Der Wüstengott (The Desert God)-- A BW/OKH Joint TL

Chapter 1: Exit Aukkie, Enter Gott

In the middle of 1942, things were starting to look good for the Allies. Although much of Europe was still under the Nazi jackboot, the surprise attack on Pearl Harbour had brought the U.S.A. into the war on the Allied side to aid in their quest to liberate Europe. It would, however, take some time before American forces could be seen fighting in Europe. In the East, the Soviet Union was holding her own with the help of American Lend Lease equipment against the relentless hordes of the Wehrmacht. Britain too, was fighting for her life in the deserts of North Africa as Panzerarmee Afrika, under the command of Generaloberst Erwin 'The Desert Fox' Rommel, threatens to roll into Egypt after the debacle that was Gazala.

Rommel_Adjutnant.jpg

Rommel conferring with one of his officers about this next move

Having sacked Neil Ritchie as the commander of the Eighth Army after the Battle of Gazala, General Claude Auchinleck was now it's de facto commander. As CinC Middle east, he could do that; the 8th was the only army under his command and it was in a dire need of a commanding officer. There was nothing he could do to reverse the situation. For now, the only hope he had of saving the Eighth Army to fight another day was to employ delaying tactics while withdrawing a further 100 miles or more east to near El Alamein on the Mediterranean coast. Only 40 miles to the south of El Alamein, the steep slopes of the Qattara Depression ruled out the possibility of armour moving round the southern flank of his defenses and limited the width of the front he had to defend.

auchinleck.jpg

The fate of the North African campaign now rests on Auchinleck's shoulders

These delaying actions fought by Auchinleck took place at Mersa Matruh on 26th and 27th June and at Fuka on the 28th. Communication breakdown and poor coordination had caused widespread confusion among the troops, leading to one division destroyed and forty tanks captured along with an enormous quantity of supplies. The chaos that resulted from the rout spread as far as Cairo, where personnel from British headquarters, rear echelon units, and the British Embassy frantically burned confidential papers in anticipation of the entry of Axis troops into the city. This was referred to as 'Ash Wednesday'. Furthermore, the rout at Mersa Matruh created problems in Auchinleck's defence arrangements, namely the scattering of X Corps.

To remedy these problems, he ordered XXX Corps (1st South African, 50th and 10th Indian Infantry Divisions) to take the coastal sector on the right of the front and XIII Corps (New Zealand and 5th Indian Divisions) to be on the left. The remains of 1st and 7th Armoured Divisions were to be held as a mobile army reserve. His intention was the fixed defensive positions should canalize and disorganize the enemy's advance while mobile units would attack their flanks and rear. The British defences at El Alamein was made up of several "boxes" (localities with dug-outs and surrounded by minefields and barbed wire), the most developed being around the railway station at Alamein. Most of the "line", however, was just open, empty desert.

250px-1stAlameinBritDefense.jpg

The British stand vigilant, ready to fight for King and country.

While things were looking very dismal for the British, Rommel has several problems of his own. Panzerarmee Afrika was exhausted and understrength. He had driven them forward ruthlessly, being confident that, provided he struck quickly before Eighth Army had time to settle, his momentum would take him through the Alamein position and he could then advance to the Nile with little further opposition. Supplies remained a problem because the Axis staff had originally expected a pause of six weeks after the capture of Tobruk. While captured supplies proved useful, water and ammunition were constantly in short supply while shortage of transport impeded the distribution of the supplies that they did have.

Rommel's plan was for the 90th Light Division and the two Afrika Korps armoured divisions to penetrate the Eighth Army lines between the Alamein box and Deir el Abyad (which he believed was defended). 90th Light was then to veer north to cut the coastal road and trap the Alamein box defenders (which he thought was occupied by the remains of 50th Infantry Division) and the Afrika Korps would veer right to attack the rear of XIII Corps. An Italian division was to attack the Alamein box from the west and another was to follow 90th Light. Italian XX Corps was to follow the Afrika Korps and deal with the Qattara box while the Italian Littoro Armoured Division and German reconnaissance units would protect the right flank.

Rommel made his first move and attacked on July 1st. The British line near El Alamein was not overrun until the evening, stalling the advance. Rommel then decided to concentrate his forces in the north on the next day, intending to break through around El Alamein. Auchinleck ordered a counter-attack at the centre of the German line but the attack failed. The British also attacked in the south and were more successful against the Italians. Because of these turn of events, Rommel decided to regroup and defend the line reached. Another British attack was carried out on July 10 at Tel el Eisa in the north and over one thousand prisoners were taken. Rommel's counterattack at Tel el Eisa achieved little.

With these successes, Auchinleck decided to attack again in the centre at the Ruweisat Ridge in two battles - the First and Second Battles of Ruweisat on July 14 and July 21. Neither battle was succcessful and the failure of armour to reach the infantry in time at the Second Battle led to the loss of 700 men. Despite this another two attacks were launched on July 27. The first in the north at Tel el Eisa was a moderate failure. The other at Miteiriya was more chaotic, as the minefields were not cleared and the infantry was left without armour support when faced with a German counter-attack. The fighting had drained the Eighth Army, and by July 31 Auchinleck ordered an end to offensive operations and the strengthening of the defences to meet a major counter-offensive courtesy of Panzerarmee Afrika.
elalamein11bl.jpg

The First Battle of El Alamein had successfully halted the toboggan that was Panzerarmee Afrika

The First Battle of El Alamein had thus ended, it's result a stalemate. However, but the Axis advance on Alexandria (and then Cairo) was halted. Still, Winston Churchill, Prime Minister of Britain, was not satisfied with the progress that Auchinleck was making. In early August Winston Churchill and General Alan Brooke, the British Chief of the Imperial General Staff visited Cairo on their way to meet Joseph Stalin in Moscow. They decided to replace Auchinleck, appointing XIII Corps commander Lieutenant-General William 'Strafer' Gott to the Eighth Army command and General Sir Harold Alexander as C-in-C Middle East Command.

gott.jpg

Lieutenant-General William 'Strafer' Gott as a Lieutenant Colonel

A big man with an aggressive, outgoing personality, Gott was popular with soldiers under his command. His nickname, Strafer, was not only a pun on the German phrase "Gott strafe England' but also an indicator to his personality. However, he was considered by some to be out of depth as a senior commander. Gott's aggressive and somewhat impetuous personality appealed to Churchill, who wanted the Eighth Army rampaging across North Africa.

It should be interesting to note that when Gott flew into El Alamein from Cairo to assume command of the Eighth Army, a massive sandstorm swept over the north-eastern end of Cyrenaica and parts of Egypt adjacent. This grounded all Luftwaffe flights in North Africa. German meteorologists had failed to predict this onslaught of nature and as a result, many planes that were out in the airfields preparing for take off had to be struck off the operational list for maintenance as sand had gotten into their engines. This was a precursor of the events that would follow later in the year.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Comments and critique are very much welcome.

EDIT:

Note: In OTL, a schwarm from 5/JG27 spotted the Bristol Bombay carrying Gott to his new command in El Alamein. Oberfeldwebel Emil Clade was credited with forcing the Bombay down onto the desert sands, while fellow fighter pilot Bernd Schneider delivered the killing blow to Gott.
 
Last edited:
Operation Toronto (Chapter 2)

British Middle East HQ July 1942 Cairo Egypt

William Gott was a man of action. He was cut from much the same cloth as Rommel himself, a true desert armored warrior. He had risen from command of a Brigade to a Corps in just 8 short months. While some in the Imperial General Staff thought he was out of his depth especially now that he had been elevated to command the entire 8th Army, the truth of the matter was he just hadn't had a chance to find himself yet (even Rommel's first battles as a division, corps, and army commander had their mistakes)

180px-GenRitchie.jpg

Gott studies his next move

Gott over the following weeks heard and read about the disaster of the Dieppe landings and the heavy casualties suffered by the 1st Canadian Division. (the losses were replaced quickly and division was brought back up to full strength and the men wiser for the experience). A visit by Prime Minister Winston Churchill after the 1st Battle of El Alamein gave him a welcome opportunity to propose a novel idea to coincide with his upcomming offensive.

Churchill and Gott watched as many of the desert warriors of the 8th army took a brief break from the laying of mines and digging of trenchs to bath in the sea.

Churchill: In my younger days serving in Africa such things were not allowed. It was thought that only the wearing of many layers would allow a man to survive in Africa
Gott: Things have changed they are all bronzed warriors now
Churchill: Thank god we have naval superiority or we could never do this and the men's spirits would decline
Gott: It's funny you should say that. I have been thinking about our naval superiority and ways for it to strengthen our counteroffensive
Churchill: The Royal Navy allready is set up for fire support missions against the coastal positions occupied by the Africa Corps
Gott: I had something else in mind
Churchill: Let us walk on the sand with some fine cigars and you'll tell me all about it
Gott: (whilst walking with the PM) My plan which the staff has codenamed operation Toronto would see the 1st Canadian Division and an additional tank brigade assigned to my theater. They would be held in Army Reserve.
Churchill: An extra exploitation force for the counterattack?
Gott: No, I would withhold them from the battle until the Africa Corps started to crack and retreat. Once our observation forces (armored cars, and planes) detected the begining of the retreat the 1st Canadian Division and the tank brigade would land in and around Tobruk severing Jerry's supply lines and eventually linking up with the 8th Army
Churchill: Well it can't go worse than Dieppe.
Gott: Tobruk is defended by less than a battalion and Cunningham has assured me that he will detail battleships and cruisers to provide the necessary fire support for the mission
Churchill: I must say Gott I like this plan. It is bold and it will catch Jerry flat footed. In combination with the Torch landings all of North Africa will be ours and then we will have a whole range of strategic options to threaten the Boche with

article-0-04ECB5E0000005DC-617_468x286.jpg

Winston surveys the desert ready for the British changeover to the offensive

Gott continued to gather and build his strength until the 8th army had nearly 200,000 men over 1000 tanks (including the new and deadly M-4 Sherman) and nearly 1000 artillery pieces. British air superiority was growing every day as the Luftwaffe was consumed at Stalingrad and unable to reinforce Africa further.

England's fast passenger liner Queen Elizabeth greatly aided in the transfer of the 1st Canadian division to Alexandria and fast transports akin to the previously famous tiger convoy brought in the reborn 4th tank brigade (although a U-Boat sank one of the transports reducing it to 160 tanks). The convoy ran the central med with little bother due good use of radio silence, several rain storms disrupting recon aircraft, and the Luftwaffe's total committment to the fight at Stalingrad.

By the middle of October Gott found himself ready to launch the decisive blow to create a string of victories for England not seen since Wellington

to be continued

your thoughts
 
Last edited:
I find the contents of the thread very interesting, but the German in the title is very probably wrong.
The German translation for "The Desert God" is "Der Wüstengott"
"The God of the Desert" = "Der Gott der Wüste"


"Die Wüste Gott" would translate as "The Gott Desert". Maybe in some alternate world there is a Gott desert which is called "Die Wüste Gott" by the alternate Germans, just as the real world Germans call the Gobi Desert "Die Wüste Gobi".
 
Farley Mowat in the desert! :eek: There will be some interesting books.

Maybe he could capture Rommel.

Waay cool. Consider me subscribed.
 
Farley Mowat in the desert! :eek: There will be some interesting books.

Maybe he could capture Rommel.

Waay cool. Consider me subscribed.
First reaction: :confused:What!?
Second reaction: Oh. Hmmm... Well, he might well CLAIM he captured Rommel:) (I like my dad's line that his books were much better with 'Truth' than with 'truth', i.e. that the individual facts might be... off, but that the broad picture is a good description.)
 
I hate to say it, but the thread's title gramatically screwed. What you probably mean is "Der Wüstengott". Wüste is grammatically feminine ("die"), but "Gott" is gramatically masculine, and so it's "der" Wüstengott. ;)
 
LOL, true enough. Mowat was indeed "loose with the facts".

Lost in the Barrens will probably be a whole new book though ITL.
 

Hyperion

Banned
Well if Gott goes on the command 8th army in Sicily, might he get along with Patton somewhat better is setting up a game plan to take the island?

Assuming the Germans have a similar sized force on the island as in OTL, though possibly some different units depending on what happens in the desert, it would definitely be a good thing for the Italian mainland if a lot of the German formations that escaped Sicily in OTL could be captured or otherwise destroyed.

Not that the Italian campaign in the end would not turn out to be the bloodbath that it was in OTL, but it might make the first couple of months somewhat easier.

With North Africa open sooner, will you show any of the effects that this might have against Japan. In OTL, the British kept a sizeable number of their carriers in the Med through 1943 and into 1944. With the Med basin cleared sooner, this might allow the British/Commonwealth to strengthen their forces in India, and possibly start sending some carriers to do harassment attacks on Japanese targets in Sumatra or somewhere.

Not enough to do any serious damage, at least early on, but it might give the British more experience, and force the Japanese to spread a few units out.

Or if you wanted to arrange a carrier attack on Singapore late in 1944 before the US retakes the Philippines.
 
I hate to say it, but the thread's title gramatically screwed. What you probably mean is "Der Wüstengott". Wüste is grammatically feminine ("die"), but "Gott" is gramatically masculine, and so it's "der" Wüstengott. ;)

I find the contents of the thread very interesting, but the German in the title is very probably wrong.
The German translation for "The Desert God" is "Der Wüstengott"
"The God of the Desert" = "Der Gott der Wüste"

"Die Wüste Gott" would translate as "The Gott Desert". Maybe in some alternate world there is a Gott desert which is called "Die Wüste Gott" by the alternate Germans, just as the real world Germans call the Gobi Desert "Die Wüste Gobi".

Gaaah!!! *repeatedly smashes head against a wall* I'm so sorry for the grammar error. It was my idea and I should have checked it out with a native German speaker. *SPOILER* I'll be using it later so thanks for the feedback *END SPOILER*

With North Africa open sooner, will you show any of the effects that this might have against Japan. In OTL, the British kept a sizeable number of their carriers in the Med through 1943 and into 1944. With the Med basin cleared sooner, this might allow the British/Commonwealth to strengthen their forces in India, and possibly start sending some carriers to do harassment attacks on Japanese targets in Sumatra or somewhere.

Not enough to do any serious damage, at least early on, but it might give the British more experience, and force the Japanese to spread a few units out.

Or if you wanted to arrange a carrier attack on Singapore late in 1944 before the US retakes the Philippines.

Hmm... Haven't really thought about that. Chances are, it may hasten the death of the IJN. Who knows? Maybe History will credit the RN and the USN in heralding the end of the IJN instead of the USN alone IOTL.

Just to ask, what effect will a carrier raid on Singapore have other than scaring the shit out the civillian population and the Japanese garrison? It won't really help strategically in the long run. For that, you need an invasion. Push Operation Zipper a few months backward if you may, but I'm still not sure of the strategic significance of this. The dry docks that could have serviced RN ships coming through were kaput and it would take some time to repair the damage, by which it would already be too late. As far as I can see, there's only propaganda value in retaking Singapore.
 

Hyperion

Banned
Gaaah!!! *repeatedly smashes head against a wall* I'm so sorry for the grammar error. It was my idea and I should have checked it out with a native German speaker. *SPOILER* I'll be using it later so thanks for the feedback *END SPOILER*



Hmm... Haven't really thought about that. Chances are, it may hasten the death of the IJN. Who knows? Maybe History will credit the RN and the USN in heralding the end of the IJN instead of the USN alone IOTL.

Just to ask, what effect will a carrier raid on Singapore have other than scaring the shit out the civillian population and the Japanese garrison? It won't really help strategically in the long run. For that, you need an invasion. Push Operation Zipper a few months backward if you may, but I'm still not sure of the strategic significance of this. The dry docks that could have serviced RN ships coming through were kaput and it would take some time to repair the damage, by which it would already be too late. As far as I can see, there's only propaganda value in retaking Singapore.

In mid to late 1944, after the US Navy stopped Japan at the Battle of The Philippines Sea, a number of Japanes warships, including at least two battleships and a number of cruisers, among other ships, fell back to the naval base and port facilities in and around Singapore.

Many of these ships would later go on the make up the southern force at the battle of Leyte Gulf, which was destroyed after several air attacks and running straight into a force of older US battleships and supporting cruisers and destroyers.

Have three or four British fleet carriers and a few escort carriers as backup launch a few attack on Singapore to knock out some Japanese ships and hit the airfields in the area after Philippines Sea, and maybe some of the ships that would have been involved at Leyte Gulf could be sunk here, or otherwise damaged to the point that they might not be able to fight.

As a result of no ships coming up from the south, some of the battleships and cruisers from the US fleet can be shifted north to engage the Yamato and other Japanese warships when they run into Taffy 3.
 
Chapter 3: End of the beginning

"Now this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning." -Winston Churchill, commenting on the Second Battle of El Alamein

On October 12th 1942, the wrath of God (yes, pun intended) fell upon Panzerarmee Afrika in the form of an artillery barrage. It was carefully planned so that all 882 guns from the Field and Medium batteries' first rounds would land across the entire 40-mile (64 km) front at the same time. After twenty minutes of heavy general bombardment, the guns switched to precision targets in support of the advancing infantry. The shelling plan continued for five and a half hours, by the end of which each gun had fired about 600 rounds.

It was the biggest artillery bombardment ever carried out during the course of the Second World War, though it would be a mere firecracker in the eyes of it's First World War predecessors. Other than shaking up the Germans, the bombardment had killed off General der Panzertruppe Georg Stumme, who stood in for Rommel while he was on sick leave. It had given him a heart attack from which he failed to recover.

At 10pm, Egyptian Summer time, 4 infantry divisions from XXX Corps advanced over the mines (the men did not weigh enough to trip the anti-tank mines) with the engineers following behind to clear a path for the tanks. This was twenty minutes after the first shells smashed into the German frontlines. By 2:00 AM the armored advance began, however progress was slow and traffic jams developed. The assault was supported by diversionary attacks to the south.

el-alamein-minefield.jpg

Sappers working to clear the mines while the wrath of Gott falls around them.

Taking control of the situation, Major-General Ritter von Thoma coordinated counterattacks against the advancing British infantry. Though their advance was bogged down, the British defeated these assaults and the first major tank engagement of the battle was fought. Having opened a six mile wide and five mile deep inroad into Rommel's position, Gott began shifting forces north to inject life into the offensive. Over the next week, the bulk of the fighting occurred in the north near a kidney-shaped depression and Tel el Eisa. Returning from sick leave on October 14, Rommel found his army stretched with only three days of fuel remaining.

Moving divisions up from the south, Rommel quickly found that they lacked the fuel to withdraw, leaving them exposed in the open. On October 15, this situation worsened when Allied aircraft sank a German tanker near Tobruk. Despite Rommel's hardships, Gott continued to have difficulty breaking through as Axis anti-tank guns mounted a stubborn defense. Two days later, Australian troops advanced northwest of Tel el Eisa towards Thompson's Post in an attempt to break through near the coast road. On the night of October 19, they succeeded in reaching road and repelled numerous enemy counterattacks.

After assaulting the Australians again with no success on October 21, Rommel began to concede that the battle was lost and began planning a retreat 50 miles west to Fuka. This was done with the consent of Hitler, who had earlier held Panzerarmee Afrika at El Alamein under his infamous 'stand and die' order issued to all Wehrmacht units. Seeing this through the eyes of recon units in the ground and in the air, Gott felt that the time was right to unleash the 1st Canadian Division and the 4th Armoured Brigade.

At 10:00 AM on October 22, the three cruisers and eight destroyers that made up Force T began shelling Tobruk in preparation for Operation Toronto. Fighters from the carrier Formidable were flying combat air patrol overhead to prevent an unlikely reprisal by the Luftwaffe. The first wave of troops moved in immediately after the forty-five minute shelling. Resistance in the town put up by the battalion-sized garrison was light and ended as fast as it begun. Once the town was taken, the Canadians took up blocking positions along the coastal road to prevent the movement of German resupply convoys along it. Meanwhile, the 4th Armoured Brigade was divided into two units. The smaller of the two units were left behind at Tobruk to act as an armoured reserve should anything go wrong. The rest of the Brigade sped off toward Fuka as part of a pincer movement that was to trap the Desert Fox.

0_2834a_76c7d47a_L.jpg

A convoy of Matilda IIs from the 4th Armoured Brigade heading towards Fuka from Tobruk. On their way there, they would lay waste to an Axis airfield at Gambut, destroying over 40 planes in the proces.

The next day, Gott launched Operation Supercharge with the goal of forcing the battle into the open and reaching Tel el Aqqaqir as well as forcing Rommel to commit to battle the last of his remaining supplies. Attacking behind an intense artillery barrage, the 2nd New Zealand Division and the 1st Armored Division met stiff resistance, as Rommel threw in his armored reserves in an attempt to hold out against the attack. In the resulting tank battle, the Germans lost over 100 tanks.

His situation hopeless, Rommel contacted Hitler and asked for permission to surrender. This was promptly denied and Rommel informed von Thoma that they were to stand fast. Hitler had given a promotion to Feldmarschall to Rommel in the hope that he would be able to break out. To make matters worse, he had learnt that a Canadian division had landed at Tobruk and had taken up blocking positions. They had also captured the surrounding airfields in the process, depriving him of air support. Due to relentless British attacks, Panzerarmee Afrika was reduced to about 7500 men and 20 tanks. Even more bad news turned up in the form of a report which informed Rommel that a hundred British tanks were coming in from the west of Fuka.


battle3.gif

Newly-promoted Feldmarschall Rommel realises that his game is up.

There was simply no way Rommel was able to break out of the crucible that Gott had trapped him in. Wanting to spare his command from further destruction, Feldmarschall Erwin Rommel surrendered on October 24, 1942. His command was the largest German command to be taken prisoner during the course of the war. This record would soon be broken by the capitulation of the Sixth Army, now fighting for his life at Stalingrad. Hitler expressed his anger through a Hitler rage during a staff meeting which infomed him of Rommel's unauthorised surrender and by having Rommel's wife and son imprisoned until the end of the war.

Gott, on the other hand, earned a new nickname and a knighthood in the aftermath of the battle. The nickname, "Der Wüstengott (The Desert God)", was so called because of a number of factors. One, the sandstorm that occured on the day that Gott took command sent rumors flying around that Gott had the ability to control the weather. More rumors upgraded Gott's status to 'god-like' after he predicted through ULTRA, which was still unknown to the Germans, that Rommel would attack at Alam El Halfa and went on to take it apart. That and the fact that it made good wordplay earned Gott the nickname of 'The Desert God'.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

To be continued...

Comments and critique are actively (to a small extent) solicted
 
Last edited:
In mid to late 1944, after the US Navy stopped Japan at the Battle of The Philippines Sea, a number of Japanes warships, including at least two battleships and a number of cruisers, among other ships, fell back to the naval base and port facilities in and around Singapore.

Many of these ships would later go on the make up the southern force at the battle of Leyte Gulf, which was destroyed after several air attacks and running straight into a force of older US battleships and supporting cruisers and destroyers.

Have three or four British fleet carriers and a few escort carriers as backup launch a few attack on Singapore to knock out some Japanese ships and hit the airfields in the area after Philippines Sea, and maybe some of the ships that would have been involved at Leyte Gulf could be sunk here, or otherwise damaged to the point that they might not be able to fight.

As a result of no ships coming up from the south, some of the battleships and cruisers from the US fleet can be shifted north to engage the Yamato and other Japanese warships when they run into Taffy 3.

Sounds good, I'll consider it.

Very good, keep it up. What happens to Torch now?

Even though I contribute to this TL, I'm not really sure about that.

My guess is this: It will still go on since the invasion fleet was in the Atlantic when Gott crushed the remnants of Panzerarmee Afrika. The Amerians will land, yes. They will only encounter light resistance put up by the Vichy French and nothing else. This will make the Americans overconfident. We all know that in OTL, this overconfidence was crushed at the rout at Kasserine Pass. The fall of the Afrika Korps butterflied this away. Without the Kasserine Pass falure to learn from, I anticipate that the Americans would get screwed one way or another at Sicily.

Still, if that does not happen, I fear for the Americans in Italy. They would then be under the command of Mark Clark, who was foolish enough to allow an entire army to escape just to capture Rome intact (Perhaps Roman history buffs wouldn't consider him a fool, yes?). Chances are, he would be foolish enough to fall into a German trap.
 

Hyperion

Banned
Sounds good, I'll consider it.



Even though I contribute to this TL, I'm not really sure about that.

My guess is this: It will still go on since the invasion fleet was in the Atlantic when Gott crushed the remnants of Panzerarmee Afrika. The Amerians will land, yes. They will only encounter light resistance put up by the Vichy French and nothing else. This will make the Americans overconfident. We all know that in OTL, this overconfidence was crushed at the rout at Kasserine Pass. The fall of the Afrika Korps butterflied this away. Without the Kasserine Pass falure to learn from, I anticipate that the Americans would get screwed one way or another at Sicily.

Still, if that does not happen, I fear for the Americans in Italy. They would then be under the command of Mark Clark, who was foolish enough to allow an entire army to escape just to capture Rome intact (Perhaps Roman history buffs wouldn't consider him a fool, yes?). Chances are, he would be foolish enough to fall into a German trap.

Hold on a second there, this may very well not be the case.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunisia_Campaign#Western_Desert

As you can see, initial allied resistance from Axis forces in Tunisia did not come from Rommel.

The allies did not initially have enough troops to land in Tunisia during Operation Torch, so positions in Tunisia that should have been captured where left untaken, due to lack of forces, and American and British troops dealing with Vichy troops.

Also, here is what happened after the OTL battle.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_El_Agheila

The biggest change here is that you've knocked out all of Rommel's army, and destroyed or captured a lot more of his equipment and vehicles.

It will take the British a while to sort out their prisoners, but that will be better than chasing them across Libya.

The big differences will be if the Vichy government in North Africa learns of the total loss of the Africa Korps, and decides to switch sides sooner. This could see Vichy troops in Tunisia blocking Axis attempts to enter Tunisia, which would make things somewhat harder for the Germans and Italians.

The big thing also will be that if the British simply have to drive to Tunisia without any major running battles, they could probably get to and maybe even past the Mareth Line sooner, especially if any Vichy troops in the area agree to let them pass.

The alternative would be that Rommel decides to throw in the towel in Africa and simply pull what few troops that are left to Sicily and Italy.

As for Italy, remember, as you have still moved up the timetable for operatiosn by several months, and have a change in British leadership, general Clark and a lot of the units that made up 5th Army may not be ready yet.

Instead, we might get Patton and the 7th Army, along with British 8th Army, going into Italy instead, mainly because a lot of troops that would have initially formed 5th Army might not be ready.

In fact, I don't even know when Clark was promoted or recommended for army command, he may not be the initial American commander in Italy anyway.
 
To Dust (Chapter 4)

Hitler's military HQ November 1942

For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yea, they have all one breath; so that a man hath no preeminence above a beast: for all is vanity. All go unto one place; all are of the dust, and all turn to dust again. -Ecclesiastes 3:19,20)

The Allies had landed all over French North Africa for operation Torch. Vichy forces were only offering token resistance as the Americans and British quickly approached the critical cities of Tunis and Bizertte. Hitler was still realing from the utter destruction of the Panzer Army Africa and the ongoing blood bath at Stalingrad. Field Marshal Keitel had asked him about sending more troops to Africa to reconstitute the DAK since there were only a few non motorized Italian formations in all of Libya and these were being quickly surrounded and overrun by Gott's victorious formations.

operation%20torch.jpg

American troops from Operation Torch storm on the beaches near Casablanca

What to do? Lenin's famous question:

Kesselring and others in the staff had called for sending the 10th Panzer Division and the elite 1st Parachute division to form a bridgehead along with air forces to delay the allies from overrunning all of Africa quickly. Hitler thought about it but everything he had sent to Africa had been lost and quickly. The situation at Stalingrad was getting worse and worse and the OKW/OKH only had 3 mechanized divisions in reseve (6th Panzer, 10th Panzer and 11th panzer with three more in the SS corps forming up Leibstandarte, Das Reich and Totemkempf that were still a month or two from being ready for comabt.) To send a third or more of available reserves to that sinkhole in Africa was just not a viable option especially when Kesselring was forced to admit that those 2 or 3 divisions and whatever Italy would committ would have to face the better part of 15 allied division who had total air and naval supremecy. The Italians and French will just have to hold what they can... Africa is lost to us

With that Hitler used the still organizing Leibstandarte and pair of other divisions to march into unoccupied France. He intended to capture the French fleet at Toulon but was frustrated when the sailors sank their vessels in the harbor.

Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-027-1451-10,_Toulon,_Panzer_IV.jpg

The French Fleet scuttles themselves to avoid capture by the Germans

By the end of November the western task forces from torch and Gott's victorious 8th army had linked up in Tunis and turned North Africa into an allied controlled zone. A planning confernce had taken place right as the fighting ended as the joint allied HQ under Eisenhower planned their next move. General George Patton who had emerged as the most energetic and aggressive American commander would command the 7th army and Gott's old desert hands with the 8th army would also be called on for what was to become operation Husky the invasion of Sicily.

Several of the more conservative British staff planners had called for both armies to land at Syracuse and the Gulf of Gela and to drive on Messina. Patton had felt the terrain in Sicily was too rough for this and called for the 7th Army to land at Palermo and the 8th Army to land at Syracuse and then to drive in a pincer towards Messina. Gott had his own ideas which he shared with Patton and Bedell Smith who was Eisenhower's deputy. Patton and Gott had met briefly and had developed a strong respect for each other's drive and ambition and certain healthy amount of one upsmanship was to mark the relationship for the years to come

Gott was the only son of a bitch in the British army that wanted to win the war right now. He knew what to do with those kraut bastards, grab 'em by the nose and kick 'em in the ass... although he couldn't articulate it as well as I could. I always liked him, I wish my army had a whole bunch of officers with his grasp for opportunity and victory.

patton-crop.jpg

George Patton and William Gott had a healthy rivalry and became the acknowledged allied experts on offensive maneuver warfare.

Patton was stunned when Gott one upped him with his idea for Husky. But the old tanker was just as much impressed by the decisiveness as he was by the boldness.

Why George should we land on Sicily and give the Germans a nice exit at Messina where they could ferry their troops off at night if we get too close to pushing them into the drink. I like your idea and want to expand it. Your plan leaves your 1st Infantry division and my 1st Canadian Division in reserve to be committed as needed to reinforce our success. I instead propose to load them up on warships like we did at operation Toranto and land them at Calabria on the toe of Italy so that Sicily is immediately isolated and we can trap whatever Jerry's or Italians are there and force their destruction or surrender.

Patton smiled... (this guy has balls, going to have to step up my game now that the Brits are becomming good at this) I love the idea general. Lets take this to Ike.

Eisenhower when presented with the unanimous support of the plan from both of the field generals who would command it consented and thus operation Husky was born.

Meanwhile over 1000 miles away the Soviet union had launched Operation Uranus and trapped the German 6th army in a huge kessel at Stalingrad. Generaloberst Paulus asked permission to break out but like Rommel a month before this permission was refused and Hitler ordered the army to defend it's positions at all costs. Hitler did however see the drastic emergancy that the 6th army was in and ordered Erich Von Manstein of the 11th Army to form a new task force (Army Group Don) to relieve the pocket.

Manstein was delayed by critical days in getting to his new headquarters due to the appaling weather conditions. He could at least be thankful that the Grofaz had ordered substantial reinforcements into the line to bolster his chances of saving Paulus. On the Chir river front he had a Luftwaffe field division, the full strength 336th infantry division and the 11th Panzer Division fresh from OKH reserve under the resourceful Hermann Balck. On the Askay front he had the 6th Panzer Division, 23rd Panzer Division, the 10th Panzer Division, 1st parachtute division, the 164th light division and a pair of Luftwaffe field divisions. Additional transport aircraft organic to the paratroopers were brought in to nourish the 6th Army from the air as Army Group Don advanced towards them.

Behind Manstein's army group they carried a great tail of 800 trucks full of 3000 tonnes of supplys ready to reinvigorate the 6th army and evacuate them from the area. Manstein was supremely frustrated by Hitler and Paulus' stubborn refusal to attack from the other direction to divert some of the Soviet forces away. Manstein was a realist he knew the 6th army couldn't stay in position or they would die... air supplies were insufficient and the weather and the hundreds of Red Air Force fighters circling over the city made supply extremely dangerous.




get.media





zakroczymfh2.jpg
Veteran troopers of the 10th Panzer Division set up a machine gun blocking position just 45kms from Stalingrad to keep Red Army Infantry away from their tanks​


Manstein's thrust with the 6th and 10th Panzer divisions made good progress completely shattering the 51st Soviet Army. In particular the tiger battalion attached to 10th Panzer enjoyed an auspicious debut scoring a knockout ratio of 8 to 1 on their first appearance in combat. Hasso Von Mantueffel, Conrad Von Hunersdorff, Franz Bake, Erhard Raus and other skilled panzer commanders moved the two armored divisions and the parachute division like lightening and crossed the Aksay river. Elements of the ringing divisions from the Kessel hurled themselves at this penetration but were stunned by the strength and skill of the German tank formations which were composed of numerous high velocity 75mm guns and the deadly 88mms on the tigers which knocked out t-34's from over 1500 meters.

Winter.jpg

6th Panzer Division on their way to relieve Stalingrad.

By the end of December Manstein wasn't sure how on earth he had done it but his army was within 5kms of the kessel and the JU-52's were bringing in enough food to make the link up a real possibility. On the following morning following an artillery barrage the 11th Panzer Regiment burst through a pair of Soviet rifle divisions and reached Stalingrad. The men of the 6th army were delerious and had given up hope. Officers had tried to encourage them and point out the sound of Manstein's guns. The supply tail surged through the lines and immediately began distributing food, fuel, ammunition and best of all warm winter clothes to the exausted 22 divisions of the 6th Army. Photos were taken which would make for excellent propaganda on the home front. There was talk of Manstein receiving the Grand Cross of the Iron Cross.

Manstein had every intention of waiting just a day or two so the men could be strengthened with full bellies and cartridge pouches and then evacuating Army Group Don and the 6th Army back towards the Aksay. Orders came in from Hitler to hold all positions which Manstein had no intention of following. However the decision had been taken out of his hands the following day.

Stalingrad_301655a.jpg

German infantry on their way to Stalingrad

Although Stalin and Zhukov had been concerned over the failure of operation Mars on the central front and the drive of Army Group Don into the Stalingrad kessel, Zhukov was fully convinced he was about to pull off the stunning achievement of the war.

Our of the winter fog the 2nd and 3rd Guards armies thundred across the Don River. Their opponents where the Italian 8th army who lacked good winter quarters and anti tank weapons capable of defeating a T-34. Their army was completely overrun as Operation Little Saturn took form. Under the command of the ruthless and agressive Vatuin the Guards armies stormed down the steppes with Rostov on the Don as their objective. Army Group A proved unable to transfer resources to this now torn open front because their forward units lacked fuel and the roads and rail lines in their sector were not sufficient to allow rapid movement.

Manstein's units were dangerously over extended at Stalingrad and would have to retreat hundreds of kilometers to even get to Rostov. Idealy the 11th Panzer Division on the Chir could have slowed them down however they had been completely exausted in their battle to draw off forces away from 6th and 10th Panzer. There was also command difficulty as this area was in the command sector of General Weich's (Army Group B) even though Manstein commanded all the formations. Manstein ordered all the troops out of Stalingrad immediately to fall back on Rostov as soon as possible. He also put out orders and directives for Army Group A in the caucuses to do the same.

Hitler was furious and countermanded Manstein's orders (which he promptly destroyed upon reading them. He had no intention of being a bootlicker like Rommel. This is my army group and god help me if we get out of this the Grofaz is more than welcome to shoot me



Manstein would not get the change to face Hitler's firing squad though. Little Saturn was an avalanche that couldn't be stopped by the remnants of Balck's understrength corps and try as Manstein might, his evacuation proved impossible. Leaving the city meant leaving cover and the 6th, 10th and 16th (from 6th Army) Panzer divisions were completely exausted by the trials of the last couple of weeks. The 3rd Guards army overran the primary airfields that were bringing in supplies to the Stalingrad area greatly increasing the threat to Army Group Don.

manstein8.jpg

Manstein after he relieved Stalingrad (although this was only temporary)

As Manstein's exausted 27 divisions pulled out of the city forces on the eastern bank of the Volga including the 61st and 62nd armies began an immediate crossing and tried to stom roll Manstein's exausted forces. Winter weather delayed their retreat as their rear guards were steadly overtaken by a mass of T-34's or immolated in artillery rocket strikes.

Time ran out and the 3rd Guards army rejoiced as they reached Rostov on the Don effectively cutting of Army Group Don and Army Group A

stalingrad-250.jpg

Soviet soldiers root out the small garison of Rostov

Manstein was stunned to hear that all the rail lines had been cut and that Rostov had fallen. It was all over. Rostov was still over 120 kilometers away and he only had fuel for 30 kilometers and only 71 servicable tanks left. This was one mirical the old Prussian Marshal couldn't pull off. Frozen on the steppes in the open there was no way his army could hold out for even a week due to the lack of shelter. The men had suffered enough. He sent represenatives through the lines to arrange terms with the 3rd Guards Army. Promises of food and safe transit were made as endless toasts were made at Vatuin's HQ. Manstein's final comminique marked the end of the old school Prussian warrior spirit commanding the German Army. From then on Hitler would only trust Nazi fanatics.

To the brave troops of Army Group Don CC: OKH

It is with a heavy heart that I that I must order you to lay down your arms. You have fought like lions and taken on nearly all the world. Your bravery and valor are unmatched and I find myself in your debt. In the face of superior numbers and a hopeless strategic situation I have found it best to spare lives so that one day Germany might rise again. May the lord be with you all.

Erich Von Manstein
Generalfeldmarshal
Army Group Don General order 43

Army Group South had been eliminated from the German order of battle. An unrecoverable blow. Zhukov's reserves had been exausted in the great endevor but now his possibilities were limitless. His mouth watered looking at his tactical maps.

to be continued...

your thoughts... sorry for the length but one doesn't try to do two parters in a cooperative tl :p
 
Wow, it´s an unlucky TL for Germany


The super stalingrad situation from little saturn was a very near miss for the russians in otl. in otl the 6th panzer division was able to pull away from the aksay and block the 3rd guards armies tank corps just long enough for formations of army group a to pull out of the caucuses and exist through rostov and for army group don to fall back.... by having them actually reach stalingrad they would be too far away to get into the fight before the 3rd guards army would reach rostov and cut them off and evacuating the city pulls the 6th army and army group don into the open where they would be at the mercy of soviet artillery and tanks
 

Hyperion

Banned
What German troops would be in Sicily right now? Given that the losses on the Eastern Front have been mitigated somewhat by a number of divisions and a massive amount of equipment not being lost or otherwise used up in Africa, this could have somewhat of a balancing effect in some areas.

The situation there would also be somewhat compensated by Manstein's initial successful entry into Stalingrad, which sounds like it did quite a bit of damage in and of itself.

The big difference will be the Italian front.


If the Italians bow out soon, I could see Sicily falling fairly quickly, especially if there aren't a lot of German troops there. The big advantage would be having troops on the Italian mainland a lot sooner, and cutting off a massive amount of troops and equipment, especially if German divisions are in Sicily.

If worst comes to worst, I could see Hitler throwing southern and central Italy away, and fortifying the Alps and northern parts of the country, as the allies would be insane to try and fight across the Alps.

For a D-Day operation, I would also think that Gott and a more flexible Patton might make better initial progress, especially at capturing Caen, thus giving allied fighter bombers bases in France to work from.

Now the other big differences will be political. In this scenario, even though the US and Russian are going to ultimately come stronger than Britain among the allied camp, Britain will likely come out with better standing, and a lot better off financially. Not that they aren't going to be in debt for years to come, but say $2.5 billion would be better than $3 billion.
 
Top