azadi

Banned
You are completely missing politically and militarily important regions of the Cossack Armies of Don and Kuban: there were plenty of the landless workers (or renters) in these areas but the land-owners had been formally the smallholders or rather communal landholders.

The problem with the rest is that outside Siberia the non-estate landowners were to a great degree communal rather than individual persons.

An idea of the nationalization of the foreign companies is interesting but it would make Britain, France and, IIRC, US as well very unhappy. BTW, how about the companies which are publicly-held and do not belong to a single owner?

What do you mean with "the companies which are publicly-held and do not belong to a single owner?" Is it companies in Russia owned by foreign states or is it shares in Russian companies held by foreigners not resident in Russia?

Azadi
 

azadi

Banned
Tsar Nikolay lives in Livadia Palace in Crimea as a retired Tsar and is paid a generous pension from the state. Aleksey will probably soon die from hemophilia. For Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia I'm not certain about their future. But as of November 3 1918 (November 16 1918) Nikolay, Aleksandra, Tatiana, Maria, Anastasia and Aleksey all lives in Livadia Palace.

Azadi
 
What do you mean with "the companies which are publicly-held and do not belong to a single owner?" Is it companies in Russia owned by foreign states or is it shares in Russian companies held by foreigners not resident in Russia?

Azadi

Simple question: who is an owner of General Electric?

In the pre-revolutionary Russia there were numerous foreign (by the location of headquarters and majority of a capital) publicly-held companies in which Russians could be shareholders.
 

azadi

Banned
Of course companies can be owned by multiple shareholders. If the majority of the shares of a company in Russia were owned by foreigners not resident in Russia, but some shares were owned by Russians or by foreigners resident in Russia, the shares of the foreigners not resident in Russia would be nationalized without compensation and the shares owned by Russians or by foreigners resident in Russia would remain privately owned or would be nationalized with compensation. But what do you mean by publicly-held companies? I associate "publicly-held companies" with state-owned or municipally owned companies, but I'm not sure that this is what you mean by "publicly-held companies".

Azadi
 

azadi

Banned
I have made a change concerning Mongolia and Tuva in Chapter 4 and a change concerning Nestor Lakoba, the OTL leader of Abkhazia from 1921-1936, in Chapter 1.

Azadi
 
Last edited:

azadi

Banned
Chapter 8: The Versailles Treaty:

After the proclamation of Germany as a republic continued revolutionary socialist unrest in Germany. The Spartakusbund, a revolutionary socialist movement in Germany led by Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxembourg, led the revolutionary socialist unrest in Germany. But the Freikorps, right-wing paramilitary units in Germany, repressed the Spartakusbund. On January 2 1919 (January 15 1919) were Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxembourg killed by a Freikorps.


On January 6 1919 (January 19 1919) were an election of the Constituent National Assembly of Germany held. SPD (Social Democratic Party) got 37,8 % of the votes, USPD (Independent Social Democratic Party), a socialist party to the left of SPD) got 7,6 % of the votes, Zentrum, a Catholic non-socialist party, got 19,6 % of the votes, the DDP (German Democratic Party), a social liberal party got 18,5 % of the votes, the DNVP (German National People’s Party), a national conservative party, got 10,2 % of the votes and the DVP (German People’s Party), a national liberal party, got 4,4 % of the votes. The Spartakusbund boycotted the election. After the election, a coalition government consisting of SPD, DDP and Zentrum was formed. Friedrich Ebert was elected President of Germany on January 29 1919 (February 11 1919) and Philipp Scheidemann (SPD) was elected Chancellor of Germany on January 31 1919 (February 13 1919).


On June 15 1919 (June 28 1919) concluded Germany and its enemies in the Great War the Versail-les Treaty. The Versailles Treaty decided, that Germany should give back Alsace-Lorraine (Elsass-Lothringen) to France, that Germany should cede its majority Polish-populated regions to Poland, that Germany should cede the Klaipeda region (Memelgebiet) to Lithuania, that Belgium should cede Eupen, Sankt Vith and Malmedy to Belgium and that North Schleswig (the part of Schleswig north of a line south of Tønder (Tondern) and north of Flensburg (Flensborg)) should decide in a referendum between returning to Denmark and remaining part of Germany. In addition, Germany should cede all its overseas colonies, pay large reparations to its enemies in the Great War, reduce the size of its armed forces signifycantly and demilitarize the Rheinland. The Saarland should be placed under the League of Nations until 1935, when Saarland would return to Germany if a majority of its inhabitants vote for it in a referendum. Danzig (Gdansk) should be a free city under the League of Nations indefinitely. Among the ceded territories of Germany, Eupen and Sankt Vith were majority German-populated, Alsace were German-speaking but of French national sentiment, Lorraine were French-speaking, Malmedy were French-speaking and Klaipeda region had a narrow Lithuanian majority but a German minority of above 40 % of the population. Saarland and Danzig had large German majorities.


On August 28 1919 (September 10 1919) concluded Austria and its enemies in the Great War the Treaty of St.Germain-en-Laye. The Treaty of St.Germain-en-Laye decided, that Austria should cede majority Italian Trentino and majority German-Speaking South Tyrol to Italy and that Czechia would keep its historic borders, which included large areas with German-speaking majorities. The Treaty of St.Germain-en-Laye prohibited Austria from uniting with Germany without the consent of the League of Nations.


On July 29 1919 (August 11 1919) enacted Germany the Weimar Constitution. The Weimar Consti-tution made Germany a republic with a president elected directly by the people for a 7-year term. The President of Germany could be reelected indefinitely. The President of Germany would be elected by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women, and both men and women could be elected President of Germany. The President of Germany should represent Germany in foreign states, should conclude treaties with foreign states with the consent of the Reichstag, should appoint and dismiss the Chancellor of Germany, should be the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of Germany, could pardon criminals and would gain special powers during an emergency in order to keep the German state functioning.

The Chancellor of Germany could be deposed by the Reichstag with a vote of no confidence.


The Reichstag would be elected by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women, and both men and women could be elected member of the Reichstag. The Reichstag would be elected for a 4-year term and the members of the Reichstag could be reelected indefinitely.


The Weimar Constitution made Germany a federation composed of Länder with significant autonomy.

The Weimar Constitution abolished all privileges of nobility in Germany, but recognized titles of nobility as part of the legal name.


The Weimar Constitution separated state and church in Germany, but decided, that the state should still raise taxes for the Catholic and Protestant churches of Germany.

On January 28 1919 (February 10 1919) voted 74,9 % of the population of North Schleswig for Denmark and 25,1 % of the population of North Schleswig for Germany. Afterwards North Schleswig was reunified with Denmark.
 
Last edited:

azadi

Banned
Chapter 9: The Turkish War of Independence:

On July 28 1920 (August 10 1920) concluded Turkey the Sevres Treaty with Great Britain, France, Italy and Greece. Turkey should cede Israel, Jordan and Iraq to Great Britain, Syria and Lebanon to France and grant Hejaz (western Saudi Arabia) and North Yemen independence. Turkey should cede Izmir and its hinterland and Eastern Thrace to Greece. Turkey should grant independence to the Hellenic Republic of Pontos in the eastern part of Turkey’s Black Sea coast. Istanbul and the Turkish Straits should be placed under international control. Southwestern Turkey should become an Italian sphere of influence and southeastern Turkey should become a French zone of influence, but southwestern Turkey and southeastern Turkey should remain under Turkish sovereignty. But the Turkish National Movement, led by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk and the Grand National Assembly of Turkey, which was established on April 10 1920 (April 23 1920) rejected the Sevres treaty.


On August 30 1920 (September 12 1920) invaded Atatürk’s army the Republic of Pontos. The Republic of Pontos collapsed quickly, and on September 16 1920 (September 29 1920) entered Atatürk’s army Trabzon, the capital of the Republic of Pontos. The government of the Republic of Pontos fled into exile in Greece.


Italy quickly abandoned its plans for establishing an Italian sphere of influence in southwestern Turkey.

France was faced with strong Turkish armed resistance in Cilicia, and after Atatürk’s army had inflicted numerous defeats on France in Cilicia concluded France and Atatürk’s government a peace agreement in Ankara on October 7 1921 (October 20 1921). France returned Cilicia to Turkey and abandoned its zone of influence in southeastern Turkey, but the Turkish-populated Hatay region became part of French Syria. Russia supplied Atatürk’s army with weapons in exchange for Atatürk recognizing all of formerly Turkish-ruled Kurdistan as Russian territory. Atatürk renounced willingly Turkish claims on Kurdistan, because Atatürk wanted to found a Turkish nation state centered in Anatolia.

On August 27 1922 (September 9 1922) entered Atatürk’s army Izmir. Most of the Greek population of Izmir fled from Izmir.

On October 19 1922 (November 1 1922) abolished the Grand National Assembly of Turkey the Ottoman sultanate.

On July 11 1923 (July 24 1923) concluded Turkey the Lausanne Treaty with Greece, Italy, France and Great Britain. The Lausanne Treaty abolished the planned Italian and French zones of influence in Turkey, returned Izmir and its hinterland to Turkey, returned East Thrace to Turkey and returned Istanbul and the Turkish straits to Turkey. Turkey ceded Israel to Great Britain and Syria (including Hatay) and Lebanon to France. Iraq and Jordan became independent kingdoms under British protection. Turkey ceded Cyprus to Great Britain and the Dodecanese Islands to Italy. Cyprus had been under British control since 1878 and the Dodecanese Islands had been under Italian control since 1912. The Greek population of Turkey were expelled to Greece except for the Greeks of Istanbul and the majority Greek-populated islands Imroz (Imvros, Gökceada) and Bozcaada (Tenedos). The Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople were allowed to remain in Istanbul. The Turkish population of Greece were expelled to Turkey except for the Turks of Western Thrace. 1,5 million Greeks were expelled from Turkey to Greece and 500000 Turks were expelled from Greece to Turkey.

On October 16 1923 (October 29 1923) were Turkey proclaimed a republic. Atatürk became President of Turkey.

On February 19 1924 (March 3 1924) was the Ottoman caliphate abolished.
 

azadi

Banned
I have made changes to Chapter 6 concerning the border between Kurdistan and Armenia and I have made changes to Chapter 5 concerning the territorial extent of Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Azadi
 

azadi

Banned
Chapter 10: The Treaty of Trianon:

On March 29 1919 (April 11 1919) were an election of the Constituent Orszaggyüles (National Assembly) of Hungary held. The Social Democratic Party of Hungary got 44,7 % of the votes, the National Independence Agrarian Party (a centrist peasant’s party) of 48 got 25,5 % of the votes, the Civic Radical Party (a social liberal party) got 8,2 % of the votes, the Party of Independence and 48 (a national liberal party) got 11,1 % of the votes and the National Union Party (a national conservative party) got 8,1 % of the votes. After the election, a coalition government consisting of the Social Democratic Party of Hungary, the National Independence Agrarian Party of 48 and the Civic Radical Party was formed. Ernö Garami, who belonged to the right-wing of the Social Democratic Party of Hungary became Minister-President of Hungary and Istvan Szabo de Nagyatad, the leader of the National Independence Agrarian Party of 48, became Minister of Agriculture of Hungary. Mihaly Karolyi was reelected President of Hungary by the Constituent Orszaggyüles of Hungary, but before his reelection stripped the Constituent Orszaggyüles the President of Hungary of most of his (or her) powers.


On May 22 1919 (June 4 1919) concluded Hungary and the victorious Allies of the Great War the Treaty of Trianon. The Treaty of Trianon decided that a line from Maramarossziget (Sighetul Mamatiei) to Zilach (Zalau) to Csucsa (Ciucea) to Zam would be the border between Hungary and Romania, that Hungary would cede Slovakia to Czechoslovakia, that Hungary would cede Vojvodina and Croatia-Slavonia to Yugoslavia and that Hungary would cede Burgenland to Austria. Sopron and its surroundings should decide between remaining Hungarian territory or becoming Austrian territory in a referendum. Among the lost territories were a majority Hungarian-populated strip in Slovakia adjacent to the border with Hungary, a majority Hungarian-populated triangle in Vojvodina adjacent to the border with Hungary and the majority Hungarian-populated Szekely Land in eastern Transylvania, which was not adjacent to Hungary. The Treaty of Trianon was signed by Hungary under protest and was met with widespread popular anger in Hungary. Popular slogans against the Treaty of Trianon in Hungary were “Nem, nem, soha!” (“No, no, never!”) and “Mindent vissza!” (“Return everything!” or “Everything back!”). In Sopron and its surroundings, 65 % of the population voted for Hungary.

On October 18 1919 (October 31 1919), the 1-year anniversary of the independence of Hungary, enacted Hungary a new constitution. The new constitution made Hungary a republic with a president elected directly by the people for a 7-year term. The President of Hungary could be reelected indefinitely. The President of Hungary would be elected by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women and both men and women could be elected President of Hungary. The President of Hungary would have very limited powers and would primarily have ceremonial and representative functions.

The Minister-President of Hungary could be deposed by the Orszaggyüles of Hungary with a vote of no confidence.

The Orszaggyüles of Hungary would be unicameral and would be elected by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women. Both men and women could be elected member of the Orszaggyüles of Hungary. The Orszaggyüles of Hungary would be elected for a 4-year term, and the members of the Orszaggyüles could be reelected indefinitely.


The new constitution of Hungary prohibited all privileges of nobility, but titles of nobility would still be recognized as part of the legal name in Hungary.


The new constitution of Hungary separated state and church.

The Constituent Orszaggyüles of Hungary had during its term enacted a land reform, which was much less far-reaching than the Great Russian Land Reform. The Hungarian land reform allowed the landlords to keep a large part of their agricultural land. The Hungarian land reform was proposed by Istvan Szabo de Nagyatad, the Minister of Agriculture of Hungary. The Constituent Orszaggyüles of Hungary had during its term nationalized all mining in Hungary and had nationalized water provision, electricity provision, gas provision, telecom and railway transport. The Constituent Orszaggyüles of Hungary had established a state-owned National Bank of Hungary.

On December 29 1919 (January 11 1920) were presidential elections and Orszaggyüles elections held in Hungary. Miklos Horthy, an admiral in the Austrian-Hungarian navy during the Great War and a great Hungarian war hero, were elected President of Hungary. He defeated incumbent President of Hungary Mihaly Karolyi in the Hungarian presidential election on December 29 1919 (January 11 1920). In the Orszaggyüles election on December 29 1919 (January 11 1920) got the Social Democratic Party of Hungary 26,2 % of the votes, the Independent Social Democratic Party of Hungary (a revolutionary socialist splinter party from the Social Democratic Party of Hungary) 13,6 % of the votes, the Civic Radical Party got 5,4 % of the votes, the National Independence Agrarian Party of 48 got 28,3 % of the votes, the Party of Independence and 48 got 15,2 % of the votes and the National Union Party got 10,1 % of the votes. After the Orszaggyüles election on December 29 1919 (January 11 1920) was a coalition government consisting of the National Independence Agrarian Party of 48 and the Party of Independence and 48 formed with the outside support of the National Union Party. Istvan Szabo de Nagyatad became Minister-President of Hungary and Albert Apponyi de Nagyapponyi, the leader of the Party of Independence and 48, became Minister for Foreign Affairs of Hungary.


Shortly after the Orszaggyüles election on December 29 1919 (January 11 1920) merged the National Independence Agrarian Party of 48 and the Party of Independence and 48 into the Republican Party of 48. Istvan Szabo de Nagyatad became Chairman of the Republican Party of 48 and Albert Apponyi de Nagyapponyi became Vice-Chairman of the Republican Party of 48. National liberalism and republicanism were declared the official ideologies of the Republican Party of 48.
 
Last edited:

azadi

Banned
I have made a change to Chapter 5 concerning the title of a female sovereign of Russia. I have decided to call a female sovereign of Russia a Tsaritsa, while a consort of a Tsar will be called a Tsarina. I have done this because the title Tsarina in the western world is associated with the consort of the Tsar, and not much with a female sovereign of Russia. Then I could use the Russian title Tsaritsa for a female sovereign of Russia.

Azadi
 

azadi

Banned
Chapter 11: Aleksandar Stamboliyski’s Bulgarian Revolution:

Bulgaria had been allied to Germany and Austria-Hungary during the Great War. Bulgaria hoped to gain North Macedonia from Serbia during the Great War. At the end of the Great War was the pro-German Tsar Ferdinand of Bulgaria forced to abdicate in favour of his son Boris. Tsar Ferdinand was exiled from Bulgaria and went into exile in Germany. On October 1 1919 (October 14 1919) became Aleksandar Stamboliyski, the leader of the Bulgarian Agrarian National Union, the Minister-President of Bulgaria. The Bulgarian Agrarian National Union was an agrarian socialist party. Aleksandar Stamboliyski had opposed Bulgarian participation in the Great War and was pro-Russian.

On November 14 1919 (November 27 1919) concluded Bulgaria the Treaty of Neuilly-sur-Seine with its enemies during the Great War. Bulgaria must return all areas it conquered during the Great War and from its pre-war territory Bulgaria must cede Western Thrace, in which Bulgarians were the largest ethnic group, to Greece.


The Stamboliyski government redistributed agricultural land and limited the amount of agricultural land a landowner was allowed to own. The Narrow Socialist Party, a revolutionary socialist party in Bulgaria, supported the Stamboliyski government. The Stamboliyski government tried to limit the power of the bourgeoisie in Bulgaria. The Bulgarian Agrarian National Union founded the Orange Guard, a peasant militia supporting the Stamboliyski government.

Stamboliyski was opposed to Bulgarian irredentism and didn’t try to regain North Macedonia from Yugoslavia.

In the election of the Bulgarian Sobranie (parliament) on April 9 1923 (April 22 1923) got the Bulgarian Agrarian National Union 53,8 % of the votes and the Narrow Socialist Party got 19,3 % of the votes.


On May 27 1923 (June 9 1923) occurred a right-wing military coup in Bulgaria. A right-wing government with Aleksandar Tsankov as Minister-President took power in Sofia, the capital of Bulgaria. Tsar Boris supported the coup and named Aleksandar Tsankov Minister-President of Bulgaria. Stamboliyski escaped from Sofia to his home village Slavovitsa. Stamboliyski rallied the Orange Guard against the coup and the Narrow Socialist Party joined Stamboliyski’s resistance against the coup. The Orange Guard and the military organization of the Narrow Socialist Party put up strong armed resistance to the coup, and the Bulgarian army suffered mass desertions to Stamboliyski’s movement. On June 1 1923 (June 14 1923) entered Stamboliyski’s rebel army Sofia. Stamboliyski’s soldiers shot and killed Tsar Boris in his palace and shot and killed Aleksandar Tsankov. Stamboliyski’s soldiers shot princess Evdokiya, the sister of Tsar Boris, who acted as First Lady of Bulgaria, because Tsar Boris was unmarried. Tsar Boris was childless too when he was killed. On June 1 1923 (June 14 1923) declared Stamboliyski Bulgaria a republic with himself as provisional President.


After the defeat of the coup began massive purges of the supporters of the coup. Most leaders of the coup were liquidated by Stamboliyski’s soldiers. Stamboliyski banned all political parties in Bulgaria except for the Bulgarian Agrarian National Union and the Narrow Socialist Party. Most prominent right-wing politicians in Bulgaria were imprisoned or exiled. Prince Kirill, the brother of Tsar Boris, and Nadezhda, the sister of Tsar Boris, were exiled from Bulgaria and went into exile in Germany. The Bulgarian army were dissolved and replaced with the Bulgarian People’s Army, which were composed of members of the Orange Guard, members of the military organization of the Narrow Socialist Party and by officers of the old Bulgarian army, which supported Stamboliyski’s government or were politically neutral. The Bulgarian navy and the Bulgarian air force weren’t merged with the Orange Guard or the military organization of the Narrow Socialist Party, but the Bulgarian navy and the Bulgarian air force were still purged of opponents of Stamboliyski’s government and the vacant positions were filled with supporters of Stamboliyski’s government or politically neutrals. The police, the courts and the civil service were purged of opponents of Stamboliyski’s government and the vacant positions were filled with supporters of Stamboliyski’s government or politically neutrals. All right-wing newspapers in Bulgaria were closed and strict censorship of the press was introduced in Bulgaria.

The Stamboliyski government nationalized after the coup all banks, all industrial companies and all supermarkets in Bulgaria without compensation. The Stamboliyski government supported continued private ownership of agricultural land.


On October 1 1923 (October 14 1923), the 4-year anniversary of Stamboliyski’s ascent to power in Bulgaria, voted 99,9 % of the Bulgarians in a referendum for a new constitution of Bulgaria, which made Bulgaria a presidential republic, where the President of Bulgaria would be both head of state and head of government. The President of Bulgaria was elected for a 4-year term and could be re-elected indefinitely. The President of Bulgaria would be elected by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women. Both men and women could be elected President of Bulgaria.


The Sobranie of Bulgaria would be unicameral and elected for a 4-year term by universal and equal suffrage for both men and women. Both men and women could be elected member of the Sobranie of Bulgaria. The members of the Sobranie of Bulgaria could be reelected indefinitely.


The Bulgarian People’s Front, an alliance of the Bulgarian Agrarian National Union and the Narrow Socialist Party, would become the sole legal political organization in Bulgaria and would get a monopoly on nominating candidates to the Sobranie of Bulgaria.


The official name of Bulgaria would become the People’s Republic of Bulgaria.


The new constitution of Bulgaria prohibited titles of nobility, which the pre-revolutionary constitution of Bulgaria also did.

The new constitution of Bulgaria made the Bulgarian Orthodox Church the state church of Bulgaria but granted full freedom of religion in Bulgaria. The new constitution of Bulgaria recognized the right to own private property and the right of inheritance, but allowed expropriation of private companies without compensation.

On November 5 1923 (November 18 1923) was Stamboliyski elected President of Bulgaria with 99,9 % of the votes.
 
Last edited:

azadi

Banned
I have made changes concerning Hungary's border with Yugoslavia in Chapter 10. Yugoslavia doesn't get the Hungarian triangle in Vojvodina because France consider Yugoslavia too pro-Russian.

Azadi
 
Last edited:

GI Jim

Banned
Surely in this circumstance there would be a significant revolt by the right wing of the Russian army to countenance these reforms? Kornilov, Wrangel, Denekin and many many more would have not simply laid their arms down and sworn loyalty to this new regime?

I can still see a high chance of civil war.
 

azadi

Banned
The position of the right wing of the Russian army was very weak on July 4 1917. The rank-and-file soldiers were tired of the war and were rebellious. In OTL 2/3 of the soldiers of the Russian army supported the October Revolution. Even if a right-wing coup against the Igor Shanskiy regime is attempted, it will fail quickly. At this time, the vast majority of the Russian people desired socialism, as shown in the OTL Constituent Assembly elections in 1917. The Igor Shanskiy regime quickly gained popularity when it made peace with Germany and carried out a far-reaching land reform. If an attempted military coup shall spiral into a civil war, it needs significant public support. Not necessary majority public support, but at least the support of a significant minority. The reason why the Russian civil war broke out OTL was that most Russian peasants, which constituted around 80 % of the Russian population, considered the Bolsheviks too radical with their ideas of collectivization of land, forced requisitioning of grain from peasants and anti-clericalism and state atheism. The Igor Shanskiy regime is far more moderate. Private ownership of agricultural land is supported and the Russian Orthodox Church is supported. In OTL the Kornilov affair failed quickly.


Another significant factor is that the Igor Shanskiy regime restores the Romanov Tsardom under Tsaritsa Olga. The restoration of the Tsardom, even if only with ceremonial and representative functions, secures the loyalty of conservative Russians and discredits a conservative rebellion. Compare with the 23-F in Spain in 1981, a conservative coup d'état. It failed because of the opposition of King Juan Carlos. Unless Tsaritsa Olga supports the coup, it will fail, and Tsaritsa Olga will probably realize, that the Igor Shanskiy government has overwhelming popular support in Russia and that it will threaten the restored Tsardom to support the coup.

Azadi
 
Last edited:
The position of the right wing of the Russian army was very weak on July 4 1917. The rank-and-file soldiers were tired of the war and were rebellious. OTL 2/3 of the soldiers of the Russian army supported the October Revolution. Even if a right-wing coup against the Igor Shanskiy regime is attempted, it will fail quickly. At this time, the vast majority of the Russian people desired socialism, as shown in the OTL Constituent Assembly elections in 1917. The Igor Shanskiy regime quickly gained popularity when it made peace with Germany and carried out a far-reaching land reform. If an attempted military coup shall spiral into a civil war, it needs significant public support. Not necessary majority public support, but at least the support of a significant minority. The reason why the Russian civil war broke out OTL was that most Russian peasants, which constituted around 80 % of the Russian population, considered the Bolsheviks too radical with their ideas of collectivization of land, forced requisitioning of grain from peasants and anti-clericalism and state atheism. The Igor Shanskiy regime is far more moderate. Private ownership of agricultural land is supported and the Russian Orthodox Church is supported. In OTL the Kornilov affair failed quickly.


Another significant factor is that the Igor Shanskiy regime restores the Romanov Tsardom under Tsaritsa Olga. The restoration of the Tsardom, even if only with ceremonial and representative functions, secures the loyalty of conservative Russians and discredits a conservative rebellion. Compare with the 23-F in Spain in 1981, a conservative coup d'état. It failed because of the opposition of King Juan Carlos. Unless Tsaritsa Olga supports the coup, it will fail, and Tsaritsa Olga will probably realize, that the Igor Shanskiy government has overwhelming popular support in Russia and that it will threaten the restored Tsardom to support the coup.

Azadi
Does the Polish-Russian border stay close to the Curzon line? I don't think there's a Polish Soviet war in this TL, so frontiers should be very different.
 

azadi

Banned
The Russian-Polish border is roughly the same as the OTL present-day borders of Poland with Belarus and Ukraine. Russia respected the independence of Poland and Lithuania after the end of the Great War in spite of the German defeat. Russia only reconquered southern Latvia from Germany. In addition, Russia conquered Ukrainian Galizia and Carpathian Ruthenia from Austria-Hungary.

Azadi
 
Top