what If the Umayyad won the Battle of the Nobles OTL first big battle and victory for the Berber in the Berber revolt who would result in the first independent Muslim (even if heritic ) state outside of the Calipahte and the the loss of western Maghreb . I chose it over Bagdoura because Umayyad already seemed in a unwinnable position by then and by defeat . Could the Berber revolt have been crushed here ? What are the consequence ? Could the Umayyad hold on Morocco and Algeria ? What are the effect on Al Andalus and the Maghreb ? And how do that affect the Abbasid revolution ? Could the Umayyad hold on longer as Caliph or are they already screwed by then ? Possible other effect ?