“Live, via Satellite”

Britannia Rules the Airwaves

Hermes2b.jpg
Artist's Impression of a Hermes satellite in orbit​

In 1963, the GPO was willing to gamble that it could relay television signals to peoples’ homes using a satellite. The concept would mean that the existing network of ground based radio transmitters would not need to be expanded to cope with the higher frequency signals needed for high quality colour TV pictures, potentially saving millions of pounds. They accepted the risk that developing and launching two or three satellites to beam radio signals down to the UK would be cheaper than installing and maintaining dozens of TV transmitters all across the country.
To this day, no one knows if they were right.

The Hermes satellite TV relay system was a huge technical challenge and demanded the best minds that British industry and the GPO could provide. The spacecraft had to be able to function for years without maintenance, be powered by the sun (nuclear generators were ruled out at a very early stage) and must be stable enough to accurately point a 16’ dish antenna to within quarter of a degree of the UK. Although the basic radio systems were well understood, in 1963 no one had built a satellite with the power to transmit directly to the public. Spacecraft such as Telstar and Syncom weighed just a few hundred pounds and their low power signals could only be picked up by giant dishes, usually dozens of feet across. To broadcast to the public, who could only have small antennas on their homes, a massive increase in transmitter power would be needed. Syncom carried 2W transmitters. Hermes would need 150W transmitters, meaning that a power input of at least 1.5kW would be required for each TV channel to be broadcast. No satellite yet built had come close to meeting these requirements.

Once it was confirmed that the “Black Anvil” missile could be adapted as a space launch vehicle, the GPO was satisfied that it would be possible to launch a satellite large enough to carry all the systems and develop the power that would be required. Hermes satellites were big, even by today’s standards. In 1964, the design was ten times larger than any other Comsat being considered. When fully fuelled they would weigh 3 tons, a mass that would need to be placed into a circular orbit 36,000km above the Earth’s surface.

Hawker Siddeley Dynamics (HSD) were chosen to build this giant. The firm had worked with the GPO and several American firms during the development of Telstar and other early satellites, and had obtained access to details of a cancelled US Navy communications programme called Advent. Abandoned in 1962, Advent would have been a big satellite like Hermes, but fell victim to its own complexity, cost overruns and problems in the development of the rocket needed to launch it. By 1964, HSD were confident that they had solved or avoided these issues.

Three years later, the first prototype Hermes sits on top of the second Silver Star rocket, the world’s newest and most powerful launch vehicle. Engineers have checked and rechecked its systems and lessons have been learned from the first flight. The time has come to push the button.

“Hermes-P”, launches from Rainbow Beach on the 6th June 1967. This first modified Silver Star core performs well, without the excessive “pogo” seen on the earlier flights. The trajectory has been modified to allow the upper stage to fire continuously to put itself and the satellite directly into geostationary transfer orbit, eliminating one of the risky engine re-starts. It achieves a 203x36302km orbit at 37.6 degrees inclination, slightly higher than planned. A little over 5 hours later, the stage’s automatic sequencer performs the apogee burn on schedule, placing the satellite into a 36299 x 36152km orbit. A minor glitch in the vernier thrusters means this is also slightly higher than intended.
The satellite separates and its telemetry carrier signal is acquired by Goonhilly at T+06:03. The 50’ wide solar reflectors are deployed, after which the spacecraft stabilises and orientates itself to allow the reflectors to lock on to the sun. All four turbine units are producing power by T+07:32. Thrusters are used to trim the orbit to 35,802 x 35912km on the second day to stop the satellite “drifting” (as seen from the ground) too quickly to the West.

As Hermes is launched, it is estimated that there are only about 6,000 colour TV sets in the country. The new “satellite-receiver” sets and aerials are incompatible with the old style of ground-based transmission. The cheapest colour set costs £99 (plus £14 10s for an aerial, plus fitting). Although a few experimental test broadcasts have been made from a single transmitter in London, the new style sets have been essentially useless until now. A few dual receiver sets (which can work with both systems) have been marketed, but these are much more expensive and sales have been disappointing. Most of the public has therefore adopted a “wait and see” policy, and it is notable that demand shot up in the days after the successful launch of Hermes-P. Thanks to stockpiles of unsold sets, the availability of easy terms or rentals and a well-planned installation campaign by the GPO nearly 100,000 new TVs are installed into people’s homes in the 11 days after the launch.

Despite the considerable press, TV and public information film coverage, some still expected their new colour sets to “spring to life” immediately. Much to their frustration, ground controllers will now spend several days testing the satellite, while also allowing it to drift towards its final position near the prime meridian.

On the 11th, the high power signal transmitter is switched on and allowed to thermally stabilise for 48 hours. Directional control of the spacecraft is switched over to the reaction wheels during this time, but is switched back to thrusters when an unexpected torque overwhelms the wheels three hours later.

To help avoid any negative public reaction to early faults, non-TV signals are used to test the relay receiver-transmitter. Signal strengths, distortion and noise levels are checked and the system passes these tests with flying colours on the 14th and 15th.

The first colour TV test card is broadcast for 10 minutes starting at 0235 in the morning of the 16th June. The test is not announced and as far as is known no-one other than BBC, ITV and GPO engineers saw it; its purpose was as a final check, both of the satellite and signal monitoring stations around the country. The first publicly announced colour test card is broadcast between 1900 and 2200 on the following day to allow the public to adjust their sets. Simultaneous broadcasts on “old” television shows viewers what to do and what they should expect to see.

Regular colour TV broadcasting in the UK begins on BBC 2 at 7PM on the 18th June, when the BBC’s new "World Circling Satellite” ident is shown for the first time. The BBC has decided to use the part-time BBC 2 channel for the duration of the experimental phase, leaving its regular BBC 1 programming in black and white on the existing ground based transmitters.

After the briefest of introductions, “Good evening and welcome to BBC Satellite Television”, the first programme is an ambitious series of live broadcasts from locations around (and off) the country, including the deck of the liner Queen Elizabeth in the English Channel and from the Orkney Islands, which have never previously received any TV signals. This latter telecast is the first example of a double satellite relay, as the outside broadcast from the Orkneys is sent up to an Intelsat satellite over the Atlantic, back down to one of the big dishes at Goonhilly then up again to Hermes-P for rebroadcast to the nation.
A later programme describing how the system works includes colour footage of the launch of Hermes-P and in a special edition of "The Sky at Night", astronomer Patrick Moore shows viewers how and when to try to spot the satellite in orbit high over the equator.

At 7pm the following evening, ITV colour broadcasting is started with a brief announcement, followed by the first colour advert to be shown on British television (it was for Kellogg's cereals). A live broadcast from Abbey Road studios includes the debut of the Beatles' latest song "All You Need Is Love", which is also transmitted to the US and Europe via the Intelsat network, for relay by those countries' traditional ground based TV systems.

The single transponder on Hermes-P can only broadcast one channel at a time. The BBC and ITV have agreed that during this experimental phase they will each broadcast on alternate days to allow both networks access to colour programming. As it is a single frequency, the public can receive the BBC and ITV programmes without retuning.

However, with only 6 colour TV cameras in the entire country it is not possible to produce everything to the new standard. A simple and very popular approach is tried by the BBC, where controllers decide to concentrate on sports broadcasts, something that can be done easily with just one camera at an event. Centre court matches at the 1967 Wimbledon lawn tennis championships are first to be shown. The first test match in colour (between England and India) is broadcast from Edgbaston in July. Football fans have to wait for the start of the season in August, when Everton meet Manchester United “in glorious colour” on the 19th.

The Hermes-P satellite itself surpasses everyone’s expectations with its reliability. A single thruster failure in August 1968 marginally increases fuel consumption, but the electronics and payload are still operating normally in July 1970 when the satellite’s fuel begins to run low. After the launch of Hermes-2 it has only been used as a backup and for a variety of experiments. The satellite is nudged into a slightly higher orbit in August 1970 and is left to "drift" (i.e. not maintain a constant position over the ground). The transmitter payload ceases to function in February 1971 when the main receiver fails. By April 1972 two of the four generator turbines have failed and it is not considered worth the effort of monitoring the spacecraft any longer.
On 2 May 1972, Hermes-P is commanded to turn its solar reflectors away from the sun. It is then placed in a slow spin to naturally stabilise its attitude before being permanently switched off.

Hermes2b.jpg
 
Brits in Space
and they give what Brits want: Football on color TV

i impress, alone the idea of Solar heated power Generators for Hermes is genius, NASA play with this idea for 20 years to install them on there Space station, but never realized it !
guess the Selene Project got now more public support. like Labor lost election because there Candidate proposed to stop Hermes do waste of Money and voter had punished him
(see UKIP leader Nigel Farage career suicide with proposal to cut down BBC to one news channel )

about new “satellite-receiver” sets, will there be also satellite-receiver local cable networks ?
i mean areas and city were big satellite-receiver take Hermes signal and provide by cable to locals for rent.
ITV could have a growing market by provide this service
 
...Something the Selene Project did actually worked?

Wow.

Makes you proud to be British.

Even better than that. Hermes isn't part of the Selene Project, its an entirely British programme.
Its one of the other key supports of the house of cards that is the UK's space efforts (others being the military's Black Anvil and the government's desire not to let the aerospace industry collapse altogether).
 
Even better than that. Hermes isn't part of the Selene Project, its an entirely British programme.
Its one of the other key supports of the house of cards that is the UK's space efforts (others being the military's Black Anvil and the government's desire not to let the aerospace industry collapse altogether).

HM Treasury: This 'Selene' thing is really expensive. I think we should cancel it.

The day after

...Her Majesty's Treasury has been hit today by several malfunctioning Aerospace Industry test flights...
 
Brits in Space
and they give what Brits want: Football on color TV
Always give the public what they want.:)

i impress, alone the idea of Solar heated power Generators for Hermes is genius, NASA play with this idea for 20 years to install them on there Space station, but never realized it !
guess the Selene Project got now more public support. like Labor lost election because there Candidate proposed to stop Hermes do waste of Money and voter had punished him
(see UKIP leader Nigel Farage career suicide with proposal to cut down BBC to one news channel )

about new “satellite-receiver” sets, will there be also satellite-receiver local cable networks ?
i mean areas and city were big satellite-receiver take Hermes signal and provide by cable to locals for rent.
ITV could have a growing market by provide this service

It won't be swinging any elections in the near future (the '70 elections were won with a sizeable majority) but the whole issue of "space" is now much more easily associated with "real success" than before. There's potential for export orders too, so it might become a bit more self-sustaining, or at least more difficult to cancel.

In the short term its probably difficult for ITV as most of the regions will be folded up into the one satellite channel. However, longer term it might be much better for local TV in the UK. As you say, local cable (or even low power ground transmitter) stations could spring up, much like a US local affiliate to a national network.
At the very least I can see a fourth channel coming along much sooner than '82.

**Not to go all political, but the sooner Nigel Farage is forgotten the better. I'm not a supporter of the EU, but he and his party are far worse.
 
HM Treasury: This 'Selene' thing is really expensive. I think we should cancel it.

The day after

...Her Majesty's Treasury has been hit today by several malfunctioning Aerospace Industry test flights...

:)

They certainly think exactly that...
...and they have been very quiet recently.
 
Early dishes for receiving C band transmissions were thousands of dollars.

I know this is a MUCH higher power transmitter than OTL's C-band satellites, but you still need to install dishes. Heck, you need to do it today.

How are you getting around that problem?

Aren't you going to need 1-2m dishes on the roofs of houses, connected to the TVs by (probably) Coax?

99£ TVs are nice, but the tv set is the least of the cost of receiving satellite....
 
I think you missed this part:
As Hermes is launched, it is estimated that there are only about 6,000 colour TV sets in the country. The new “satellite-receiver” sets and aerials are incompatible with the old style of ground-based transmission. The cheapest colour set costs £99 (plus £14 10s for an aerial, plus fitting)
So it seems they're not that expensive here.

Excellent story here anyway STS. I wonder if you're ever going to get around to the EU applications again though given there has been substantial progress on Anglo-Franco relations since DeGaul last rejected UK ascension the the EU.
 
I think you missed this part:

So it seems they're not that expensive here.

Excellent story here anyway STS. I wonder if you're ever going to get around to the EU applications again though given there has been substantial progress on Anglo-Franco relations since DeGaul last rejected UK ascension the the EU.

How the frip does a £14 aerial pick up a satellite signal?

That doesn't happen iOTL with huge advances in tech.
 
Early dishes for receiving C band transmissions were thousands of dollars.

I know this is a MUCH higher power transmitter than OTL's C-band satellites, but you still need to install dishes. Heck, you need to do it today.

How are you getting around that problem?

Aren't you going to need 1-2m dishes on the roofs of houses, connected to the TVs by (probably) Coax?

99£ TVs are nice, but the tv set is the least of the cost of receiving satellite....

Based on your previous comments on this same topic, I suggest a bit of research into radio communications theory might be in order. There is nothing fundamentally different about receiving a signal from a satellite, so long as you get it right. With the right antenna, you can pick up simple signals from satellites using a very ordinary cheap radio. If you know what a link budget is, have a browse of the attached (the zip file only contains an Excel sheet). Bear in mind the signals would be FM, hence the relatively low SNR - no sane individual would attempt TV satellite relay with AM signals.
View attachment Link.zip

I suspect you may be thinking of multi-channel “set top” units - the old cable or "big dish" boxes?
There is/was electronics in those (even the early ones) that could not have been built at any price in 1967. Another part of the reason they were so expensive was that they had to take weak satellite signals and convert them to TV-compatible formats - partly a consequence of the failings of the NTSC format, which suffered form being developed in c.1950. It was much better than the c.1936 405 line UK system, but later development such as PAL and SECAM were much more satellite-friendly.

Hermes avoids most of that – The “satellite-receiver” TVs I mention in the story are designed from the start to receive only the Hermes satellite signals, so there is no need for the same level of signal conversion (and there are certainly no digitally selectable tuners or anything like that). Essentially they are just ordinary TVs, but with a powered receiver element designed for the higher frequencies.
Definitely coax, no bent coat hangers used as a cheap aerial on top of the set:(

As I say, a radio signal is … a radio signal, provided that it is strong enough for the job; that’s why the satellites are so big and have such a high gain transmission antennas. The 3dB signal width for a 16’ antenna in the C-band matches the size of the UK quite well. Real satellites not only had lower power transmitters, but didn't have anything like that level of gain - they were limited by launch vehicles and in any case were designed for point-point relay, not direct-to-home.
There are some genuine advantages to satellite signals – fewer atmospherics and almost none of the ground and ionospheric reflections that were the bane of terrestrial analogue TV (until I wrote this story I had forgotten how awful '70s TV pictures were - remember image ghosting and picture drift?).

With the Hermes system, to see a decent(ish) picture, you would need a 1m dish and a good quality set (with analogue electronics being what they were, that is not necessarily the “cheapest £99” one). Let’s just say the debate over how to get a good picture would have a bright future in the UK, but bear in mind that it’s being compared to the old 405 line B/W VHF system, which had lots of interference issues.
 
How the frip does a £14 aerial pick up a satellite signal?

It helps if you point it in the right direction.:)

That doesn't happen iOTL with huge advances in tech.

£14 10s in 1967 is the equivalent of about £400 today (depending on which inflation measure you pick) - you can buy a satphone or a satellite internet terminal for that - and that actually talks to satellites, it doesn't just receive signals from them.
A 1m dish antenna is only a bit of pressed steel and and few components. £14 10s is almost a rip-off (of course, the more expensive sets include a "free" antenna).
 
The Man who makes the Machines

[Something a bit different today; more of a traditional short story “on the theme” of the Selene Project.]

Monday was a normal day for Geoff Styles as his newish Ford Cortina coughed into life and he set off for the Hawker-Hydromatics factory near Stevenage. The rain was a welcome relief from the hot weather of the last few days, but he thought it made the stained brick and concrete car park look even less tidy than usual. Geoff was a designer, working on one of the least known and least appreciated parts of the Selene Project. The Selene Experimental Research Programme (or SERP) wouldn’t build Moonships or giant rockets, it was concerned with the detail; fundamental research into the little bits and pieces that would allow everything else to work. It was a boffin’s delight; there were no loudmouthed astronauts or big public displays in SERP, but there were a lot of very bright scientists.

Opening up his desk and extracting his draughtsman’s tools from the exact places he carefully placed them every evening, he settled down for the morning; he had to carefully amend the details of a liquid Methane tank vent before one of his juniors would be given the job of producing several copies. Miss Jones, who was definitely the most attractive of the tea ladies, unusually so in fact, passed by his desk. Enid, who brought his tea after 11, always late and just too cool to be properly enjoyed, certainly lacked any such charms. Distracted by her departing legs as she passed down through the office pushing the nine o’clock tea to Sir Crispin and the managers’ offices above, he thought back to a day three months ago.

He had been similarly distracted then and, engrossed in his thoughts, he hadn’t noticed Fred, a rather too chirpy office boy, who walked briskly up and said “Mr Tracepurcel says he wants to see you this morning”. After a brief pause, during which Geoff had considered all the possible ways that this could mean bad news, he quietly replied “Let him know I’ll be there in a few minutes”.

Mr Tracepurcel was the deputy personnel manager, and definitely a “Mr” or “Sir” to the likes of Fred the messenger. To Geoff, he would always be “Harold”, Mr Tracepurcel having once made the mistake of introducing his first name in conversation. As a senior designer, and therefore very much the equal of any deputy manager, Geoff therefore never felt obliged to refer to him as Mr Tracepurcel. The fact that this familiarity also obviously annoyed the slightly pompous man was the icing on the cake.

After delaying long enough to make it clear that he hadn’t dropped everything to rush up to see a man who was only the deputy personnel manager, he walked slowly towards the lift at the end of the building, rode up a floor and paused briefly to knock before entering Harold’s office. Leaving an hour or so later, he felt rather silly for being so petty-minded as to have made the man wait. At the meeting, he had received very exciting news.

He had been very busy in the three months since that meeting, but now Monday was over. It had been a completely normal day. At his desk at 8:45 sharp, as always, an hour for lunch, as always and a steady drive the seven miles back to his and Sheila’s little house in Welwyn Garden City.

Tomorrow would not be a normal day. He had happy memories of the last time he left the country, on a schoolboy trip to France, spluttering over French cigarettes and discovering the delights of Vin-de-Gare, a liquid which probably contained equal amounts of grape and typewriter correction fluid.

This next trip would be very different, for tomorrow he would board a flying boat for a six day trip to the other side of the world to see his experimental fluid control system launched into space.

Sitting back in the canvas military-style transport seat of the Princess flying boat as it roared out down the Bristol Channel, his nerves started to go on edge. All his previous flights had been years ago while testing the Trident airliner. At least that had been a quiet, smooth jet.

However, being flown to Australia for free wasn’t all bad and he knew it would probably be the high point of an otherwise un-glamourous career. His job was responsible, even vital, but wasn’t anything like the Project directors or the Astronauts, people who were always on the television, men who could do no wrong; even though Geoff knew they often were. Of course, most of them knew it themselves too, but it gave him a little satisfaction to think that “I’m know right, while Mr.Clever whats-his-face on the telly has just got it wrong”.

The only time he had met one of these men face to face had been about six months ago. One of the astronauts had been round on a “goodwill tour”, part of the promotional side of the Project and intended to let the men and women in the little firms and the back offices know that they were all vital to The Project. To start with, he hadn’t liked the man much. James “Call me Jock” Waters had irritated him from the second they’d first met.
“So you’re the man designing this Methane retention tank vent, I hear there’s a bit of trouble with gas ingestion in zero-G”.

Call-me-Jock (as Geoff immediately thought of him) was quite right. No doubt he’d been well briefed and perhaps it should have been flattering that one of the Project’s heroic astronauts knew exactly what he was working on. However, Geoff had been embarrassed that his part of the project was “in trouble”, mumbled slightly before launching into a stream of technical babble about viscosity, G-forces and expected flow rates. He was intimidated by the man’s calm, self-confident assurance, something that Geoff knew he didn’t have.

Now, sitting in the noisy flying boat, he realised he was envious too. He’d spent much of his life as a designer, boosting his fragile ego by choosing to look down on pilots – after all, all they did was drive aeroplanes – he designed them, well, bits of them anyway.

Call-me-Jock was a different breed; not just a pilot with a pilot’s glib self-assurance, there was something more, a quiet but absolute self-confidence mixed with a very sharp eye for detail. Not much would get past Call-me-Jock, and he clearly wasn’t easily put off. Call-me-Jock wasn’t even intimidated by Sir Crispin. On that day the Chairman had tried to move Jock on, away from the babbling, embarrassed designer who obviously wasn’t doing much for the image of the firm. Call-me-Jock was having none of it, and over the next five minutes had casually calmed Geoff down and had a brief, genuinely technical discussion about the suction head requirements of the J-650’s turbopump.

Things had steadily improved from there. His design for the propellant settling devices had been through several cycles of test and re-design and he was now enroute for Australia to supervise the checks on an experiment that would prove them in orbit. He was also desperate to light up his pipe, partly out of habit but mostly to drown out the smell of oil and jet fuel. Four hours into the flight, his ears battered by the continued roar of the flying boat’s ten engines, Geoff felt he was earning his “free” trip. Certainly no-one would pay to fly on this thing.

Checkout of the experiment for which he was responsible took a few days, but was relatively easy for Geoff and his assistant. Once in space, the SERP-1 satellite would make a series of orbit changes. Electrical sensors inside a tank would monitor the position and behaviour of the liquid Methane inside as it flowed over, and was hopefully retained by, a series of pipes, baffles and mesh grids. On a real spacecraft like the PROM, devices like these would be vital to ensure that liquid fuel, and not gas, flowed straight into the main engine when it started.

The other experiment being carried was some type of star sensor and was causing endless problems for the dozen or so men who had to test it before flight. The problems worked well for Geoff, as they allowed him a few days off. An overnight trip to Brisbane was nice, but it wasn’t London. A day on the largest and emptiest beach imaginable and a ride in a high-speed motorboat out to swim over a coral reef was like nothing he’d ever seen. Mike, the Aussie engineer who owned the boat talked endlessly about his parent’s farm out to the east “just a small place, about twenty thousand acres” he’d said with a big grin. Things were on a different scale over here.

Once the final tests on the payload were complete and the rocket was erected on the pad, there was little more for Geoff to do but wait for the launch controllers to work their way through the countdown sequence. Running a test back home on one piece of equipment usually involved a few chaps with a bank of switches and a dozen data recorders. The control room for a Blue Star launch had over 50 people in it. He counted forty oscilloscopes and display screens as well as countless meters and indicator lights. He’d previously overheard one of the technicians saying that they would make over 20,000 “flips” on the various switches before the rocket finally left the pad.

When it did, the noise was indescribable. Sitting on the beach with thousands of other Rainbow Beach personnel, locals and their families, the rocket arced up into the sky in front of him before disappearing into the thin clouds, the flame of the engines still visible as a rapidly moving spot of diffuse light.

The flight home was much more comfortable, and he was relieved to be spared the discomfort of the Princess; there wasn’t one due for nearly two weeks. Being surrounded by enthusiastic businessmen and a few excited families on board the modern airliner helped to lighten his mood. After all that effort and care, the damned rocket hadn’t worked. Some switch flipping error, some broken wire … something caused the heavy payload fairing to stay attached after the second stage fired. The whole lot, including his meticulously design Methane trap, had been incinerated as it fell back into the atmosphere somewhere over the Pacific.

However, life must move on and he was looking forward to seeing Sheila again. He had an exciting new idea; it would be a big step, leaving Hydromatics and convincing Sheila, what with her mother's current health problem, but Geoff was pretty sure she would be up for it in the end. It had been clear from Mike and a dozen others he’d talked to that there was plenty of work to go to. He was happy his trip hadn’t been completely wasted, after all, he’d found a new home.
 
A nice little update. I like it! Feel free to sprinkle some more of these 'personal' bits across the rest of the story ;)
If the point of this update was to show some of the more 'mundane' parts of rocket science, then I really want to read more of the exciting side!
Other than that, keep it up! There is still a long way to go to the lunar landing we're all hoping for, but the road there is quite cool in itself!
 
Uncertain Operations

Jul-67
Lunar Orbiter A3
BSLV-13 launches the third Wide Angle photography mission. The Blue Star launcher functions normally and places the satellite into a 185x173km Earth orbit. Twelve minutes later, the translunar injection burn begins, putting the spacecraft onto a nearly perfect trajectory towards the Moon.
A 1.05s course correction at T+23:58 reduces the targeted perilune and is so accurate that a second course correction planned for the following day is not needed. Lunar orbit insertion consists of a 67s burn at T+75:13, leaving the satellite in a 139x867km orbit. A braking manoeuvre 4 orbits later drops it into the 139x154km mapping orbit, in doing so burning up all of the remaining fuel (ground calculations predict approximately 0.4kg remaining – an amount insufficient for any further engine firings).
Photography starts at T+89h and continues for 63 orbits. The stability of this low lunar orbit is found to be much better than that of LO-A2. At T+215h the film jams and will not advance further. All attempts to unjam it fail and with no better options, the film is cut at T+228h to free it for development and scanning. The 178 images that were exposed are successfully radioed back to Earth over the next 16 days. Radio monitoring of the orbit continues until day 57 when an electrical fault in the control system causes the satellite to rapidly lose power. Based on the trend of the orbital change, it probably hit the lunar surface in early 1968.

Jul-67 Overseas
NASA launches its XS-20 flight SP-5. Carrying additional fuel and supplies, the mission makes a rendezvous with the Agena target stage previously used on Apollo 5. Following the deorbit burn, the spacecraft flies another "skip glide" re-entry, landing at White Sands after an 11 hour 58 minute flight.


Jul-67
S-103 Black Anvil test flight from Rainbow Beach
Unmodified core used to test a Rolls-Royce booster engine recovery system and provide flight dynamics data. Despite considerable resonant vibration in the fuel feed and combustion chambers, the missile performs adequately.
The booster pack is jettisoned and coasts to 96km altitude before re-entering at nearly Mach 10. It survives entry but does not deploy any of its parachutes and is destroyed on impact with the sea. Film of the event and floating debris suggests that the recovery pods fitted to the side of the booster pack may have been damaged during re-entry.
The core of the missile continues until engine cutoff. Flight telemetry is received throughout the burn. No active payload is carried and the missile would have broken up on re-entry about 3,800mi downrange.

The last Blue Streak core is delivered to the Ministry of Technology for use as a launch vehicle.
The manufacturer, Hawker Siddeley, has been instructed to dismantle the production line as there will be no further demand for production of Blue Streak cores. 39 missiles remain in RAF service, with a further 10 in reserve and 12 available for use as satellite launchers.

Sud Aviation deliver the first test article of their “Explorateur” lunar lander to Farnborough for resonance testing. A huge new vibration rig has been constructed to measure the dynamic responses of satellite payloads on the Silver Star booster. The problems on Flights S-101 and 102 have shown the need for better testing of how a complete payload and launch vehicle behave under the stresses and shocks encountered in flight.


OTR-17
Blue Streak test & training flight from Rainbow Beach. Range: 1,698mi, impact 2,800' from target point. The missile carries a side pod with a materials test vehicle, which is successfully recovered from the sea.

Aug-67 Overseas
NASA probe Lunar Orbiter 4 enters a highly inclined orbit around the Moon. It returns 409 images including the first high quality pictures of areas near the lunar poles.

Aug-67
The lunar landing test vehicle crashes at Farnborough. Fortunately, the pilot ejects before impact and survives. It is one of the last tests using the original design and the loss is blamed on feedback in the rather simple analogue control system. A new Mark 2 version is already under construction which will use a modified version of the PROM’s computer to control its flight, allowing for much more flexibility in developing effective control techniques.


Sep-67
The Intelsat Organisation signs a contract with Hawker Siddeley for two "Intelsat 4A" class satellites.
These will be based on the design of Hermes, but with the large high gain antenna and transmitter system replaced by several smaller units to provide international telephone and TV relay capability. HSD are to subcontract BAC to provide the Silver Star launch vehicles. The satellites are to be ready for launch by the first quarter of 1971.
Intelsat also award a contract to Hughes in the US to provide four smaller "Intelsat 4B" satellites, which will be launched by NASA.


SERP-1
BSLV-14 launches the first orbital test flight of the "Selene Experimental Research Programme" (SERP), the function of which is to design, test and verify materials and systems to be used in the Project’s spacecraft.
Although mostly lab and test chamber work, the programme plans to conduct a series of flights to test several systems and techniques in space. This launch of a fluid dynamics experiment is lost when the payload fairing fails to jettison shortly after second stage ignition. Carrying the extra weight of the fairing during the second stage burn means that the spacecraft never achieves orbit.


Concerns over the fuel margins on Lunar Orbiter missions are to be addressed on future flights.
Lunar Orbiter A3 followed a nearly perfect trajectory and still depleted its entire fuel reserve merely to enter orbit. Changes to the design of the probes since the last major review have increased dry mass to 431kg, while the rated capability of the rocket has remained at 425kg. There has also been a slight underperformance of the second stage on both A2 and A3 flights, resulting in the Orbiter probes being injected into a lower Earth orbit than was planned.
Several changes are to be made to the programme before the next mission:
- Fuel sensors on the first and second stages are to be more precisely calibrated to help eliminate the underperformance of the Blue Star launcher.
- Minor changes to the Lunar Orbiter spacecraft will reduce weight by 2kg.
- The translunar flight is to be slowed to 94 hours, slightly reducing both TLI and LOI requirements.
- The last "wide angle" spacecraft (A4) will be delayed until after the first narrow angle mission has flown, to allow greater flexibility in the areas to be photographed.
- The next flight (the "narrow angle" A5 spacecraft) is planned for December.

Further wind tunnel tests of the Black Anvil booster pack recovery system tested on S-103 suggest that hypersonic shock reflections may have caused damage to the recovery pods. The new data suggests that recovery of the booster pack would require considerably more heat shielding and an improved stabilisation system during re-entry. Model tests will continue in an attempt to study the problems.


Oct-67 Overseas
Televised hearings into the Apollo 5 failure are concluded in the US.
Testimony from contractors, NASA managers and the astronauts has revealed a catalogue of minor faults in the Apollo CSM construction and operational processes. Most parties are strongly supportive of continuing the programme, but many improvements are needed. The problems on Apollo 5 and a series of accidents on the ground are found to be due to a lack of effective quality control rather than poor design. Changes to many details of the Apollo Block 2 and the planned Block 3 vehicles will be made before flights are resumed. NASA has not wasted time since Apollo 5 and the redesign is already well under way. The agency expects to fly Apollo 6 in January, then launch its first Orbital Laboratory later next year.

The Atlas rocket carrying NASA’s Surveyor 2 lunar lander fails shortly after liftoff from Cape Canaveral.

NASA launches SA-301, the first test flight of its large new "Saturn III" launch vehicle.
Three F-1 engines, each producing 1.45 million pounds-thrust, propel this 1,500 ton vehicle off the pad. A second stage with four 200,000lbf Hydrogen/Oxygen engines then takes over, before a third stage uses one of these same J-2 engines to place a 68 ton payload into low Earth orbit, making the rocket four times more capable than anything else that has flown before. Saturn III rockets will be used to launch the “Orbital Lab” space stations and are vital to NASA’s lunar plans.
The flight is a complete success. The dummy payload is simply a water tank, which is vented once in orbit producing a spectacular but short lived cloud of ice crystals.

The Soviet Union announces that the Cosmos 186 and 188 spacecraft have performed a fully automated docking in Earth orbit.


Nov-67
OTR-18
Blue Streak Test from Benbecula. Range: 1,682mi, impact 3,700' from target. An atmospheric sampling experiment that was carried in a side mounted canister is never recovered.

Nov-67 Overseas
NASA launches SP-6, the final test flight of the XS-20 Spaceplane.
The mission re-flies the same vehicle used on SP-3, making this the first time that a spacecraft has been reused. It accomplishes an "orbital turn", a manoeuver that sees it dive into the atmosphere and use aerodynamic forces to slightly change the plane of its orbit before skipping back out into space. A semi-automatic landing is made at Edwards AFB six hours after launch.


Nov-67
The first PROM spacecraft departs the UK for Australia on an RAAF Hercules transport.
Spacecraft 006 is the first flight-ready vehicle to be completed, although in fact the Propulsion Module contains very live few systems. It will be used to make an unmanned test flight on a Silver Star rocket.


Dec-67 Overseas
The last of NASA’s lunar imaging flights, Lunar Orbiter 5, completes its photography mission. 468 images of both the near and farside of the Moon are returned.

Dec-67
Lunar Orbiter A5
BSLV-14 - First of the Narrow Angle orbiters. There is still a slight underburn on the Blue Star second stage, however the third stage is able to correct and a 193x194km Earth orbit is achieved. Translunar injection is more accurate than ever before and only a 0.7s correction burn is needed 24 hours out from Earth. The spacecraft reaches a minimum speed (relative to Earth) of just 841mph at T+90:03. Lunar orbit injection is at T+94:05 and lasts 65s, resulting in a 136x706km orbit.
Another burn two orbits later overperforms and sends the spacecraft into a 137x50km orbit - plans called for a near circular orbit at 135km. This is regarded as dangerously low given the limited control and knowledge of lunar gravity. The camera team also informs flight controllers that the camera is not design to operate this low and images will be smeared due to the rate of travel over the lunar surface. The next day a correction burn is partly successful and moves the probe to a 112x137km orbit. Engine operation was erratic, possibly due to the tiny quantity of fuel left in the tanks not feeding through to the engine smoothly.
Rather than risk using the engine again, the orbit is deemed adequate and photography begins.
After 3 days the orbit has changed to 98x147km, due to unpredicted lunar gravity effects. Another engine burn is attempted, producing less than half the impulse that it should have delivered. However, this raises the orbit to 127x147km and photography continues until day 10, when perilune has again fallen to 99km.
A third attempt to fire the engine produces virtually no impulse and only raises perilune to 106km. The film is cut and the develop/scan process starts. Readout continues for 23 days, returning 269 complete images until the film mechanism jams. The last few pictures were very blurred and analysts suggest that developer fluid may have leaked into the scanning chamber. Radio contact is maintained with the spacecraft until it hits the lunar surface on day 40.


An attempt to launch Aurora 1, the first test of the PROM spacecraft, is aborted during the countdown. Problems with both rocket and spacecraft are found and the vehicle is moved back to the hangar for changes to be made. Work is suspended until after the New Year.

Jan-68 Overseas
American TV network CBS announces it has reserved the option to buy two modified Hermes-type relay satellites from Hawker Siddeley.
These will be equipped to broadcast US-compatible signals to every part of the continental United States. They will allow the network to bypass some local re-broadcasters, making it easier to offer genuinely nationwide advertising to their sponsors. Unlike the British versions, these will not be direct-to-home broadcast satellites; they will still rely on ground stations and cable or local broadcasts. Services are planned to start in 1969 and promise a better quality picture than existing broadcasts. As an incentive to viewers and cable networks, they announce that an extra CBS "satellite only" channel will be introduced, carrying additional sports and news shows in return for a small subscription.
To attempt to minimise any negative publicity arising from the purchase of a foreign satellite, the network stresses the transmitter systems on the satellites will be built “to specialised American specifications” by Bell Labs in the US and that discussions are under way with NASA regarding launching the satellites on an American Saturn rocket.


Jan-68
Explorateur 1 / SSLV-3
First of the French built unmanned lunar landing vehicles.
Launch, orbital coast and translunar injection are all performed successfully by the Silver Star launcher. The upper stage still has 2.4t of propellant remaining, meaning that the Silver Star sent a total mass of 8.9t towards the Moon, in doing so setting another record for the British rocket. The 4.1t lander and its propulsion stages are released 52 minutes after liftoff. The new Selene ground control facility at Biscarosse should have acquired a signal from the Explorateur spacecraft shortly after that, but it never did. Attempts to communicate with the spacecraft continue for two days until it is formally declared lost. Calculations based on its last known trajectory show that it would have hit the Moon just over 70 hours after launch.

Jan-68 Overseas
NASA launches its Apollo 6 mission into Earth orbit. The crew of two perform a comprehensive shake down flight of the improved Apollo spacecraft during an 11 day mission. An attempt to rendezvous with the upper stage of the Saturn 1A rocket is abandoned when control of the stage is lost. Other than this, the mission is a complete success, including a "stand up" spacewalk in which astronaut Gene Cernan anchors himself in the hatch of the CM and performs various practical tasks at a station fitted just outside.
The space agency also confirms to Hawker Siddeley in the UK and their potential customer CBS that it can adapt the Saturn 1A rocket to send a 3.2t Hermes satellite to geostationary orbit. A "Centaur" upper stage could be fitted to the top of the Saturn to send the payload into the high orbit.


Jan-68
The Prime Minister and Defence Secretary announce that British forces east of Suez will be greatly reduced over the next two years. The draw down will include a complete pull out from Malaysia and Aden, with only a small force to be retained in Singapore. Forces based on British Overseas Territories on the Christmas Islands are to be retained as part of Black Anvil deployment to these isolated regions.
 
A quite exciting 'regular' update! The US is having their Apollo 1 hearings analogue, the French try to put a lander on the moon, unsuccesfully, and CBS wants a TV satellite! Also nice to see that Blue Streak test from the narrative update fit into it. Not much to comment on, other than to say it all seems to be going according to plan! I'm sure lots will be going wrong between now and whenever TTL finishes though :p
 
Balanced on a Knife Edge

The Selene Crisis of 1967

During the press “silly season” in August, there are a series of leaks from a Treasury backed report into the finances of the Selene Project. The details that emerge suggest that the UK side of the Project is £27M over budget, to date. Although a significant sum, this is only about 10% overshoot on the original estimates; hardly unusual for a technology development programme. What captures more attention is the suggestion that this is only the tip of the iceburg. Press and public reaction to the leaks are mixed, while official reaction is muted by security concerns.

The public have been broadly supportive of the "space programme", although to many, that term means “British space successes”, it is not specific to the activities of the Selene Project. The success of Hermes-P has increased overall public support dramatically, even though it is still very early days for the sales of satellite-receiver TV sets. Being able to watch television by satellite is a daily reminder of how everyone will benefit from the Space Age, and this sense of goodwill spills over into many other aspects of space research. The idea that Britain is leading the way is certainly popular with the public, while the possibility of export orders and the retention of high-tech skills in the UK mean that space has a wide base of support within the political establishment. The public seem willing, within reason, to accept that this type of work is not cheap.

In late August, an internal security inquiry is started into a separate leak of sensitive Treasury data related to several defence projects, including Black Anvil. Although the inquiry is only concerned with the release of information related to these projects, the inter-dependent nature of the missile and space programmes means that the publication of the report on the finances of the Selene Project is placed on hold while the security implications are reviewed more closely.

The “tip of the iceburg” hinted at in the press stories is what really concerns the Treasury. It seems likely that some of the Projects' many subcontractors are not reporting or allocating costs appropriately. It seems that there is no clear delineation between some civil and military expenditures, and it is suggested that costs are being charged to “Defence” when they should be met from Selene funds. The timing of sub-contractor reporting is criticised, as the most recent complete accounts are for the period to the end of 1965, leaving far too much room for errors and overspend to be hidden.

As part of general cost-cutting measures agreed in October, the Ministries of Technology and Defence agree not to expand Black Anvil production beyond 14 missile cores per year. Of a variety of cost saving options, this was thought to be the least damaging (at least to the all-important deterrent programme). Earlier plans foresaw the need for 115 missile cores by the middle of 1974, to cover the strategic missile, satellite launch and Selene requirements. This change will see the production of only 95-98 cores by then. The reduction will remove the need for additional production facilities at both BAC and Rolls-Royce plants, saving an estimated £37M during the period 1968-73 and deferring a further £65M until after that period. Delays in the Black Anvil missile programme are not acceptable, so the reduced production means there will be far fewer rockets available for the space programme. With orders for “Hermes” satellites likely to take priority, most of the cuts will have come from the Selene Project.

The SPC is forced to consider the impact of these changes. Allowing for “Explorateur” and “Aurora” flights, there will only be 10 or 11 of the large "Constellation" launchers available in the period to the middle of 1974. With a test programme of 6 or 7 launches, a lunar landing would have to be delayed until late 1973, simply due to the lack of availability of booster cores. Contractors and planning groups are asked to consider the scale of the Constellation test programme and whether some flights could be amalgamated or moved onto single core Silver Star rockets.

The long-delayed blow finally falls in early November, when the Auditor General and Treasury are cleared to distribute their report into the financial management of the Selene Project. It concludes that the British part of the Project has directly overspent £33M during the period 1963-1966 and this is likely to have increased to £56M as of July 1967. The nominal authorised budget of the British part of Selene stands at £61M for 1967, but it is clear that at the present rate the Project is on course to spend approximately £80M. The SPC comes in for heavy criticism:
- The Selene Project Committee (the SPC) is not providing adequate management supervision of contracts and operational spending.
- The SPC's reports are outdated and the committee does not work as part of the day-to-day running of the Project, instead only convening when decisions are needed.
- Committee decisions are dominated by the needs of international co-operation and engineering, without adequate regard to cost.
On the more positive side, the engineering and scientific sides of the Project are regarded as being of very high quality. No-one is unpatriotic enough to criticise British engineering, or unwise enough to criticise the productivity of the British worker.

However, the facts show that the Project is running at least 6 months behind schedule and is over its original budget on an annual basis, not counting the additional costs that will be incurred later due to the delays. Although this is hardly cause for congratulation, the situation is notably better than some development programmes; it is compared favourably to the AGR nuclear power project. The report concludes that Britain should seek to reduce the scope of the Selene Project on cost grounds, if it cannot be cancelled altogether.

The Project’s many supporters are quick to point out the benefits to Britain of continuing with Selene, however the SPC proves to be unable to comment on its alleged failings. The Committee appears to have been caught completely off guard by the level of criticism and it quickly becomes clear that the report is accurate; the SPC does not have the ability to exercise day to day control over the Project or provide clear, up to date reports on much of what is go on. The SPC grew out of the international diplomacy that led to the founding of the Selene Project. Although several members with legal and scientific experience have since joined, the committee itself has little industrial management and no accounting experience.

A week later, British members of the SPC finally issue a statement in defence of their management of the Project. It is too little, too late. No one has time to pay them much attention amid the flurry of other announcements that day.

In the course of discussions earlier in the month, the American government refused to provide additional financial support or extend further loans to Britain. Against the advice of some in his cabinet, Prime Minister Wilson stopped short of attempting to force President Johnson into providing support by threatening the withdrawal of British forces from the Far East. American loans were the last option and the balance of payments crisis has now become acute. Despite earlier assurances by the government, Sterling has to be devalued.

Amongst many subsequent measures, the British government are persuaded to seek further negotiations with France, with the aim of cancelling the Selene Project.
 
This is most alarming news!

Or it would be were I not confident that there would be no TL called "The Selene Project" if the darn thing gets cancelled before any of its manned hardware flies with a crew aboard.

Given OTL British history postwar, that's just exactly the sort of thing HMG tends to do of course. So perhaps I should be very afraid?:eek:

And most definitely ashamed to be a Yank; LBJ's administration's fiscal brinksmanship with our best and most beloved ally would leave me shocked and appalled if only I were not by now so painfully aware of how many other times since 1945 we've demonstrated this an abusive relationship. Douglas Adams once compared the collective personality of the USA to a sullen teenage boy, and I hang my head in shame it seems to be so.

Nevertheless I remain pretty sure that Selene the project will remain on track--if not on schedule. All the setbacks and delays hitherto seem to have the effect of shaking down the project to something more realistic and solid.
 
Top