rebeu
Banned
How about some sort of Tuareg independence / autonomy?
How about a return to precolonial lack of Arab/Berber dichotomy to begin with
How about some sort of Tuareg independence / autonomy?
I'm thinking of how we've been told the British Empire will collapse--and this is in the face of the triumph of the Empire in the Great War and the manner in which it was achieved, with much collaboration (however grudgingly conceded) of native peoples of Africa and India that has brought them many gains. We've also been told of a conservative backlash in the British Empire.
The guys who were dressed in "traditional garb", versus the Congolese who were dressed in the latest suits. That suggests the world looks at non-European states very differently. Look at how the Japanese dressed at Paris in 1919; western clothing.
I think Zollverein entry for Alsace is a bit premature. How does this work, exactly? Goods can flow through Alsace into France? Its outside of France's tariff wall?
Why do the Greeks get Thessalonica and Crete?
I would expect India would be there as its own delegation, even if there's an unofficial Congress delegation.
I think Jonathan already said that they were - but there was no mention, and I don't think there'd be much discussion of India, either. In my view, it wouldn't be viewed as an international issue - no fighting took place there involving the war directly, and Britain's problems are its own.
Question: is the apparatus of French Indochina kept with the British, or is the responsibility for the new territories left to the Raj?
I'd expect that the British will keep Indochina separately administered. They were already uncomfortable with the idea of incorporating Burma into India and as you know ultimately split Burma off in 1937. The British will probably create a new structure and maintain much of the French-speaking elite there to smooth the transition.
Western education was a potent force in detaching pribumi participants from their traditional roots, rendering them often having more in common with fellow educated natives from other ethnicities then with their own people back home. That was how our common identity was concepted. A unified identity is an inevitability with Ethical Policy.
Here we have calls for independent East Indies before even East Indians themselves decided they want it, and a colonial overlord forced to pursue that end before their own colonial subjects even started demanding it.
Those peasants in China are going to change things - they'll be separated from the Qing ruling class not just in the obvious social and economic barriers, but also ethnic and religious ones. And then there are the Chinese generals who fought in Korea, most smart enough not to accept invitations home without knowing how they'll retain a military command. The Emperor has an uphill struggle ahead. But that's fair enough; so do his people.
So the patriarchy is restored, as IOTL 1918? I would have thought that a revamping of the Most Holy Synod as a more grassroots, representative organ would be more in the spirit of the new regime.
Now I'm believe Peter Moller wrote another book in which he described the reactions within the various powers to the result of the Great War.
Could you be so kind as to reprint the relevant chapter?
About the Duchy of Alsace-Lorraine, what is the succession law?
It leads me to another question about the extent of autonomy of the Duchy. The facts of the Duchy being under French law and having its own constitution are contradictory as there could be contradictions between the two texts.
I have also questions as to the involvement of the Princes in politics, not only the Imperial family. I mean the collateral branches of the dynasty, the Lucien branch (virulent Republicans)or the illegitimate sons of Napoleon III
How about some sort of Tuareg independence / autonomy?
How about a return to precolonial lack of Arab/Berber dichotomy to begin with
HIV spreading widely this early?
Well, I picked the right day to catch up This is a truly sublime timeline, I must say. Here comes the twentieth century!
A couple thoughts on the last few posts.
The guys who were dressed in "traditional garb", versus the Congolese who were dressed in the latest suits. That suggests the world looks at non-European states very differently. Look at how the Japanese dressed at Paris in 1919; western clothing.
I think Zollverein entry for Alsace is a bit premature. How does this work, exactly? Goods can flow through Alsace into France? Its outside of France's tariff wall?
Why do the Greeks get Thessalonica and Crete?
"The most Italy would do was guarantee that, if he returned to the Vatican as a private citizen, he would not be molested." I'm a terrible person for laughing at this.
I'd imagine that the Emperor will have to walk a fine line in his reforms - the gentry won't tolerate him giving too much to the peasants, but if he tries too hard to restore the old order, he'll end up in a civil war against his own people. It will be very easy to fall off that line and end up facing a coup or an uprising; quite likely he'll have to fend off both.
He's aiming for something like OTL's Hundred Days Reform, and the victory in Korea has given him some political capital, but implementation will be a daunting task.
Long time lurker, first time poster
This is my favorite timeline on the site and I look forward to seeing how the world ITTL develops in the 20th Century.
One question though, what is the status of Papua New Guinea ITTL? Was Kaiser-Wilhelmsland established or was the area colonized by the British?
Wow, thanks for all the responses!
the "Kingdom of the Arabs" (Algeria south of the Atlas) essentially is an autonomous Tuareg state, with the postwar settlement leaving it French but internally self-governing. In practice, it will be influenced by the Toucouleur and Bornu as well as by France.
On Tolstoy - how is he holding up, anway? My image of him is that of one of those people who venerate freedom and tolerance, but have difficulties with practising what they preach; some of his writing is quite cranky and he managed to alienate many personal friends and family when they didn't agree with him and his ideals. I imagine that he risks running out of allies quite soon; also, there is a danger that he'll surround himself with flunkies who tell him how right he is, instead of critical people who disagree with him.And Russia's constitutional status will indeed remain open for the time being, with Tolstoy's rather ambiguous position being an excuse for not making any definite moves in either direction.
Turkestan will be really interesting : Chagatai will likely be the lingua Franca but with what alphabet, Arabic or Cyrillic? I think Arabic is the most likely because it's the one of the Ottomans.
You know that's a good point. It effectively means that the delegates from these countries decided they didn't need to worry about western sensibilities and could dictate their terms despite any discomfort or alienation the Europeans in Washington might feel. A bridge too far?
Out of curiosity, you mentioned Ottoman dress as being "non Western". What is the fashion in the Ottoman Empire currently? OTL's semi-European dress with features such as the fez, or has there been a limited return to traditional Ottoman clothing? Or something else entirely?
If I read it right, France has effectively entered the Zollverein as its largest member, but with any need to pay dues or submit to a higher authority delegated to one of its incorporated vassals.
The Emperor will never again have as open a window to power into reform as he did in the OTL Hundred Days or TTL during the war. But that itself may be to the good - it will likely mean a steadier pace of reforms. He won't go all Gorbachev and allow the reactionaries and conservatives to unify behind a coup. Any attempts will be less evenly supported, and Cixi may not get involved (and if she doesn't soon, she'll be too old to be effective).
My favorite thing about this thread is the relevant, constructive, insightful discourse that follows almost every update. I'm not sure I've seen anything else quite like it on this board
One question though, what is the status of Papua New Guinea ITTL? Was Kaiser-Wilhelmsland established or was the area colonized by the British
Wiki shows the large majority of Tuareg people living in modern day Niger and Mali ie TTL Bornu and Toucaleur.
It also mentions that Tuareg society was heavily dependent upon slavery.
What's the attitude to that among the Abcarists and Belloists? I imagine the herder/scholars of Toucaleur are more tolerant towards it.
On Tolstoy - how is he holding up, anway? My image of him is that of one of those people who venerate freedom and tolerance, but have difficulties with practising what they preach; some of his writing is quite cranky and he managed to alienate many personal friends and family when they didn't agree with him and his ideals.
A sustained social and economic crisis in the UK seems like a reasonably likely outcome, as it is after any great war, which with Ireland being a trigger point, well.
I really like Verne as a prime minister, Michel Strogoff is one of my favourite novels. However his radical utopianism is going to get him a lot of enemies. Even if the deal in Alsace favours France, the nationalist press is going to say he is a traitor. I can't see him last more than a few years with all you said he would do : problems in the colonies, in regards to the vote for women (France was quite conservative and didn't give the right to vote before WW2) and his personality (he follows his emotions). But hopefully he will have a major impact on the French psyche.
Have you think about universal expositions and Olympic games? Because Verne could use one of these to leave his mark on the Parisian landscape.
Turkestan will be really interesting : Chagatai will likely be the lingua Franca but with what alphabet, Arabic or Cyrillic? I think Arabic is the most likely because it's the one of the Ottomans.
IOTL Ataturk deliberately attempted to westernise Turkey by adopting the Latin script, banning fezzes and suchlike.
ITTL the Ottomans are more successful and modern than they were in our 'sick man of Europe' stage but they maintain more of their 'oriental' aspects.