If the Thule start colonizing Novaja Zemlja around 1575, there's chance they'll meet some Russian sniff-around explorers, fur hunters, tax collectors and such quite soon.
Very likely. It's an inevitable development, the only issue is when. The successful permanent settlements are around 1580, and they're moving south from there. My guess is that they encounter Russians between 1585 and 1595.
The thing is, its not as if they set foot on the island, and the whole thing automatically goes Thule Red on the map.
Initial colonizing groups from Franz Josef Land will be no more than a few dozen or a couple of hundred, tops. There will probably be more. And the population will expand, but it will take time for them to really establish some degree of control or presence over the Novaya. Let's say a generation. And probably another two or three generations after that to really consolidate.
It'll be in the period from 1600 on that the Sea Thule tend to come into their own in terms of reaching their maximum populations and refining their Agricultural/Pastoral/Subsistence packages to their islands.
The Thule will establish contact (probably not very peaceful) with the local Nenets, and IIRC Russia had started to solidify a sort of claim of suzerainity over their mainland brethren around this time.
I'm not sure if the Nenets were occupying Novaya Zemyla. There are references that suggest that the Russians shipped the Nenets up there to consolidate their claim to the Islands against England. They certainly inhabited the region of mainland between Novaya Zemyla and Severnaya Zemyla.
I dunno. The North Island seems pretty difficult. The South Island would probably have been at least seasonally visited by the Nenet accompanying Reindeer migration. So likely, there would have eventually been contact with the Nenet and possibly conflict, as the Sea Thule shifted from subsisting on sea resources to consolidating and expanding land use. Populations of both, however, might be thin enough that they can avoid each other and avoid conflict.... for the time being. On the other hand, as I've noted, the Nenet were not nearly as warlike as the eastern peoples, and there may be significant chances for cultural influence of Thule on the Nenet.
Novaja Zemlja is very close to the mainland.
Correct. The peninsula closest to the southernmost part of Novaya is only 70 kilometers (45 miles) away. Even straight south, its only 180 kilometers (115 miles) to the Mainland. That's a pretty short hop, given the distances that the Sea Thule travel.
And the guy currently on top is Moscow is not going to take kindly any sort of what he sees as interference into perceived Russian tribute sphere.
Would he? Although the Russians were hunting and trading in the area at the time, they didn't establish jurisdiction and dominance until the early 19th century.
There wouldn't be any awareness that this is the cutting edge of a circumpolar civilization. Rather, what the Russians would note is the emergence of handfuls of primitive villages in the middle of nowhere. If they even noted emergence.
If the Thule are reasonably friendly and prepared to trade (and the Russians will have desirable trade goods) they might not care all that much. The Russian presence in the area is primarily commercial, so if the Thule communities are profitable, the Russians are good with that.
And actually, its probably in the interests of the Novaya Sea Thule. The Russian goods they trade for will move from them to Franz Josef and Severnaya Zemyla. Svernaya Zemyla will gateway to the Talmyr peninsula, and then the Laptev Sea Thule. Going the other direction, Franz Josef will connect to Svalbard, and from Svalbard to Greenland.
Trade and communication routes reverse, there's likely further migration to Novaya, and the Novaya Sea Thule become fairly sophisticated and politically and economically astute, working with Russian partners. The Sea Thule overall might stand to profit very well developing a robust trading network based on their interface with the Russians.
It will take several more decades for the Thule to be recognized as a challenge.
Note also that this is the time when trade trough the Arctic began to establish a significant route between Arkhanelsk and Britain...
Novaya was visited by the British and Dutch, searching for the Northwest Passage, in the 16th century, prior to Thule arrival. And this is also the period of rivalry between the British and Russians. There was also prior Norwegian involvement.
And we can expect Russian penetration of Siberia to be not well received by the Novaya Zemyla Sea Thule, and perhaps others of the Sea Thule, when they find that the Russians are dealing directly with their Nenet clients.
So yes, there's potential for things to get interesting... if and when the British and Dutch start to offer better deals, if and when the Norwegians get involved, if and when the Russians start stepping on Sea Thule toes, if and when the Russians start pushing up against the Siberian Thule..
The funny thing is that in this way, actually the Thule discover Europe (well, sort of) before or simultanously with the European discovery of America...
Well, the C-Man is 1492. John Cabot finds continental North America around 1497. Through the 1500's you've got a lot of coastal exploration, and the Spanish are establishing settlements. The Aztecs are overthrown in 1521. It takes into the 1600's for momentum to really pick up in North America.
But in a sense, you're correct. The timing is nearly simultaneous, and the Thule are colonizing their arctic islands faster than the Europeans are establishing presences in North America. It is funny.
Also, from Severnaja Zemlja the hop to Taimyr is short, and from there, the Western Thule frontier is not very far...
Maybe 500 miles or so following the coasts, which is no great challenge for the Sea Thule.
I'm not sure they can or will colonize Taimyr. Russian encroachment in the area is coming.
Not sure. I think its going to be contested. The Thule will establish settlements, make life hard on the locals, and have better land use than either the locals or the Russians. But for the Russians, control of rivers and streams through forts is pretty essential. And all of those rivers and streams are draining into the Arctic.
The Russians will certainly be occupied with the battle with the Sibir Khanate through the later part of the 1500's. But after that? The 1600's will be interesting, 1700's even more so.
But they are pretty much explorers, they'd stumble into they kin coming the opposite direction. I suppose they dialects could even be mutually incomprehensible at this point, or close to, but they'd recognize as "civilized thule" nontheless I think.
Somewhat. The Thule in this timeline are more culturally mobile. There's less isolation. Wandering Shamans, literacy, continuing expansion of technologies and techniques are working against centrifugal forces. The different regions of Thule are mixing more.
The Siberian Thule for instance, have deep deep roots in Alaska. Alaska connects to McKenzie, McKenzie culture links to both Baffin and Hudson Bay, Baffin is tied to Ellesmere, Ellesmere is influential in Greenland, and Greenland is the source of the Sea Thule.
You're probably seeing linguistic divergence on the level of England and Jamaica.
And of course, there's different cultural priorities. The language of the Siberian Thule focuses a lot on war, and they've got a lot of different words for different kinds of ambush. The language of the Sea Thule has a lot of different words for sea and ice conditions.
So in view of each - they talk real funny, but its intelligible if they talk slow and careful. At least at this point in history.