Alternate Super Bowls, 1999-Future

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

I’ll start it off:

Super Bowl XXXIV: Indianapolis Colts def. St. Louis Rams 42-40, MVP QB Peyton Manning

Super Bowl XXXV: New York Giants def. Oakland Raiders 24-14, MVP DE Michael Strahan

Colonel Zoidberg · Apr 23, 2019

Super Bowl XXXVI: St. Louis Rams defeat Miami Dolphins, 35-24, MVP Kurt Warner

Super Bowl XXXVII: New England Patriots defeat Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 19-17, MVP Drew Bledsoe

aaronupright · Apr 23, 2019

Bledsoe gets to the Hall of Fame ITTL. Excellent.
If there was any justice in the world, he would already be in.
ETA: SBXXXVIII. Carolina Panthers 31, Indianapolis Colts 27. MVP Jake Delhomme, QB
SBXXXIX. San Fransisco 49ner 44, Indianapolis Colts 14. MVP Tom Brady QB.
SBXL. SAN Fransisco 49ner 21, Pittsburg Steelers: 12. MVP Tom Brady QB.

TimTurner · Apr 23, 2019

Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England Patriots defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 41-33, MVP Corey Dillon
Super Bowl XXXIX: Dallas Cowboys defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 20-17, MVP Tony Romo

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

TimTurner said:
Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England Patriots defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 41-33, MVP Tom Brady
Super Bowl XXXIX: Dallas Cowboys defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 20-17, MVP Tony Romo

Why would Tom Brady end up on the Pats if he just won two with the 49ers, and the Pats have elite QB Drew Bledsoe?

TimTurner · Apr 23, 2019

Calcaterra said:
Why would Tom Brady end up on the Pats if he just won two with the 49ers, and the Pats have elite QB Drew Bledsoe?

oh.
need to edit that.

aaronupright · Apr 23, 2019

Yeah I think Eli Manning is probably the one who ends up in NE? Bledsoe’s successor.
One of the POD is that the tuck rule game has a different outcome?

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

aaronupright said:
Bledsoe gets to the Hall of Fame ITTL. Excellent.
If there was any justice in the world, he would already be in.
ETA: SBXXXVIII. Carolina Panthers 31, Indianapolis Colts 27. MVP Jake Delhomme, QB
SBXXXIX. San Fransisco 49ner 44, Indianapolis Colts 14. MVP Tom Brady QB.
SBXL. SAN Fransisco 49ner 21, Pittsburg Steelers: 12. MVP Tom Brady QB.

SB XLI: New Orleans Saints def. San Diego Chargers 35-10, MVP Drew Brees

SB XLII: Indianapolis Colts def. Green Bay Packers 28-24, MVP Reggie Wayne

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

aaronupright said:
Yeah I think Eli Manning is probably the one who ends up in NE? Bledsoe’s successor.
One of the POD is that the tuck rule game has a different outcome?

I would imagine the Colts’ win would butterfly away certain events, like Bledsoe’s injury and the such.

Curtain Jerker · Apr 23, 2019

In my dormant Tuck Rule timeline (cheap plug!) the Rams won the 2002 Super Bowl over Oakland, Oakland won the 2003 Super Bowl over Tampa, and Tampa won the 2004 Super Bowl over New England.

aaronupright · Apr 23, 2019

Calcaterra said:
SB XLI: New Orleans Saints def. San Diego Chargers 35-10, MVP Drew Brees

SB XLII: Indianapolis Colts def. Green Bay Packers 28-24, MVP Reggie Wayne

SBXLIII: New England Patriots 27, San Fransisco 49ners 23. MVP Eli Manning, QB. (18-1 season for 49ners, yeah Brady does not escape this in any time line)
SBXLIV:Miami Dolphins 31, New Orleans Saints 19. MVP Chad Pennington QB.
SBXLV: New England Patriots 34,Chicago Bears 31. MVP Eli Manning QB

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

TimTurner said:
Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England Patriots defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 41-33, MVP Corey Dillon
Super Bowl XXXIX: Dallas Cowboys defeat Philadelphia Eagles, 20-17, MVP Tony Romo

The Cowboys and Eagles are in the same division, as well as the same conference. This is impossible.

White Lightning · Apr 23, 2019

Not if either team is moved due to realignment. Maybe put Dallas in the same division as their inter state rival Houston?

Colonel Zoidberg · Apr 23, 2019

Calcaterra said:
The Cowboys and Eagles are in the same division, as well as the same conference. This is impossible.

So is the Cowboys winning another Super Bowl but here we are.

SB XLVI: Cleveland Browns 37, San Francisco 49ers 34, MVP AJ Hawk
SB XLVII: Arizona Cardinals 28, Kansas City Chiefs 23, MVP Aaron Rodgers

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

Colonel Zoidberg said:
So is the Cowboys winning another Super Bowl but here we are.

SB XLVI: Cleveland Browns 37, San Francisco 49ers 34, MVP AJ Hawk
SB XLVII: Arizona Cardinals 28, Kansas City Chiefs 23, MVP Aaron Rodgers

You must be a charitable soul with those Super Bowl picks.

Colonel Zoidberg · Apr 23, 2019

Calcaterra said:
You must be a charitable soul with those Super Bowl picks.

Something like that.

Super Bowl XLVIII: Buffalo Bills 33, San Francisco 49ers 27, 2 OT, MVP Marshawn Lynch

aaronupright · Apr 23, 2019

How many has Brady lost now?
SBXLIX. Washington Redskins 31, New England Patriots 25. MVP Alex Smith. QB
SB50 San Fransisco 49ners 29, Indianapolis Colts 10. MVP: Chris Long DE.

Corjomc · Apr 23, 2019

Superbowl C: Berlin Thunder 37, Chicago Bears 35, MVP Otto Hertz, QB

Nivek · Apr 23, 2019

aaronupright said:
If there was any justice in the world, he would already be in.

why? he is barely on very good hall too..he never achieve anything sans a superbowl loss

Calcaterra · Apr 23, 2019

aaronupright said:
How many has Brady lost now?
SBXLIX. Washington Redskins 31, New England Patriots 25. MVP Alex Smith. QB
SB50 San Fransisco 49ners 29, Indianapolis Colts 10. MVP: Chris Long DE.

I believe one out of four played.

SB LI: Indianapolis Colts def. Atlanta Falcons, 48-10, MVP Peyton Manning (last game)

SB LII: Atlanta Falcons def. Cleveland Browns, 23-16, MVP Russell Wilson