Divided America: An alternate 19th Century

The Eight Nations of America
The Civil War in the United States, fought 1861 – 1870 and the division of that former nation into 6 nations was the critical event of the second half of the 19th Century. Those six nations along with Canada and Mexico formed the community of nations in North America well into the 20th Century.

Decision point: Lincoln is defeated in 1864
In 1864, the Confederacy found itself on the defensive and Lincoln faced a difficult task of conquering the South. Although the North had won important victories at Gettysburg and Vicksburg, the South still had strong armies in the field and the South had won an important victory at Chickamauga in the fall of 1863. As the battle reached its crisis, General Thomas, commander of the Union XIV corps is killed and this led to the collapse of the entire Army of the Cumberland after the other two corps of that army were already in full scale retreat, and the timely death of General Bragg left General Longstreet in command of the Southern Army of the Tennessee at a decisive moment. His ruthless pursuit managed to bag the entire Army of the Cumberland, along with its commander General Rosecrans. The disaster, which cost the Union 16,000 casualties plus 40,000 prisoners (at the cost of 18,000 Confederate casualties) offset in part the defeat at Vicksburg and forced Lincoln to leave Grant in the West.

The start of 1864 saw Grant in the West with 2 armies, the Army of the Tennessee (named after the river, while the Southern one is named after the state) under the command of Sherman operating in the Mississippi Valley, and the Army of the Ohio under Grant himself operating in Kentucky. Longstreet remained in command of the Southern Army of the Tennessee now dug in at Chattanooga, while General Johnson began to organize a new Army of Mississippi to defend Mississippi and Alabama from Sherman, while Lee remained in the East facing Meade (Army of the Potomac), Butler (Army of the James) and Sigel (Army of West Virginia).

In Louisiana, Admiral Porter and General Banks suffer catastrophic defeat as the Southern Army under General Kirby Smith prevent them from completing the critical engineering effort needed to get the ironclad fleet downriver and the force Admiral Porter to scuttle his entire fleet (and his career along with Banks). The destruction of this fleet and 10,000 Union prisoners is the opening fiasco of the summer.

The spring and summer of 1864 saw offensives by Grant and Sherman against Johnson and Longstreet. At Chattanooga, Grant found himself locked in an effective deadlock with Longstreet as that master of defensive warfare had converted his position into an impregnable fortress and Grant was plagued by cavalry raids by Bedford Forrest in his rear that forced him to leave large numbers of troops to guard his rear. A siege developed and by October Grant had managed to make little headway. Meanwhile, Sherman had managed to take most of Mississippi, but had failed to force Johnson into battle and although much of Mississippi and parts of Alabama had been fought over, had not managed to reach Mobile. A Navy attack of Mobile Bay failed when the USS Hartford, carrying Admiral Farragut (commander of the attack) hit a mine and was destroyed with most of its crew, resulting in the attack being called off.

In Virginia, Lee and Meade sparred in a series of inclusive battles in the Wilderness before Lee managed to outflank Meade, forcing him to pull back to Washington. This set the stage for Lee sending Early to deal with Sigel (whom he promptly embarrassed at New Market and sent retreating to West Virginia) and Lee was free to advance on Butler and savage the Army of the James and force its evacuation at the Bermuda Hundred.

By late October, the Union is facing stalemate in Northern Virginia, Georgia and the Mississippi Valley, and has suffered disastrous defeat in Louisiana and eastern Virginia. Lincoln is turned out of office in November and McClellan is elected President of the United States. Realizing the McClellan will give them better terms, Davis continues to stall when Lincoln starts negotiations. With little choice, Lincoln orders Grant and Meade to hold in place, appoints Grant commander of all US Armies (who leaves McPherson in command at Chattanooga), and orders Grant to have Sherman reinforced in order to try one last time for a victory. Sherman, reinforced massively, drives on Mobile and manages to drive Johnson out of Alabama and Mississippi (and incidently frees a great many slaves) and takes Mobile Bay by Christmas.

But it is too late. Support for the war collapses in the North, and Lincoln has been forced to suspend conscription after the November election. Many veterans of the Union Army, whose 3 year enlistments are coming to an end begin going home in November and Union Army morale is at a nadir. Lincoln calls off further advances as 1865 begins and agrees to an armistice in place until negotiations can begin with the new McClellan Administration.

Mexico and Central America 1862-1870
While the United States was fighting its war, critical events were happening in Mexico as well. In 1862, Spain and France decide to punish Mexico for the decision by the Juarez government to suspend debt payments. The British too initially consider action but decide that events in North America are too uncertain to risk angering the United States. On May 5, 1862, French troops wreck the Mexican Army at the Battle of Puebla and through the rest of 1862 and 1863 proceed to conquer all of Mexico except for mountain regions held by forces loyal to Juarez. By 1864, Napoleon has installed Maximilian as Emperor of Mexico and also solidified an alliance with the Hapsburgs and Austria. This alliance was to be crucial to events in Europe in a very short time. With the defeat of Lincoln in the November 1864 election, France grants the Confederate government recognition in exchange for it renouncing the Monroe Doctrine as it applies to Mexico. Spain, eager to regain territory, assembles an army financed by the French, and joins in on the conquest of Mexico, and proceed to conquer all of Central America north of Panama from 1865-1870. With North America continuing to split apart, neither France nor Spain need fear action by the Americans, and only the British threat to intervene saves Colombia from losing Panama.

This does however keep the French Army busy in Mexico as reinforcements are sent in to finally defeat Mexican forces (and kill Juarez) in 1868.

A House Divided Against Itself Cannot Stand: The Civil War continues 1865-1870
In March 1865 McClellan becomes President of the United States and Lincoln leaves office and moves to California to start a new life. A wave of resignations hits the Union Army as well as Sherman quiets and moves back to California. Most of the wartime army goes home as well, leaving only a relatively small Regular Army which is soon ordered to key points along the border with the Confederacy and the United States to stem the mass migration of former slaves seeking to escape the Confederacy. McClellan agrees to give pull Union troops out of all occupied Southern states, but holds firm on keeping Missouri and Kentucky as both have very large Unionist populations. However, rioting in Baltimore and an extreme shortage of troops eventually convinces him to give up eastern Maryland including Baltimore and Washington DC after a reasonable period of time to evacuate government records and other valuables such as the Library of Congress and contents of the Patent Office. The US capital is provisionally moved to Philadelphia, while the Confederacy debates moving their capital too.

The Democratic Congress and President find themselves with a nation discouraged and with huge debts. Funding measures to build the Transcontinental Railroad are defeated, and in reaction, the western states of California, Washington, Oregon and Nevada secede from the Union in the fall of 1865. A government is formed in San Francisco and the Pacific Union is formed with all four states. The territorial governments of Colorado (which includes Wyoming at this point), Montana, Idaho, and Arizona also send representatives to San Francisco and consider joining In the end New Mexico and Arizona join the Pacific Union along with Idaho, while Colorado and Wyoming remain part of the US. Discussions over Montana between the US and Pacific Union result in it remaining a US Territory. The British Government immediately recognizes the new nation in exchange for a commercial treaty and McClellan is forced to accept the disaster in his first year in office. Taking advantage of the situation, the Mormons in Utah declare their independence as well and since neither the Pacific Union nor the US Government is willing to try to conquer them, both nations grant recognition.

The McClellan Administration limps through the next three years facing harsh criticism before being voted out of office in 1868. The Democrats dump McClellan for selling out the West and Winfield Scott Hancock, a hero of Gettysburg, wins the Democratic nomination and defeats Schuler Colfax with ease. Hancock works closely with General Grant, who remained in the Army post war and between them and the assistance of General Sheridan crush the Sioux and other Plains tribes (thus keeping the British and Pacific Union from expanding any further east) and work to improve relations with the other nations of North America. Hancock also improves the Navy, recognizing that the United States must become a trading nation to survive as it will have to compete for the minerals of western North America and the agricultural products of Texas.

Meanwhile, the Confederacy has its own problems. The end of the war is a Southern victory, but only of sorts. Although nearly 400,000 Blacks managed to either reach the North or already lived there after the Civil War, the South still had 4 million Blacks in its territories. Of these, 250,000 live in Texas (out of a population of 800,000 not counting Indians), and another 400,000 in Louisiana (out of 750,000 people, and nearly 1/3 are Free Blacks), and a mere 100,000 (out of 700,000) living in Arkansas. In all, nearly 1 million Blacks have been freed by Union military action and as the Union Army leaves Louisiana, Arkansas, Mississippi, and Alabama it simply hands over most of its weapons to the former slave population. In addition, nearly 180,000 Blacks served in the Union Army during the war, and most of them (nearly 100,000 in all) promptly head to Louisiana to help their brethren.

In short order Davis finds himself fighting a new Civil War, this time White against Black, and practically everywhere in the South. Texas, dealing with a serious problem with Comanche and other Indians, acts promptly. When Davis is unable to send troops to help defend the Texas Frontier, the Texas Government decides to rid itself of two problems at once. First, it is facing a serious lack of money, and secondly it has a serious internal security problem. Texas secedes from the Confederacy in 1867 when Davis asks for troops to fight the war back east, and then makes a deal with Louisiana and France. France will pay all debts owed by the Texas government and provide weapons and a few ships. In exchange, Texas will act against Mexican Rebels using Texas as a base, close its ports to the Central American governments, allow the Blacks in Louisiana to have a secure border with Texas. In exchange for British recognition and money, Texas also ends slavery, using the British money to reimburse owners and those who chose to remain in Texas are given free land in the Rio Grande Valley and basic tools and seed. Texas laws make life difficult for former slaves everywhere but in the former Indian Territory and Rio Grande Valley which strongly encourages movement.

Louisiana takes in 150,000 Blacks that Texas expels (most of whom had been sent there during the Civil War to prevent them fleeing to Yankee forces). Texas promptly uses the French money to expand its Army and proceeds over the next year to wipe out the Comanche and Apache (those in New Mexico) Indians by wiping out the Buffalo and launching several winter campaigns when the Indians are vulnerable while annexing Indian Territory (Oklahoma) and secure the border with Louisiana and Mexico.

Meanwhile, Davis finds himself fighting a war even more ruinously expensive then the last one. Robert E. Lee and Joseph E. Johnson both decline to serve in a war to crush a servile rebellion, leaving P.G.T. Beauregard as commander of the Army. He assigns Longstreet to watch the Yankees, while sending Bedford Forrest to deal with the rebellions in the Mississippi Valley. A horrific slaughter rages across the CSA throughout 1866-1868 as rebellions outside of the Mississippi Valley are brutally crushed, and nearly 1 million blacks are locked up into camps. Another 1 million flee to Louisiana (where nearly 600,000 Whites flee Louisiana, Mississippi and parts of Alabama and Arkansas, and another 20,000 are killed) and by 1867 the Confederate government is fighting a semi conventional war against Blacks defending Louisiana and parts of Alabama and Mississippi and Arkansas.

Seeing an opportunity to get even, Abolitionists in the United States funnel money, arms and a considerable number of former Union officers to help the Blacks and the war continues in an uncommonly harsh fashion for the next two years. Although Forrest manages to drive Black forces out of Alabama, Arkansas and northern Mississippi by 1868, the Confederate government finds itself exhausted economically and the British government (which is facing serious pressure at home) is threatening a blockade and economic embargo. With little choice, Davis agrees to a peace treaty with the new nation of Louisiana and sends Vice President Stephens and retired General Robert E. Lee to negotiate with the President of Louisiana, Frederick Douglas and in May 1869 the Treaty of Lena is signed. Louisiana gets to keep all of the state of Mississippi plus Louisiana, in exchange, the Confederate States of America deports nearly 2 million blacks still living in its territory to the new nation. The United States and Texas both promptly recognize the new nation and money begins pouring in from the United States, principally from Abolitionist groups and companies who realize that Louisiana controls the mouth of the Mississippi. At the end of the war, Arkansas, with some bribes by railroad companies in the United States and irritation at the Confederate government leaves the Confederacy and joins the Republic of Texas. As part of that deal former general Cleburne is made President of the Republic of Texas and Arkansas, which is formally known as the Lone Star Republic.

By the end of 1870 the long Civil War is over. The nations of the United States, the Pacific Union, Texas, Deseret, Louisiana and the Confederacy have emerged as successors to the old United States, and the issue of Slavery has destroyed the continental nation dreamed of by the Founding Fathers. The awful war is finally over, at the cost of nearly 2 million lives from all the various nations (including Indians killed in Texas, New Mexico and in the Great Plains) and the map of North America has changed forever. The Confederacy seceded to keep slavery and finds that it has its independence and no longer has slavery. Many in the Old South wonder if it was worth it.
 
Last edited:
authors note: I wrote this one back in 2007 and thought it would be fun to share

more to come, as I did a history pretty much up to 1900
 
The 21 Weeks War (Bismark's disaster) 1866
Prussia decides that the time is ripe to achieve dominance in Germany and triggers a war with Austria in order to end Austrian dominance in the German Confederation while France is busy in North America and the British are focusing there too. Bismark fails to realize however that success in Mexico has cemented a much stronger alliance between France and Austria than he ever expected.

Armed with excellent weapons, and having superb leadership and doctrine, Prussia is convinced it can win. Italy also sees the chance to take Venetia from Austria. However, France is still paying attention to Europe and France and Spain see an opportunity to humble Italy and ensure that Prussia doesn’t dominate Germany. Britain chooses to remain neutral, while Russia is dealing with its own problems and opportunities elsewhere.

In May, the Italians under Garabaldi invade Veneta, and quickly suffer defeat at Custoza in June, and defeat at sea at Lissa in July. However, the Italians recover and win a victory at Bezzecca and begin driving on Trento.

Meanwhile, in Germany, the Prussians and Austrians fight a major battle at Konnigratz on July 3 that results in a major but not decisive Prussian victory and threatens to end the war right then and there. However, the Kingdom of Hannover manages to defeat a small Prussian Army at Langensalza, and that buys time for a large French Army to enter Bavaria and threaten Prussia from the south. Forced to deal with the French, the Prussians have to call off their pursuit of the Austrians, and deploy reinforcements to face both Hannover and the leave only a small force to watch the Austrians. The combined French/Bavarian/Hanoverian Army manages to win a draw in a fierce three day battle at Munster. This buys time for the Austrians to recover, and they promptly reinforce their position in Italy and drive them back out of Venice. Bismark now finds that his plan of a quick victory over Austria is in dire danger and realizes that disaster looms. Moltke does his best, managing to hold off the French and Austrians from driving into Prussia, but can do little to prevent Bavaria, Hannover and other German nations from overrunning provinces of the Rhine, Westphalia, and Prussian Saxony. Defeated, Bismark asks for peace by November 1866, and those territories become part of Hannover (Rhineland), independent as part of the German Confederation (Westphalia), or are annexed by Saxony (Prussian Saxony). Italy too is forced to accept defeat and Veneta remains in Austrian hands. Prussia and its territories are also expelled from the German Confederation.

As a result of the war, France and Spain become stronger allies with Austria and the German Confederation, Bismark is forced into retirement, and considerable resentment arises in both Italy and Prussia against those nations, particularly France and Austria. Bismark’s dream of a united Germany is postponed. In addition, angered by the Prussian attempt to conquer Hannover, the British provide considerable economic help to Austria, which helps it quickly recover financially from the war
 
comments are welcome and yes I fully realize that plausibility is stretched a bit (not quit to folding space but still most definitely stretched)

the main goal when I wrote this was to create a situation where the United States and Germany are not the primary economic and military powerhouses of the early 20th Century, so stretching was required.

So the main points are, the CSA manages to hold off long enough to win a peace of political exhaustion due to Union mistakes and some better moves by them, allowing the French to retain hold of Mexico, breaking the Monroe Doctrine and thus bringing Spain back to Central America with French backing. Closer Franco-Austrian relations due to success in Mexico leads to victory against Prussia in 1866 and thus ends Bismarks dream of a united Germany.

Meanwhile in North America, Lincoln had predicted at the start of the Civil War that if secession was successful, further secession would occur. I agree with his assessment.
 
I think its an interesting timeline, and I'll be following it eagerly.

However, a couple of points:

I'm not sure I see the West Coast simply seceding over the trans-continental railway not being built. Why wouldn't they just find another source of funding? Or try later? Enough people wanted it OTL that it really was destined to be built in one form or another. Also, who are these settlers so keen to abandon the USA? Most settlers were happy with the homesteading acts of the Federal Government and were so scattered and dependent on Army Forts that they needed Washington. I mean, there were only 9000ish people in all Wyoming in 1870....

By the period you're talking about those Mormons interested in an independent state were a true minority - most were aware that working within the USA would make more sense and pushed instead for being their own state. Not that this causes huge problems given your POD that weakens Washington, but it does mean you need to think about where a Mormon state sees its allies lie given that OTL they sent troops against the CSA. Also, by 1900 one in four residents of Utah was NOT of the LDS faith and there is little in your POD to prevent this migration. How do non-Mormons fit into Deseret?

I think you're vastly overestimating how a fractured USA, an independent Texas that OTL was floundering resource-wise by 1863, and other forces would overcome the Native Americans. Historically the Comanche and Sioux were not push-overs for a united USA and the five year time frame you have for pacifying the West seems extremely generous.

I think the slave revolt was realistically handled, but I'm not sure Frederick Douglas would be the leader. Usually such revolts generate their own leaders whilst Douglas had no real connection to the area and OTL was reluctant to get involved in revolts such as Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry.

Finally, I think you're overestimating the financial capacity of France to pull this all off considering the financial crisis that intervention in Mexico brought OTL.
 
I think its an interesting timeline, and I'll be following it eagerly.

However, a couple of points:

I'm not sure I see the West Coast simply seceding over the trans-continental railway not being built. Why wouldn't they just find another source of funding? Or try later? Enough people wanted it OTL that it really was destined to be built in one form or another. Also, who are these settlers so keen to abandon the USA? Most settlers were happy with the homesteading acts of the Federal Government and were so scattered and dependent on Army Forts that they needed Washington. I mean, there were only 9000ish people in all Wyoming in 1870....

By the period you're talking about those Mormons interested in an independent state were a true minority - most were aware that working within the USA would make more sense and pushed instead for being their own state. Not that this causes huge problems given your POD that weakens Washington, but it does mean you need to think about where a Mormon state sees its allies lie given that OTL they sent troops against the CSA. Also, by 1900 one in four residents of Utah was NOT of the LDS faith and there is little in your POD to prevent this migration. How do non-Mormons fit into Deseret?

I think you're vastly overestimating how a fractured USA, an independent Texas that OTL was floundering resource-wise by 1863, and other forces would overcome the Native Americans. Historically the Comanche and Sioux were not push-overs for a united USA and the five year time frame you have for pacifying the West seems extremely generous.

I think the slave revolt was realistically handled, but I'm not sure Frederick Douglas would be the leader. Usually such revolts generate their own leaders whilst Douglas had no real connection to the area and OTL was reluctant to get involved in revolts such as Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry.

Finally, I think you're overestimating the financial capacity of France to pull this all off considering the financial crisis that intervention in Mexico brought OTL.

I view the western secession as a compromise measure by the pro Northern and pro Southern settlers and population to put the problems of the East behind them. That and post war bitterness blues. Losing the war would be pretty traumatic, as much as or perhaps more so than the trauma that the South suffered in OTL. As to the Indians... in the end it was slaughtering the buffalo that really did it, and one thing Americans are good at is shooting things. One way or another starvation will break them, as it did in OTL.

Douglas I picked as a familiar face as it were.

If the French capture the Mexican silver mines they go a long way toward paying for their entanglement.

As to the Mormons, the fact that the American military governor in Utah kept a cannon pointed at the Tabernacle during much of the Civil War really did happen. There was some bitterness even after his superiors ordered him to knock it off. Most of the gentile settlement came with the TransContinental Railroad and for most of the 19th Century was limited to towns people in Salt Lake City. "Men to Match My Mountains" (a classic on the settlement of the Great Basin) is pretty good about the Mormon settlement of Utah
 
I view the western secession as a compromise measure by the pro Northern and pro Southern settlers and population to put the problems of the East behind them. That and post war bitterness blues. Losing the war would be pretty traumatic, as much as or perhaps more so than the trauma that the South suffered in OTL. As to the Indians... in the end it was slaughtering the buffalo that really did it, and one thing Americans are good at is shooting things. One way or another starvation will break them, as it did in OTL.

Douglas I picked as a familiar face as it were.

If the French capture the Mexican silver mines they go a long way toward paying for their entanglement.

As to the Mormons, the fact that the American military governor in Utah kept a cannon pointed at the Tabernacle during much of the Civil War really did happen. There was some bitterness even after his superiors ordered him to knock it off. Most of the gentile settlement came with the TransContinental Railroad and for most of the 19th Century was limited to towns people in Salt Lake City. "Men to Match My Mountains" (a classic on the settlement of the Great Basin) is pretty good about the Mormon settlement of Utah

I agree regarding the Mormons, although any surviving Deseret will still need to deal with an influx on non-LDS settlers railway or not (and will need railways itself to survive long term).

I think the French really would need more than Mexican silver mines to do what you have them doing (and you've glossed over the HUGE internal problems Napoleon III faced OTL) but its a plausible enough change.

But I'm less convinced by the West. Yes there were some Southern settlers but OTL they were a significant minority and I just find it hard to see pro-Union states splitting away so readily post-1864 even with a defeat (which wouldn't have been anywhere near as traumatic IMHO - as there would have been none of the property or personal damage that the South suffered IOTL in the West).

Plus I still think you underestimate the Native Americans. It was nowhere near as simple as just an issue of Buffalo and native groups represented significant problems for a unified USA that surrounded them on both sides OTL. Opposition continued well into the 1880s. In this scenario, I think the various factions would be more inclined to use the natives as buffers or clients to shield each other. At least until they wanted the land. You might actually see various groups prop up certain tribes.

But as I say, an interesting timeline that I'll be following!
 
Interesting TL; I'll be watching this. However, a few points:
-McClellan's loss of most of the country means there's no earthly way another Democrat gets elected president in 1868. I think you're much more likely to see new parties emerge, since both Democrats and Republicans will be perceived as having failed spectacularly. I'd look for the radical Republicans to form their own party, and there will potentially be several variations of the "stabbed in the back" theory surfacing. A Radical president in 1868 will also make it easier for the U.S. government to fund the Louisiana rebels directly. You can still make Hancock president eventually, but doing it some time in the 1870s might make more sense.
-With the U.S. splintering, the Canadian federation might not happen, as there are a lot of internal tensions that got glossed over for fear of the possibility of a fenian raid. If a united dominion happens, it'll probably be much later ITTL.
-Pacific Union sounds... kind of modern and post-cold war as a name for a country. Republic of California, Republic of Cascadia or something like that feels more likely.

Anyway, looking forward to this.
 
Interesting TL; I'll be watching this. However, a few points:
-McClellan's loss of most of the country means there's no earthly way another Democrat gets elected president in 1868. I think you're much more likely to see new parties emerge, since both Democrats and Republicans will be perceived as having failed spectacularly. I'd look for the radical Republicans to form their own party, and there will potentially be several variations of the "stabbed in the back" theory surfacing. A Radical president in 1868 will also make it easier for the U.S. government to fund the Louisiana rebels directly. You can still make Hancock president eventually, but doing it some time in the 1870s might make more sense.
-With the U.S. splintering, the Canadian federation might not happen, as there are a lot of internal tensions that got glossed over for fear of the possibility of a fenian raid. If a united dominion happens, it'll probably be much later ITTL.
-Pacific Union sounds... kind of modern and post-cold war as a name for a country. Republic of California, Republic of Cascadia or something like that feels more likely.

Anyway, looking forward to this.

regarding Pacific Union... reverse those words and you get the Union Pacific railroad. I considered other options, particularly Cascadia. However California was out (Oregon would object), while Cascadia is out (California would object). Californians and Oregonians frequently do not see eye to eye (a long history of it too!). I also considered something involving the Rockies but in the end I decided that as the focus on this new country is toward the Pacific, and Union has a certain magic to it (in terms of familiarity in that era) Pacific Union it is

I didn't give a lot of thought to Canada in the original writing, but I will look at it. I am open to suggestions regarding the future of Canada in this situation

I did spend a lot of time on the various US elections though. Both parties are indeed looking at failure, and thus both are fractured, but in the end I decided the Hancock, who is a war hero and very charismatic according to history would win by enough to overshadow McClellan's failure (and his war record too for that matter) and Hancock would attract the votes of the veterans. Colfax didn't have either the charisma or war record, which is why there is no President Colfax in OTL. However figure the Republicans still have a lot of power, particularly in New England, which would be their stronghold, enough to ensure that the US government looks the other way or actively helps in supporting Louisiana. The Democrats would have the Presidency and the House, but the Republicans would still control the Senate. As to third parties, they will be along soon enough.
 
The Eight Nations of America
The Civil War in the United States, fought 1861 – 1870 and the division of that former nation into 6 nations was the critical event of the second half of the 19th Century. Those six nations along with Canada and Mexico formed the community of nations in North America well into the 20th Century. (SNIP) .

edited a bit, decided that the Pacific Union gets a bit less territory, the US keeps a bit more, Texas will be somewhat different (gets Arkansas, loses New Mexico), the Confederacy loses Arkansas, Kentucky, western Maryland, but the US loses Baltimore and eastern Maryland and DC is untenable as a capital. Mormons remain as is

as to the Plains Indians... they were defeated by wiping out the Buffalo and by winter campaigns by the US cavalry that attacked their villages during the winter, burning their winter stores and killing their ponies. The Plains Indians were terrible about security. Even Custer surprised them while they camped. Although in his case there were simply too many of them.
 
Last edited:
with Arkansas in the Lone Star Republic, a direct rail connection from Missouri to central Texas can be built, which will be useful for transporting all those longhorns by the mid 1870s (and ending the cattledrives)
 
As a Californian, the Pacific Union is literally the perfect place to have a country.

You should have it extend to the Rockies because I'm a Caliwanker.
 
As a Californian, the Pacific Union is literally the perfect place to have a country.

You should have it extend to the Rockies because I'm a Caliwanker.

originally i did, but further research makes it pretty clear that Wyoming, Colorado and Montana are logically part of the US due to the Missouri River transportation route (to very nearly the edge of Montana) and easier approach for rail

and the mining products are all going east by wagon, then rail and steamboat, and thus they are economically part of the East. The Great Basin is the bigger geographical divide in terms of economic development. For the northern part of the area, the headwaters of the Snake River at at Yellowstone (edge of Wyoming) so Idaho and points west are naturally part of the western economic zone.

New Mexico went to California because of the California Column during the Civil War and its role in beating up Indians, plus New Mexico would hate being part of Texas
 
23star.gif




The United States 1866- 1876
The first year of the McClellan Administration is a disaster. The secession of California and Nevada, taking with them vast wealth in terms of gold and silver, triggers a massive economic panic as the value of the Greenback and US bonds plunge. To add fuel to this disaster, the McClellan Administration also demobilizes, slashing ships and regiments from the Navy and Army,, and canceling military contracts in a determined effort to slash government spending. By 1867, the United States is in the worst financial depression it would suffer in the 19th Century. Congress finally acts forcefully, permanently ending the secession threat, dealing with the question of Black Americans and citizenship, and creating an income tax to guarantee a stronger tax base less reliant on tariffs (authors note: the 13th, 14th, 15th and 16th Amendments as historically written) in spite of McClellan's objections.. Also helpful are large orders for durable goods from the Pacific Union and Texas, grain exports to Central America to feed the French, Spanish and their colonial forces in Central America and Congress forcing through sharp increases in military spending as fighting continues in the South and occasionally spills north as well as continued fighting on the Great Plains as the great Indian uprisings that started during the Civil War continue manages to halt the slide.

Indeed as both parties join forces to impeach McClellan, they manage to restore some confidence that the political parties are still worthy of support. His resignation just before the trial in March 1868 and Vice President Pendleton's fine caretaker efforts during the next few months also help restore faith in the parties. Pendleton also makes possible the victory by Hancock, a man well respected by Union veterans and strongly supported by the Grand Army of the Republic Veterans organization and for the Democratic Party. Former Vice President and later Senator Pendleton would later serve in the Hancock Administration and his civil service reforms laid the groundwork for the modern civil service and ended the old spoils system.



The Hancock years 1869 – 1877
President Hancock pushes through Congress a defense bill that expands the Regular Army to 75,000 men, and Navy (and Marines) to 35,000 men and an authorized strength of 150 warships, with most of the wartime fleet to be replaced. Recruiting is easy, as many men are desperate for a job, any job, even a job in the Army or Navy. An increase in pay is also authorized so that officers and non commissioned officers have an easier time living on their pay. The Defense Act also creates large numbers of orders for weapons while orders for nearly 80 warships to replace worn out or unsuitable older ships creates jobs in shipbuilding, the steel mills and many other industries. Modernization and expansion of the defenses of Saint Louis (and its vital control of the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers), as well as the coastal defenses of New York City, Philadelphia, Boston, Portsmouth, and Providence also created many jobs and required many orders for guns and other equipment.

While there is opposition to this massive increase in government spending to nearly wartime levels, the continued fighting in the Confederacy as it dealt with its own civil war, the invasion of Central America by the Franco-Spanish (as well as Hispaniola), and strong pressure by some manufacturers desperate for orders keeps defense spending high for the next 20 years.

Hancock also pushes through funds for railroad lines to Denver, Cheyenne, and Montana, which really means some significant land give aways in Kansas, eastern Colorado, and in the Dakota Territory, but results in railroad lines from the Pacific Union and careful negotiation with the Mormons linking the United States and Pacific Union by rail by 1874 at Salt Lake City and Provo and in 1878 the Great Northern Railroad Line.

The Hancock Administration fought and subdued the Plains tribes in a series of wars 1869-1878 that at its peak saw 10 cavalry regiments and 6 infantry regiments deployed in forts and active campaigns, and involved several fierce battles. The worst defeat was the loss of Colonel Custer and much of the 7th Cavalry at Little Big Horn, but the Nez Perce but up a very effective fight as well. The mass slaughter of the Buffalo, as well as the spread of the railroads and the settlers that came with them did nearly as much as the Army in finally breaking the Indians and reducing them to wards of the US government confined to reservations. One major windfall of this is the discovery of gold in the Black Hills of Dakota, which will eventually lead to the development of the Homestake Mine which will eventually produce 20 million ounces of gold. By the 1880s $4 million in silver and $3 million in gold will be coming out of the Black Hills, which will do wonders to improve the value of the US Dollar.

The other major accomplishment was the complete removal of the United States government from Washington DC, which was stripped of records and indeed many of the buildings themselves were removed brick by brick, and the establishment of a new national capital at a new Federal District a few miles east of Chicago on Lake Michigan. The State of Indiana loses Lake County, and the new city, Columbia (authors note: what we know as Gary, Indiana, which did not exist until later in the century), is built between 1869-1876, with a massive celebration held in Chicago and Columbia on July 4, 1876.


By the Centennial Celebration the United States has recovered economically from the Civil War and is by far the giant in terms of its economy, military power and population in North America.

The election of 1876 is a relatively routine affair, as Hancock refuses to consider a third term, citing George Washington, and Rutherford Hayes, a Republican wins comfortably in the general election against Samuel Tilden from the Democrats, as the citizens of the United States decide to give the Republicans another chance.


The States of the United States 1876

Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Potomac (authors note: the eight northern and western counties of Maryland), Delaware, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Huron (authors note: Northern Michigan), Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, West Virginia, Nebraska, and in 1876, Colorado. The territories of North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming and Montana are on the road to statehood. The flag has 23 stars as of 1876
 
Last edited:
The Republic of Texarkana

th



The Republic of Texarkana
The Republic of Texas formed in 1867 after it seceded from the Confederacy in response to demands for troops while it was dealing with its own problems with the Comanche and raiders crossing the Rio Grande from Mexico. It was joined by the 5 Nations of the Indian Territory and Arkansas soon after for similar reasons and mutual commercial interests. Financial assistance from France and the British Empire, along with quick recognition from the United States and the European powers followed, although in the case of the United States it seems to be a matter of spite at the Confederacy and desire by the Railroads to extend a rail road line from Saint Louis through Arkansas into central Texas to take advantage of the Texas beef trade. Indeed for the first few years of the existence jobs building the railroad and driving the nearly 5 million cattle from central and south Texas into Arkansas and later to the rail head as it moved south generated a lot of cash for the Texas economy which was struggling to shift from cotton production to something that did not require large numbers of slaves.

In spite of the fact that 150,000 former slaves leave Texas for Louisiana, the population of Texarkana grows considerably during this period as nearly 100,000 Whites flee Louisiana for points north and west, and nearly 200,000 people immigrate from the Confederacy and from Europe to the new Republic to take advantage of cheap land and to get a new start. Of the former slave population, tight restrictions soon mean that most move to the port cities of Galveston and Indianola where there are jobs at the ports, or move south to the Rio Grande Valley which is highly encouraged by the Republic. While Blacks have voting rights only in the South Texas, they are allowed to own property and receive reasonable pay and live in official safety in Galveston and the other ports.

The Republic is organized into the states of Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas and South Texas, with the territories of Pecos and Washita which are west of the Pecos (for Pecos) or carved out the Texas Panhandle and western Oklahoma (for Washita). The town of Texarkana which is on the border of Texas and Arkansas, and very close to Oklahoma is made the national capital, while the towns of Austin, Little Rock, Corpus Christi, and Muskogee are the state capitals, and the city of El Paso and Lawton (authors note: next to Fort Sill in OTL) are the territorial capitals.


Texarkana has a government identical to that of the United States and has also incorporated a provision outlawing secession. Black immigration is not permitted but unlike the Confederacy the Texarkana Republic has official and reasonably good relations with the Black majority nation to its east, and it cooperated with the United States and Pacific Union during the Indian Wars with the Plains and Southwestern tribes such as the Comanche, Cheyenne and Apache. It also has friendly relations with the Franco-Austrian Empire of Mexico to its south and polices its border to prevent arms smuggling and attacks on the occupiers of Mexico from its soil. The Texarkana Republic has conscription, and a significant sized army but only a few gunboats which serve as revenue cutters.

By the 1880s, the extension of railroads to the Rio Grande Valley leads to the development of a significant export trade in citrus fruit and vegetables by rail to the United States. This trade, along with the Beef trade and export of large amounts of wheat and some cotton make up the bulk of the Republics exports and while not rich, the Republic is reasonably economically prosperous by the 1880s and has recovered from the Civil War. The destruction of the Buffalo and fierce combat have eliminated the threat from the Plains Indians with most confined to reservations in Washita.
 
Last edited:
this project continues, but my other project has been eating most of my free time lately

the other nations will be posted as time allows... next up will be the Pacific Union which hopefully will be coming reasonably soon
 
Top