Detail of a painting representing Duke Godfrey's funeral in 1099 A.D.
The apostolic see of Jerusalem was nominally held by Patriarch Simon II, who, however, had been exiled to Constantinople after the Turks conquered the city. Respectful of their oaths towards Basileus Alexius I Komnenos, his seat in the Church of the Holy Sepulcher remained unoccupied until the Patriarch finally decided to return, in late 1101.
This provision, however, would soon prove to be a ceremonious masquerade in order to gratify the Greeks in Constantinople, as the Latins immediately established a separate ecclesiastic jurisdiction – the so-called “
Roman Church of Jerusalem” – under Bishop Ademar de Monteil, unanimously elected to fulfill the office in the stead of the Holy See. The
Al-Aqsa Mosque, an impressive Islamic sanctuary that had been almost untouched by the depredations of the city’s capture, was chosen to be the headquarters of this new parallel patriarchate. According to the legend, the mosque had been built over the ruins of the legendary temple inaugurated by the Biblical King Solomon, and thus the place became known simply as the “Temple of Solomon”.
Whatever were the original intentions of Pope Urban II – who was unknowingly about to die of natural causes – or of the Crusaders, it came to happen that the realm of Jerusalem was born officially as a theocratic state. Nevertheless, even if Bishop Adhemar himself was no stranger to arms – having distinguished himself in various battles during the campaign – he knew that a lay prince would have to be appointed to serve as a military protector of the Holy Land.
The choice would necessarily be between
Duke Godfrey of Lower Lotharingia and
Count Raymond of Toulouse, who were the senior leaders of the expedition, with the most salient aristocratic titles and lineages, and also the wealthiest lords. In the context of the feudal society, these premises were quintessential, as a lord needed to have resources and prestige – or, as Bishop Adhemar himself called,
dignitas and
auctoritas – to exact obligations and rewards the vassals, even if all of them were
de iure subjects of the Pope.
As it happens, Duke Godfrey had since the beginning of 1099 been struck with a recurrent and debilitating fever. The contemporary sources all describe different symptoms, that went from bouts of delirium to blood cough, but it was most likely that he had contracted malaria, a mosquito-transmitted disease that was endemic in the Levant at the time. In any event, his sickness had already manifested during the Siege of Jerusalem, and, after the victory, sapped Godfrey from his health to the point that Bishop Adhemar de Monteil and the other leaders could simply predict that the Lotharingian noble would pass away soon.
Indeed, Godfrey passed away in 1099, barely a week after the conquest of Jerusalem, in the new court he had established inside the
Tower of David. A procession was conducted from there, where his veterans solemnly carried his body to a suitable burial spot in the sacred grounds of the Mount of the Olives.
According to
Arnulf of Chocques (the sole eyewitness account of his deceasing) Duke Godfrey had proclaimed to be very happy to die in the place where Christ had suffered his ultimate fate and then resurrected.
Godfrey had never married, and thus was childless, but his younger brother
Baldwin of Boulogne was currently ruling in Edessa as its self-proclaimed Count.
Baldwin arrived (with his mixed Lotharingian and Armenian retinue) in the next week from the fort of Turbessel to pay the respects to his deceased brother. The Count of Edessa arrived just in time to join the requiem mass, and was mildly surprised by the fact that thousands of the pilgrims participated in the funeral of the endeared Duke.
Count Raymond of Toulouse was the natural choice, then to become the secular ruler of Jerusalem. It seems, however, that he, at first, vehemently refused to accept the offer of becoming King of Jerusalem – his piety would not allow it, and he shuddered at the mere thought of wearing a crown in the place where Christ had suffered and died. Soon enough, the Provençal lord changed his mind, however, and, in the same month of April, was ceremoniously invested with the neutral honorific of “Defender of the Holy Land”, and a more tangible title as “
Duke of Galilee”.
It is highly probable that Count Raymond was actually Bishop Adhemar’s prime candidate to held thislay principality – they, after all, had been the very first ones to accept Pope Urban II’s summon in Clairmont, a few years before, and were mutual friends and political allies who shared the same vision for the new nation founded in the Holy Land. In fact, it is likely that Count Raymond, even if out of genuine piety had no desire to be King of Jerusalem, as his successors would later proclaim themselves, abhorred even more the thought of having his rival Bohemond in this prestigious position. The Italo-Norman lord, despite lacking resources and being from a parvenu dynasty, was venerated by the pilgrims, knights and minor lordlings due to his military prowess, and had demonstrated the ambition of establishing for himself a kingdom in the Orient.
No sources expressly attest the underlying causes of Raymond’s change of mind, but at least one chronicle briefly mentions that the Frankish and Italian knights acclaimed Bohemond with a golden diadem that had been pillaged from an Islamic mosque, as if he was supposed to be crowned their new King. Count Raymond and Bishop Adhemar must have been alarmed by this unexpected episode, and quickly safeguarded their own interests by alienating the Italo-Norman lord from any positions of authority. This conclusion is corroborated by the fact that Bohemond was not given any meaningful position inside Jerusalem itself, and, not long afterwards, departed from the city altogether with his followers to procure a kingdom for himself.
*****
Thus, Count Raymond was officially anointed as the Defender of the Holy Land and Duke of Galilee, under the nominal suzerainty of Bishop Adhemar of Jerusalem, who himself answered directly to Pope Urban II. Before their messages communicating these episodes arrived in Rome, however, the
Pontifex Maximus passed away, in July 1099. His successor, Pope Paschal II, was quickly elected to sit in the vacant throne in the next month, and happily ratified the ceremonies celebrated in Jerusalem.
Despite the resounding victories of the Crusade, however, there was still a loose end, one that might have, yet again, caused the undoing of the whole expedition: a vast Fatimid army, led by the
Vizier of Egypt,
al-Malik al-Afdal ibn Badr al-Jamali Shahanshah, was marching to retrieve Jerusalem and exact revenge in the name of Allah upon the Christians.
_______________
Chapter Notes: OTL, Godfrey of Bouillon actually refused the crown of Jerusalem, when it was offered to him, claiming that he refused “to wear a crown of gold in the place where Jesus had worn a crown of thorns”. At the time, he was the most popular and most powerful leader of the First Crusade, but the crown had indeed been offered to Count Raymond, who outright refused it was well, and thus Godfrey accepted the nomination but avoided using a kingly title, preferring the more neutral “Advocate of the St. Sepulcher”. Nevertheless, he became a de facto hereditary monarch, and his younger brother, Baldwin, the self-proclaimed Count of Edessa, succeeded him in 1101 as “King of Jerusalem” and thus the De Boulogne Dynasty was established.