The Rainbow. A World War One on Canada's West Coast Timeline

A winner!

Major T.V. Scudamore of the British Columbia Regiment, having been captured at Ypres after being wounded, wrote of the "contemptible" Ross rifle, "Those in the front line with that rifle will never forget... what it is like to be charged by the flower of the German army... and be unable to fire a shot in return."[8]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_rifle
My understanding is that it was an excellent rifle, especially for sporting purposes. But totally failed in the muck and grime of the trenches.
Militia in BC should have no problem keeping it clean, which means there's no reason for it not to work.

OTOH. Militia. A sloppy soldier (easy enough) and a sloppy sergeant (less so) could result in lousy maintenance and that problem, I suppose.
A tho away line like 'Hunh. Joe. No wonder he was captured, he never did take care of his kit.' ought to take care of the problem, IMO.
 
I have one very important question. Will the mighty Canadian Shovel Shield make an appearance.

Is the hole for opening syrup bottles?

OTOH. Militia. A sloppy soldier (easy enough) and a sloppy sergeant (less so) could result in lousy maintenance and that problem, I suppose.
A tho away line like 'Hunh. Joe. No wonder he was captured, he never did take care of his kit.' ought to take care of the problem, IMO.

Backwater posting. An improperly maintained armory with weapons that aren't stored or cleaned properly. Unlikely i know, but the wilderness of Canada is exactly where such a thing might be found. After all, the Huns will never attack there.

Joe doesn't even need to be overly sloppy, just a little clumsy. Oops, dropped the rifle in a puddle (Not hard to find those in Canada), and didn't clean it since he had to hurry to his post on the bridge.
 
Is the hole for opening syrup bottles?



Backwater posting. An improperly maintained armory with weapons that aren't stored or cleaned properly. Unlikely i know, but the wilderness of Canada is exactly where such a thing might be found. After all, the Huns will never attack there.

Joe doesn't even need to be overly sloppy, just a little clumsy. Oops, dropped the rifle in a puddle (Not hard to find those in Canada), and didn't clean it since he had to hurry to his post on the bridge.


Sadly no. You're supposed to stick the handle in the ground and then lay down and stick your rifle through the big hole. The problem was that the shovel was terrible as a shovel due to having a big hole in it and being too heavy. It was also terrible as a shield because the blade covered such a small area as to be pointless and the metal was so thin as to be completely unable to stop anything.
 
Sadly no. You're supposed to stick the handle in the ground and then lay down and stick your rifle through the big hole. The problem was that the shovel was terrible as a shovel due to having a big hole in it and being too heavy. It was also terrible as a shield because the blade covered such a small area as to be pointless and the metal was so thin as to be completely unable to stop anything.

That was bungled then. A shield that will do anything is too heavy to be a shovel. If you want it to be a monopod, put a hook or a platform partway up, or give it a typical 'Y' handle. Stick the blade in the dirt, and you have a monopod.
 
That was bungled then. A shield that will do anything is too heavy to be a shovel. If you want it to be a monopod, put a hook or a platform partway up, or give it a typical 'Y' handle. Stick the blade in the dirt, and you have a monopod.

And you've just proved you're significantly smarter then every bastard in the Canadian military leadership that approved that thing.
 
with any luck on the 18th a suitable scapegoat will be found ........hopefully the canadian army will be spared a few years of cronyism perpetrated by Sam.
 
Sir Sam Hughes?
The very same.
"...almost everyone who knew him was convinced he was in some way insane.[46]"

A great ATL OP would be "What if Sam Hughes was not insane?"

He would make an excellent character in a story, he provides so much material. But it would be hard to make him more extreme in fiction than he was in reality. For our purposes Hughes only plays a tangential role, and the sailors have no use for shovels.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacAdam_Shield_Shovel

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Hughes
 
That was bungled then. A shield that will do anything is too heavy to be a shovel. If you want it to be a monopod, put a hook or a platform partway up, or give it a typical 'Y' handle. Stick the blade in the dirt, and you have a monopod.
Hole was supposed to be for the eye. It was a terrible idea. The Wiki article says Canadian snipers did use them on occasion later in the war. but a bunch of layers stacked up.
 
My understanding is that it was an excellent rifle, especially for sporting purposes. But totally failed in the muck and grime of the trenches.
Militia in BC should have no problem keeping it clean, which means there's no reason for it not to work.

OTOH. Militia. A sloppy soldier (easy enough) and a sloppy sergeant (less so) could result in lousy maintenance and that problem, I suppose.
A tho away line like 'Hunh. Joe. No wonder he was captured, he never did take care of his kit.' ought to take care of the problem, IMO.
The Ross made an excellent sporting weapon, and Canadian snipers continued to use them until the end of the war and beyond. Presumably snipers could take the time to give the rifle the care it needed.

I am exaggerating the rifle's failings for dramatic effect, although any rifle can jam at any time.
 
A spark dancing
Aug 17, 1820. Digby Island, Prince Rupert harbour.

Stabbootsman Lange stood in the bow of the leading yawl. The oarsmen were working hard, and the landing beach lay just ahead. Out of the fog he could see the two towers and the roof of his objective, the Dominion Wireless Station Digby Island. Prince Rupert’s crew had cut the submarine cable to the station, but operators could still send signals manually. Captain Von Schönberg preferred that they did not. Back on the Nürnberg, the wireless operator was monitoring the airwaves, and prepared to jam on the first dot or dash that the station transmitted.

But that would tip their hand to all the wireless equipped ships in the harbour that some caper was up. If his team was fast, they could storm the wireless station before they got word off. The two boats ground up on the beach, and the men jumped ashore. Most were armed with rifles, some also carried axes and bolt cutters, and a pair of men trailed behind carrying the now obligatory crate of Dynamite.

As the men left the beach they had to clamber over huge logs that had become stranded at the high tide mark. Then they had to scramble up a steep bank that left them almost exhausted when they reached the top. The men caught their breath in the tree line. Lange could see the station was a collection of wood frame buildings. One was two stories and looked like a farmhouse. The others seemed to be storerooms and shacks. All were quite new looking. The buildings sat in the middle of a hundred meter clearing, tangled with shrubs and giant stumps. The masts holding up the antenna were made of wood, stepped like ship’s masts, well over 70 meters tall and supported by guy wires, with the long antenna wire stretched between almost lost in the fog.

Having scouted the location, the main body of men advanced towards the largest building at a walk, covering the building with their rifles and weaving between stumps and shrubs. A pair of men headed towards each mast, running at a crouch, One sailor, the best rifle shot, climbed up onto a stump as tall as a house, and took an overwatch position with his rifle. Some faint sounds of explosions came from the distance. A dog began to bark.

The door opened, and a man stuck his head out. “Paddy! Quiet!” he yelled at the dog, then closed the door again. The dog stopped barking, then started up again. Some more distant explosions sounded. The men broke into a run.

A pair of sailors reached the bottom of one of the radio masts, and noticing the antenna and ground wires wire running up the pole, cut them with their axe.

The Canadian opened the door again, but before he could shush the barking dog, he noticed thirty-odd armed men in German naval uniforms approaching the front door at a full run, only a few paces away. The Canadian ducked back inside shouting. Lange and his men thundered up the stairs onto the veranda and shouldered the door aside without slowing. The dog, a spaniel, stood a distance down the veranda, barking its head off. In the front room the first Canadian was shouting and pointing, and two other men in khaki uniforms sat at a kitchen table, looking up from their card game. Two rifles leaned against the wall in the corner of the room. One of the militiamen looked over at the rifles.

“No, no, no,” said Lange, pointing his Navy Luger carbine at the men. The men remained seated. The front room of the house continued to fill with German sailors.

“Search the building!” Lange ordered. The men in the front room were ushered outside at gunpoint, with their hands in the air. Teams of sailors searched upstairs and down. At the back of the first floor was the radio operations room. The radio operator, having interpreted the commotion, was wildly tapping on his key. The sailors interrupted him. He tried frantically to get a few more words into his alarm message, until one of the sailors said “Antenna,” and made a snipping motion with his first two fingers. Through a small window in the operations room, the Germans could see a spark dancing on the transmitter gear in the next room.

Upstairs were accommodations. Outside was an engine house with a big one cylinder Fairbanks Morse, a generator shed, and sundry storage outbuildings. Beside the engine house was a 500 gallon gasoline tank, half full. The wireless operator and three more men in civilian clothing were produced by the search of the station.

The Canadians were informed they were prisoners of war, and were marched back to the boats under guard. The dog followed them. The radio operations equipment was destroyed with axes. Some sailors were about to do the same with the transmitter and its transformer, when they were stopped by another crewman of the landing party, who was cross-trained as an electrician. “There could be a million volts in those boxes,” he said. “Don’t be in such a hurry to kill yourself. We are burning the building down anyway.” Dynamite charges were placed in the Fairbanks Morse engine and the generators.

At Lange’s direction, sailors opened the drain tap on the gasoline tank and filled some buckets. The men poured gasoline down the halls of the radio building, leading in a trail to the front door. Fuses were lit in the sheds. Lange and the remaining landing party stood by the front steps. A sailor stuck a match. There were sounds of running footsteps from inside. Lange motioned for the sailor to freeze, and the man blew out his match. The men raised their rifles to cover the doorway. A woman and a girl of about 10 years, in long dresses, ran out the front door, their eyes wild. They stopped short when they saw they were looking down a dozen rifle barrels.

Lange motioned for the men to lower their guns. “I ordered the building to be searched,” he said sharply to his men. He turned to face the woman, and dug deep to find the English words. “I apologize ma’am. We thought we had cleared the building.”

The girl clung to her mother, but she did not cry. Instead she looked like she would take all the Germans on by herself, given an opportunity. “We hid,” said the woman. “But then we smelled the fumes. Where is my husband?”

“He is a prisoner of war.” Lange replied. The woman recoiled. “But I give you my word that he is safe,” Lange continued. “And he will be released at the earliest opportunity. You should see him again soon.” The Spaniel returned from across the clearing, and leaned against the girl’s legs.

“Please now,” said Lange, “move back from the building. Your shoes have been walking in gasoline.” The sailors stood back to let them pass. “Is there a place you can walk to from here for shelter?”

The woman responded cautiously, as if she suspected she was being interrogated. “Yes,” she said curtly.

“You should go then.” said Lange. The girl looked at Lange, and then up at her mother. This was not what she expected. “We will be leaving now. Do not return to these buildings, they will all be destroyed. Again I apologize. I am afraid this is what war is like.”

The woman and girl walked away, slowly at first, then they broke into a run. The dog ran beside them.

“That was too close,” said Lange. “Alright. Back to it.” The sailor with the match box lit and threw a match onto the front steps. A fireball burst on the stairs, blasting heat in the men’s faces. The flames raced in through the front door, and the windows lit up orange. The remainder of the party, with Lange at the rear, headed back for the boats. They were halfway across the clearing when the upstairs windows shattered, and the flames reached past the roof of the building. The Dynamite charges went off on the other side of the building. The remaining gasoline in the fuel tank went off in an enormous fireball. The sailors at the bases of the antenna masts waited until the landing party was past. Then they used boltcutters to cut the guywires on the sides of the masts facing away from the station. When the landing party was safely back at the treeline they lit the fuses on the charges placed at the base of the masts.

As these men reached the treeline, the wireless masts were blasted by explosions, and they fell, one after the other towards the blazing wireless operations building. One landed directly on the roof, slicing through the building and raising a burst of sparks and flames. Ten minutes later the party was back in its boats and rowing away.

https://www.roughradio.ca/albums/bowerman/wjb000-025.html
 
Last edited:

Driftless

Donor
The Germans have had success by a combination of daring, good planning, and taking selected objectives by surprise. Those actions have been in comparatively isolated locations, but with this attack into Port Rupert, that measure of surprise is quickly fading. Future activity is likely to end in some real shooting matches.
 
Was the militia armed with the Ross at that time, or something older, such as Martini Henry's?
I expect it would be whatever was available. Lee-Metfords, Boer War Era Lee-Enfields, and Rosses. Osprey Canadian Corps of World War I says the Ross was the standard Canadian infantry rifle since 1905.
 
The Germans have had success by a combination of daring, good planning, and taking selected objectives by surprise. Those actions have been in comparatively isolated locations, but with this attack into Port Rupert, that measure of surprise is quickly fading. Future activity is likely to end in some real shooting matches.

Only if more than two militia can be summoned to a given location.
 

Driftless

Donor
There are lots of militia in Victoria, and Vancouver, and as well Vernon, which is 6 hours inland.

Right, that's where I'd expect them to be. Other than that, only very important locations. He who is strong everywhere is strong no where

The next round at Port Rupert could resemble the Battle of Penang, where the Emden caught the Russians and French by surprise and sank the Russian cruiser Zhemchug and the French destroyer Mousquet. But here, there is some level of awareness of the immediate German presence, so it largely depends on how prepared the Russian auxiliary cruiser and the Canadian gunboat are to take on the Nurnberg. Both are overmatched one-on-one, but that may not matter. Add to that whatever armed militia response Captain Fry can scratch up in short order onshore. Still, I'd think there would be some more shots exchanged shortly.

Certainly, after these two daring and destructive raids (Anyox for sure and assuming Port Rupert), the hunt for the Nurnberg would almost certainly be kicked into even more urgency and more forces assigned.
 
The next round at Port Rupert could resemble the Battle of Penang, where the Emden caught the Russians and French by surprise and sank the Russian cruiser Zhemchug and the French destroyer Mousquet. But here, there is some level of awareness of the immediate German presence, so it largely depends on how prepared the Russian auxiliary cruiser and the Canadian gunboat are to take on the Nurnberg. Both are overmatched one-on-one, but that may not matter. Add to that whatever armed militia response Captain Fry can scratch up in short order onshore. Still, I'd think there would be some more shots exchanged shortly.

Certainly, after these two daring and destructive raids (Anyox for sure and assuming Port Rupert), the hunt for the Nurnberg would almost certainly be kicked into even more urgency and more forces assigned.
For context, The Battle of Penang (A pretty one sided battle) happened on October 28, 1914. The action here is currently happening on August 17th, 1914. War was only declared on the 4th, 13 days ago. Events ITTL could cause wide reaching changes to Royal Navy deployment compared to OTL. But in the short term, as per Premier McBride's briefing to cabinet in the Chapter entitled Standing Orders, there are only very limited resources available within reach. All this is as per OTL.
 
Top