Chapter One Hundred and Sixty
A New Beginning
Part I
A New Beginning
Part I
From “The Radicals 1860-1872” by Hugh W. McGrath
New England Press 2001
“Privately Senator Wade made it clear that when he looked at his potential rivals for the Republican nomination, Chase, Hamlin, Holt or Butler he had no doubt that he could beat them all. For Wade there was only one fear – that the party would turn to a war hero and there was one hero above all, Philip Kearny Jr, who could, with a single word, crush his chances of the presidency…”
From “Philip Kearny – The Myth and The Man” by Dr. P. Capaldi
University of Illinois Press 2003
“As both an emissary for himself and on behalf of others, it was Dan Sickles who approached his friend about his political ambitions. Writing to Kearny while he was away in Europe, Sickles asked whether, if offered, Kearny would accept the Republican nomination for President.
“The Republican Party of Wade and his cabal is still a sectional party and I will not stand as a candidate for one part of our country against another…” replied Kearny. Sickles next letter was “pure Dan” (Kearny).
“Would you view an offer of the Democratic nomination any more favorably?” Kearny’s answer remained the same…
The question remains whether Kearny intended or expected Sickles to disseminate this information as widely as he did. The fact remains that in short order Sickles had informed his intimates in both parties and breathed life into a multitude of presidential hopefuls…”
From “The Rivals – Lincoln and his Cabinet” by Amelia Doggett
Grosvenor 2008
“Months before the scheduled Republican convention in Chicago the names of the likely contenders were on every lip: Benjamin Wade, Salmon P. Chase, Joseph Holt, Benjamin Butler, David Davis and Hannibal Hamlin. First Phil Kearny and then John F. Reynolds had rejected any approach from party operatives who were less than impressed by the likely candidates. Joseph Hooker flirted with the idea of candidacy but he was also being tempted with office in Massachusetts…
“Wade represents the wrath of God on earth; Spoons Butler all seven deadly sins; Hamlin killers who abhor killing; Holt the lovers of dull competency; Chase represents anyone who’ll let him; and Davis those too cowardly to choose another…” was William Seward’s scathing view…”
Senator Benjamin Wade of Ohio, Former Secretary of the Treasury Salmon P. Chase of Ohio, Vice President Joseph Holt of Kentucky, Congressman Benjamin Butler of Massachusetts, Chief Justice David Davis of Illinois, and Former Vice President Hannibal Hamlin of Maine
From “Chasing the White House – Salmon P. Chase and his Campaign to be President” by Albert Niven
Grosvenor 2001
“It was agonizing for Chase. The Democratic convention was to be held in Tammany Hall, New York well before the Republican convention. It was obvious that the Republicans were infinitely better placed to win the election but the Democrats were so desperate for a viable candidate that they would consider a willing former Republican. Their desperation was matched only by Chase’s own to be President. Chase’s great fear however was that, with his fellow Ohioan Benjamin Wade in the race, he could not guarantee the support of his own state. He had many willing supporters as the result of his former patronage as Secretary of Treasury but he knew that support was ephemeral. It would harden if he could show the support of the Ohio delegation but it would vanish like mist if Wade gained momentum…
Chase was not above swapping horses in mid-stream if the Democrats would offer him the nomination but he wanted to fight for the Republican nomination first. The timing of the Democrat’s Convention denied him that opportunity and no amount of scheming on his part could have it delayed. Thus, did Chase finally commit to a Republican candidacy and he approached the one Ohioan whose support might provide critical, General Jacob Dolson Cox, Director of the Bureau of Collectors…”
From “A True Deputy – The Vice Presidency of Joseph Holt” by Justice McClintock
Grosvenor 2004
“Those who thought Reconstruction perfected in its current form feared the consequences of a Wade presidency and did not see much attraction in the alternatives. “Ben Wade will drive every white southerner with a pistol or a musket to become a bushwhacker and Butler will have us at war with England in a week. We need a sound man more in the mould of Lincoln…” (Governor James Wadsworth of New York)…
It was felt that Holt, as Lincoln’s Vice President, could command the loyalty of the newly enfranchised black voters of the South; as a Kentuckian the border states; and as a man who had served under Buchanan and Lincoln he could encourage the less radical elements of the party…
Although initially reluctant a meeting with Governor Bull Nelson and Senator Rousseau of Kentucky in which they pledged the support of his home delegation convinced Holt that it was his duty to allow his name to go forward…”
From “Tammany Ablaze – Democratic Politics from 1864-1900” by Otis R. Mayhew
Buffalo 2003
“The Democrats were desperate to avoid the chaos of the Columbus Convention of 1864, though it had been some time prior since a Democratic convention had not resulted in chaos, and yet once again there was no clear candidate…
The Democrats were keen to leave their ‘Copperhead’ label behind and thus looked first for a unifying war hero. Kearny’s refusal was mere proforma as few Democrats dreamed that miracle would come to pass but they did seek out other politician-generals who might take up the baton...
The most obvious candidate in blue was General Winfield Scott Hancock who was known to have voiced opposition to the scope of Reconstruction and his gentle hand in North Carolina had left a lasting impression. His absence in the depths of Abyssinia and the uncertain outcome of that campaign meant they dare not risk his nomination. It was a matter of question in any event if such a committed soldier would accept a nomination while on active service…
Lew Wallace’s name was circulated and it was obvious he was interested but even he doubted he could muster the support to win outright in an early Convention ballot and instead looked to his native Indiana for advancement…
In the absence of a committed Democrat in uniform the old names from the 1864 Convention bubbled back to the surface: Horatio Seymour, Lazarus Powell, George Pendleton, Thomas A. Hendricks and even Andrew Johnson. Added to these were favorite sons such as James E. English of Connecticut and Joel Parker of New Jersey…
That is not to say many actively sought the nomination. Most senior Democrats understood that their nominee would be a sacrificial lamb in the name of keeping the party alive on the national level…
Horatio Seymour quashed any suggestion he might accept the nomination to run again. One humiliation was enough. Having already turned down nomination once in 1864 and been selected anyway he announced his intentions clearly “If nominated again I will announce my intentions to vote the Republican straight ticket for the rest of my days”…
Fernando Wood’s view was that the party needed someone who thought they deserved to win; believed they had even the faintest chance of winning; who would not humiliate the Party in running; but whom the party could afford to see humiliated by the result. Wood’s conclusion was clear – George Hunt Pendleton of Ohio. A committed Democrat who, however much he had been a Copperhead, was pragmatic enough now to moderate his tone against all but the worst excesses of Reconstruction; who had a big enough name in the country; and who, Wood understood, was unlikely to win re-election to Congress from his Ohio district in any event. What is more Pendleton’s name had risen to the top twice during the endless balloting of the 64 Convention…
With the Ohio, New York and New Jersey delegations leading the way it only took four ballots to propel Pendleton to the nomination. One anonymous wit in the Democratic Party was quoted in the New York Tribune as saying “if he wins Pendleton is fool enough to do no harm and if he loses he’s fool enough to be no loss”…
The real controversy started on the nomination for the vice-president. Having put a former Copperhead at the top of the ticket many thought it necessary to lure back the War Democrats with a more moderate name at the bottom of the ticket. The old men of the Democratic party in their smoke filled backrooms decided upon Governor James E. English of Connecticut. English had actually voted with the Republicans more often that not while part of the 38th Congress on all the key legislation, opposing only the Confiscation Act…
It took six rather stormy ballots to force through English with both Wood and Joel Parker having to disavow their home states delegations' attempts to have them nominated instead of English. Neither of them intended to play second fiddle to Pendleton on a losing ticket…
Pendleton was furious when he found out his running mate was English. They had not spoken since the stormy scenes in the 38th Congress when English had led a handful of Democrats to join the War Democrats and Republicans in passing key legislation. Indeed, it was well that the candidates adhered to the convention that they should not actively travel and campaign for no evidence has been found that the two men either spoke or corresponded directly at any time between the end of the 38th Congress and the death of James English in 1889…”
George Hunt Pendleton of Ohio and James Edward English of Connecticut
From “The Rivals – Lincoln and his Cabinet” by Amelia Doggett
Grosvenor 2008
“In the run up to the Republican convention in Chicago Republican backed newspapers began their campaigns in support of their anointed candidates. Men like Wade, Chase and particularly Butler and their adherents would stoop far to smear their opponents with accusations of every species of corruption, moral turpitude and, in Butler’s case, every sin listed in the bible and some entirely of his own invention…
President Lincoln wrote many letters to the potential candidates, their supporters and newspaper editors asking them to conduct a respectful campaign. “Never before have I engaged in so much spitting into the wind…and just like Canute my feet are getting wet.” With the exception of Joseph Holt, Lincoln did not have a high opinion of any of his potential successors…”
From “The 100 Greatest Movie Quotes of All Time” by George Gregory and Amy Li
Morrison Bros. 2011
With One Hand Behind My Back 1949 – Marlborough Pictures
Marcus Graves as Robert Todd Lincoln: “It can't end this way. It mustn't. Father isn’t time you picked the successor you want? The successor the country needs?”
James J. Bierce as President Lincoln in "With One Hand Behind My Back"
From “The Radicals 1860-1872” by Hugh W. McGrath
New England Press 2001
“The National Union Party’s convention at the Academy of Music in Philadelphia was supposed to mark the end of the party. It was supposed to be adjourned with a pledge to endorse the candidate chosen at the Republican Party Convention in 10 days’ time. A 25 year old delegate from the District of Columbia would ensure it was anything but…”