Union and Liberty: An American TL

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just ran the simulation (a basic Python program I wrote a while ago). Probably not perfect, but basically what I wanted to accomplish. I'll add a run down of some of the teams today or tomorrow. I haven't quite decided how ties in points at the end of the season will be decided this early in the rule formation, but I'm thinking number of wins for now. The goals for/away/difference is just there for interest since that's what I have the program display.

Code:
New England Football League, 1891-1892 season

Club                  Pl Po  W  D  L  GF GA  GD
Boston Artillery      26 41 17  7  2  72 22  50
Harvard University    26 39 18  3  5  62 20  42
Yale University       26 38 17  4  5  77 27  50
Boston Commons        26 35 16  3  7  61 24  37
Brown University      26 33 12  5  9  42 44  -2
Cambridge Municipal   26 27 12  3 11  33 35  -2
New Haven Town        26 24 11  3 12  32 38  -6
Aquidneck Island FC   26 24  9  6 11  30 36  -6
Dartmouth College     26 23  9  5 12  20 50 -30
Bridgeport City       26 20  8  4 14  22 47 -25
Providence City       26 18  9  0 17  37 62 -25
Salem Town FC         26 18  5  8 13  20 44 -24
Amoskeag Manu. AC     26 17  6  5 15  23 47 -24
Hartford Athletic     26 10  2  6 18  19 54 -35
And here's the draft of the logos of the two biggest teams in the modern NEFL, Boston Commons and Boston Artillery. I used FM Live's badge creator to make both.

NEFLBostonCommons.png
NEFLBostonArtillery.png
 
Last edited:
Just ran the simulation (a basic Python program I wrote a while ago). Probably not perfect, but basically what I wanted to accomplish. I'll add a run down of some of the teams today or tomorrow. I haven't quite decided how ties in points at the end of the season will be decided this early in the rule formation, but I'm thinking number of wins for now. The goals for/away/difference is just there for interest since that's what I have the program display.

Code:
New England Football League, 1891-1892 season

Club                  Pl Po  W  D  L  GF GA  GD
Boston Artillery      26 41 17  7  2  72 22  50
Harvard University    26 39 18  3  5  62 20  42
Yale University       26 38 17  4  5  77 27  50
Boston Commons        26 35 16  3  7  61 24  37
Brown University      26 33 12  5  9  42 44  -2
Cambridge Municipal   26 27 12  3 11  33 35  -2
New Haven Town        26 24 11  3 12  32 38  -6
Aquidneck Island FC   26 24  9  6 11  30 36  -6
Dartmouth College     26 23  9  5 12  20 50 -30
Bridgeport City       26 20  8  4 14  22 47 -25
Providence City       26 18  9  0 17  37 62 -25
Salem Town FC         26 18  5  8 13  20 44 -24
Amoskeag Manu. AC     26 17  6  5 15  23 47 -24
Hartford Athletic     26 10  2  6 18  19 54 -35
And here's the draft of the logos of the two biggest teams in the modern NEFL, Boston Commons and Boston Artillery. I used FM Live's badge creator to make both.

NEFLBostonCommons.png
NEFLBostonArtillery.png

This is pretty cool. It is supposed to be soccer right? not American football?
I want to guess Boston Commons was probably set up by Irish Immigrants while Artillery was the "American" club originally.
 
Yup, soccer. And yes, Boston Commons is the team supported by the Catholic and Irish community, with their field on the grounds of the Boston Commons. Boston Artillery, meanwhile, is located at Dorcester Oval in South Boston. I was going for a Rangers/Celtic-esque rivalry with these two teams.
 
Wilcoxchar, you by any chance Nate Silver? I'm only half joking. Your writing style and the fact that you run simulations to discover who wins a fictional in-TL tournament remind me of him. In any case, keep up the great work!
 
Wilcoxchar, you by any chance Nate Silver? I'm only half joking. Your writing style and the fact that you run simulations to discover who wins a fictional in-TL tournament remind me of him. In any case, keep up the great work!
Haha, no I'm not him. Thanks for the compliment though. :D


I've got a question for all of you. How soon in the TL would it be reasonable to have a presidential or vice presidential candidate from a former Confederate state? I've been thinking about this but in the circumstances I'm not entirely sure. Would before 1900 be too early?
 
Well in 1892 OTL there was a guy from Virginia who was the Populist VP under James Weaver? But a serious candidate didn't come until Woodrow Wilson....so I would say probably a little early.
 
I've got a question for all of you. How soon in the TL would it be reasonable to have a presidential or vice presidential candidate from a former Confederate state? I've been thinking about this but in the circumstances I'm not entirely sure. Would before 1900 be too early?


Well in 1892 OTL there was a guy from Virginia who was the Populist VP under James Weaver? But a serious candidate didn't come until Woodrow Wilson....so I would say probably a little early.

Actually the late 1880s/90s might not be too early in TTL due to the differences of this Civil War to OTL. In TTL the Civil War could be interpreted as an attempt of a power grab by some Southern politicians that was more like a coup than an attempt at session. Here is why:
Not every southern state seceded: Tennessee, Houston and Tejas, and Jackson all remained loyal to the Union. Jackson was invaded by the rebels but then fought it way back into loyalty. Cuba seceded at first but then had an inner rebellion against the Confederacy. (I'm not sure if Calhoun experienced a similar uprising). The admission of Veracruz as a Confederate a state clearly suggested that the Confederate politicians were more interested in filibustering than defending state rights.
Furthermore you have a figure like Robert E. Lee, a southerner that remained loyal, fought for the Union, and then became president. The last years of reconstruction happened under his presidency.

All this would prove that the rebellion was not widely supported by the South overall. You could even argue it was only a minority who did support it. Thus Southern identity in TTL would likely resemble of OTL's. Most likely it would revolve around figures like Houston, and Lee as well as those who rebelled against the Confederacy. There could be a sense of "we fought in our own land against the slavers".

Also the Gulf Coast and Mississippi shores are much more populated ITTL than OTL. It received a much larger influx of immigrants from the North and else where as well as being more diverse by having a large hispanic and Catholic concentration in Cuba, Florida, Jackson, Tejas (and maybe Louisiana?). This would certainly make the South much less culturally stagnant than OTLs and being more open to change and influx of ideas.

So as long as your candidate did not fight for the South or was a member of the Confederate congress there shouldn't be a reason why he can't run for President.
 
Part Seventy-One: Tipping the Scales
Time for another main update.

Part Seventy-One: Tipping the Scales


A Million Little Parties:
As the Republican and Democratic parties settled into their respective positions in the Third Party System, regional parties and smaller national parties began gaining popularity. Tensions between the two parties and the dominance of the Republicans in the North and the Democrats in the South led to a level of dissatisfaction in the politics of both major parties. The first appearance of minor parties in Congress since the National War occurred after the midterm elections of 1878. The Redback Party, which promoted moving the dollar off of any metallic standard, was at first the most successful minor party, gaining 8 seats in the House of Representatives in 1878. The rise of minor parties in the elections of 1878 gave control of the House of Representatives to the Democratic Party as many of the minor parties were in the North.

The Redback Party gained much of its support in the Old Northwest. It's main leaders were James B. Weaver of Iowa and Edward Gilette of Indiana. The Redback Party gained a number of representatives in the following decade and reached its height in the early 1890s, when the party had 18 members of the House of Representatives and 2 senators. The Redback Party ran counter to the bimetallic platform of the Republican Party and the gold standard platform of the Democratic Party. The Redback Party achieved its voting base largely from rural agricultural voters, but lost its appeal once other minor parties began coopting moving off of a metal-backed currency on their platforms.

While the Redback Party was the most prominent party of the era, there were several other notable minor parties. The Temperance Party was the main political front of the growing moderation movement to ban alcohol and was popular mostly among religious revivalists. The Prohibition Party became the first party after the National War to nominate a candidate for executive office from a former Confederate state in 1892. This era also saw the beginning of the rise of far leftist parties in the United States. The American Socialist Party, the Union Labor Party, and the American Workers' Party were all formed during the 1880s. The leftist movement would continue to grow in urban areas in the early 20th century.


The Election of 1880:
After the Democratic Party gained control of the House of Representatives in 1878, they blocked most efforts by Burnside or the Republican members in the Senate to enact any other important legislation. With the Republican Party's lawmaking ability curtailed, the election of 1880 proved to be a difficult one for them. Accopmanying these issues were the growing feud between President Burnside and Congressman Blaine over the reasons for the Republicans' losing ground.

The feud came to a head in the Republican National Convention when the nominations for the Vice Presidential candidate were being allocated. Blaine had been winning the ballot as he was a nationally known Republican, but Burnside made a statement that if Blaine were nominated, he would not accept the presidential nomination as he was unwilling to campaign with Blaine. After Burnside's statement at the convention, the ballot slowly shifted toward Benjamin Harrison of Ohio who was confirmed as the Republican Vice Presidential candidate on the ninth ballot.

While the Republicans were miring over the conflict within the party, the Democrats were hitting their stride. The Democratc National Convention nominated former Union general Winfield Scott Hancock for president and Illinois senator John M. Palmer. Palmer was a noted advocate for liberal economic policies while Hancock was revered in the North for his successes in the National War. In an ironic twist, many Southern states still ended up voting for the Democratic Party even though Hancock was their presidential candidate because of poor campaigning by Burnside and the continued stigma of Fremont's policies in the South. Hancock defeat Burnside for the presidency and became the first president elected on the Democratic ticket since before the National War.

Hancock/Palmer: 175 EVs
Burnside/Harrison: 154 EVs
 
So we are going to see a mult-party system in TTL's future? Cool. I like how the TL has two unrelated Winfield Scotts for president. Will probably be confusing for elementary school children in the future (although probably neither is a significantly memorable president).

As always great update!

Just of curiosity, do you. Have any comments on what I posted about the South previously. How it will differ from OTL's?
 

Death

Banned
The development of third parties developing out side the elitists 2 party black and white USA system of OLT in this update is a sure sign of a democracy gaining stability through more choice and verity.
 
British North America

Looking at the map you did, I have a suggestion. In OTL, before HBC Lands were transferred to Canada, the country around the Hudsons Bay north of Manitoba, and round to Labrador was known as New Britain. It would be very interesting to see a revival of that here. It is only a suggestion. Think of it what you will.
 
Just of curiosity, do you. Have any comments on what I posted about the South previously. How it will differ from OTL's?
I like your analysis of public perception of the National War in both the North and the South. I do think that this will lead to an earlier candidacy from a former Confederate state, but I wasn't sure how much earlier. The 1890s does sound reasonable. I'm actually going to edit the first candidacy in the Prohibition Party to 1888, due to looking at the planned candidate I had for it. I also like the idea of using Lee and others as models of the backlash against the secession, either retroactively using it as a not necessarily sincere "we were always with you so vote for us" sort of way or as an actual movement.

The development of third parties developing out side the elitists 2 party black and white USA system of OLT in this update is a sure sign of a democracy gaining stability through more choice and verity.
Well, these will only be minor parties and probably won't have much effect on politics for now other than pushing their issues. But it will be a predecessor for more influential third parties later on.

Looking at the map you did, I have a suggestion. In OTL, before HBC Lands were transferred to Canada, the country around the Hudsons Bay north of Manitoba, and round to Labrador was known as New Britain. It would be very interesting to see a revival of that here. It is only a suggestion. Think of it what you will.
Hmmm, I do like the idea of having New North Wales and New South Wales as administrative divisions in Canada, but it will depend on how the settlement patterns end up and whether there is a need for separate provinces in the north.
 
Science and Technology #2
Update time! This one's a tech update, and has some big hints about the society of the future in the TL. Added footnotes.

Science and Technology #2

Elemental Discoveries:
The nineteenth century was a time of great scientific advancement in the fields of chemistry. As such, during this era came the discovery of many new elements and ways to detect and organoize the list of elements. Using new methods to isolate and identify individual elements that had evolved with the Industrial Revolution, scientists in Europe were able to discover many new elements that gave further insight into the similarities between properties of certain elements and led to the first standard classification of all known elements.

The major elemental discoveries that occurred during this period were made largely by a few scientists using the new technique of spectral analysis. The main scientists to use this method were German chemist Robert Bunsen and English chemist William James Herschel[1] while Herschel was a doctoral student of Bunsen's at the University of Göttingen. Together, Herschel and Bunsen pioneered the method of examining the emission lines of compounds to determine their constituent elements, and thus discovered four new elements in the 1860s. They isolated the alkali metals bunsenium and herschelium[2] through their blue spectral lines in 1862. Thallium was discovered by Bunsen and Herschel in 1865. After the European Wars broke out in 1866, Herschel left Göttingen to continue his education in Great Britain. In 1867, Bunsen identified a fourth element which exhibited a dark blue spectral line. The element was named borussium[3] because of this dark blue color and the recent conquest of the city of Gottingen by Prussia.

Along with all the new elements being discovered, some scientists began noticing similar properties between certain groups of elements. Scientists such as Swedish chemist August Kekule started to try to come up with ways to categorize the known elements in a standard table that would easily display the similar elements and would provide an easy way to classify all the elements that had been discovered. Kekule published his version of what is now the periodic table of elements in 1870. It was organized by ordering the elements by their relative masses and putting elements with similar properties in the same column. With this method of organization, the discovered elements formed seven roughly neat columns and formed the basis for the table we use today.


The Viennese Scientific Exodus:
For much of the 19th century, the city of Vienna and the University of Vienna had been the pinnacle of scientific thought in the Austrian Empire and one of the major locations of scientific discovery and advancement in Europe at the time. However, the fall of the Habsburg dynasty after the European Wars and the rise of the Viennese Workers' State led to several important scientists leaving Austria to other countries in Europe.

Most of the brilliant minds who left Vienna in the 1870s went to Germany where they continued their work at the larger universities in Berlin, Göttingen, Munich, and Heidelberg. Geologist Ferdinand Zirkel went to the University of Berlin where he later would travel on topographical surveys of the African Great Lakes and ascend Mount Kilimandscharo. Botanist Rudolf Schrödinger[4] and physicist Johann Mendel continued their work at the University of Munich.


The Communication Revolution:
The most influential technological advancements in the 1870s and 1880s, however, were in the field of communication. The growth in use of the telephone in Italy and France during the 1860s inspired Nikola Tesla to work on communications technology. Tesla left for Rome in 1871 after only a year at the University of Vienna, and stayed in Italy for fifteen years before leaving for the United States. From 1888 to 1899, Tesla pioneered innovations in telephone communication and led Union Telegraph and Telephone, the United States' oldest telephone company. Tesla's chairing of UT&T helped to expand the lines owned by the company throughout the entire country from its original network in the Northeast of the country. By 1900, UT&T had become a communications giant within the United States.

Along with the telephone, the invention and innovations made related to the typewriter also led to the revolution in communication in the early 20th century. Much as the telephone allowed individuals to speak to each other over long distances, the typewriter allowed much easier and faster writing up and printing of documents. The typewriter standardized many of the grammatical conventions in the American language today, and gradually led to the informal adoption of American for most government and business transactions in the United States. Additionally, the typewriter allowed women to enter the workforce en masse for the first time as many women began their careers as typists transcribing dictated messages.

Around the turn of the century, several inventors combined the ideas behind the telephone and the typewriter to create machines that could receive messages from afar and immediately transcribe the message onto a sheet of paper. These became known as teletype machines, and were originally used primarily by news networks and stock exchanges to maintain updates of real time information from around the world. In the Great War, the militaries of the world adapted the teletype machine for general communication to relay tactical and strategic information from the front lines. After the Great War, companies took advantage of the communications infrastructure created during this time and began serving individual teletype machines that allowed two individuals to send typed messages instantly from one location to another.

[1] Grandson of William Herschel, discoverer of Uranus. In OTL William James Herschel did some pioneering work with fingerprinting.
[2] Bunsenium = caesium, herschelium = rubidium
[3] Borussium = indium
[4] Rudolf is the father of Erwin Schrödinger
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the comments guys!

Oh God, the fax in the turn of the century? That is awesome.
I'm trying not to spoil too much this early, but I'm actually aiming for more of a proto-email/IM thing that might develop into a sort of internet. Still trying to figure out fully how it will work, but I think I've gotten peer to peer stuff down. I was thinking of having switchboard operators for the teletype machines and/or having two machines being on the same frequency to send signals so they don't get mixed up with other machines. Any advice on whether this system would work and how to improve it would be most welcome.

And about the fax machine, the first facsimile machine in OTL was the pantelegraph in the 1860s.
 
Thanks for the comments guys!

I'm trying not to spoil too much this early, but I'm actually aiming for more of a proto-email/IM thing that might develop into a sort of internet. Still trying to figure out fully how it will work, but I think I've gotten peer to peer stuff down. I was thinking of having switchboard operators for the teletype machines and/or having two machines being on the same frequency to send signals so they don't get mixed up with other machines. Any advice on whether this system would work and how to improve it would be most welcome.

And about the fax machine, the first facsimile machine in OTL was the pantelegraph in the 1860s.

Something like this would create a HUGE social change! Globalization could happen at an exponential rate compared to OTL, with people being able to communicate quite easily across the world. Would proto-social networking also be developed?. Maybe something like a UN or WTO will form 30 years beforehand because of the convenience of communication. I know there were ways of communicating across the world back then, but from what the Middle East is showing us now, social networking, the internet, and e-mail can easily facilitate political change.
 
The proto-fax is really cool. But the coolest part about the update is that AT&T does not exist in this TL!! Despite the similar name UT&T can't be anything similar to it because it is headed by Tesla.

If you get significant development in electricity and wireless technology early on (you have Tesla incharge so it should not be hard). I think the system you described should be able to work.

You could also have mobile phones very early on if you work with two way radio. These would very similar to the 1970s 80s car-phones of OTL. You just need to figure out how to make them smaller.

Overall cool update. And it should be exciting to see what the difference in technology will do to culture and as a consequence everything else.

Will tech be significantly more advanced than OTL by the time you get to present time?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top