In 1535 would start off with tragedy. King James and Queen Margaret had organized a joust for Lady's Day. Prince Alexander, a man of twenty was eager to participate. Unfortunately, a cruel twist of fate would see him fall from his horse, hitting his head against the railing, dying just a few hours later. His abrupt death was a devastating blow to the entire court.
Both Prince James and Prince Arthur returned to London for their brother's funeral, the former reuniting and reconciling with Prince Henry. The Stewarts were united in their grief. But circumstances threatened to shatter the fragile peace.
Henry Percy, Lord of Northumberland died suddenly in May despite being of good health. Poison was suspected. Thomas Percy, his younger brother, came to Sir Thoma More, proclaiming the Dowager Countess Lady Anne, a witch, an adulterer, and a heretic. He accused her of murdering his brother, cuclkholding him, and trying to pass off her bastard son by Sir Thomas Wyatt as his heir.
Lady Anne, of course, turned the accusation around, calling Thomas Percy's words as a thinly veiled attempt to usurp his nephew, and accusing him of doing the dark deed. Despite most of the evidence being circumstantial, Sir Thomas More still encouraged the monarchs to arrest the dowager countess on suspicion of murder, adultery, and heresy. After some discussion, Queen Margaret agreed the lady would brought to London for questioning.
Doubting she would remain alive if she went to London, Anne choose to take her children and head for Stirling Castle to throw herself on the mercy of the Princess of Wales. Renee welcomed her old friend with open arms, promising protection. When a letter arrived from London, demanding Lady Anne be brought before the court, Renee and Anne turned to Prince James, beseeching him to protect her from the unjust and vicious slander spread by her enemies.
Prince James agreed, feeling that the Lord Chancellor had already made up his mind about Anne because of her religious views and would stack the court unfairly against her. He instead sent a letter to his parents, stating that Lady Anne was under house arrest, her children were in his custody, and he requested to take charge in the investigation.
Of course, this led to Prince Henry calling his brother out for his hypocrisy, subtly hinting at the crown prince's own heresy.
Finally King James put his foot down, reminding his sons that the last time he checked, neither he nor Margaret were dead. They were the ones in charge here, and Lady Anne best get herself to London before she proclaimed a traitor for disobeying her monarchs' command!
Prince James decided to escort Lady Anne to London himself, riding out in full armor in front of the procession like he was a knight defending an innocent maiden. His wife wanted to come as well, but Anne insisted she stay in Stirling with their children for she trusted no one more than her oldest friend to protect the new Earl of Northumberland and his two sisters.
Once the Prince of Wales and his entourage arrived at Whitehall, it could not be more clear that while the official feud was between Lady Anne and her former brother-in-law, Thomas Percy, the true fight was between those who supported the religious reforms and those who did not. Prince James stood by Anne's side while his brother Prince Henry stood by the side of Thomas Percy.
Prince Arthur wisely decided to return to Ireland, saying he much preferred arguing with Irish Lords than deal with his brothers' spat.
Despite Princes James, Princess Renee, and Lady Anne's fears while King James, Queen Margaret, and Sir Thomas More might have been well aware that at least one of the charges leveled against Lady Anne was most certainly true, they were willing to give her a fair hearing.
Sir Percy trotted out witnesses who would swear up and down that they saw Anne Boleyn practicing witchcraft, sleeping with various men, and so on and so forth. George Boleyn, Viscount Rochford nearly charged at one of the grooms who hinted at having seen him enter his sister's bedchamber and not come out until morning. A cook insisted that it was Anne's lady who had taken the plate containing Northumberland's supper, saying her mistress wanted to add something to it.
By the end of it, even Prince Henry was skeptical. After all, no one could be so blatant about their crimes. Cromwell acted as Anne's legal advisor and wasted no time tearing apart each of the witnesses' stories, then bringing out several witnesses including Sir Thomas Wyatt who swore up and down that for all his love for Lady Anne, he had never lain with her. Cromwell then interrogated Anne herself, who put on a touching show of a grieving widow who was terrified of what would happen to her and her children should she be found guilty of crimes she did not commit.
Then came the final nail in Sir Thomas Percy's coffin. Letters from him to the Earl of Talbot, plotting to murder of the Earl of Northumberland, and to tarnish Anne's reputation to the point where she and her children would be disgraced. Both Percy and Talbot denied the existence of these letters, but the tide was against them. They were outspoken in their hatred of Anne, and had clearly manufactured evidence against her.
They both were arrested on suspicion of murder and conspiracy, taking down two of Lady Anne's greatest opponents, allowing her and through her, Prince James, to continue to spread the reformation in the North.
It was a blow to the Catholic cause.