Hi everyone, I heard that's people want to see an American king soon, and of course, I respond to such desires with an update on elections in Massachusetts. Makes sense, right? Also, I am slowly editing earlier posts (only got two so far) for grammar/legibility. I don't know how I was so illiterate before, or how y'all put up with it. Thanks for sticking it out so far, I'm going to work on my illiteracy.
“The difference between a democracy and a dictatorship is that in a democracy you vote first and take orders later; in a dictatorship you don't have to waste your time voting.”
--Charles Bukowski
Following the announcement that the former legislature of the F.R.R. of Massachusetts were to be tried for treason, a number of voices began to speak out against Bowdoin. While there were few protests (unsurprising considering Massachusetts had a number of New York soldiers keeping the peace), the public outcry was great enough that Bowdoin agreed to postpone the trials until August. This extra time would allow for a more thorough combing of documents from the former Regulator government, as well as time for the former members of the legislature to find lawyers. Finding lawyers for the Regulators would prove to be difficult for the former legislature, as many of the lawyers in Boston and Massachusetts as a whole were upper class and resented the Regulators. Luckily for the legislature’s members, Roger Sherman volunteered to defend them without any payment despite his presence at the Constitutional Convention.
As June turned to July and the papers of the former Regulator government continued to be sifted through, the details of the meeting between the former Regulator Executive Taylor Hammond and Lord St. Helens was discovered. News of the plan for British aid to Massachusetts spread across America to overwhelming outrage. Now, not only were the British encouraging Indian attacks in the West, but they were trying to tear states away from the Union! This fueled anti-English sentiment to new heights, and over the next few months, British traders would suffer attacks by Americans.
As August rolled around, debates about the upcoming trial began to share with debates over the Constitution question. While the Constitution was seen in a positive light in Massachusetts, especially with the provision assigning a number of powers to the states and the rights guaranteed to the people. However, the question of whether or not Massachusetts should support a Republic or a King was highly controversial. Many of the poor and debt holding population were Republican, and many of the more wealthy population wanted a Monarchy to prevent another Hopswood from coming to power.
The debate on the Constitution took a brief backseat on August 16th, as the trial began. For two long, grueling weeks, Roger Sherman defended the legislative Regulators from every attack and criticism in the court in daily sessions. Special newspapers spread the minutes of the trials to crowds of Bostonians, and every day the court was packed with spectators. Five separate lawyers stood for the prosecution. On August 30th, the trial came to an end and the news was announced to an eager crowd surrounding the courthouse. Despite the jury being entirely from Boston’s upper class and the judge being one of Boston’s most conservative, Roger Sherman saved the legislative Regulators.
The people of Massachusetts were stunned, the elite were mortified and Bowdoin was infuriated. What should have been a political victory for Bowdoin that (in his mind) would have cemented his victory in the upcoming election was now a humiliating defeat for his government. Despite this, hope wasn't entirely lost for Bowdoin. The upcoming election turned into a four candidate race between Bowdoin, John Hancock, Daniel Shays and Roger Sherman serving as candidates.
When he returned to Massachusetts, Roger Sherman hadn't intended on running for a political office. However, after his defense of the former Regulators, a number of Massachusettsans from the mercantile and middle class feared that Massachusetts’ government would be seized by populists. Recognizing that Bowdoin was about as likely to win as George III, the bourgeois convinced Sherman to accept being their last minute candidate for governor.
Daniel Shays on the other hand took a direct mandate from the people to run for the governorship. After his release from the Regulator prison, Shays had planned on returning home to a quiet life. Unfortunately for Shays, he attracted tales of heroism, valor and honor and had become incredibly popular with Massachusetts’ lower classes. Reluctantly, Shays accepted the nomination. Shays’ candidacy caused some stir in Massachusetts as Shays had been the leader of a rebellion months prior, and now he was running for office! A common counter argument to such notion was that the other three candidates were rebels against royalist Massachusetts, yet they were running for office in Massachusetts as well.
Similarly to Shays, John Hancock drew much of his support from Massachusetts’ lower class. Unlike Shays, Hancock’s devotion to the people was often doubted during his candidacy due to his wealth (Hancock was worth about 7/10ths of a percent of the USA’s entire economy) and the fact that he had fled Massachusetts when the Regulators took charge. Despite this, Hancock was relatively popular due to his prior governorship of Massachusetts.
James Bowdoin II was of all candidates, the least likely to win. His conservative leadership was unpopular with a restless state that had recently tried their hardest to overthrow him. Despite this, he did see almost universal support from the upper classes of Massachusetts, and his relaxing of some harsher measures did give Bowdoin a small chance to win.
The election went surprisingly well for a state that had just suffered two governments being overthrown within a year prior. No incidents of political violence were recorded as the election proceeded. On September 28th, the election results finally were compiled, and the fate of Massachusetts wavered in the balance, and the margin of victory was dreadfully slim. By two votes, Daniel Shays had beat Roger Sherman and became governor of Massachusetts on October 3rd. With the Constitutional question still hanging in the air, and the crisis of debt for poor farmers not having been resolved, Governor Shays faced a difficult governorship. But, Clark Hopswood was gone so how bad could it truly be?