Pyrrhus of Germany - An Alternate Timeline of WWI and Hence

The Prelude/Chapter 0
  • Prelude: The year is 1913. The Balkan Powederkeg is being lit and tensions are rising. New weapons have been created and the nations are eager to use them.
    Colonial ambition in Africa is building up, everyone wants their slice of the continent, and relations are uneasy.
    Britain is threatened by German naval buildup and France yearns for revenge for the events of 1870-71.

    Only time will tell what shall cause the eventual war, and who shall win it.

    (This is my second timeline, the prelude is more a thing i wrote so i could get the post out. Criticize the things i write here as much as you want.)
     
    Chapter I - A Conflict Begins - 1914
  • 1914 - June 28th - Sarajevo - "The line has been lit"
    A man stands near the motorcade. The man's name was Cabrinovic and he was hiding a bomb which he would throw to the motorcade.
    10:10 AM. The car of Franz Ferdinand approaches Cabrinovic. Cabrinovic throws the bomb which land directly in the car, explonding. Both the Archduke and his wife perished along with ~10 other people.

    Austria-Hungary was outraged and began to prepare demands to Serbia. Some decided that due to the brutality of the archdukes death the serbians should pay much more, but the notion was rejected.

    1914 - July 4th
    Austria-Hungary gains German aid in case of war with Russia.

    1914 - July 23rd
    Austria-Hungary sends an ultimatum to Serbia.

    1914 - July 28th - "The Powderkeg explodes"
    Austria-Hungary declares war against Serbia. Soon after the intricate web of alliances would begin to declare.

    1914 - July 30th
    Germany sends Russia an ultimatum, escalating the conflict.

    1914 - August 1st - "The Escalation"
    Germany declares war upon the Czardom of Russia, sending a portion of troops to the border. The Eastern front opens.

    1914 - August 2nd - "The Escalation"
    Germany invades Luxemburg
    The skirmish of Jocherey happens, where the first German casualty, Albert Mayer, and first French casualty, Jules-Andre Peugeot, occurred before the war.

    1914 - August 2nd-20th - "The Escalation"
    Germany captures Longwy opening up France for invasion.

    1914 - August 3rd - "The Escalation"
    The germans declare war upon France. This opens the Western Front.

    1914 - August 4th - "The Escalation"
    Germany invades Belgium after refusal for military access. This violates neutrality.
    Britain declares war upon Germany for for violating Belgian neutrality.


    (In the next post ill actually start diverging the happenings and using a better format. Ill cover the fronts in 1914 among other things, Criticize if you want)
     
    Chapter II - Western Front - The Battle of the Frontiers -1914
  • The War Begins
    The tension which had built up in Europe from june 28th to August 14th had finally boiled over. The war had begun.

    Battle of the Frontiers
    Belgian Capitulation - 4th of august-12th of November 1914

    During the beginning of the war, the 1st, 2nd and 3rd armies of the German Empire attacked belgium.
    Battle of Liege - 5th-15th of august
    A part of the 2nd army attacked Liege, in Belgium. Throughout the 5th of august the German army marched on to Liege. The fighting concluded with ~4000 casualties on the germans and anywhere from 6000-16 000 on the side of the Belgians. On 7th of august, Luddendorf captured the Citadel of Liege. A demand of surrender was sent, but it was refused.
    The Siege of Liege took place from 8th-15th of august. Throughout these days forts around Liege were captured until around the 15th Liege was taken.

    Around the same time Namur was taken.
    Battle of Halen
    Around the market town of Halen a battle took place between Belgian and German soldiers. Some 600 Germans were killen in contrast to 120 Belgians.
    Battle of Charleroi and Battle of Mons - 21st-23rd of August 1914
    In the battle of Charleroi the German 2nd and 3rd armies fought the French 5th Army. The Germans managed to cut off French retreat and destroy large parts of the army. Eventuallt the french managed to retreat inflicting large casualties on the germans in return, the battle is seen as a success.
    In Mons the battle was usuccessful for the British, although sustaining 2000 casualties, the Germans did lose 5500 men.
    (This is also part of the rest of the Battle of the Frontiers)
    Siege of Antwerp - 28th of September- 9th of October 1914
    Antwerp was besieged from 28th of September until 9th of October. The Bombardment of Antwerp begun on 28th of September. On 1st of October the German army began their attack on Belgium. Though succesfull the assault ultimately led to losses on the German side, around 72 000 men died. Casualties on the side of the entente were similar.
    On the 9th of October the city capitulated.
    ------
    Alsace - Battle of Mulhouse - 7th-10th, 14th-26th of August 1914
    7th-10th of August 1914

    The French began an advance toward Alsace began on the 7th of August. They advanced from Belfort to Mulhouse and Colmar, with relative ease. They seized the town of Altkirch in a bayonet charge.
    On 9th of August the Germans launched an attack to recapture Mulhouse capturing it by 10th of august.
    On the 14th of august the french becan a counterattack capturing Thann and Altkirch. Once they began assaulting the Germans in Mulhouse they faced a loss however, being repelled and soon after reinforcements came and recaptured areas that were lost.
    ------
    Battle of Lorraine - 14th-25th of August 1914
    Two corps of the French 1st army avanced toward Sarrebourg, and two to Vosges, and others went to Morhange in echelon. France captured several passes to protect the southern flank. The army advanced along the vosges passes, and captured Donon. When the French attacked Cirrey they were quickly repulsed by the Gemans. The second army attacking methodically managed to push back the Germans, but took many casualties in the progress. On 17th of august, the French army advanced to Sarrebourg, where the Germans had left prompting an advance to the north splitting the french army. Then at 20th of august a german counterattack forced retreat to the French military and returning the front line to status quo.
    ------
    Battle of Ardennes - 21-23rd of August 1914
    The Battle of Ardennes took place between the 21st and 23rd of august. The battle began on the 21st of august, where a large assault by the French started the battle. The french underestimated the size of the german force when invading Belgium, and the dug in german troops defended well in the fog and heavy rain, especially since the french had no artillery support. When the fog lifted German troops took French guns by suprise and silenced them with artillery. The german counterattack routed a division. Overall the battle of ardennes was a major german success, with the germans taking ~25 000 casualties as opposed to the French ~50 000.
    ------
    Battle of Charleroi and Battle of Mons - 21st-23rd of August 1914
    In the battle of Charleroi the German 2nd and 3rd armies fought the French 5th Army. The Germans managed to cut off French retreat and destroy large parts of the army. Eventuallt the french managed to retreat inflicting large casualties on the germans in return, the battle is seen as a success.
    In Mons the battle was usuccessful for the British, although sustaining 2000 casualties, the Germans did lose 5500 men.
    (Same as the entry in the Belgian section)
    ------
    ------
    (Sorry if the battles are inaccurate, i couldnt make sense of half the stuff i read. Mostly i (with few exceptions) i just changed casualty numbers. It should still be different enough to set the stage. Thanks for reading and please critique)
     
    Chapter 2.5 - The First Battles of Marne and Ypres - The Race to the Sea - 1914
  • The First Battle of Marne - 5th-16th of September 1914
    After the great retreat of the French army following the battle of Cambrai, the Germans managed to come close to the french border. This led to the First Battle of Marne in 1914
    The fighting was intense in the battle of Marne. The French exploited a gap in the german first and second armies to drive them back, while succesfull at first the Germans pushed back the allied counteroffensive. From there the allied saw much success at driving back the German forces. The second attempt at exploiting another gap that formed came on 12th of September, which is when the Germans were forced to retreat and dig trenches. Some saw this as the war being lost.
    Throughout 12th-16th of September the German and French attempted to break lines even more, yet failed.
    Afterwards the Trench Warfare of the First World War

    The First Battle of Ypres - 19th of October-22nd of November 1914
    Battle of Langemark:In the battle of Langemark the germans managed to win against the combined forces of France and the BEF. Tehy captured Ypres.
    Battle of Gheluvelt: The Battle of Gheluvelt was inconclusive.
    Battle of Nonne Bosschen: The germans managed to inflict good casualties against their enemies and won.

    The Race to the Sea - 17th September - 19th October
    The race to the sea was a series of battles on the western front of ww1. It set the stage for the rest of the war, and ended in a somewhat German sidedvictory.

    (I dont blame people for not caring because of the cliched nature of this TL, please critique.)
     
    Chapter 3 - The Eastern Front - 1914
  • The War in the East
    In the east Russia, Germany and her ally Austria-Hungary battled for dominance in the region.

    The Invasion of East Prussia - 17th of August-14th of September 1914
    Battle of Stallupönen - 17th of August 1914 - Beginning of the war in the East
    Though a relatively minor battle in the Eastern Front, it did begin the War. Ending up a minor victory for Russian forces, it was dismissed by the Germans as but a minor setback.
    Battle of Gumbinnen - 20th of August 1914
    The battle of Gumbinnen was the second battle of the Eastern Front. In the morning a German infantry division approached the Russian division. The cavalry led by Huseyn Khan Nakhchivanski was able to aid the Russian forces, securing victory in the battle. The Russian casualties were left at around 16 000, while the Germans took around 20 000 casualties.
    The loss forced the German army to consider retreat toward the vistula river, and leaving some men to hold the Prussian capital Königsberg. Although the Russians had bad supply it steadily improved overtime, the campaign would still have its challenges.

    The Battle of Tannenberg - 26th-30th of August 1914
    The battle of tannenberg was a loss for the Russians, although the Germans did not achieve their coal of encircling and destroying the Russian second army. The battle began on the 27th of August, and proved to be a formidable loss to the Russian campaign. While the battle was still considered a near major victory for the Germans, the Russian1st and 2nd armies managed to retreat, while only taking 50 000 casualties. Compared to the Germans 25 000 casualties. The Russians retreated, but they didnt leave East Prussiaquite yet.
    First battle of the Masurian Lakes - 7th-14th of September 1914
    The German offensive continued onto the Masurian Lakes, where it would be halted. The Russian 1st, 2nd and 10th armies were up against the German 8th army, who would rely on the chance of reinforcements and better equipment. The Germans managed to inflict massive casualties against the Russians, up to 60 000 according to Russian estimates. The Russians managed to sustain morale and inflict upwards of 19 000 causalties against germany and capture a few thousand. The battle was considered a minor victory by Russian command while German command considered it a major loss. It managed to stop the German offensive against the Russians for a while.

    Due to the relative stalemate at the Eastern Front Germany didnt follow through on pland to invade Warsaw, holding them off for until later.
    The Battle of Galicia - 23rd of August-11th of September
    Battle of Krasnik - 23rd-25th of August 1914 - Beginning of war in Galicia
    The Battle of Krasnik was a Austro-Hungarian victory. The Russians took around 23 000 Casualties, while the Austro-Hungarians took 16 000. Afterward the Russian army returned to positions and held.
    Battle of Komarow - 26th of August-2nd of September 1914
    The Battle of Komarow was a minor Austro-Hungarian victory, while loosing merely 3 000 of their 200 000 men, they managed to capture 21 000 Russian POWs. This success wouldn't be remade until later.
    Battle of Gnila Lipa - 26th-30th of August 1914
    The first success for the Russians during the battle of Galicia was in Gnila Lipa. While sustaining only light casualties, around 1 000-2 000 men estimated, they managed to inflict around 30 000 casualties on the Austro-Hungarian force.
    The Russian 8th army also advanced to Bukovina around this time.
    Battle of Rawa - 3rd-11th of September 1914
    The Battle of Rawa is considered a major success for the Russian military. Sustaining 40 000-50 000 casualties the Russians inflicted at least 55 000 casualties and took 80 000 for prisoners. Afterwards the Austrian army under Auffenberg retreated to the River San, instead of the Biala River. This abandoned the Przemyzl fortress to Russian siege.

    In total the Russian offensive into Galicia was very much succesfull, and a failure for the Austro-Hungarians.

    Siege of Przemyzl - 16th September 1914-22nd March 1915
    First Siege:
    The first siege of Przemyzl was an Austro-hungarina victory. Russians lost 30 000 men across four days and gained nothing in return.
    Second Siege: The second siege ended up as an Austro-Hungarian loss. Despite some German help against Russians the fortress fell.


    Notable to mention the Carpathian Front which was fought between 1914 and 1915.

    (Thanks for reading, please critique, You know the drill)
    (Note: Im not sure if anything wouldve gone this way, and its not that realistic at all. I removed the Battles of Vistula and Lodz because i determined that they happened due to a German Assault which did not happen in This tl.)
     
    Chapter IV - The Balkan Front - 1914
  • The War in The Balkans
    The War in the Balkans in 1914 consisted of the Serbian Front.

    The Serbian Campaign - 28th July 1914-19th October 1915
    The Serbian Campaign in 1914
    -Battle of Cer - 15th-24th August 1914

    The battle of Cer was a major Serbian success in WW1. Throughout the battle the Serbians sustained relatively few casualties while inflicting 50 000-60 000 casualties.
    -Battle of Drina - 7th-24th September 1914
    Unlike the Battle of Cer the batlle of Drina was inconclusive. A total of 30 000-40 000 casualties on both sides were inflicted, and the austro-Hugarian advance was halted.
    Battle of Kolubara - 16th November-15th December 1914
    The Battle of Kolubara was another victory for Serbia. Casualties inflicted were ~100 000 on the Serbian side and ~200 000 for the Austro-Hungarins

    (Balkans in 1914 doesnt have much, really short)
     
    Chapter V - The Middle Eastern Front - 1914
  • Prelude
    On August 2nd the Ottoman Empire and the German Empire signed a secret Ottoman-German Alliance. This was followed by a treaty with Bulgaria in 1915. The Ottomans also developed two major plans of attack, one of which created by von Schellendorf, which was seen as more German oriented. This was opposed by the plan of Hafiz Hakki Pasha, who created a plan focusing more on Russia rather than the German plan which was seen to not take ottoman conditions into account. Hafiz Hakki Pasha's plan was shelved because of resources. Schellendorfs plan was thus the primary. As result of the Schellendorf plan being selected as the primary many battles were fought on Ottoman soil.

    November
    In November the Middle Eastern theatre began. After two german warships were tranferred to the Ottoman navy, and shelled the port of Odessa Russia declared war upon the Ottoman Empire. On the 3rd the first British attack against the Ottomans happened as the Britinh Navy attacked the port of Dardenelles. Soon afterwards Britain and France declared war against the Ottoman Empire, and on the 11th the Ottomans drafteed declaration of Jihad, which was publicized on the 14th.
    First Lord Admilarty Winston Churchill proposed a naval atack on the Ottoman capital, ordering ships to be ready by February 1916.
    Simultaneously the Ottoman 4th army was preparing a force of 20 000 to capture the Suez Canal, teh supplies and such for the crossinf of the desert being organized by Bavarian Colonel Kress von Kressenstein.

    The Caucasus reached its first armed conflict with the Begmann Offensive, in which the 9th-11th and 13th corps of the Ottoman 3rd army fought against the invading Russian force. Alongside them the Fortress of Erzurum had 32 000 men. The Russians crossed the border on the 1st and began the advance toward Erzurum. 3rd army commander Hasan izzet Pasha assumed that the Russian force was superior in forces, thus ordering the 9th corps to retreat to Erzurum. He also sent the 2nd Cavalry Division, 1300 strong to enact reconnaisance against the Russians. The cavalry divison fought a victorious battle in Köpruköy village on the 4th. Enver pasha adviced Hasan Izzet Pasha to crush seperately moving Russian forces. Hasan Izzet Pasha followed these instructions though with caution. The plan Hasan Izzet had was to rout the Vanguard and then retreat back to Erzurum. The 7th was a foggy day. three divisions of the 9th Corp moved to Hassankale, the Russian forces were supposed to be east of Köpruköy, but truly they had moved toward Badicivan, 10 kilometers north of Köpruköy. A regiment of the 9th corp came under heavy fire from the Russians and retreated to Hassankale, where the 9th Corp regrouped and were sent back to the Russians. On the first day of the attack the Ottoman troops made little to no success, but on the second day they managed to rout the Russian forces. German Lieutenant Colonel Felix Guse told Hasan izzett that a retreat would be benefiucial after a succesfull battle, for if the Russians return with a grater force a defeat was possible. Thus Hasan izzet ordered a retreat decree to the troops, which although protested by some ultimately passed. The retreat to Erzurum led to no further casualties and only light fighting against advancing Russian troops, which were mostly victorious. This meant that the Russian advance became halted, allowing the Ottomans to launch a counterattack in more favourable conditions.

    On 8th of November Ottoman high command insisted that Hasan izzet make a counter offensive against the russians so that they could later begin to advance into Tiblisi, inviting an Caucasus Muslim revolt. The Ottoman 9th corp reinforced by the 9th corp on the left flank began the counteroffensive to push back the Russians. Due to retreating to Erzum earlier the Ottomans had proper winter clothes to use during the offensive, preventing many casualties from Hypothermia. The Russians were successful along the southern shoulder, where Armenian volunteers took Karaköze and Dogubeyazit. By the end the Russians held a good 20 kilometers into Ottoman territory.

    A British naval force bombarded the fort at Fao. The IEF (Indian Expeditionary Force) cosisting of the 6th Division landed in Fao. The landing was opposed by a mere 350 Ottoman troops and a few cannons. Later on the 22nd the British occupied the city of Basra against a group of 3 000 arabian recruits. In the result 1 200 men and Safi Pasha were captured. From there the allied offensive into Mesopotamia would begin.

    December
    The Battle of Sarikamish began on the 22nd. It was an attempt by the now better equipped Ottoman forces to capture the area for an advance toward Tibilisi. In it the 3rd Army battled with the Russian Caucasus Army. Due to the better clothing the Ottomans had they lost fewer men to cold conditions. The battle itself took place across some 1300 kilometers between the Black Sea and Lake Van. This made troop concentration difficult. The 10th corp made a manouver being victorious in smaller battles along the frontline. This led to General Istomin withdrawing his troops. Overall the initial phase of the battle was more or less in the Ottomans favour.
    From the 25th until the 26th the Ottomans were caught in a snowstorm. This led to the halt of the Ottoman troops. Many soldiers froze to death.
    Afterward the battle got more intense. The Russians began a steady victory against Ottoman forces, leading to the eventual defeat of Ottoman forces on January 4th 1915. This led to a total Ottoman retreat from which a small portion of the original army managed to come back.

    Overall
    Overall the Caucasian offensive ended up in a stalemate between Russian and Ottoman troops, with the Russians on a slight edge after the battle of Sarikamish.
    In Mesopotamia the IEF and British forces remain largely unattended, leading to a quick advance in 1915.

    (Thanks to AustrianFanboy i managed to at least make the descriptions a bit cleaner, i think? I did read a good part of the Marne without Moltke 2.0 TL and tried to take lessons from it but still somehow managed to make it about Battles rather thank the actual front. Hopefullt ill make a better thing with the next post. I fell into the trap of making a detailed-ish account of a battle, while completely ignoring a cohesive frontlin again. I wonder how i manage to be so bad at this lol.

    However i feel like this was at least and improvement over the last few posts, but didnt do much. Ill only learn by doing anyway, and a huge part of that is critique. And if anyones willing could you please explain how i can maintain the feeling of a proper and cohesive frontline. I have no idea and would appreciate it.

    Anyway thanks a lot for reading and please critique this mess of a TL)
     
    Last edited:
    Chapter VI - Asian Front - 1914
  • Tsingtao
    The Imperial Japanese and Royal Navies sent multiple ships to blockade the port of Kiaochow. Accompanying the Japanese ships was the 18th Infantry Division, consisting of 25 000 men and ~140 artillery pieces. The 18th Infantry began landing at Lungkow on September 2nd. Later they would also land at Lau Schan. China protested this as breaking her neutrality. 1500 british soldiers were sent as well.
    An Japanese assault on the garrison began and ended on November 6th as the Germans surrendered.
    Occupation of German Samoa and Papua New Guinea by New Zealand and Australia
    A rather quick invasion of both were carried, with the few battles fought ending in an allied victory.
    ------------
    (to my knowledge theres no more land battles in Asia, ill cover that in the naval one, i think? once i get to 1915 ill reform the format even mure)
     
    Top