Mini Cold War between Haiti and Dominican Republic

Intro and Map
This is just a small idea I've had bouncing around in my head for a while, about a mini-cold war between the Dominican Republic and Haiti based around the years of conflict both countries have had OTL and how especially during the racist rule of Trujillo, the Haitians would grow to really oppose the DR leading to an extended period of conflict between the two leading to the present. Its pretty ASB but :noexpression:

here's a map showing one of the main issues the two countries fight over:

Hispaniola-2locaap.png


EDIT: There is a second image notification after the map, this is a glitch or something, there is no second image.
script>
 
Last edited:
Parsley Massacre and 1st Hispaniola War (1937)
Like in OTL, here Rafael Trujillo decided to forcefully evict and kill Haitians in the bordering regions of the Dominican Republic, thankfully in this timeline the Haitian government caught on to what their neighbours were doing and moved in to prevent further massacres from occurring, this basically helped lower the death toll of the Parsley Massacre but in the process basically started a war between the two countries. The war is a disaster for Haiti and as shown in the map, they lose Fort Liberte (renamed Rafael) which will become a big point of contention between the two. The reason the war lasts for so long is that the Haitians refused to surrender, believing they could get back Fort Liberte until the Americans force a peace between the two countries, sparking off the long, long hostility between them.
Parsley-Massacre.png

1st-Hispaniolan-War.png
 
This is just a small idea I've had bouncing around in my head for a while, about a mini-cold war between the Dominican Republic and Haiti based around the years of conflict both countries have had OTL and how especially during the racist rule of Trujillo, the Haitians would grow to really oppose the DR leading to an extended period of conflict between the two leading to the present. Its pretty ASB but :noexpression:

here's a map showing one of the main issues the two countries fight over:

script>

The second image isn't showing
 
Francois Duvalier (1957-1968)
Francois Duvalier (14 April 1907 - 27 February 1968), commonly referred to as Papa Doc, was President of Haiti from 1957 to 1968, having been elected on a black nationalist, anti-Dominican platform.

Born into poverty in Port-au-Prince in 1907, Duvalier would work his way up to become a Physician, enrolling into the University of Haiti in 1928 and leaving with his degree 3 years later off the back of his mother’s 3 jobs. Duvalier would serve in the 1st Hispaniola War in 1937 after his uncle got killed by a Dominican soldier. His experiences in the conflict shaped Duvalier’s political views greatly, fostering a deep hatred for the other half of the island and placing him firmly within the negritude movement. In 1939 Duvalier would marry Simone Duvalier (Mama Doc.)

After the war, Haiti was thrown into chaos as Stenio Vincent was soon deposed by the military who blamed the loss all on him (very fortunate for the them) in February 1938 and a unity government was soon formed after that under Franck Lavaud. The military government soon began to mismanage the country greatly, beginning a North Korea-like policy of armament that nearly bankrupted Haiti and led to a re-democratisation in 1942. The next few elected presidents also pushed for a well-armed Haiti to fight the Dominican Republic but by the 1950s the people of Haiti, having spent the past 2 decades or so being raised on a revanchist education, clamoured for a 2nd war to take back Fort Liberte. This led to a military coup under Paul Magloire in 1954 that promised a round 2 of the conflict which would end victorious.

Paul Magloire quickly showed himself to be the least hawkish general possible, preferring to steal money from the government to line his pockets so he could live in luxury within the Presidential Palace (it was rumoured he would have an orgy a night, of course that’s exaggerated, it was only an orgy every other week.) in 1957 the people had had enough and forcefully kicked the military out of power, aided by other rivals to his power hoping they’d get a chance into power. Elections were held in October between over 18 candidates but Duvalier and his National Unity Party came out on top, advocating for a harsh foreign policy towards Haiti’s neighbour and riding the popularity of Duvalier’s black nationalism.

Duvalier would begin a massive armament program, using his newfound ‘anti-communist’ beliefs (aided by the executions of Cuban aid workers in Haiti) to get weapons from the Eisenhower government, wary of the fascistic Trujillo regime and their sheltering of Nazis. This led Duvalier to abandon his earlier marxist beliefs and to instead embrace the right-wing of the nation, becoming the favourite leader of the mulatto elite. It must be said that Duvalier was nowhere near as corrupt as Magloire was, implementing a very free market system that allowed American and French corporations to have a field day in a nation with no real rules on anything really, as long as workers got paid something (that something being very low.) This led to unparalleled economic growth in Haiti.

In 1964 Duvalier decided the nation was ready for round 2 and so gave the order to attack on 2nd March. The war will be talked about at a later date but it proved to be a failure for the Haitians although Duvalier claimed a victory based on the amount of civilians killed by the surprise attack. The war ended on the 2nd of May not having changed much except deepening the divide on the island.

Duvalier stayed in power surprisingly after that, crushing a military coup that attempted to blame him, and fully establishing himself as the most influential leader Haiti had had since Dessalines himself, bringing a full decade of domestic stability and economic growth to the former impoverished nation.

In 1968, while out in his iconic black Sedan, carrying the infamous Presidential Machine-gun, he was shot by his driver, who turned out to be a Dominican assassin hired by Ramfis Trujillo, Rafael’s notoriously cruel and sadistic son who is rumoured to have had a week long party (drug-fuelled orgy) in celebration over his father’s rival’s death.

Francois was succeeded by his equally ruthless daughter, Marie-Denise, who would prove to be even more influential than her father and an equal match for her geopolitical foe, Ramfis.

The Presidential Machine-gun now resides within the National Museum, a source of humour for the Western world, but strangely enough a source of pride for Haitians everywhere.

Duvalier-Wikibox.png
 
Rafael Trujillo (1930-1961)
Rafael Trujillo (14 October 1891 - 30 May 1961), commonly referred to as El Jefe (the boss) and as La Cabra (the goat), was President of the Dominican Republic from 1930 to 1961, infamously one of the most ruthless and brutal dictators the American hemisphere has ever seen, his notoriety aided by his personal vendetta with Haiti for much of his time in power.

Born into a middle-class family in San Cristobal in 1891, Trujillo turned to crime early into his life, leading a violent gang until he signed up for the Dominican army, impressing his superiors to the point that he became Commander-in-Chief. Trujillo proceeded to use the army to manoeuvre his way into power, staging a coup against President Vasquez in 1930 and then winning the following ‘election’ (Trujillo ran against no-one).

Trujillo used a hurricane that hit the island only a few weeks after the start of his term as an excuse to implement martial law and to rebuild Santo Domingo, renaming it Ciudad Trujillo. In 1931 Trujillo would officially make his personal clique, the Dominican Party, the only legally allowed political party in the country, beginning his dictatorial 30 year reign.

Trujillo, requiring an enemy to unite his country behind his rule , as other fascists did at the time, chose the black-majority Haitians in the border regions of the country, using the army to begin the notorious Parsley Massacre in October 1937. Trujillo underestimated the political will in Haiti to fight his openly racist government and the massacre was interrupted by interventions by the Haitian army and local militias, this led to organised combat between the two nations and began the 1st Hispaniola War. The Dominicans won outright, being a wealthier, better armed nation and Trujillo was overjoyed by the occupation of Fort Liberte, quickly renaming it Rafael after himself.

Trujillo spent the rest of his time in power brutally oppressing his people, his son, Ramfis, sadistically raping a number of girls during this time. Trujillo established a cult of personality built around himself but also his Far-right antihaitianismo ideology, realising that the island of Hispaniola would be split geopolitically for years to come and that when he was finally gone, the country would still have the will to defeat it’s neighbour.

The 1940s and 1950s were marked by an absolute hatred between Haitians and Dominicans, and Trujillo, a self-proclaimed white supremacist, opened his borders to white refugees from war-torn Europe throughout the 1940s, even allowing Jewish refugees into the country, but quickly stopped once he began to receive ex-Nazis who didn’t want to be caught by the Allies or the Soviets or the newly formed nation of Israel. The Dominican Republic in this time became an apartheidist state, reducing its black population to 2nd class citizens or worse. Trujillo justified this by claiming black people to be a 5th column for Haiti, his claims resonated with the mixed and white Dominicans, angered by retaliatory killings of white people and Dominicans by vengeful Haitians.

Trujillo found his greatest enemy though in Francois Duvalier, who he himself had a bone to pick with Trujillo, and he wasn’t afraid of showing it. From 1957 to 1961, while the CIA tried many methods to assassinate Castro, Duvalier and Trujillo attempted to assassinate each other as well, from exploding limousines, poisoned whiskey and killer prostitutes to firing missiles at each other’s home. The island of Hispaniola infamously became one of the most militarised borders after the two Koreas and Berlin. Both leaders used their right-wing, hyper-capitalist rhetoric and actions to receive weapons from the USA to defend themselves form Soviet infiltration but really just to fight each other.

It is said that Rafael Trujillo’s greatest regret is dying before he could truly face Duvalier on the battlefield, a showdown between two Carribean ‘supermen’, recreating the historical divide and conflict between the African slaves and the European slavemasters.

The showdown would have to be reserved for their children, for although the 2nd Hispaniola war occurred in 1964 between Francois and Ramfis, Ramfis would be tested by an equally ruthless and hard-headed leader in Marie-Denise Duvalier for rest of the 20th Century.

Trujillo-Wikibox.png
 
Last edited:
How did Rafael die?
Well I already had Duvalier get assassinated so I didn’t want Trujillo to also get assassinated (although he was OTL). Basically Trujillo dies of diabetes, I was thinking how a lot of dictators live really unhealthy lives, they eat a lot and they normally do a lot of drugs and all this does add up, especially for a guy who’s been ruling for like 30 years. So he basically died from excess everything I guess
 
1964 2nd Hispaniola War and 1964 Haitian Coup Attempt
After nearly 20 years of waiting, the Haitian people on the 29th March 1964 attacked the former Haitian town of Rafael (Fort Liberte). The Haitian army had been preparing this for decades and had received massive equipment deliveries from the USA, including tanks and aircraft, and had received the go ahead from Francois Duvalier to attack. The Haitian army quickly defeated the defending force on the border and entered the town, proceeding to massacre a large number of civilians based on how white they were, Duvalier proclaiming this to be akin to Dessalines' expulsion of French slave-owners form the island nearly 2 centuries earlier. The Dominican Republic had also been preparing for a second showdown but Ramfis Trujillo, paranoid as he was, had kept most of the army in and around Santo Domingo. The Dominicans reacted with force which led to a pitched battle for Rafael, including the first tank battle ever fought on the island (in which 2 Haitians Shermans were destroyed by 3 Dominican Shermans). The Haitians were defeated, but at a high cost for both sides, and guerrilla fighting continued until the Americans had to step in again on 2nd April, President Johnson famously calling it a 'waste of' his 'time'.

The war dropped confidence greatly in the Duvalier government and the military, needing a scapegoat, decided to repeat their actions with Stenio Vincent 30 years ago and attempted to stage a coup on 18 June 1964 against Duvalier. Surprisingly, members of the feared 'Tonton Macoutes' joined the military, being promised a free hand in exploiting the country that Duvalier hadn't allowed. The coup failed completely: the 40 traitorous guards in the presidential palace were subdued by the overwhelmingly majority-loyal guards within, the Army on the outside didn't fare much better, with a massive blunder of not having told other military units the coup would take place leading to the presidential guard firing upon the encroaching military, furthermore, the one M4 Sherman tank they brought as backup being destroyed by the anti-aircraft gun that had been deployed to fire at Dominican planes in the front lawn. After the coup failed, Duvalier, enraged, made sure the families of the generals were visited by the Tontons Macoutes and had mass purges done within the army and the Tontons Macoutes.

This all would end in Duvalier secluding himself for much of his remaining time in power, only leaving the Presidential palace on the 2nd May of every month, and getting assassinated by Ramfis Trujillo when he saw how Duvalier was rebuilding his power base after the disastrous year.

2nd-Hispaniola-War.png

1964-Haitian-Coup-Attempt.png
 
It's an interesting TL.

I'm not sure how the Haitians would actually lose the second war though given that by 1964 the UN was up and running and once Haiti captured Fort Liberte there would likely be UN, US and OAS pressure for a ceasefire which would see Haiti remaining in control of the town but not necessarily recapturing all of the annexed area
 
It's an interesting TL.

I'm not sure how the Haitians would actually lose the second war though given that by 1964 the UN was up and running and once Haiti captured Fort Liberte there would likely be UN, US and OAS pressure for a ceasefire which would see Haiti remaining in control of the town but not necessarily recapturing all of the annexed area

I’m glad you’re enjoying this!

I haven’t actually though of the UN’s reaction to this, or the reaction of any foreign power really, which is weird considering a large chunk of this TL is set in the Cold War.

But I was thinking that actually Haïti doesn’t hold fort Liberte for very long at all, quickly being pushed out by the Dominicans, bringing everything back to ‘normal’
 
I’m glad you’re enjoying this!

I haven’t actually though of the UN’s reaction to this, or the reaction of any foreign power really, which is weird considering a large chunk of this TL is set in the Cold War.

But I was thinking that actually Haïti doesn’t hold fort Liberte for very long at all, quickly being pushed out by the Dominicans, bringing everything back to ‘normal’

The way the UN acted in the various wars in the 1950s and 1960s I would expect they would have been acting from the very day any shooting started to get a ceasefire. Once Haiti captured Fort Liberte they would indicate willingness to accept a ceasefire and there would have been IMMENSE pressure by the OAS, US and UN for Dom Rep to accept (and in any of these TLs, US sanctions against Dom Rep are going to bite).

I just don't see how Dom Rep manages to retake Fort Liberte unless the town is only held for a matter of minutes.
 
The way the UN acted in the various wars in the 1950s and 1960s I would expect they would have been acting from the very day any shooting started to get a ceasefire. Once Haiti captured Fort Liberte they would indicate willingness to accept a ceasefire and there would have been IMMENSE pressure by the OAS, US and UN for Dom Rep to accept (and in any of these TLs, US sanctions against Dom Rep are going to bite).

I just don't see how Dom Rep manages to retake Fort Liberte unless the town is only held for a matter of minutes.

Yeaahhhh... I’ll probably go back and rewrite some things, didn’t even think about the UN or anything else until you brought it up.
 
Top