George "Big Southern" McGovern was an American historian, author, fighter pilot, and politician. The son of immigrants, McGovern was born to a Methodist Republican family on a 600‑person farming community in Avon, South Dakota. His father worked in coal mines from the age of nine and was orphaned at thirteen before growing up to be a professional baseball player. Giving up his career on account his teammates' heavy drinking, gambling and womanizing, the elder McGovern entered the seminary before meeting and wedding Canadian born Frances McGovern (née: McLean).
George was the second oldest of four children and lived on edge of poverty for much of his childhood. His fathers' salary chiefly consisted of potatoes, cabbages, and other food items. Attending public schools, McGovern was painfully shy and rebellious only to the point of seeing movies (a worldly amusement forbidden to Wesleyan Methodists). Growing up during the Great Depression, McGovern's formative years were spent with underpaid workers and struggling farmers and influenced by currents of populism, agrarian unrest, and the "practical divinity" of cleric John Wesley, who sought to fight poverty, injustice, and ignorance.
Supplementing his forensic university scholarship with a variety of odd jobs, McGovern volunteered to join the United States Air Force after the attack on Pearl Harbor. Promoted to Second Lieutenant McGovern participated in the "Big Week" strategic bombing campaign across Southern Europe, which goaded the Luftwaffe into confrontation with the United States Strategic Air Forces. Stationed at San Giovanni Airfield near Cerignola in the Apulia region of Italy, McGovern and his crew found a starving, disease-ridden local population wracked by the ill fortunes of war and far worse off than anything they had seen during the Great Depression. This sight greatly influenced McGovern's later motivation to fight hunger across the world.
Lieutenant McGovern came within inches of being fatally wounded by stray shrapnel, nearly collided mid-air during a close-formation flight, survived a blown wheel during a mission over enemy territory, and was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross after landing a plane with two destroyed engines on an unforgiving field that had claimed the lives of several previous crews. McGovern also later recalled an incident over Austria in which he accidentally bombed a family farmhouse when a jammed bomb improvidentally released above the structure and destroyed it. The event haunted McGovern for decades until he recounted the incident to the Austrian press forty years later. The owner of the farm approached the media to let him know that no one had been hurt, and that he felt the damage to his farm had been worth the price if it helped achieve the defeat of Nazi Germany in some small way. McGovern reportedly teared up receiving this news.
As the war drew to a close McGovern's embarked upon his 35th mission, a sortie against the heavily fortified city of Linz. the sky turned black and red with flak – McGovern later recalled "Hell can't be any worse than that" – and his aircraft was hit multiple times resulting in 110 holes in its fuselage and wings and an inoperative hydraulic system. McGovern's waist gunner was injured, and his flight engineer was so unnerved by his experience that he would subsequently be hospitalized with battle fatigue but McGovern managed to bring back the plane safely with the assistance of an improvised landing technique. Following the end of the war, McGovern flew food relief flights to northern Italy, then flew back to the United States with his crew. He was discharged from the Army Air Forces in July 1945 and awarded the Air Medal with three oak leaf clusters.
For a while McGovern suffered from nightmares about flying through flak barrages or his plane being on fire but eventually regained his composure. Nominally a Republican growing up, McGovern began to admire Democratic President Franklin Delano Roosevelt during the war even though he supported Roosevelt's opponent Thomas Dewey in the 1944 presidential election. Supporting Henry Wallace for President in 1948, McGovern was later captivated by a radio broadcast of Governor Adlai Stevenson's speech upon accepting the Democratic nomination in 1952. He immediately dedicated himself to Stevenson's campaign and named his only son Steven, born immediately after the convention, after his new hero. Although Stevenson lost the election, McGovern remained active in politics, believing that the "engine of progress in our time in America is the Democratic Party".
In 1956, McGovern sought elective office himself, and ran for the House of Representatives from South Dakota's 1st congressional district, his opponent's campaign implied that McGovern's support for admitting the People's Republic of China to the United Nations and his past support for Henry Wallace meant that McGovern was a Communist appeaser or sympathizer. In his closing speech, McGovern responded: "I have always despised communism and every other ruthless tyranny over the mind and spirit of man." McGovern staged an upset victory, gaining 116,516 votes to his opponent's 105,835, and became the first Democrat elected to Congress from South Dakota in 22 years.
In the 86th United States Congress, McGovern was assigned to the House Committee on Agriculture. The longtime chair of the committee, Harold D. Cooley, would subsequently remark, "I cannot recall a single member of Congress who has fought more vigorously or intelligently for American farmers than Congressman McGovern." McGovern was defeated in his 1960 bid for Senate, but was picked to become a Special Assistant to the President and first director of Kennedy's high-priority Food for Peace program, which realized what McGovern had been advocating in the House.
As director, McGovern urged the greater use of food to enable foreign economic development, saying, "We should thank God that we have a food abundance and use the over-supply among the under-privileged at home and abroad." By the close of 1961, the Food for Peace program was operating in a dozen countries, and 10 million more people had been fed with American surplus than the year before. In February 1962, McGovern visited India and oversaw a greatly expanded school lunch program thanks to Food for Peace; subsequently one in five Indian schoolchildren would be fed from it, and by mid-1962, 35 million children around the world. During an audience in Rome, Pope John XXIII warmly praised McGovern's work, and the distribution program was also popular among South Dakota's wheat farmers.
McGovern was instrumental in the creation of the United Nations-run World Food Programme in December 1961; it started distributing food to stricken regions of the world the following year and would go on to become the largest humanitarian agency fighting hunger worldwide. By 1965 the program had become a vital force in the world, improving living conditions and economies of allies and creating a powerful barrier to the spread of Communism. The program was later lauded by President George Romney as "one of few truly spectacular achievements in an otherwise bleak administration" and "the greatest unseen weapon of our third-world policy" upon its formal incorporation into the State Department in 1965. [1] [2]
On matters of foreign policy, McGovern fit solidly into the mold of the typical "Romney Democrat". Backing the war in Viet nam under President Kennedy, McGovern flatly rejected unconditional withdrawal of U.S. forces from Southeast Asia and criticized anti-war draft-card burnings as "immature, impractical, and illegal" [3] Serving as Secretary of Agriculture in the First Romney Administration, McGovern lent his expertise to the logistical nightmare that was feeding those still displaced by the Goldsboro Disaster. After seeing through the creation of the North Carolina Exclusion Zone, McGovern felt situation sufficiently stabilized enough to resign his post. Never fancying himself an administrator, McGovern yearned for another opportunity to run for the Senate. In 1966 McGovern defeated his perennial rival, Marine Fighter Ace and Former South Dakota Governor Joe Foss, to become the state's first Democratic Senator in over twenty years.
It was during his first successful senatorial campaign that McGovern received the nickname of "Big Southern", an allusion to both his bombing runs during "The
Big Week" in the late war and his tireless advocacy for his home state of
South Dakota. Originally conceived as a moniker to counter that of Joe "Ace of Aces" Foss, McGovern was reportedly embarrassed by the name as it conveyed too much "machismo" for his personal tastes. But when the press picked up on it, especially the part about McGovern's reluctance, the name stuck.
In the Senate McGovern gained a reputation as a bridge builder, working with both sides on pertinent issues. Backing Romney's civil rights and affordable housing initiatives, McGovern nonetheless opposed the deep cuts to the space budget used to pay for the latter program. After loosing to Governor John Connally in the 1972 Democratic Primaries, McGovern helped carry the West for the Texan in the general campaign. Following a Democratic take over of the White House in 1972, McGovern fell in lockstep with the "Connally Creed" of acknowledging the mistakes of previous administrations on civil rights and working to improve the lives of the nation's poor, black or white. [4] It was at this time that McGovern dropped his support for school busing and began advocating for an affirmative action program based on income rather than race.
As a top "Connie Hawk", McGovern voted in favor of U.S. military intervention in the Azores and Cape Verde Islands. [5] Although initially optimistic about the election of Massachusetts Senator Edward Brooke to the presidency, McGovern would later become fiercely critical of Brooke's failure to prevent the East Timor Genocide. Noting that the occupation affected a percentage of the East Timorese population that made "Hitler's operation look tame", McGovern joined his Democratic colleagues in calling for a condemnation of Indonesian strongman Muhammad Suharto for war crimes. [6] McGovern's military background, western appeal, strong union support, and political service in both Democratic and Republican administrations made him a frontrunner for the Democratic nomination in 1980. Being put off by his defeat to Connally in 1972, he ultimately decided against it and backed former Vice President Birch Bayh. When Robert Morgen clinched the nomination, McGovern declared he would back him "1000 percent" but later withdrew his support after the Edwards Leaks. With President Brooke's re-election, George "Big Southern" McGovern maintains his status as a frontrunner for the next presidential nomination... [7]
Footnotes
[1] This is where things start to diverge, IOTL McGovern resigned as Director of Food for Peace in order to run for Senate in 1962. ITTL Goldsboro makes such a run untenable and McGovern completes his directorship, which ends in 1965.
[2] Johnson merged Food For Peace into the State Department IOTL, Romney has just as much reason to do so ITTL.
[3] IOTL, in 1963, McGovern questioned U.S. involvement in Vietnam, but this criticism was limited to one speech and McGovern did not speak on the issue again until 1965. IOTL McGovern voted for the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, which allowed Johnson to escalate the war in Vietnam. Wayne Morse, one of only two senators to oppose the resolution, noted that McGovern's later opposition to the resolution fell into the category of "very interesting, but very belated". Since Romney ended the war early ITTL, McGovern is seen as just another "Romney Democrat" who opposed the Vietnam War once it became unpopular with the public.
[4] IOTL McGovern supported school busing but did not practice it with his own children, it isn't hard to imagine a turnaround for him on the issue.
[5] IOTL McGovern backed the First Gulf War, the Azores and Cape Verde Wars are similar in size, scope, and intent ITTL.
[6] IOTL McGovern advocated military intervention to overthrow Pol Pot, his quote on genocide stems from that advocacy IOTL.
[7] IOTL McGovern ran for president in 1968 and 1972. IOTL he also considered running for president in 1976, 1984, and 1992.
[8] Large chunks of this update are taken from McGovern's Wikipedia page.