stationed in their area of responsibility.

As it is the case for the governors of prefectures, it is forbidden for a vicarius to serve in the province from which his family or his wife’s come from.

The diocesis are, in order of prefecture :

  • Africae : Mauretania (Caesarea), Africa (Utica), Egypt (Alexandria)

  • Occidentalis : Hispania (Tarraco), Gallia (Lutetia), Britannia (Eboracum), Italia (Neapolis), Germania (Augustodunum Germanicum), Albis (Colonia Albia)

  • Illyrici : Iazygeia (Aquincum), Dacia (Sarmizegetusa), Thracesis (Serdica), Illyria (Salona), Graecia (Corinthus)

  • Orientalis : Asia (Ephesus), Pontica (Sinope), Mesopotamia (Babylon), Syria (Caesarea)
The diocesis are themselve divided into a multitude of provinces, currently numbering 140, under the supervision of a procurator of the equestrian order ranking as a sexagenarii, being granted 60 000 sestertii a year for his office.

Being a level of appeal for cases heard at the local level, they are often the final word on unimportant cases although an appeal is still possible to the diocesian vicarius, yet the need to travel to the diocesian capital often mean people don’t go to that level. They are also the first level of justice in cases where capital offenses are to be tried or when properties and sums of a worth above a thousand sestertii are in play.

Among the duties of the procurator is also the supervision of the tax collection efforts by the locally elected magistrates of the pagi, districts and towns. This is why an equestrian having held such duties before being elevated into the Senate is inducted at the rank of the former quaestors, as decreed by the divine Marcus Petillius Cerialis.

The procurator are also responsible for the main infrastructure of their province, including the canals, bridges and aqueduct that cross the borders of a pagus. This is why a procurator quadragenarii rei machinatorum is appointed to their province, the more junior, although often older, equestrian having followed the cursus of the Academia Militaria Practica of Rome before being appointed to such a position.

If an infrastructure cross between multiple provinces the imperial jurisprudence coming from the rescrit of the divine Titus Valerius Maximus is that the procurator at the end of the aqueduc or at the extremity of a canal or bridge closest to Rome that is in charge of the maintenance on the whole course of the infrastructure, but the other procurators have to contribute funds, resources and manpower from their budget in accordance to the part of the infrastructure that is on their territory (always the half in case of bridges).

In case of major troubles those civilian administrators are authorised to assemble the praesidis units of their territory to confront the threat, but only on the territory on which their imperium is valid, and they will immediately give their power to any owner of the imperium maius sent by the Emperor such as, for instance, the governor of the prefecture or a general appointed to lead an army of multiple legions, although he may never be submitted to the orders of a simple legion legatus not provided with a specific mandate by the Emperor or the governor of the prefecture.

It is to be noted that the procurator, like the vicarius or the governor, may not have his family’s base of power or his wife’s in the province which he has received in his care for his four years mandate.

Under the procurator are the three levels of local magistrature, elected by the locals amongst their own notables. Whereas the three previous positions see a single man hold command for a given territory, those magistratures are still following the old rules of having two men in charge : the magistrates of the pagus, mainly responsibles for roads and security on them, making sure the district and town official do not misbehave while collecting the taxes on trade or while supervising the imperial properties that are also part of their duties.

The pagus magistrate are paid 10 000 sestertii a year for a two years mandate, both to entice them to the function and make it less interesting to cheat, especially as anyone who’s convicted for concussion or stealing from the taxes or from the properties they have to manage is fined between 100 000 and 400 000 sestertii depending on the amount stolen and the richness of the pagus. As such it may be seen as a less desirable position as the former procurator Augusti, which was a much better paid position, but the fact that a pagus magistrate is locally elected means one does have to travel to Rome or provinces far away to exerce it, and thus it is seen as better than the previous arrangement, especially as it does give access to further career in the administration as a procurator quadragenarii.

The district magistrates are only paid 5000 sestertii a year for two years of service, but they do not oversee cases above a value of a thousand sestertii and mainly collect the head tax, the harvest tax and the inheritance tax : while of course some very rich persons have a vicesima hereditatium above 5000 sestertii, the 5% tax on their inheritance is often levied directly in Rome and not in the province so the lower salary is not seen as a problem, especially as if caught cheating they would be fined between 50 000 and 200 000 sestertii.

Finally the town magistrates only receive a thousand sestertii a year, a recent innovation to attract candidates for the function, they are in charge of maintaining the city infrastructure and collect some local taxes such as the one on wood for the bath’s furnaces.

Overall the appearance of the old roman traditions has been preserved, and there is still a cursus honorum for both the senatorial class and the equestrian class that would be recognizable by the divine Augustus.

The young man of senatorial origin who wants to take the seat of his elders will have to first spend a year, from the age of 15 to the age of 16, at the Academia Militaria Principalia, the Princep’s academy, of Rome : there he shall learn discipline and command, before going to the legions where he’ll serve until he is 25 years old, at which time he will be able to become one of the 25 quaestors of the next year.

As quaestor he shall either go to the provinces as assistant to a vicarius or stay in Rome where he may be appointed quaestor to the Princeps or to the Heir, places of great honor, quaestor of Rome itself or quaestor extra-ordinarii tasked with a special mission by the Princeps.

Following the questure he will campaign for a position as one of the 14 edils, a role similar to the one of the town magistrates but limited to one of the 14 sectors of Rome defined by the divine Augustus : responsible for the maintenance of buildings, they are also in charge of religious festivals depending on whether they are plebeians or patricians.

From the age of 30 the young senator can compete for the post of praetor, of which there are 25, most of them being put in charge of the various tribunals inside Rome, a precious experience for those who are going to be designated as vicarii. Those not given a tribunal are kept by the Princeps for special missions, similar to the quaestors extra ordinarii.

While being a vicarius is not necessary to become consul, the two year posting often gives a boost to a career of the man who will then attempt, from the age of 33 (as the youngest age one can try to achieve such a exalted position), to become consul of Rome.

Another career choice possible for the praetor as he exits his charge is to become a legionary commander in the province, in charge for two years of one of the 30 legions, a high honor that can also lead to the honor of the consulate, especially if one manages to crush a barbarian raid or otherwise distinguish himself in his defense of the borders of the empire.

Last but not least, the consulate itself, formerly the highest position in Rome before the avenement of the Empire. It had become somewhat of a tradition for the Emperor to designate the consuls according to ones’ merits or political usefulness, often taking the post himself at least in the beginning of the year so that his name would be given to the year. But following the reforms of the divine Marcus Aurelius the practice of designing suffect consults for just a few day in order to insure having enough provincial governors proved to be less useful and the consulate regained part of its prestige even if the consuls had no imperium outside of the pomerium of Rome.

The prestigious position was a pre required experience before being trusted with one of the highly coveted and extremely powerful position of governor of a prefecture or one of the other senatorial prefecture such as the praefectus urbanus, commander of the urban cohort of Rome, one of the two types of units in charge of the security of the capital.

Similarly the Equestrian order still has its cursus honorum, or rather it has three, depending on whether they wanted to follow the civilian, machinatori or military cursus.

The military career is open to anyone who reaches the rank of centurio primus pilus of a cohors in either a legion or an auxiliary unit. They can either try to reach the rank of centurio primus pilus of one of the thirty legions of Rome, which will give them a shot to the rank of praefectus castrorum, or they can either go to the schola militaria practica to become one of the prised engineers of the empire, or if they can afford it, they can go for the command road, with various options there too.

First in the command road is the position of praefectus cohors quingenaria, commander of 5 centuries of auxiliaries either as an independent command or as one of three in a larger and more common auxiliary cohors equitata miliaria.

The next promotion, after at least two years in the position, could be as tribunus angusticlavus in a legion, one of five officers of equestrian rank at the level of tribune (which he knew from personal experience are much more experienced but less socially important than the five young men of senatorial rank commanding the other cohors of the legion). The tribuni angusticlavi are considered as having the same rank as the civilian sexagenarii officials, as do the usually slightly older tribunus rei machinatorum attached to each legion under the direct orders of the praefectus of the camp after their studies at the schola. The position lasts for another two years.

The next rank they can reach is that of tribune of a cohors equitata miliaria or praefectus castrum, for another two years. Another option is to become one of the 18 praefectus schola tactica, the schools for centurions that existes in each diocese. It makes those officials almost equal in rank to a vicarius, save for the fact they are not part of the Senate, and they are seen as pillar of fidelity toward the emperor for they are charged with the teaching of the imperial doctrina to the officers of the army. Another military option is command of one of the fleet, with the exception of the Misena fleet which is considered the top of the fleet career. Ranked as equal to their centenarii colleagues of the civil service, those few men who reach this elevated level make their cities proud, with many having a statue erected in his honour on the forum of his native town…

From such a position and if they have gone through the machinatorum path, they can become praefectus schola machinatorum, director of the school, or, if they have been prefect of a provincial school of tactics, prefect of the imperial school of tactics, both ranks counting as equal to the civilian trecenarii. They can also of course be granted one of the civilian positions of ducenarii or trecenarii rate, or even reach the pinnacle of the equestrian career as one of the two two years tribune of the praetorian guard.

If they choose instead for the civilian course after their minimum military service they can have one of a range of postings : procurator aquarum, in charge of some specific aqueduc or procurator rei machinatorum were two such entry level positions for those who left the Academia Militaria Practica without wanting to enter a military career. Their rank is called quadragenarii for their only gain 40 000 sestertii per year of service.

Most civilian equestrian are of the sexagenarii rank, including the 140 procurator augusti in charge of the provinces, the procurators a rei privatae managing some particular imperial properties or the praefecti civitatis, special ambassadorial positions sent to client states such as the Bosphorean kingdom where they make sure the interests of Rome are well defended.

The rank of centenarii is often held by some of the men in charge of the central administration of the empire or holding special commissions for the emperor, some of the most famous being the procurator monetae or the ab epistulis latinis and the ab epistulis graecis in charge of the emperor’s correspondence.

The two ducenarii office, bringing 200 000 sestertii a year to those holding those positions, are those of the a rationibus, charged of collecting all taxes, and of the a rei privatae, manager of the Emperor’s private holdings. Some procurator augusti extra-ordinarii are also induced at that rank when necessary.

Above them are the trecenarii offices : the praefectus of the vigilae of Rome, the praefectus annonae in charge of the food transport to Rome, the praefectus Aegypti, a special position responsible only to the emperor that can countermand any order by the vicarius in charge of Aegyptus, with the power to give direct orders to the legions to intervene in civil affairs in the area should he feel the need, orders which not even the senatorial praefectus of Africa can countermand.

Also in this category are the procurator a studiis, in charge of information gathering, the procurator a libellis, who selected and prepared the cases submitted to the Emperor’s judgement and the procurator a cognitionibus, charged with preparing the cases against those the Emperor designates as needing to be investigated.

But the ultimate position of the equestrian cursus honorum is of course that of prefect of the praetorian guard, with its enormous one million sestertii a year salary and unrivalled power in the Empire safe for that of the Princeps and of his heir. “

His feather was in need of resharpening, his hand was cramped from too much writing, but he thought he now had answered properly the first question of his examination… It was his own potential future he’d described there, a career of which he’d never thought but that could be his for the taking. His head spinned with the thought. But it did not have much time. A look at the sandglass in front of the room told him the story : he’d spent a bit less than half his allocated time writing this answer...
 
Last edited:

Hecatee

Donor
this very long post (the second one may come later this week) is both a refresher, a place to condensate a lot of info I have in various notes and also shows a number of evolution from the time of Marcus Aurelius (a new diocese, suppression of a rank of machinatorum due to the provinces being a lot smaller, massive increase - x10 - of the number of active civilian machinatorum, ...).
 
Another great post! it's nice to get a good look at the new roman bureaucracy, if this trend of training and examination continues maybe a bit more meritocracy will slip into the system.
 
The other interesting thing is that it is a written examination and not a viva. This would imply a much higher quality of literacy than was the norm IOTL
 

Hecatee

Donor
Another great post! it's nice to get a good look at the new roman bureaucracy, if this trend of training and examination continues maybe a bit more meritocracy will slip into the system.

Well the system in a way already includes more meritocracy than OTL, even if patronage remains an important element of Roman life. On the Senatorial level rather little change even if there are some more people entering the system and some less getting the consulate : the Senate will soon need to become bigger in theoretical numbers although not in actual number of persons present : there are more people in the province and the Senate is now mainly made of young men in their late twenties who need to get the Princeps favor (or at least not be stopped by him) and so are rather devoted, and older men in their fifties and beyond who have had all the positions they could, and are there to make sure their sons succeed in getting into the Senate before going back to their estate to quiet and usually content retirement.

The other interesting thing is that it is a written examination and not a viva. This would imply a much higher quality of literacy than was the norm IOTL

Two elements : centurions, although they can rise up through the rank, were often young men from equestrian rank starting directly at the centurion level thanks to their money, so those would have a rather high literacy level. Those coming from the ranks may also have had to learn because every roman "NCO" had to be able to read orders and documents, and write reports. In theory all soldiers (at least in the legion) had basic reading abilities. We know that soldiers read books (including, famously, poetry by Martial or Juvenal). And the empire has been putting more emphasis on learning for close to a century now, so that too is having an effect. Add to that a year in a school where our newly promoted centurion has had to read and write a lot, and this exam should come as no surprise.
 
Just a heads up. You change from writing in present tense to writing in past tense halfway through the chapter.

The district magistrates are only paid 5000 sestertii a year for two years of service, but they do not oversee cases above a value of a thousand sestertii and mainly collect the head tax, the harvest tax and the inheritance tax : while of course some very rich persons had a vicesima hereditatium above 5000 sestertii, the 5% tax on their inheritance was often levied directly in Rome and not in the province so the lower salary was not seen as a problem, especially as caught cheating they would be fined between 50 000 and 200 000 sestertii.

Finally the town magistrates only received a thousand sestertii a year, a recent innovation to attract candidates for the function, they were in charge of maintaining the city infrastructure and collect some local taxes such as the one on wood for the bath’s furnaces.

Overall the appearance of the old roman traditions had been preserved, and there were still a cursus honorum for both the senatorial class and the equestrian class that would have been recognizable by the divine Augustus.
Here specificaly.
 

Hecatee

Donor
Just a heads up. You change from writing in present tense to writing in past tense halfway through the chapter.
Thanks, I tried to look for consistency but writing in a foreign langage and being late for my update made me take shortcuts including not doing a full reread... I'll update later with some style revision (but in theory none on content)
 
@Hecatee I have a few questions.


One, I am not sure how big these new divisions are, the top level ones bellow the Emperor are explained. But how big are these diocese, new provinces and other administrative divisions above the town magistrate who is also understood. Try giving examples in terms of countries or well known regions.


Two, what is Rome now, politically speaking? To start, what do the people think? Obviously gone are the days of First Among Equals shadowplay, the Emperor is the Emperor indisputably now. But do the people still think they live in a Republic despite of this and other issues? While obviously not a Republic for real since there seem to be no elections of any kind anymore, just appointment upwards through the ranks by your superiors.

At the same time Rome is not really a Feudal Monarchy either. No landed/permanent titles, not even for the Emperor anymore. Maybe best described as an Oligarchy with fairly entrenched Aristocrats in the form of the Equestrian and Senatorial classes? Even the Emperors are chosen from within this class and the title should theoretically rotate among these influential families. Speaking of the Emperorship, is the Senate empowered enough to reject a proposed Imperial Heir?

There is some Meritocracy with people being able to earn entry into the Equestrian class with hard work. But it seems even the highest achieving Equestrians will not become Senators unless raised up directly by the Emperor for special achievements like that guy who defended Britain. So it seems there is not full Meritocracy yet, though seems Chinese influence is helping it grow. Furthermore, what happens if a child of a Senator or an Equestrian does not start their Cursus Honorum for whatever reason or fails entirely, do they lose this status, do their children have a shot at CH if their father failed?

Quite a few "?" there, hope you don't feel overwhelmed :p
 

Hecatee

Donor
@Hecatee I have a few questions.


One, I am not sure how big these new divisions are, the top level ones bellow the Emperor are explained. But how big are these diocese, new provinces and other administrative divisions above the town magistrate who is also understood. Try giving examples in terms of countries or well known regions.


Two, what is Rome now, politically speaking? To start, what do the people think? Obviously gone are the days of First Among Equals shadowplay, the Emperor is the Emperor indisputably now. But do the people still think they live in a Republic despite of this and other issues? While obviously not a Republic for real since there seem to be no elections of any kind anymore, just appointment upwards through the ranks by your superiors.

At the same time Rome is not really a Feudal Monarchy either. No landed/permanent titles, not even for the Emperor anymore. Maybe best described as an Oligarchy with fairly entrenched Aristocrats in the form of the Equestrian and Senatorial classes? Even the Emperors are chosen from within this class and the title should theoretically rotate among these influential families. Speaking of the Emperorship, is the Senate empowered enough to reject a proposed Imperial Heir?

There is some Meritocracy with people being able to earn entry into the Equestrian class with hard work. But it seems even the highest achieving Equestrians will not become Senators unless raised up directly by the Emperor for special achievements like that guy who defended Britain. So it seems there is not full Meritocracy yet, though seems Chinese influence is helping it grow. Furthermore, what happens if a child of a Senator or an Equestrian does not start their Cursus Honorum for whatever reason or fails entirely, do they lose this status, do their children have a shot at CH if their father failed?

Quite a few "?" there, hope you don't feel overwhelmed :p

So the prefectures and diocesis are rather clear, I won't get into it except to give back the previously availlable information on them :

  • Africae (capital Carthage, 3 diocesis) : diocesis of Mauretania (maroc/algeria), diocesis of Africa (tunisia/lybia except cyrenaica), diocesis of Egypt (Cyrenaica, Egypt without Sinai)
  • Occidentalis (capital Lugdunum, 5 diocesis): diocesis Hispania (Spain, Portugal), diocesis Gallia (France extended to the Rhine in the north), diocesis Britannia, diocesis Italia (Italia except Rome area, imperial direct control), diocesis Germania (East of the Rhine below Bonna to the sources of the Viadua)+ Bohemia + Austria), diocesis Albis (Netherlands, Germany East of the Rhine above Bonna to the Viadua, continental Danemark)
  • Illyrici (capital Serdica, 5 diocesis): diocesis Iazygeia (Hungary), diocesis Dacia (Romania + Moldavia/Wallachia), diocesis Thracesis (Bulgaria + Greek and Turkish Thracia, inclusing Byzantium), diocesis Illyria (ex-Yougoslavia + Albania), diocesis Graecia (Greece and all islands in eastern med west of Rhodos)
  • Orientalis (capital Antiocheia, 4 diocesis): Diocesis Asia (western and southern Turkey), Diocesis Pontica (northern and eastern Turkey) Diocesis Mesopotamia (Iraq), Diocesis Syria (Syria, Lebanon, Israël, Palestine, Jordan, Sinai)

The provinces are around 5 days horseback from the most distant point to the other. That means an average size around 150 to 200 000 km², around a third of the size of France. In practice a lot of provinces are smaller : for instance Sicily is only 25 000 km².

The pagus level is on average around 7000 to 8000 km², the size of a large French departement. It usually holds about 2 to 4 districts, which may hold a number of towns with their local magistrates. Thus for instance Tuscany is divided in 3 pagi but holds of course quite a number of towns and cities.

About politics. Complex topic... To the basic citizens the formal form of their nation is not important, beside most are not even citizens (which they were OTL but here we did not have the 212 Caracalla edict). For those who care to split hairs, they go back to Polybius book VI and declare that they live in an Aristocracy, a governement by the best ones, and keep it at that even if SPQR is still used in propaganda. The use of the term aristocracy also promotes the idea that merit can get you higher in the foodchain since it literraly mean "rule by the better ones".

First : there are elections going on up to the Pagus level, but you need money to be campaigning, so the candidates do come from the local rich, the richer the higher level they aim for. Also note that Roman citizenship is not a condition to enter the election in a town that does not have roman citizenship, in fact completing a mandate a city magistrate does give the citizenship, allowing to postulate for further functions. At the level of the pagus all candidates have equestrian level fortune at least. Often the pagus level is taken by retired equestrians of the military career come home to enjoy life after too many years in the camps...

In Rome itself all positions up to and including the praetor position, although the list of candidates is filtered by the Emperor. The consuls are formally elected by the Senate, altough it is simply rubberstamping the Emperor's choice.

At every point in time we have around 150 young senators serving in the legions as tribunus laticlavus, with around 17 to 20 new ones every year. Then we have 25 quaestors, 14 aedils, 25 praetors, 30 legion commanders, 18 vicarii, 2 consuls and 4 governors. That is between 275 to 300 senators serving the Empire and Rome at any given time, two to three times more than in the late republican period, which means that the senate has had to be enlarged again to 900 senators (Augustus had reduced it from 900 to 600).

While reaching the senate level is hard, it is not unheard of : there are new families coming into the senate every few years, so an upward mobility does exist and is seen to exist by the elites. Usually it will happen thanks to some good mariages and a lot of money, or indeed by imperial adlectio, direct addition of an individual to the senate. The larger senate makes it somewhat easier than in the early principate.

The Senate is not a simple rubber stambing chamber, and in case of the designation of an heir the senatorial leaders will be consulted, so that the vote is but the conclusion of an hidden exchange of views.

The equestrian class is even more open : get rich enough or be brave and clever enough and you will get into the order and from there you can build up your career. In that I'm not straying too far from OTL : we have at least two exemples of soldiers from the rank getting to the position of prefect of the praetorian guard in the second half of the 2nd century, here in fact I've increased the number of availlable positions. The army gives around 200 positions (primus pilus centurions) that give access to the equestrian rank, (the legions have around 2000 centurions, the auxiliary units around 2500, so that's 200 primus pilus out of around 4500 centurions overall).

The equestrian order has a large number of members active in the army and administration : there are around 600 equestrians in the civil cursus honorum and around 700 hundred in the military path, for a total of around 1300 active at any time, which means that in fact you have at least three to four time as many availlable. And they themselve do not represent all the equestrians of the empire, only those who decided to invest in a career : let's say around 5000 out of some 35 to 50 000 persons rich enough to claim the rank in the Empire.

This indeed makes the system highly oligarchic, especially when one remembers that there are maybe 10 millions citizens in the empire, for an overall population of around 80 millions, and thus only around 6000 people actually taking a leading role in the direction of the empire...

As for those of senatorial families or equestrian families that do not enter the cursus honorum of their class : they keep the rank and that's it, although in case of bad behaviour or gross failure or criminal activity they can be expelled from their order by the emperor acting thanks to his powers as permanent censor.
 

Hecatee

Donor
Just a heads up. You change from writing in present tense to writing in past tense halfway through the chapter.


Here specificaly.
corrected, once more thanks for your vigilence

Long form written examinations with broad questions, I really feel for are Roman friend!
Bad university memories ? :) Here in Belgium students are just getting back to school, so an exam seemed appropriate :)
 
@Hecatee thank you for the response!

And ouch, that is an exceedingly small number of nobles (because that is what they are really) compared to the commoners. Coupled with the whole citizen vs non-citizen and not to mention slave stratification it could lead to some serious issues as a national identity forms and people get more educated and affluent and therefore demanding. There is simply so few nobles numerically, their total numbers are not even 0,1% of the total, I think even in highly stratified societies nobles always were usually a few percent of the pop. What could they even do against emerging class consciousness? Only make concessions, probably in the form of increasing upwards mobility even further.
While I think social unrest of some kind, even if it never boils over into civil war, is inevitable as Roman society modernizes. Small numbers of the aristocratic classes could be a benefit since they will produce less envy and resentment simply by being fewer in number. Not to mention these classes aren't nowhere near the drain on the system feudal nobles were, at least not yet.

Lastly, so Questors, Aediles and Praetors are elected? By the people of Rome? Like how they did in the old days, going out to a voting field and standing in penned in areas to express their will?
 
Top