Brazilian WI: Roberto Silveira doesn't die so young?

Though he is rarely (if ever) remembered nowadays, Roberto Silveira was one of the most promising left-wing Brazilian politicians of his generation, together with people like Leonel Brizola, Waldir Pires and Miguel Arraes. Much like Brizola, Silveira got into politics at a very young age, and his rise was just as meteoric: he was elected to a seat in the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly in 1947, reelected in 1950, then into the lieutenant governorship in 1954, and was finally became governor in 1958, at the age of thirty-five.

Silveira's administration of Rio de Janeiro (which didn't include the city in question at the time - the state's capital was Niterói) was marked by several infrastructure projects, as well as a land reform program. His prestige was such that, when then vice president João Goulart traveled to the US at his fellow VP Richard Nixon's invitation (I can't find an exact date for that trip, unfortunately), Silveira went along with him, and he wasn't even governor yet.

Unfortunately, Silveira's career ended just as suddenly and dramatically as it began: on February 21 1961, as he was preparing to inspect regions affected by rains and floods days prior, his helicopter crashed and burst into flames. He died a week later, at the age of thirty-seven, as a result of the burns he suffered. So what if he listened to his aides and decided to travel to the flood-stricken places by car rather than by helicopter, thus avoiding his untimely death?

One thing I'm really curious about is how Silveira's survival could affect the crisis that followed Jânio Quadros' resignation, which is just months away. He would, without a doubt, support Brizola's campaign to ensure João Goulart's accession as president, which has some interesting implications given "Old" Rio's strategic position right on Guanabara's doorstep. Things might end up escalating IOTL, with the military ministers ordering the Navy to storm Niterói and kicking off a civil war.

Or, the anti-putschists' stronger position could mean Jango takes office with all his powers from the get go, sparing Brazil from the waste of time that was parliamentarianism.

@Gukpard @Guilherme Loureiro @Aluma @Taunay

Lastly, here's a picture, just so y'all know what the guy actually looked like.

roberto silveira.jpeg
 
Though he is rarely (if ever) remembered nowadays, Roberto Silveira was one of the most promising left-wing Brazilian politicians of his generation, together with people like Leonel Brizola, Waldir Pires and Miguel Arraes. Much like Brizola, Silveira got into politics at a very young age, and his rise was just as meteoric: he was elected to a seat in the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly in 1947, reelected in 1950, then into the lieutenant governorship in 1954, and was finally became governor in 1958, at the age of thirty-five.

Silveira's administration of Rio de Janeiro (which didn't include the city in question at the time - the state's capital was Niterói) was marked by several infrastructure projects, as well as a land reform program. His prestige was such that, when then vice president João Goulart traveled to the US at his fellow VP Richard Nixon's invitation (I can't find an exact date for that trip, unfortunately), Silveira went along with him, and he wasn't even governor yet.

Unfortunately, Silveira's career ended just as suddenly and dramatically as it began: on February 21 1961, as he was preparing to inspect regions affected by rains and floods days prior, his helicopter crashed and burst into flames. He died a week later, at the age of thirty-seven, as a result of the burns he suffered. So what if he listened to his aides and decided to travel to the flood-stricken places by car rather than by helicopter, thus avoiding his untimely death?

One thing I'm really curious about is how Silveira's survival could affect the crisis that followed Jânio Quadros' resignation, which is just months away. He would, without a doubt, support Brizola's campaign to ensure João Goulart's accession as president, which has some interesting implications given "Old" Rio's strategic position right on Guanabara's doorstep. Things might end up escalating IOTL, with the military ministers ordering the Navy to storm Niterói and kicking off a civil war.

Or, the anti-putschists' stronger position could mean Jango takes office with all his powers from the get go, sparing Brazil from the waste of time that was parliamentarianism.

@Gukpard @Guilherme Loureiro @Aluma @Taunay

Lastly, here's a picture, just so y'all know what the guy actually looked like.

View attachment 832801
This is amazing. I'd never heard of this person before. If the coup is prevented, could he become a senator or even president (maybe if he moderates a bit)?
 
I would like to present a third possibility as a POD

Roberto Silveira staying temporarily on the US for a bit longer(a week or so) when visiting with Goulart as a request of Nixon's gabinet to serve as an act of good will between the two governments, when in truth Washington only wants to learn more of his character(considering, as you said, it was highly unusual that a head of state would bring some guy who isnt even governor alongside him) and perhaps have someone to serve as a backup should Goulart go rogue, which butterflies his death by a few days

That way not only you can avoid his death, but when the circunstances that led to 64 occur you could have Washington telling the military they'd support their move to remove the president if they could place the governor guy as a compromise candidate in his place, being someone they determined to be trustworthy(thus no commie danger), connected enough to Goulart to have legitimacy and left enough that it wont raise eyebrows like yet another right wing dictatorship would(not that they care but the more "democratic-looking" the better) and that way you could butterfly away João's death as well

Thus Brazil remains on it's moderate left path instead of falling into an authoritarian government that still pursues nationalistic and social policies to reduce inequality and try modernizing Brazil but raising less red flags(pun intended) with the gringos while Goulart gets to retire since he trusts Silveira
 
I would like to present a third possibility as a POD

Roberto Silveira staying temporarily on the US for a bit longer(a week or so) when visiting with Goulart as a request of Nixon's gabinet to serve as an act of good will between the two governments, when in truth Washington only wants to learn more of his character(considering, as you said, it was highly unusual that a head of state would bring some guy who isnt even governor alongside him) and perhaps have someone to serve as a backup should Goulart go rogue, which butterflies his death by a few days

That way not only you can avoid his death, but when the circunstances that led to 64 occur you could have Washington telling the military they'd support their move to remove the president if they could place the governor guy as a compromise candidate in his place, being someone they determined to be trustworthy(thus no commie danger), connected enough to Goulart to have legitimacy and left enough that it wont raise eyebrows like yet another right wing dictatorship would(not that they care but the more "democratic-looking" the better) and that way you could butterfly away João's death as well

Thus Brazil remains on it's moderate left path instead of falling into an authoritarian government that still pursues nationalistic and social policies to reduce inequality and try modernizing Brazil but raising less red flags(pun intended) with the gringos while Goulart gets to retire since he trusts Silveira
I love how creative your scenarios are lol
 
I love how creative your scenarios are lol
Thank you very much you cute bean!

Also to make it clear, the military coup itself as it happened IOTL wouldnt be happening in that scenario since I dont ever see Silveira willingly consenting to being part of it

Rather the military would privately threat to do it, the US would also "subtly" show its support(as much subtle a warship in our coast is) and Goulart would "willingly" abdicate with Roberto being later placed in charge through bureocratic shenanigans(the congress calls for a new election? Idk)

But yeah I think that would be a fun setting
 
This is amazing. I'd never heard of this person before. If the coup is prevented, could he become a senator or even president (maybe if he moderates a bit)?
That would depend on how the Jango administration develops. If Silveira manages to steal Brizola's thunder during the Campanha da Legalidade (which is very possible, in my view - he'd be Lacerda's nemesis, staring him down from the other side of the Guanabara Bay) and become the leader of the radical left, Brizola might paint himself as a moderate. Which is something he could genuinely be at times - he made an alliance with Plínio fucking Salgado in 1958, after all.
 
Brizola the moderate
Now that sounds wild
Eh, the moderates (San Tiago Dantas and others, the "positive left") were in favor of stuff like reopening relations with the USSR and opposing the embargo on Cuba. It'd be a rhetorical difference rather than on policy, but rhetoric alone can make a huge difference, so...
 
Last edited:
Eh, even the moderates were in favor of stuff like reopening relations with the USSR and opposing the embargo on Cuba. It'd be a rhetorical difference rather than anything substantive.
Oh, a classic
Still find the idea of him pulling a Lula rather funny
 
Fun fact, Silveira had to deal with a massive riot in Niterói a few months after his inauguration as governor. You see, the local ferry company (which linked Niterói to Rio city) was owned by a private company, which prioritized profit over quality. The workers went on strike in May 21 1959, and the chaos that ensued was the straw that broke the camel's back.

The following day, thousands of angry commuters burned the ferry terminal to the ground, before marching to the company owner's residence and ransacking it as well. Silveira not only refused to deploy the police against them, but kept the army from stepping in. His approach likely prevented a massacre (six people died IOTL, had the army been allowed to move in that figure would've been in the dozens at the very least) and reinforced his image as a defender of the common people. The rioters eventually returned to their homes and the ferry company was made a public utility.

As one can see, the guy was what the Americans would call a chad.
 
Last edited:
To change the subject a little, how much of a difference would it make for João Goulart to take the presidency with all of his constitutional powers, without parliamentarianism? IOTL Brazil went through three prime ministers in two years, which should be enough to tell how dysfunctional the system was.

Would Jango be in a better position to put inflation back under control, with a two year headstart? How could this affect the 1962 elections?

@Gukpard @Guilherme Loureiro
 
Top