The Union Forever: A TL

Victory Over Spain
Victory Over Spain



zpage292.gif

Battle of Havana, 1878​




The Battle of Havana

The last major engagement of the war was the Battle of Havana. Major General James McPherson started encircling the island’s capital in the middle of May, 1878. American forces were bolstered by thousands of Cuban freedom fighters who, with American victory in sight, flocked to the Stars and Stripes. Havana however was strongly defended. The Spanish believed that if they could bleed the Americans a little longer and let the yellow fever continue to decimate their ranks, the United States would discuss a negotiated peace. For the next three weeks, the U.S. Navy bombarded Havana as McPherson’s forces continued to encircle the city. In what would become common place in later wars, McPherson made excellent use of trenches to protect his forces from the defending Spaniards. Trenches however did not negate the fact that the Americans were making painfully slow progress towards taking the city.

On June 2nd 1878, Lt. Colonel J.E.B. Stuart and his exhausted 1st Volunteer Calvary triumphantly joined the besieging American army. Upon his arrival, Major General Ulysses S. Grant commented to Stuart that it was “a confounded miracle that the North ever won the War of the Rebellion with the South possessing horsemen such as yourself.” Lt. Colonel Custer’s 3rd Calvary arrived at the American camp two days later. It has been reported that Custer was so angry upon learning that Stuart had beat him to Havana that, as one of his subordinates put it, “the good Colonel nearly ripped his long hair out in disgust.”

The finally assault on the city began the morning of June 21, 1878. American forces launched a withering four hour artillery barrage on the city’s defenses before ordering a full frontal assault. The Spanish forces put up fierce resistance but were steadily pushed back into the city in what proved to be a determined urban defense.

A few hours into the battle, in a move that has often been criticized by military historians, General McPherson ordered Stuart’s cavalry regiment to exploit a gap in the Spanish defenses and rush into the center of the city. Stuart made surprising good progress until he reached Havana’s Plaza de la Catedral in the center of the city where the 1st Volunteer Cavalry came under heavy fire. Amongst the gunfire, J.E.B. Stuart was mortally wounded when a Spanish bullet pierced his lower abdomen. Stuart was then dragged into the nearby Catedral de San Cristobal, which housed the mortal remains of Christopher Columbus, where the remnants of his cavalry regiment had taken refuge.

Upon seeing smoke rise from the center of the city, Custer, whose 3rd Calvary had been kept in reserve during the battle, led his regiment without orders into the embattled city. Although Custer would later state that he did this because he “could sense that American lives were in peril,” it is more likely that he charged into Havana against orders because he believed that the battle would soon be won and the chance to win glory would be over. Regardless, the 3rd Calvary did reach the hard pressed survivors of Stuart’s regiment. Custer led his men in a dismounted charge through the Plaza, shooting his way into the besieged Catedral de San Cristobal. It what now has become a famous exchange, Custer upon seeing the dying J.E.B. Stuart doffed his hat and said “ Sir, I have arrived!” to which the ailing Stuart replied “ Yes, but as always, I was here first.” Both men laughed at the absurdity of situation after which Custer, with the assistance from one of his troopers, a 19 year old corporal from New York named Theodore Roosevelt, carried Stuart to the top of the Cathedral where together they unfurled the first American flag to fly over the city.

These two daring, if not reckless, cavalry charges into the city center proved too much for the Spaniards who officially surrendered later that day. Interestingly, amongst the captured Spanish was an American named William W. Loring from North Carolina. Loring had served as a colonel in the Union army before fighting for the Confederate Army as a general during the Civil War. Following the South’s defeat, Loring was even briefly employed as a military advisor by the Ottoman Sultan, before Turkish financial constraints made Loring seek employment with the Spanish government. Despite pleas from Loring that he had not “actively participated in the resent hostilities” against American forces he was nonetheless tried and hanged as a traitor ten days later.

William_W._Loring.jpg
220px-William_W._Loring_as_Pasha.jpg

William W. Long in the Confederate and Ottoman Armies​

The capture of the city was officially celebrated three days later with a massive parade through the city where, as had almost become customary at this point, the Battle Cry of Freedom was sung with the appropriate lyrical changes tailored for the Spanish.

Yes we'll rally round the flag, boys, we'll rally once again,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom,
We will rally from the Southland, we'll gather from the North,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!


(Chorus)
The Union forever! Hurrah, boys, hurrah!
Down with the tyrants, and up with the stars;
While we rally round the flag, boys, rally once again,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!


We are springing to the call with a million freemen more,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
And we'll fill our vacant ranks of our brothers gone before,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
Chorus
We will welcome to our numbers the loyal, true and brave,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
And although he may be poor, not a man shall be a slave,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
Chorus
So we're springing to the call from the East and from the West,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
And we'll hurl the evil crew from the land we love best,
Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
Chorus


The Treaty of Amsterdam (1878)

With the fall of Havana coming a week after the capture of Puerto Rico it became clear that the war was over. Still, it took over a month before the final peace treaty was signed in the Netherlands. The Treaty of Amsterdam was official signed on July 25, 1878. Its stipulations were simple; Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the rest of Spain’s West Indian possessions were to be ceded to the United States without compensation. Although some of the American delegates pressed for the annexation of some of Spain’s Pacific territories, the lack of American activity in the Pacific during the war undermined this claimed.

Effects of the War

The Spanish-American War had a large affect on both nations. For the United States, it was a major step in healing the wounds of the Civil War as Southerners and Northerners both fought valiantly against a foreign enemy. The United States also greatly increased its Caribbean holdings which now included Cuba, Santo Domingo, Puerto Rico, and a few other minor islands. The United States would also soon undergo several military reforms in light of lessons learned from the war. This victory though had not come cheap. The war, although lasting less than 11 months, cost the Americans 1,352 men killed and many more wounded or wrecked by disease.

Spain however, suffered much worse, losing an estimated 7,800 men killed and wounded. Furthermore having lost the the last remnants of their New World empire, the ruling military junta was overthrown and Spain was plunged yet again into civil war.

In the end, the Spanish-American War marked an important turning point in American history. For the first time, the United States had soundly beat a European Power and proved to the world that it was a force to be reckoned with.
16_victory.jpg
 
Last edited:
A Spanish civil war and the US entering the big boys' club much earlier. Very interesting... the only independent country of the Caribbean is Haiti, which shares a border with the US.
I wonder what becomes of the Philippines ITTL?
 
A Spanish civil war and the US entering the big boys' club much earlier. Very interesting... the only independent country of the Caribbean is Haiti, which shares a border with the US.
I wonder what becomes of the Philippines ITTL?


The next installment will deal with the Philippines. Lets just say that they wont be staying Spanish for much longer.
 
The 1880s: Domestic Developments
The 1880s
Domestic Developments

The 1880s were an eventful time for the United States as the nation continued to industrialize and settle its western territories.

The 1880 Presidential Election and the Cuban Question

In November of 1880, President Arthur Boreman was reelected by a narrow margin over Democratic candidate Thomas S. Bayard of Delaware and his running mate Samuel J. Randall of Pennsylvania. Boreman’s triumph was mainly attributed to the victory over Spain two years earlier. However, the issue of what to do with America’s newfound Caribbean holdings divided the nation. Some, mostly Radical Republicans, wanted to grant the territories full independence. Other’s feared the addition of more non-whites into the nation, but still wanted to reap the financial benefits. These politicians, mostly Democrats, favored a policy of lording over the islands as protectorates. Boreman however wished for the islands to one day join the Union, stating that they “rightfully belong to America as it was American blood which paid for their freedom.” Furthermore, America had intervened at the tail end of Cuba’s troubled fight for freedom against the Spanish, and as such few native leaders were left to lead an independent Cuba. With this in mind, and by two close votes in Congress, Cuba and Puerto Rico joined Santo Domingo as U.S. territories. Although there were some in Cuba which resented being annexed by the United States, many saw it as the only alternative to the anarchy and civil war which had prevailed for most of the 1870s.

The Panic of 1883

A severe but short lived economic depression hit the United States in 1883. Historians mostly cite over speculation on American gold reserves as the downturn's cause. However, the economy rebounded by the end of 1885, and continued to grow rapidly well into the 1890s.

The Democrats Return to Power: The Election of President Samuel J. Randall

494px-Samuel_J._Randall_-_Brady-Handy.jpg

Samuel J. Randall
Democrat from Pennsylvania
19th President of the United States of America


With the nation in the grips of a severe economic recession, American voters decided that the time was ripe for a political shakeup. The 1884 elections saw the first Democratic President elected since James Buchanan in 1856. Samuel J. Randall, an influential congressman from Pennsylvania, and his vice presidential candidate David B. Hill of New York, easily beat the Republican ticket of former Vice President James Blaine of Maine and Chester A. Arthur of New York.

Randall proved to be a popular president, winning reelection in 1888 against Republican challenger John Sherman of Ohio, the younger brother of Lt. General William T Sherman. In foreign policy Randall pursued a more isolationist path than his Republican predecessor, largely keeping America out of foreign entanglements. President Randall was a moderate in domestic affairs, leaving issues such as civil rights, statehood for the Caribbean territories, and women’s suffrage largely untouched. Arguably the most enduring legacy of the Randall Administration was the repeated allegations of corruption and scandals which plagued his years in office.

States Admitted to the Union during the 1880s

Flag of Dakota.png

Name: Dakota Capital: Lincoln City Date of Statehood: March 6, 1885 Postal Abbreviation: DK

Flag of Washington.png

Name: Washington Capital: Olympia Date of Statehood: February 23, 1886 Postal Abbreviation: WA

Flag of Jefferson.png

Name: Jefferson Capital: Shermanburg Date of Statehood: November 17, 1886 Postal Abbreviation: JF

Flag of Pasapa.png
Name: Pasapa Capital: Beryl Date of Statehood: March 16, 1887 Postal Abbreviation: PS

Flag of Laramie.png

Name: Laramie Capital: Fort Laramie Date of Statehood: July 3, 1887 Postal Abbreviation: LR

Flag of Absaroka.png

Name: Absaroka Capital: Boreman Date of Statehood: November 5, 1888 Postal Abbreviation: AB
 
Last edited:
Ah! Grocer's apostrophe! Ah!

Otherwise, nice update. I suppose the peoples of the Caribbean will be even more familiar with the Marines than IOTL...though OTOH being able to grow bananas in Cuba instead might mean Dole et. al. just stick to the US. Seems to be going relatively as per OTL, boring scandal-plagued administrations, industrial development and growth, etc. etc.
 

The Dude

Banned
I just caught up on this TL. I really liked the part with Custer and Stuart. I also liked how you managed to work in TR.
 
Ah! Grocer's apostrophe! Ah!

Seems to be going relatively as per OTL, boring scandal-plagued administrations, industrial development and growth, etc. etc.

To a degree. Some differences from OTL are...

1) The West is being settled faster because of the higher population resulting from a shorter Civil War. As such Native Americans are fairing worse than OTL.

2) There are higher levels of German and Italian immigration to the United States due to those nations not being entirely unified.

3) The conditions for Blacks in the South are not as bad as OTL because of a considerably less severe Civil War and Reconstruction (The TL’s Reconciliation). Furthermore many of the western states have sizable black communities due to the Homestead Act of 1865.

The next installment will deal with the 1880s abroad where butterflies are making some interesting changes. Cheers.
 
Same objections apply, unless they are significantly changing the words. 'Down with the traitors' 'no man shall live a slave' etc. are all clearly about beating the South in the Civil War.

Even if you significantly change the words, I would predict that its association with the Civil War would make it unpopular among Southern congressmen.

Indeed Gentlemen, good observations. If the Battle Cry of Freedom became the National Anthem with the original lyrics posted above it would seem odd and probably remain unpopular in the South. However, if you will read closely I said it will eventually become the National Anthem after some changes.

*SPOILERS*

The Battle Cry of Freedom will not be offically adopted until the early 20th Century after subsequent wars with foreign powers and changes in the lyrics. And don't worry I will post the final lyrics of the song when the time comes. Cheers.
Of course, the numbers of Canadians (especially on this board) who think "the Mapleleaf Forever" (all about beating down the Frenchies) ought to be the Canadian anthem....
 
1) would the US navy of the time actually beaten the Spanish? OTL, 20? years later the Spanish had not improved their fleet in that time, and the US had.
2) How many US soldiers got sent to Cuba. I didn't see a number (there may have been one, but I didn't see it). THe Orbat you list looks to me like roughly 10k soldiers ??? Since the Spanish put 100k into Cuba for one revolt and something like 250k for another, how is the US winning on land?
 
Expansion of Imperial France

Expansion of Imperial France


Second French Empire.png



Under Napoleon IV, the Second French Empire prospered during the 1880s by continuing to industrialize and expand at a rapid pace. France purchased the Philippine Islands in 1879 from the cash strapped Spanish republican government that was then temporarily in power. France also gained control of Egypt during a brief war in 1883 after a series of anti-European riots, which France claimed were orchestrated by the unruly Khedive Tewfik Pasha, led to a successful French invasion. Napoleon IV relished following in the footsteps of his great-uncle and even visited the conquered province in 1885. Possession of Egypt also guaranteed French control of the Suez Canal of which Britain was a partial stockholder. Although officially the United Kingdom supported the French invasion, many historians have cited the 1883 Franco-Egyptian War as an important beginning step in the deterioration of Anglo-French relations.

During the 1880s, Imperial France strengthened its alliances with other empires. The Austro-Hungarian Empire remained chief amongst France’s allies who, like France, wished to see Italy and Prussia’s ambitions kept in checked. In the Americas, France found a receptive ally in the Empire of Brazil who welcomed French investment in exchange for Brazilian natural resources. It was also during the 1880s that France began to align its self with the Ottoman Empire. The Ottomans saw the French as a potential counterweight to the British who were expanding their holdings in Arabia, and to the Russians, the Turks' age old enemy to the north.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps the Americans who went to Hawaii OTL go to the Caribbean TTL? The US is more expansionist but also more Atlantic looking TTL. Heck they might be going more for Africa and ignoring the Pacific TTL...
 
1) would the US navy of the time actually beaten the Spanish? OTL, 20? years later the Spanish had not improved their fleet in that time, and the US had.
2) How many US soldiers got sent to Cuba. I didn't see a number (there may have been one, but I didn't see it). THe Orbat you list looks to me like roughly 10k soldiers ??? Since the Spanish put 100k into Cuba for one revolt and something like 250k for another, how is the US winning on land?

Good points, however

1)The U.S. still had a large number of vessels from the Civil War that were recommissioned to fight against Spain. Even though this TL's Spanish-American war is tougher on the U.S., I think it is safe to say that the U.S would be victorious for a number of reasons including proximity to the Caribbean, greater industrial capacity, and a lot of excellent battle hardened veterans left over from the Civil War. Also don't forget that Spain was very unstable during this time and was ruled by a military junta during war so it is likely that Spain had to keep a lot of troops back home.

2) the initial invasion force in Cuba was 10,000 men but the U.S. continued to pour men into the island. Furthermore most of Spain's forces were poorly trained, lead, equipped, and scattered over the island in small garrisons.
 
Top