DBWI: The most ASB timeline of the 20th and 21st Centuries ever.

YLi

Alright AH.com, your job is to help me come up with the most ASB possible timeline for the 20th Century. It'll work like this, I suggest events that happen in the TL, and you tell me why they're completely ASB given our current timeline. Let's start off with the first 5.

1914: Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire is assassinated by a Serbian radical, thus precipitating World War I.

1917: Russian Revolution. Communists overthrow the Russian Czar

1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany

1945: Nuclear bombs are dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, effectively ending the Second World War.

9/11/2001: Al Qaida crashes several airplanes into the World Trade Centers and the Pentagon, killing nearly 3,000.

ooc: Basically, we're living in an Alternate History, and you have to tell me why OTL is now ASB.
 

Haggis

Pfft! Serbian nationalism, what type of shit is that? We all know that the Serbs gave up their nationalist strains in the 1820s when the First Greek Republic, in tandem with the Egyptian Republic of 98, marched into the Balkans and brought true civilization to them.

And a Russian Revolution? Those guys will never overthrow their tsar, no matter how many of his own people he kills in the building projects.

Hitler? Did you just throw together some Allemanic names? Maybe you meant Aloisa Hiedlerton, the Secretary of Defense for the Bavarian Co-Prosperity Sphere.

Where is Hiroshima and Nagasaki? They sound vaguely Jepangi.

al-Qaida? The student group in Lebanon that has been peacefully protesting the continued Ottoman presence in their homeland?
 

Douglas

YLi said:
1914: Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire is assassinated by a Serbian radical, thus precipitating World War I.
Click to expand...

The idea of a world war is preposterous...the world's economies would shut down. Our world has been too economically interdependent since the beginning of the 20th century to have anything close to a conflict that could be called a "world war".

1917: Russian Revolution. Communists overthrow the Russian Czar
Click to expand...

Haggis took care of this one. Next thing you'll be telling me in your TL is that Anarchists have taken over the Ottoman Empire...:rolleyes:

1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany
Click to expand...

Can't have a Germany unless you can get Prussia to democratize before the 1940 revolution splits it.

1945: Nuclear bombs are dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, effectively ending the Second World War.
Click to expand...

You need an early POD to get nuclear weapons before the OTL date of 1960.

9/11/2001: Al Qaida crashes several airplanes into the World Trade Centers and the Pentagon, killing nearly 3,000.
Click to expand...

Is that Arabic? Unlikely that such a group could exist without the Ottomans coming down very hard on it.
 
Mr_ Bondoc

Mr_ Bondoc

Obviously you have been reading too much H.G. Wells and Jules Verne, for my liking. But this seems a liitle far-fetched for several reasons.

YLi said:
Alright AH.com, your job is to help me come up with the most ASB possible timeline for the 20th Century. It'll work like this, I suggest events that happen in the TL, and you tell me why they're completely ASB given our current timeline. Let's start off with the first 5.

1914: Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire is assassinated by a Serbian radical, thus precipitating World War I.
Click to expand...

Considering that the Hapsburgh Dynasty's history of isolationism, wouldn't it be more likely that the assassination be seen as an internal affair, and in a worse case scenario a bloody civil war along ethnic and religious lines? Other than that, why would it involve other countries?

1917: Russian Revolution. Communists overthrow the Russian Czar
Click to expand...

Let me get this straight... Communism as described by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels describes a Socialist state emerging as a result of the abuses of an industrial state. Despite Czar Nicholas II's domestic policies, wouldn't a "Communist Revolution" take place in Great Britain, France, or Germany? If anything, Russia is more of a agrarian society backed by a absolute monarchy....

1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany
Click to expand...

This one is clearly silly. Adolf Hitler was one of the key artists of the Weimar School of Impressionism. Are you proposing that Pablo Picasso become the absolute dictator of Spain? Or how about Norman Rockwell as President?

1945: Nuclear bombs are dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, effectively ending the Second World War.
Click to expand...

Let me guess, Germany with its scientific geniuses and technical skill, decided to go to war with Japan... If anything, considering all of hte great physicists at the time period (e.g. Einstein, Planck, Schrodinger, et al.) were in Germany, this is the only logical conclusion...

9/11/2001: Al Qaida crashes several airplanes into the World Trade Centers and the Pentagon, killing nearly 3,000.

ooc: Basically, we're living in an Alternate History, and you have to tell me why OTL is now ASB.
Click to expand...
Why would America be involved in the affairs of the "Great Game". If anything, the affairs of the Ottoman Empire have been the purview of the states of Great Britain, France and Russia. As such, why would the Ottoman Empire attack the United States? Russia had up to 500,000 troops in the region until 1991, and Great Britain along with France have had permanent bases in the region since the 1700s. Surely those countries would be larger targets....
 

YLi

The next five:

1922: Mustafa Kemal takes power in the Republic of Turkey

1948: The nation of Israel is formed.

1949: Communists under Mao Zedong take control in China.

1969: The Americans land on the moon. Neil Armstrong's first line "One Small Step for Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind."

1974: President Richard Nixon resigns amidst the Watergate Scandal
 

NapoleonXIV

Banned
Assasinating Franz Ferdinand. "Uncle Franz" the most beloved leader of all time. What madman would do that?

The same in Russia, the people loved the little father, kindly Rasputin, tragic little Alexi. The whole world's hearts went out to brave and lovely Anastasia and the good job she did despite it all. It's the world's biggest fairy tale.

Adolf... How would a minor Bauhaus architect come to be in charge of a country??

Nuclear bombs on Japan?? Now I know you're mad. I reporting you for advocating genocide of probably the most innocuous and peaceful people in the world.

And then ARABS attack the US?? Our fastest friends and staunchest allies, whose cheap oil has kept America strong for 75 years?

That does it, I'm reporting this. ASB is one thing but this war crazy insanity is something else, no civilization could ever survive in the dystopia you're proposing here.
 

Mr. Evangelical

Banned
1914: Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire is assassinated by a Serbian radical, thus precipitating World War I.

1917: Russian Revolution. Communists overthrow the Russian Czar

1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany

1945: Nuclear bombs are dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, effectively ending the Second World War.

9/11/2001: Al Qaida crashes several airplanes into the World Trade Centers and the Pentagon, killing nearly 3,000.

ooc: Basically, we're living in an Alternate History, and you have to tell me why OTL is now ASB.
Click to expand...

1. Why would Serbia attack it's own country? After the democratization of the country in 1867, all ethnicities were treated equally there. Serbia joined as a province in 1900. And Franz Ferdinand was just a famous actor from the country, never into A-H politics.

2. The Czar would never be taken down. There was no man to lead any revolution. Besides, people were happy with the Czar. (Lenin is OTL Conservative in this one)

3. You mean that artist popular in the Weimar Republic of Germany? He was also apolitical and didn't care about politics. He was more concerned with his art and helping out his rabbi.

4. First of all, there was never any world war. Second of all, Nuclear weapons weren't made until 1954.

5. Al-Qaida? What the hell is that? It sounds Arabic. But The Ottomans are allies of The Americans, due to trade. why attack a trading partner?
 

Emperor Qianlong

Mr. Evangelical said:
1. Why would Serbia attack it's own country? After the democratization of the country in 1867, all ethnicities were treated equally there. Serbia joined as a province in 1900. And Franz Ferdinand was just a famous actor from the country, never into A-H politics.

2. The Czar would never be taken down. There was no man to lead any revolution. Besides, people were happy with the Czar. (Lenin is OTL Conservative in this one)

3. You mean that artist popular in the Weimar Republic of Germany? He was also apolitical and didn't care about politics. He was more concerned with his art and helping out his rabbi.

4. First of all, there was never any world war. Second of all, Nuclear weapons weren't made until 1954.

5. Al-Qaida? What the hell is that? It sounds Arabic. But The Ottomans are allies of The Americans, due to trade. why attack a trading partner?
Click to expand...

OOC: There's a serious inconsistency there. How would there have been a Weimar Republic if there wasn't WWI. Also, without WWII it would probably never have been called Weimar. Just a nitpick... ;)
 

Theodoric

YLi said:
The next five:

1922: Mustafa Kemal takes power in the Republic of Turkey

1948: The nation of Israel is formed.

1949: Communists under Mao Zedong take control in China.

1969: The Americans land on the moon. Neil Armstrong's first line "One Small Step for Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind."

1974: President Richard Nixon resigns amidst the Watergate Scandal
Click to expand...

1: Wasn't he one of those secularist republicans? Pah, I could never see this happening, with the Ottoman Empire resurging the way it did at the time. Secularism was doomed anyway; there's a reason the capital was named 'Islambol'.

2. The Ottoman Empire would never have allowed this to happen. I mean, in order for the Zionists to win, they needed to have the support of England or the US, and both were in no state to challenge the Ottomans in the region.

4. The Ottomans would never have anyone else land on the Moon, especially not the Americans, of all people. They could never have built the rockets in the first place, with the naval blockades. (OOC: Note I didn't say who was blocking whose harbours)
 
Last edited:

Mr. Evangelical

Banned
OOC: There's a serious inconsistency there. How would there have been a Weimar Republic if there wasn't WWI. Also, without WWII it would probably never have been called Weimar. Just a nitpick... ;)
Click to expand...

OOC: Shit, just call it Germany. I put that there by mistake.

1922: Mustafa Kemal takes power in the Republic of Turkey

1948: The nation of Israel is formed.

1949: Communists under Mao Zedong take control in China.

1969: The Americans land on the moon. Neil Armstrong's first line "One Small Step for Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind."

1974: President Richard Nixon resigns amidst the Watergate Scandal
Click to expand...


1. You mean the Jewish guy? During that time, only Muslims could be in power in The Ottoman Empire. Remember, it wasn't until 1945 that a non-Muslim could be elected.

2. Why would the Jews separate? The Ottomans grew nicer to them and protected them. It just seems stupid they would split. Hell, currently a Jewish woman herself is the current Ottoman President.

3. You forgot the fact he did take over some, but only the Island of Taiwan. Mainlander Chinese were and always will be nationialists.

4. Why would anyone want to travel to the moon? After the first nuke was made in Russia, they accidently hit the thing. It glows everynight, and its always a full moon. It may have dangerous mutations that could eat you whole there.

5. You mean the VP? Gerald Ford was President from 1968-1976. He was one of the cleanest politicians during the late 60;s and the 70's. Nixon tried to run in '76, but lost to Jimmy Carter.
 
Hawkeye

Hawkeye

Mr_ Bondoc said:
Let me get this straight... Communism as described by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels describes a Socialist state emerging as a result of the abuses of an industrial state. Despite Czar Nicholas II's domestic policies, wouldn't a "Communist Revolution" take place in Great Britain, France, or Germany? If anything, Russia is more of a agrarian society backed by a absolute monarchy....
Click to expand...

Well during the end of his career Marx did consider Russia as a candidate for the first socialist state.

Mr_ Bondoc said:
Why would America be involved in the affairs of the "Great Game". If anything, the affairs of the Ottoman Empire have been the purview of the states of Great Britain, France and Russia. As such, why would the Ottoman Empire attack the United States? Russia had up to 500,000 troops in the region until 1991, and Great Britain along with France have had permanent bases in the region since the 1700s. Surely those countries would be larger targets....
Click to expand...

Russia was in an alliance with Great Britain and France. Whatever alliance that Russia is in I'm sure the Ottomon Empire would join the alliance with Germany and Austria before you can say Arabian Barbecue. If they lost in a war then I'm sure the Ottomon Empire would have splinterd into several smaller nations and if the U.S. did something to really piss off one of these new nations it would naturally strick back.

YLi said:
1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany
Click to expand...

Who's Adolf Hitler?
 

Alexius

On your latest 5:
Mustafa Kemal? That idiot who failed to defend Gallipoli? How on Earth does he end up running Turkey?
Hold on- Republic of Turkey? Next you'll be saying that the Hejaz gets independence!

Where does the Nation of Israel get formed ITTL? Uganda? Alaska? Probably somewhere crowded and ASB, like Palestine- but that can't be right, as your Kemal point means that there'd be a 26-year power vacuum, and I can't imagine Jewish guerillas emerging victorious.

Mao? The Propaganda secretary? What happened to Chiang Kai-Shek?

Americans landing on the moon? At least 6 countries could get there first!
 
Last edited:

wilcoxchar

1914: Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire is assassinated by a Serbian radical, thus precipitating World War I.
Click to expand...
First of all, it would be called World War II. World War I would've been back with Napoleon. ;) And Franz Ferdinand? Second Emperor of Mexico? Why would he be killed by Serbs, let alone be back in the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

1917: Russian Revolution. Communists overthrow the Russian Czar.
Click to expand...
Communism? In a large agrarian state such as Russia? That would never be possible. Try a small industrialized country, like Catalonia did IOTL.

1933: Adolf Hitler comes to power in Germany
Click to expand...
As many have said, that nutjob painter? I might be able to see him coming to power in Bavaria, but that's still a stretch.

1949: Communists under Mao Zedong take control in China.
Click to expand...
That's even more absurd than Communism in Russia! See my previous response to your "Russian Revolution".

1974: President Richard Nixon resigns amidst the Watergate Scandal
Click to expand...
What? Nixon President in 1974? Everyone knows he wouldn't have been able to run in '74 once his two terms were up in '68. And Nixon involved in a sex scandal? *shudders*
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top
Top