Chapter 13: By Leaps and Bounds, Part I: Setting the Stage.
“The NRO guys are like puppy dogs, delighted to show you what they can do—as long as you don’t tell”
- Author Unknown, 1979.
(Don McLean, American Pie)
As Apollo matured, so did her components; The LM in particular saw a series of upgrades, turning it from a lander capable of staying mere hours on the lunar surface to one capable of days, then weeks, then months on the surface. These upgrades would vary, and ultimately split the LM into three major variants. The first of these variants was the original, G or H-Class Lunar Module, that which had been used on Apollo’s 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14. With Apollo 15, however, the LM would see fuel and engine performance increases, allowing further payload to be brought to and from the surface.
Foremost of these payloads was the LRV, a small battery powered rover for the astronauts to traverse the surface with; This, alongside extra consumables and upgraded suits would allow the astronauts to stay on the surface for up to three days. However, these upgrades would be but a stepping stone towards NASA’s ultimate goal: The L-Class missions. These missions were still a ways away, and while NASA didn’t presently need to uprate the Saturn V’s capabilities, the need to do so soon had been identified. This ultimately led to the Uprated Saturn Launchers Program, an initiative to upgrade multiple components of the Saturn V, and Saturn IB launchers.
The J-2 would be the first engine to see these changes. A program of cost-savings, reliability increases and capability expansions led to a vastly simplified and much more efficient engine, the J-2S. The J-2S, or J-2 Simplified, was to run on the tap-off cycle rather than the original J-2’s gas generator. This, it was hoped, would dramatically reduce part count, and streamline engine production. By 1970, the engine had received thousands of seconds of run time, and was expected to fly by 1972.
The H-1 engine was also expected to reap the rewards of costs-savings and upratings. An engine development program had begun with the aim of extending the engines runtime, as well as thrust and chamber pressure. At the start of the program, 250,000 pound-force was identified to be the nominal thrust level, with the goal of up to 240 seconds of run time being proven. This was to be an extensive upgrade from the 205,000 pounds of thrust achieved on Apollo 4, but the engine development would coincide with NASA’s final uprating of the program.
With a thrust increase of 15% over that of the current engine, the addition of throttling and ISP increases, the F-1A was to be a behemoth of an engine. The engine was to see extensive manufacturing simplifications, and reliability increases. The aim with the F-1A was largely at post-Apollo vehicle designs, where a 15-45% thrust increase at launch could be accounted for properly. In the meantime, engine development would march on slowly, with first test-fires being expected in 1975 or 1976.
These engine upgrades were but part of a larger whole. The S-IB and S-IVB were to see extensive upgrades over the coming years, extending propellant capabilities, increasing engine count and even allowing for longer-duration use. NASA hoped these upgrades, alongside the cost savings and capability enhancements they would bring, would allow both the Saturn V and Saturn IB to take a much more active role in the late-Apollo program.
Apollo was rapidly maturing, and as a result so were her missions, The J-Class missions were set to be the first with a dedicated scientist-pilot on board and as a result, the missions were anticipated to yield much more dramatic results. These pilots would, however, have to wait for the latter half of the J-Class flights, as Apollo’s 15 and 16 were primarily focused on testing and analyzing the performance of the J-Class upgrades. And it was with these goals that Apollo 15 was rolled out to the pad, awaiting her final call for launch.
Prior to liftoff, political discussions began to take flight. Heads of NASA and the Soviet Space Program met alongside their diplomats to begin discussion of further cooperation and risk aversion. In the autumn of ‘70, it was agreed that NASA and the Soviet Space Agency would communicate their intended launch dates, landing sites and additional information; This was in an attempt to avoid Stepping on each other's feet as Jacob Beam, the US Diplomat to the Kremlin would put it. However, before long these discussions began evolving. The discussion was rapidly shifting away from the risk aversion the two nations originally intended, and towards joint operations in space. With the Soviets planning future lunar missions, as well as continued operations in Earth Orbit, NASA saw an opportunity to prove to the nation that they were more than a weapon of the cold war, but that they could be a tool of peace.
It was with this mindset that The Agreement Concerning Cooperation in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space for Peaceful Purposes, Often known as the Apollo-Soyuz Treaty was drafted; The treaty, covering three distinct missions, would start with a multinational docking in orbit of the Earth, Apollo Soyuz Test Project-I (ASTP-1). This flight would see a jointly developed docking adapter be placed into orbit alongside the Apollo in 1974, with a Soyuz joining the crew shortly after for a multi-day docked flight before parting ways. The next mission, ASTP-II, was to be a joint lunar-operation conducted in 1976 or 1977, in which multiple crafts from the two nations would descend upon a commonly decided upon site, chosen by 1974. The third and final mission outlined in the treaty consisted of a multi-month mission to Skylab or her successor, aimed at demonstrating the potential for cooperative stationkeeping exercises in the nations’ future. It was under this emblem of peace, that Humphrey addressed the senate on the 12th of September, 1970, mere hours before the scheduled liftoff of Apollo 15.
(Humphrey addresses a Congressional Hearing, emphasizing the importance of cooperating with the Soviets in manned and unmanned spaceflight)
President Humphrey addressed the houses of congress, emphasizing the importance of international cooperation in this new ear of manned space exploration; He also expressed his intentions to set a budget floor for the space agency, stating his belief that until the Shuttle and Space Transportation System had been developed, the agency needed to maintain at minimum a funding level at 1.5% of the national budget, and no less than 1% thereafter. This decision was bold, and to many seemed uncalled for; However, with the presidency controlled by the Democrats, and both houses of congress under their control, the motion seemed doable.
It was on the back of these promises, and the continued development of uprated Saturn vehicles, the voyager and surveyor probes, and all the gifts Apollo had wrought the nation that Apollo 15 lifted off from LC-39B. With final negotiations still underway, and with an all-too-familiar roar, Apollo 15 lifted off for the heavens. All 5 main engines screamed to life, delivering the over 7 million pounds of thrust necessary to throw the monolithic rocket off the launch pad. Eugene Cernan, Kennith Mattingly, and Stuart Roosa were now on their way, and reporting nominal performance from the first and second stages. As the rocket finally made orbit, all systems were performing nominally, and the three men were given the go ahead:
Odyssey, go for TLI.
Cernan: Roger, Go for TLI.
(Liftoff of Apollo 15, September 9th, 1970.)
After a short and by all accounts uneventful coast, Apollo 15 arrived at the lunar sphere of influence. Delivering the crew of Odyssey and the promise of a true scientific endeavor to the moon. The crew peered out their window in awe, awaiting loss of signal and preparing for the maneuver ahead of them.
Cernan: Here she is!
Roosa: We can see the lunar surface real well out the window, flight.
Capcom: We’re thrilled to hear it you three, make sure you’re ready for LOI
Cernan: Roger. Don, Harrison, one of you grab a shot out that window, it looks beautiful!
(A crescent Earth in the Lunar Shadow, Apollo 15, 1970.)
Cernan: Alright Houston, we’ll see you lovely folks on the other side!
Capcom: Roger that Odyssey.
Odyssey lit her main engine, and began the now-mundane process of lunar orbit insertion. The spacecraft slowed her velocity by nearly 2,600 feet per second (~800m/s) , capturing securely into lunar orbit. The spacecraft reappeared on tracking and data relays minutes later, showing that the maneuver had gone properly as it had over half a dozen times prior.
Cernan: This is Odyssey, how do you copy?
Capcom: 10/10 15. We hear you perfectly!
Cernan: Beautiful.
Before long, Gene Cernan and Stuart Roosa donned their A9L suits and boarded Endeavour. The spacecraft undocked, and as many had before them, they began their descent. Today’s destination was the eastern Mare Serenitatis: the Sea of Serenity. As the crew descended towards the surface they noticed subtle landmarks along the way, notifying them that they were well within their landing corridor.
Roosa: 50 up, down at 3, holding her steady Gene.
Cernan: Roger- Ok Houston we’re lookin’ good
Capcom: Read you loud and clear 15. Keep her steady!
Cernan: You bet-
Roosa: 30, down at 2.
Cernan 2 feet per second
…
Roosa: Down at 1… 0.5… contact!
Cernan: Engine cut-
Roosa: Disengage-
Cernan: Houston, serenity here. Endeavour is down!
Capcom: Roger you down Endeavour. Welcome to the moon!
Roosa: This sure is something-
…
…
Roosa: It's just incredible. I’m at a loss for words.
After initial stay/no-stay polls came back green, the men began preparations for EVA. Their helmets were fastened, and they began their descent. Once both men had descended the ladder to the lunar plains below them, their next task began. Unpack the LRV. The LRV, or Lunar Roving Vehicle, was a compact electric rover that could be used to extend the astronauts effective traversable distance from 2 miles to well over 15. Needless to say, the LRV was in part, the backbone of the J-Class missions, and as such its unfolding was a mission critical endeavor.
Cernan: Okay flight, the rover is coming along well
Capcom: Roger you loud and clear, LRV deployment is going good.
Before long, and with little added effort, the men managed to free the LRV from the Lunar Modules bay. As the rover unfolded, her wheels flipped into an active position, and the rover was slowly but surely descending towards the surface. The seats flipped open, and the astronauts had secured their ride for the evening. Humanities most distant of joyrides was about to begin.
Roosa: Convertible is ready babe!
Cernan: She sure is, Tell Boeing they did a good job on this one!
Capcom: Roger, will do Gene-
The two men boarded the rover, and her wheels began to turn. Before long the two men were gliding across the surface at a blisteringly fast 8mph (13km/h).
Roosa: Yippee!
Cernan: Let’s see what this bad boy can do!
For the next few hours, the men roved around the lunar surface, gathering numerous distant samples before ultimately returning to the lunar module. Their surface samples marked the broadest and most varied collection of regolith brought back by a single mission to date, and their documentation of the lunar surface proved fruitful. The two men went to sleep that night knowing full well that they had done groundbreaking science, and were having the time of their lives doing it.
On the second day of the mission, Roosa and Cernan sought out to deploy a series of scientific payloads. These ranged from measurement and data collection equipment to small explosive devices designed to deliver data on the Moon’s interior makeup. Day two of the mission proved fruitful, and the mission was wrapped up with an additional day of travel across the lunar surface. The two men set out on their journey yet again to rove across the lunar surface in search of surface samples.
…
Cernan: Picking up some speed here, outta slow down-
Roosa: ugh-
Cernan: One of the wheels caught something flight, looks like our fender is a bit busted.
Capcom: Roger that Gene, let’s go ahead and see if we can get it buffed out.
The damage had been somewhat severe, with the fender extension falling off entirely as they scraped against a rock. An attempt was made to fix the fender with duct tape, however due to the severe abrasion of the lunar regolith this proved an unobtainable solution. Ultimately it was suggested by Stuart Roosa- Why don’t we use the map? And before long, the men had taped the map in place of their fender extension; While the fix had been messy, and looked somewhat uninspiring, the tape held, and the men continued their drive. Roosa and Cernan eventually disembarked their rover, slowly striding towards a boulder in the distance.
Cernan: Bit of a hard time jumping around in these things
…
Roosa: Bet I can beat ya there!
Cernan: You’re on, old man!
After a short footrace across the regolith dusted plains, the astronauts continued their journey across the surface ahead of them, eventually returning to the LM a few hours later. Before long, their 3 day stint on the lunar surface was over, and the time had come to begin their ascent back to Odyssey. The Computer was set, and the launch commenced-
Cernan: We’re up and away, Houston.
Roosa: So long, friend- take care of 16 for us!
(Cernan Salutes shortly before liftoff)
Apollo’s 16, 17 and 18 would largely repeat the success of 15 before them; The missions flying to a number of sites determined by the agency in the months leading up to their arrival. While the Surveyor, Ranger, and Lunar Orbiter programs had provided NASA with ample data in the lead-up to Apollo, the time seemed evident for a more extensive study of the lunar topography. It was with this goal that an old favor, offered to NASA in the decade prior was finally dusted off and redeemed:
Project Upward.
Project Upward was a mission proposed in the early 1960’s long before Apollo had first taken flight. The mission was to see the delivery of a KH-7 reconnaissance satellite alongside the Apollo to lunar orbit. This, the NRO had promised, would allow NASA to achieve the highest degree of fidelity when documenting the lunar surface. This mission however was turned down in 1966, when NASA deemed they had received enough imagery for the time being from the first two lunar orbiters.
The agency had, however, changed its mind about this decision and in 1970 a request to use a newer KH-8 was sent to the NRO. While the USAF, CIA and NRO were primarily focused on Soviet Activities, the mission was seen as a potential demonstration of cutting-edge imagery technology. With nearly no hesitation, the request was approved, and NASA was sent a delivery by the NRO that winter. This was, of course, under one main condition:
The images were not to be made public under any circumstance.
After agreeing to this, NASA moved forward developing the A19SP or the Apollo-19 Scientific Package. The instrument unit would be based around that worked on by the NRO in their 1962 proposal, with a few exceptions. Namely, the module would include a small number of scientific instruments alongside the primary imaging system. These instruments would vary in use case, ranging from spectrometry lenses for the primary optics, to altimeters and accelerometers. These instruments used in tandem with the platform in a near-polar inclination would allow the spacecraft to map the gravitational field, surface features and even chemical makeup of the lunar surface. This would give NASA the plethora of data and factors necessary to move forward with longer term exploration of the lunar surface.
(Early design of the A19SP)
As Apollos 16, 17 and 18 landed on the moon successfully, Apollo 19’s survey approached ever closer. The mission, dubbed I-Prime, was truly one of a kind, and would prove something of a logistical challenge. The 28 day mission would well-exceed Apollo’s previous staying capabilities, and as such the spacecraft would need extra supplies to be included, and only a skeleton crew would be flown. The crew of two would lessen the load on the Apollo spacecraft just enough that the nearly month-long freeflight proved feasible. By the close of 1971 the plan had been sealed, and in January, the two-man crew were scheduled for liftoff.
(Apollo 19 rolls out to the Launchpad)
The rocket raised off the pad, as it had for countless flights before. However today’s mission had a unique combination of changes allowing the rocket to greatly overperform. In tandem with a lighter payload, the second and third stages of AS-514 were utilizing the newly flight certified J-2S engine. The engine had racked up tens of thousands of seconds of run-time on test stands and by 1970, NASA had certified AS-514 to be modified to utilize the engine. This would ultimately raise the gargantuan rocket's TLI-capabilities from 45 tons, to just over 50.
The crew had made it to orbit, and TLI shortly followed. After the S-IVB had depleted its usefulness, and the stage had been safed, the petals of the adapter opened up, and the Apollo separated from the spent stage beneath it. Resolution, you are go for docking-
McDivitt: Roger that, Houston.
…
…
Irwin: Okay flight, we’re docking with the package.
Capcom: Roger that James, glad to hear-
McDivitt: But I didn’t say anything-
Irwin: (Laughing) Shut it.
McDivitt: Extraction and separation complete. We’re on our way!
The two men arrived at the moon just under 3 days later; They inserted themselves into lunar orbit successfully, and began their month-long endeavor. The camera was started, and would run almost uninterrupted for the next 670 or so hours. During this time, the astronauts would perform numerous EVA’s to gather science, maintain the platform and perform inspections on the spacecraft’s health.
Apollo would hold up, proving not only that the spacecraft was fit for the task, but that it was ready for the tasks ahead of it. NASA’s upcoming project, Skylab, alongside the variety of longer duration missions the agency had planned would require Apollo to stay the 4 weeks in orbit at least, with some missions set to require many times this duration. Nevertheless, NASA proved as optimistic as they did correct. The spacecraft easily outperformed its initial designed lifespan and allowed the collection of a momentous amount of scientific data. The astronauts performed numerous manual collections alongside the near-automated main optics payload.
The astronauts would gather spectrometry scans of many regions around the moon; Particular emphasis was given to those sites not visited by previous missions, namely the highlands, poles and the far side of the moon. While NASA was not considering landings on the far side of the moon, the former two seemed promising. Landings in both the highest and lowest parts of the lunar surface proved an intriguing proposition. This proposition only became more so once data collection showed something quite…
extraordinary.