These wikiboxes are based on
a list I wrote last year during the height of COVID- the pandemic inspired me to research similar periods in American history. It is generally not appreciated how bad the aftermath of World War I was for the United States and the world. 1918-1920 was a period of war, pandemic, race massacres, authoritarianism, and depression- all of which were badly handled by Woodrow Wilson. There is a reason Warren Harding was elected with one of the biggest landslides in American history. It was a very fraught period with reactionary politics which very easily could have gone quite differently in any number of ways.
Kaspar the Unfriendly Ghost: The Red Scare and the Ku Klux Klan
The German surrender at the end of 1918 brought only a temporary respite in World War I. The Kaiser abdicated at the war's conclusion, resulting in the establishment of an unstable transition government. The transition government was quickly overthrown in the Spartacist Revolution at the start of 1919, which saw Rosa Luxemburg establishing a Communist government in Berlin. Wilhelm III declared himself the new Kaiser from his exile in the Netherlands, and Freikorps factions continued to violently resist the Communists. Otto Landsberg, the leader of the Republican exile government, had the support of the Allies. The Communist government withdrew from negotiations with the Allies, and Rosa Luxemberg spoke of inspiring global communist revolution. The Allies took such talk seriously- the rapid victories of Communists in Russia and Germany made the idea of global communist revolution seem all too plausible, and there were fears that the Communists would inspire or support revolutions across Europe. The Allies invaded the German Rhineland a few months after the Spartacist Revolution in an attempt to overthrow the Spartacist government. The Allied Invasion ended up saving the shaky fledgling Communist government by giving it a foreign enemy to rally against. The Landsberg government was discredited as a foreign puppet, and public support for the Communists increased as the government mobilized to defeat the invaders.
The U.S Army joined the Franco-British invasion of Germany. President Thomas Marshall feared the spread of left-wing radicalism and believed that military action was needed to contain it. There had been a surge of radicalism given the unstable circumstances in the United States. The Influenza pandemic had killed over one million Americans, including President Woodrow Wilson a few weeks before the Kaiser surrendered. The war and the pandemic led to a decline in GDP and a surge in radicalism. While left-wing radicals remained marginal in the United States, a series of high profile attacks increased fear of Bolshevism in the United States. The most significant of these attacks would end up killing President Marshall himself.
The Italian anarchist Luigi Galleani, an advocate of "propaganda of the deed", ordered his lieutenant, Mario Buda to organize the destruction of the White House. Buda infiltrated the White House disguised as a plumber. While the Galleanists were not Bolsheviks they opposed the Allied invasion of Germany, viewing it as an act of imperial aggression, and believed that the rapid Communist victories in Europe indicated that the United States was ripe for revolution. The bombing and destruction of the White House by the Galleani Gang increased the fear of Bolshevism in the United States tenfold. Most Americans did not distinguish between differing leftist factions, believing the Galleanists to be agents of the Communist International (which included Communist governments in Germany, Russia, Hungary, Finland, and Austria). Public support for the continuation of World War I had been tentative, and many Americans called for troops to return home since the Germans had retreated from France and Belgium. Opposition to the war evaporated in the aftermath of the White House Bombing. Secretary of State Robert Lansing succeeded Marshall as President and mounted a full scale war on left-wing radicalism. American troops were fully committed to an invasion of Germany, which had degenerated into trench warfare stalemate. Lansing asked Congress to pass the National Security Act, which allowed Attorney General Palmer to conduct mass arrests and persecution of leftists and left-wing organizations. A wave of pogroms swept the country, killing thousands of African-Americans. Italians suspected of anarchist sympathies became the target of vigilante violence. The Industrial Workers of the World, the ACLU, and the NAACP were banned. (The NAACP was declared illegal under the justification that W.E.B. Dubois had communist sympathies.) The Lansing government additionally sent military expeditions to Russia - but the Arkhangelsk and Vladivostok expeditions were defeated. Lansing also secured an American mandate for Armenia in order to protect Armenians from Turkey and to attack the Communists in the Caucasus. While the Democratic Party benefited from a sympathy vote in the 1920 Presidential Election, the poor state of the economy and the poor military progress of the Allies led to Robert Lansing losing the 1920 Presidential election to Warren Harding.
The Harding Presidency would prove rather disastrous. Harding oversaw the failure of the American expedition into Armenia and the emergence of a new strain of influenza (spread by the mobilization of troops) which would kill hundreds of thousands of Americans and millions worldwide. As the Allied militaries were exhausted after years of war, Harding recognized that the continued presence of Allied troops in western Germany was not sustainable. Years of stalemate and trench warfare had failed to remove the Communist governments, and troop morale was on the verge of collapse. Harding entered negotiations with the Communist International. A ceasefire was declared in May of 1922, although the Allies did not officially recognize any of the new Communist governments. The Communist International was left in control of Germany, Austria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Poland, Finland, the Baltic states, Russia, and Romania. The Allied efforts to destroy the Communist International had failed. President Harding was commonly blamed for America's defeats, and he was further blamed for the post-war Depression, which saw deflation and high unemployment. Harding was further caught up in the Teapot Dome Scandal- congressional investigators determined that Harding was aware of Interior Secretary Fall's corruption and had directed a coverup. Harding was further found to have blackmailed a journalist who uncovered his extramarital affairs. One of Harding's mistresses, Carrie Phillips, was revealed to have been a German sympathizer, which fed into accusations that Harding had deliberately botched the war effort. Harding was impeached and removed from office in 1924, leaving the presidency to Vice President Nicholas Murray Butler. Butler signed immigration restrictions into law. Butler received the blame in the 1924 Presidential Election for Harding's scandals (Butler was not involved) and for the armistice with the Communists (Butler was prominently involved with Harding's foreign policy). The Democrats doubled down on anti-communism, nominating Alexander Mitchell Palmer over William Gibbs McAdoo. Palmer attacked Harding and Butler as soft on communism, citing Harding's pardon of Eugene Debs. Palmer even charged Butler with Communist sympathies. These were untrue charges- Harding and Butler had agreed to the armistice only out of necessity, and the Harding administration had violently suppressed railroad and coal strikes, killing hundreds of workers. Butler had been a vocal opponent of the Reds since the Bolshevik Revolution. In an attempt to booster his anti-communist credentials, Butler embarked on an anti-Semitic purge- arresting and deporting Jewish immigrants suspected of Communist sympathies. Butler touted his persecution of Jewish immigrants during the presidential campaign, saying he was defending American Christianity from a conspiracy of Bolshevik subversives. While Palmer said he would not renew hostilities with Germany and Russia, he vowed to renew his domestic crackdown on left-wing subversives he claimed had undermined the war effort. Palmer also called for a policy of containment to counter the spread of Communism. Palmer further promised to fix America's economic problems. Palmer won a comfortable victory over President Butler.
Palmer began his presidency with a renewed crackdown on leftists- persecution had subsided somewhat under the Republicans. Palmer targeted suspected Communists, arrested labor union leaders, and ordered police raids on union headquarters. Palmer signed a second version of the National Security Act which centralized power under the executive branch and gave the President nearly unlimited power to designate dissidents as terrorists. J. Edgar Hoover's Bureau of Investigation spearheaded Palmer's new anti-communist purge. Palmer also involved the United States in multiple military conflicts- the Spanish and Italian Civil Wars- in order to defeat Communist insurgents. While the Spanish Civil War ended with the decisive defeat of the Republicans, the Italian Civil War was a long and costly conflict. American troops were stationed in Italy to support the authoritarian government of Gabriele D'Annunzio, but suffered heavy losses at the hands of Communist guerrillas. Palmer believed that the Italian Communists had Galleanists among their ranks, and Italian-Americans became the target of renewed persecution in the United States as the war dragged on.
The silent film classic,
Mario and Luigi, which featured Lon Chaney and Ford Sterling as Mario Buda and Luigi Galleani, the orchestrators of the White House Bombing, was typical of the anti-Italian sentiment of the 1920s.
Following the death of Vice President Samuel Ralston, Palmer lobbied the state legislatures to pass the 20th amendment, which affected the presidential line of succession. The 20th amendment had passed Congress following the assassination of President Marshall, who had died without a Vice President. When the amendment was ratified, Palmer appointed his longtime ally Senator Oscar Underwood of Alabama as his Vice President. Palmer had befriended Underwood when they were both members of the House of Representatives. Underwood's appointment was rightly seen as a snub against the Ku Klux Klan. The Ku Klux Klan had grown rapidly in influence as a result of the Red Scare, with recruits seeing the Klan as a bulwark against Communism and Radicalism. Government officials, including President Palmer, had spent years warning of conspiracies directed by foreign Communists, which had fostered an environment ripe for the expansion of conspiracy theorist groups like the Klan. Butler's promotion of anti-Semitic conspiracy theories in the 1924 Presidential campaign sparked an anti-Semitic scare in the Republican Party which the Klan used to bolster recruitment. Palmer had defeated the KKK's preferred candidate, William Gibbs McAdoo, at the 1924 Democratic Convention. The selection of Samuel Ralston, who was supported by the Klan, as his running mate was seen as a concession to the Klan. Vice President Underwood, however, was a vocal opponent of the KKK. President Palmer largely ignored the Klan, as he was focused on persecuting Communists. However, as the KKK grew to ten million members, the issue became difficult for Palmer to avoid mentioning. In the "Secret Societies" speech of 1927, Palmer publicly denounced the KKK. Palmer declared that secret societies and vigilantism undermined public order and that combatting radicalism should be left to the Justice Department and the Police. Palmer additionally appointed numerous Catholics to high office and supported Catholic politicians like Al Smith. As Palmer courted the Catholic vote (despite persecution of Italian-Americans, Palmer framed American involvement in the Italian Civil War as protecting the Catholic Church from Communists), Palmer's progressive allies worked to block the anti-Catholic Klan's involvement in Democratic Party politics. The Klan did not suffer any persecution or investigation as the Justice Department ignored right-wing radicalism.
Stymied by the Democrats, the Ku Klux Klan turned towards the Republicans. Numerous Republican politicians were members of the Klan. The Republican Party's national leadership had been discredited by the Communist Armistice. When Oregon Senator Kaspar K. Kubli started his presidential campaign, he denounced the Republican "Old Guard" as sellouts who had surrendered to Communism. The Republican "Old Guard" further had its reputation stained by the corruption and incompetence of the Harding presidency. Many prominent Republicans had been discredited politically because of their association with Harding. Kubli, as a first term Senator and relative newcomer to national politics, was able to sell himself as a Washington outsider and reformer who would confront political corruption. Kubli was, of course, a virulent racist and open member of the Klan. His initials even spelt KKK, which was seen by the Klan as a benign portent. The Ku Klux Klan mobilized to elect state delegates to the 1928 Republican National Convention in support of Kubli. The Klan further benefitted from anti-Catholic and anti-Italian sentiment among Republicans, which was augmented by the ongoing war in Italy. Republicans who had lost faith in GOP leadership following the impeachment of Harding and the defeat of Butler in 1924 were primed to support Senator Kubli's candidacy. Despite his defeat in 1924, Butler made a comeback presidential bid at the 1928 Republican National Convention. Butler had returned to his previous job as President of Columbia University. Butler denounced the Klan's racial and religious bigotry as too violent and extreme. Butler further denounced the KKK's Confederate sympathies, declaring that the GOP was the Party of Lincoln and that pro-KKK Republicans were betraying the GOP's founding principles. As an effete East Coast egghead associated with the failed Harding administration, Butler proved the perfect foil for Kubli, who gained support from nativist Midwesterners who disliked Butler's elitism and internationalism. While Butler's status as the former President allowed him to lead on the first ballot, his support rapidly collapsed as the KKK attacked his record. Senator William Borah poised himself as the candidate of the progressives, but he was attacked for his support of normalizing diplomatic relations with the Communists. Frank Lowden gathered votes from both conservative and anti-Klan delegates, but Kubli eventually won a majority of delegates and defeated Lowden. The Klan had seized control over the Republican Party. Kubli doubled down on his far-right, anti-establishment credentials by selecting Los Angeles radio preacher Robert Shuler as his Vice President. Shuler was not a member of the Klan, but his Protestant nativism matched the Klan's own views. Known as a fiery radio demagogue, Shuler was known for his denunciation of Catholics, Jews, Negroes, Darwinists, Communists, and Alcohol. Kubli's courting of talk radio allowed him to enlist various radio programs as Klan propagandists.
Kubli vowed to crack down on bootlegging and to reinforce prohibition. He launched racist tirades against Italian-Americans, blaming them for organized crime and bootlegging. Kubli declared the Catholic Church to be an anti-American conspiracy, and promised to ban the Church altogether. Kubli attacked President Palmer for his courting of the Catholic and Jewish Vote. Kubli claimed to be even more anti-communist than Palmer, the arch anti-Bolshevik. Kubli criticized Palmer's Quaker faith, suggesting that Quaker pacifism was undermining the fight against Communism and that Palmer, because of the Quaker history of abolitionism, supported "race-mixing". Kubli denounced Palmer's management of the Italian Civil War and suggested that Palmer's progressive economic policies indicated he was secretly a Socialist or a Communist.
Above all, what doomed Palmer's re-election campaign was the Great Depression. Palmer had presided over a moderate economic recovery following the 1922-23 recession. The stock market crash of 1927, however, resulted in an economic collapse which destroyed the savings of many Americans and rapidly increased unemployment. The worst of the Great Depression was yet to come, but the effects of the Depression were quite apparent by 1928. Palmer's popularity rapidly declined throughout 1928. Kubli won the 1928 Presidential Election in a landslide. Despite Kubli's outreach to southern Democrats in order to build a "Grand White Coalition", Palmer won the majority of the former Confederacy. The first Klansman to be elected President was thus ironically voted into office by Northern states. Palmer additionally won Massachusetts, New York and Rhode Island because of Catholic and Jewish voters. After the election, President-elect Kubli held meetings with senior Klan officials and Southern segregationists in a bid to win southern support for his agenda in Congress and in future campaigns. After all, it was quite natural that the old heartland of the Klan ally with the first Klan President. Burton K. Wheeler, a Democratic senator who was the Progressive candidate for Vice President in 1924, resurrected the Progressive ticket to provide a more left-wing alternative to the two major party candidates. Wheeler courted Democrats dissatisfied with Palmer's handling of the Great Depression, and his running mate, anti-Klan progressive Republican Senator Hiram Johnson, courted Republicans distrustful of the KKK. The Progressive ticket won Montana and North Dakota.
The 1928 Presidential Election was a particularly violent campaign, as the KKK murdered hundreds of ethnic activists who criticized the Klan's white supremacist policies. Following Kubli's election the Klan celebrated by holding massive parades dressed in full Klan uniform. These parades and rallies quickly turned into attacks on minorities and minority neighborhoods. Blacks, Jews, Hispanics, and Italians were all targeted by Klan militants as Kubli promised start his presidency by purging Italian-American mobsters. In New York City the month after the election, Exalted Cyclops Fred Trump led a Klan mob against the Italian neighborhood of East Flatbush. Trump demanded the Italians of East Flatbush surrender the Mafia bootleggers and Communists who allegedly lived in the neighborhood. A low ranking two bit crook named Harold Giuliani, who was part of the gang defending the neighborhood, excitedly fired a gun at the Klan mob. Trump killed Giuliani and ransacked East Flatbush without police interference, killing dozens of Italians. The Mafia vowed to retaliate against the Klan for the unprompted massacre of Italians. The Battle of East Flatbush thus marked the start of the Mafia-KKK Wars, and a wave of ethnic conflict that would define the Kubli presidency.
TO BE CONTINUED