偉大な恐ろしい戦争: A more bloody and impactful Boshin War

Who is winning the war?

  • Shogunate

    Votes: 5 18.5%
  • Empire

    Votes: 16 59.3%
  • Shogunate (barely)

    Votes: 2 7.4%
  • Empire (barely)

    Votes: 4 14.8%

  • Total voters
    27
  • Poll closed .
Prologue
第 1 章: 日本のオープニングと時代の終わり。- Chapter one: The Opening of Japan and the end of an era.

1200px-Sekigaharascreen.jpg

(The Battle of Sekigahara was known as the blueprint for ひどい大戦, or “The Great Terrible War” of Japan)


All of that changed in 1852 when the United States sent Commodore Matthew Perry to force Japan to open their country to foreign trade. Fearing sharing the fate of Qing China only a generation ago, the Tokugawa government agreed to open Japan in 1854 (effected in 1855) in the Convention of Kanagawa.

article-2385208-1B28910B000005DC-224_964x1230.jpg

(Although historically Commodore Perry was seen in Japan as an evil man who destroyed the innocence of Japan, many modern historians in Japan view him as the catalyst to a modern Japan. Some radicals within the debate even view him as an honorable demigod who was chosen by Amaterasu to create a great modern Japan and wish to honor him as such.)


Economic Troubles:


Part of the opening of Japan was the unfair trade deals that came with it. For example, foreign merchants could not be tried by Japanese courts, leading to foreign merchants getting away with unfair practices. One of the most ruinous to Japan was the practice of arbitrage, or taking advantage of different price levels in different markets. In the West, the gold-silver ratio was at 1:15. But in Japan it was only 1:5. So western merchants flooded the Japanese gold markets, buying up all the gold so it could be sold at a much higher price elsewhere, destroying the Japanese currency. Rising prices and a daily weakening currency lead to mass famines and bankruptcies across Japan, leading to growing anger at the Tokugawa administration.


440px-YokohamaForeignTradersSadahide1861.jpg

(A foreign trading house)





The slogan “Sonno Joi”, or Revere the “Emperor, Expel the Barbarians”, became a rallying cry of a newly created pro-emperor movement, which blamed the Shogunate for the economic crisis, and believing that it was only moral for the Emperor of Japan, a Godly figure, to run the affairs of Japan, not an intermediary military dictatorship.

Foreigner_and_Wrestler_at_Yokohama_1861.jpg

(One of the popular poster of the Sonno Joi movement)


After much turmoil in Japan, Emperor Komei in 1863 ordered the end of westernization of Japan and the expulsion of Japan with the 攘夷実行の勅命 or jōi jikkō no chokumei. The response of the Western powers would go down in the annals of history as the precursor of “The Great Terrible War”.


The_Emperor_Komei.jpg


(Emperor Komei was always less liked by historians than his son Meiji, and is criticized for his rash decision making. Had he not died soon thereafter many historians predicted a highly worse off Japan.)
 
Namagumi Incident
第 2 章: ウエスタンかもしれないし、教訓を学んだ。- Chapter two: Western might and a lesson learned.

Namamugi incident:

Emperor Komei’s ban of westerners was not well-received by the nations of the West. It created a tension so thick that one more action would break the camel’s back. Surely enough, the dromedary’s vertebrae cracked when in 1862 the Namamugi Incident occurred. The Namamugi Incident was when a group of samurai slaughtered four British subjects in Namamugi village. A small misunderstanding led the samurai, who were already fervent sonno joi supporters and had a xenophobic hatred of westerners, to kill Charles Richardson and his three business partners.

CharlesRichardson.jpg

(Charles Richardson’s deceased body was used primarily in Britain but also across the West as a propaganda tool to “teach the true barbarians a lesson in White man’s civility”. This was the perfect casus belli for Western nations to “explain why” the Shogun was so scared of them.)


The Western Response:



The two domains of Japan that faced the brunt of the Western hostilities were the Satsuma and Choshu domains. The Namamugi Incident occurred within the Satsuma domain, so they were going to feel the wrath of the British Empire. British warships in 1863 appeared into the coast of Kagoshima during the bombardment of Kagoshima.

KagoshimaBirdView.jpg

(A bird’s eye view of the bombardment of Kagoshima)

A decisive victory for the British, only 8 British sailors died (and were on one ship), while 244 Japanese citizens (majority of whom lived in the homes) either died or were wounded. The Satsuma clan were rather diplomatic after the incident, paying 35,000 pounds to the British as reparations instead of the original demand of 29,000. After that the Satsuma obtained two warships from Britain within a year, as well as British mechanics who would come back to Kagoshima and repair some of the buildings they destroyed (though never formally giving money to the Satsuma). This rather favorable result to the Satsuma could only happen under the leadership of Shimazu Hisamitsu, who realized that the British if cozied up to, would be instrumental for the glory of the Shimazu clan and Satsuma domain.


Shimazu_Hisamitsu_%E5%B3%B6%E6%B4%A5%E4%B9%85%E5%85%89.jpg

(Shimazu Hisamitsu was regarded as one of the wisest leaders in the Bakamatsu and “The Great Terrible War”. His almost uncanny ability to make friends out of the most likely of foes was what defined him not only as an honorable daimyo but also a modern statesman that Japan even to this day looks up to.)


The Shimonoseki Campaign:



The other domain that was targeted by the Western powers was Choshu domain. Daimyo Mouri Takachika was spearheading the sonno-joi movement, and had an unusually high hatred for the westerners. As a sonno-joi leader, he was also a threat to the Shogun, and attacking him would not incite the wrath of the shogun (rather, it would help garner favor), and would still show the supremacy of the West.

In 1863 a group of British, French, Dutch and American ships bombarded the port town of Shimonoseki, or known in Japanese textbooks as 死の雲, or “The Cloud of Death”, referencing the smoke created by the intense bombarding.

With heavy bombardments and a surprise attack coinciding, the westerners only had four casualties while the amount of ethnic Nipponese casualties was 427 (the carnage of the soldiers in the town square was around half of the casualties).


Mouri_Takachika.jpg

(Daimyo Takimacha was known for his passion and courage, however his inability to judge the situation about how to posture to the western powers is evidence for a certain lack of judgement. No one can deny though his bravery during the war, and the charisma of his leadership.)

Aftermath of the attacks:



The two devastating bombardments had proven to the Emperor-supporters that full rejection of the West would be foolish and that for the emperor to come back to power there would be a need to be, firstly more an organized and secondly more embracing of western technology and nations. Certainly, the Shogun could still be blamed for bowing to the west, but a more conciliatory tone at least privately towards the West would be wise.
 
The Imperial Cabinet
章 3: 帝国軍の形成 - Chapter 3: The formation of the Imperial forces



The formation of an “Imperial Cabinet”:

The supporters of the emperor had decided that to overthrow the Shogunate, they must assemble a strong, mobile and frightening force quickly. One of the greatest impediments to a great Imperial alliance was the bitter rivalry between the Satsuma and Choshu domains. The Shimazu and Mouri clans were too proud for them to easily thaw their frosty relationship. Tosa representative and future Sakomoto Ryoma worked on being a bridge-builder between the Satsuma and Choshu, using his tact and wit to help create the alliance in 1866. But he could not have done it without the backing of Daimyo Hisamitsu. After long and hard diplomatic discussions with both Hisamitsu (a wise prescence) and Takachika, Ryoma successfully brought the Satsuma and Choshu domains together, creating the platform for a great Imperial alliance. A Tosa Representative himself, after convincing his daimyo Yamauchi Yoshige, he brought the Tosa into the fray, strengthening the alliance closer to the center of Japan. Saga domain was also brought into the Imperial fray after negotiations between Ryoma, Hisamitsu and Saga’s daimyo Nabeshima Naohiro, entrenching a mighty Western stronghold for the Imperial cause. Many of them were members of the 影の内閣, or “shadow cabinet”.



Sakamoto_Ryoma.jpg

(Sakamoto Ryoma was regarded by historians as a genius diplomat and a modernist visionary of Japan. Nicknamed the “John Locke of Japan” by his peers, Ryomi’s commitment to liberty and modernization made him a political maverick and visionary).

Yodo_Yamauchi.jpg

(Tosa daimyo Toyoshige was a brilliant diplomat. A master of realpolitik, he headed the Imperial inter-diplomatic system, coercing many Shogunate retainers and even a daimyo or two to the Imperial cause.)


Nabeshima_Naohiro.jpg

(Nabeshima Naohiro was the daimyo of Saga, which included Japan’s only medieval port to trade with the Dutch. Having access to modern technology at a level even greater than the Satsuma, his domain joining the Imperial fold not only help entrenched an Imperial commitment to a modernized Japan, but also ensured a healthy start against the Shogunal army for a westernized army.)


Shimazu_Hisamitsu_%E5%B3%B6%E6%B4%A5%E4%B9%85%E5%85%89.jpg

(Shimazu Hisamitsu was in many ways the “prime minister” of the cabinet. His wisdom allowed for an efficient running of the Imperial forces. Ryoma was essentially his pupil, who learned many great things from Hisamitsu. Hisamitsu never quite had the relationship with Emperor Meiji as Ryomi had, and so Ryomi was the link between Emperor Meiji.)


Mouri_Takachika.jpg

(Morui Takachika commanded the war department of the Imperial cabinet. The equal of Hisamitsu in rank, although he required some help for concise planning of the war effort, his commitment to an offensive campaign would be lauded by both military historians and generals alike.)


"Satsuma, Choshu, Tosa and Saga domains served as the primary domains for the Imperial cause. While others joined or had some involvement with the Emperor's side, I didn't call them the four seasons of Japan for nothing" - "Memoirs of Waging War in the Land of Cherry Blossoms" by General Codrington
 
Last edited:
Emperor Meiji and the Tactical Triumvirate
The Crowning of the New Emperor and the Tactical Triumvirate:

Meiji_Emperor.jpg

(Emperor Meiji in his military uniform, a signature to his commitment of modernizing Japan.)

When Emperor Komei passed away in 1867, his son Mutsuhito became Emperor Meiji. A sharp man with greater sensibilities than his late father, Emperor Meiji used his recent Imperial cabinet assembled in 1866 and started working with them to secretly mobilize a force to overthrow the Shogunate. However, to run his military on the ground, Emperor Meiji brought together sharp military minds to both command and run the Imperial military, also known as the “tactical triumvirate”.

The Tactical Triumvirate:

Saigo_Takamori.jpg

(Takamori was a fervent believer in the emperor’s cause as well as the sanctity of the samurai. His highly conservative approach to cultural modernization had him at loggerheads with Ryomi, as well as some of Emperor Meiji’s programs. But his courage in battle would never be forgotten by his fellow Imperialists, saving him much trouble from confrontation.)

A retired British General who served in the Crimean war, Sir William John Codrington was payed a hefty salary by the Imperial Domains to train the Imperial army with modern Western tactics and skills. As a foreign veteran who commanded in the Crimean War barely more than a decade ago, General Codrington had the skill, experience and authority to turn the Imperial army from a gunpowder army to a modern fighting force.

William_John_Codrington.jpg

(Originally little more than a high-ranking mercenary, as he fought with his new-found Imperial comrades, he grew more affectionate for the cause and even became good friends with Omura Masujiro and Sakamoto Ryomi. He developed a strong rivalry with Takemori.)



Masujiro_Omura_cropped.jpg

(Nicknamed “Napoleon of the East”, Masujiro’s military genius was world renowned. His friendship with Codrington and uneasy relationship with Takamori as well as Takimacha had a defining impact on military progression, causing some major gains as well as major losses. Had there not been such a confrontational relationship between Masujiro and Takamori as times, many historians agreed that many pains would not have occurred.)
 
The Crowning of the New Emperor and the Tactical Triumvirate:

Meiji_Emperor.jpg

(Emperor Meiji in his military uniform, a signature to his commitment of modernizing Japan.)

When Emperor Komei passed away in 1867, his son Mutsuhito became Emperor Meiji. A sharp man with greater sensibilities than his late father, Emperor Meiji used his recent Imperial cabinet assembled in 1866 and started working with them to secretly mobilize a force to overthrow the Shogunate. However, to run his military on the ground, Emperor Meiji brought together sharp military minds to both command and run the Imperial military, also known as the “tactical triumvirate”.

The Tactical Triumvirate:

Saigo_Takamori.jpg

(Takamori was a fervent believer in the emperor’s cause as well as the sanctity of the samurai. His highly conservative approach to cultural modernization had him at loggerheads with Ryomi, as well as some of Emperor Meiji’s programs. But his courage in battle would never be forgotten by his fellow Imperialists, saving him much trouble from confrontation.)

A retired British General who served in the Crimean war, Sir William John Codrington was payed a hefty salary by the Imperial Domains to train the Imperial army with modern Western tactics and skills. As a foreign veteran who commanded in the Crimean War barely more than a decade ago, General Codrington had the skill, experience and authority to turn the Imperial army from a gunpowder army to a modern fighting force.

William_John_Codrington.jpg

(Originally little more than a high-ranking mercenary, as he fought with his new-found Imperial comrades, he grew more affectionate for the cause and even became good friends with Omura Masujiro and Sakamoto Ryomi. He developed a strong rivalry with Takemori.)



Masujiro_Omura_cropped.jpg

(Nicknamed “Napoleon of the East”, Masujiro’s military genius was world renowned. His friendship with Codrington and uneasy relationship with Takamori as well as Takimacha had a defining impact on military progression, causing some major gains as well as major losses. Had there not been such a confrontational relationship between Masujiro and Takamori as times, many historians agreed that many pains would not have occurred.)
Just to clarify, it's ryoma, not ryomi. also, it's Mouri Takachika
 
The setup for war
Planning for an attack and expansion of the Imperial War Cabinet:

Emperor Meiji knew that he and the Shogun were going to butt heads sometime soon. Although trying to keep it as discreet as possible. He asked Takachika if he would like anyone to help him organize the military as the assistant war secretary. Takachika’s reply was one that contradicted his personality in one way and defined it in another; his loyal aide during the Shimonoseki campaign, Takasuki Shinsaku. Shinsaku was a Choshu samurai who believed in working with the West and bringing in commoners into the army at a whole other level to modernize the army. He had opposing views with Takachika on the Imperial stance towards the West and Takachika dismissed his friend’s regards on working with the West after the bombing to establish better relations. Learning the hard way, Takimacha realized his mistake, and although he personally would never revert his views or feel he truly made a mistake, he recognized his flaws and had Shinsaku as his highest-ranking retainer as well as assistant war secretary.


“Shinsaku was so grateful to Takachika that he promised that it would be his goal to “never report a military defeat ever”. Takachika did the unusual; put his mind over his heart. But he still used his heart when it came to endorsing a friend, which still makes Takachika man of the heart” – “The Great, Terrible War”, by Omura Masujiro.



Shinsaku_Takasugi.jpg


"Takasugi Shinsaku was an ardent enthusiast of Masujiro’s and loved working closely with him on the few times they worked together. As part of the cabinet structure and not the tactical force, he was the tactical mind within the cabinet. He gained the respect of Hisamitsu and Hisamitsu had him as a contact between him and Takachika. Takachika never bended over back to the Satsuma demands, but his surprisingly reasonable attitude was noted when Shinsaku was part of an operation. Many historians to this day criticize Emperor Meiji for not making Shinsaku a higher member of the operation, and credit Takachika for raising him up in the beginning" - "Memoirs of Waging War in the Land of Cherry Blossoms", by General Codrington.


Keiheitai.jpg

(Takasugi Shinsaku with his 奇兵隊 “Kiheitai”, or “irregular militia”. It was a sign of tactical genius and was greatly appreciated by Masujiro, who established the more formal bits of the army.)

With his war cabinet fully established and well-oiled, Emperor Meiji knew that all he had to do now was to play the waiting game. His intuition however told him he would not have to play that game for long.
 
Top