Alternate Electoral Maps

Status
Not open for further replies.
2017-2025: Hillary Rodham Clinton/Elizabeth Warren (D) (45)
2025-2033: Amy Klobuchar/Cory Booker (D) (46)
2033-2041: Joseph P. Kennedy/Will Burns (D) (47)

The death of the Republican Party, the Grand Old Party of Lincoln, had been predicted for years, and it finally began with the nomination of Donald Trump in 2016. Hillary Rodham Clinton won in a landslide and became the forty-fifth President of the United States. Despite his loss, Trump was still popular with the Republican base, and ran again in 2020. When he failed to clinch the nomination, he did as he'd promised in 2016, and walked out of the convention. He and his supporters, angry with the Republican establishment, formed the American Party (they were well aware of the implications). Hillary's re-election was an even more resounding landslide.

This led to a kind of second Era of Good Feelings. Moderates started turning to the Democrats, and the rest were split between the Republicans and Neo Know Nothings (they didn't call themselves that). For the next twenty years the Democratic Party controlled Congress and the White House. But it was not all sunshine and rainbows. A spectre was hanging over the Democratic Party: the spectre of Bernie Sanders.

The left wing of the Democratic Party was incredibly restive. Nomination after nomination, progressive candidates tried and failed. And the Democratic supermajorities in Congress required an ideological rainbow coalition that made the left of the party feel quite stifled, including Senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, and a few Millennial veterans of Bernie Sanders' 2016 campaign who had since gotten elected to Congress. In 2036 an attempt had been made to challenge President Kennedy in the general election, and it proved to only be a bump in the road; that party was the Progressive-Green Party.

In 2040 Mark Zuckerberg, the billionaire founder of Facebook and one-term senator (at the time of course), announced he would be running for the Democratic nomination. Fellow senator and former "Berner" Audrey Zinn (no relation to Howard Zinn, but the irony was helpful) of Washington rose to challenge her. It was just like 2016, and several contests in between: moderate-ish neoliberal versus loony socialist (Zinn was one of several members of the Congressional Democratic Socialist Caucus), and the outcome was the same as well. But instead of conceding, Zinn capitalized on the anger on the left, and pulled a Trump.

2040

Mark Zuckerberg/Kevin Lee (D)
Audrey Zinn/Tammy Baldwin (L)
Jerry Falwell III/Jefferson Watts (A)

vL6rE4j.png


Mark Zuckerberg became the forty-eighth President of the United States. But like the Republican Party after 1856, the Labor Party (officially Labor-Progressive-Green) was not dead.
 
1980 after Carter beats Reagan 1976 and has a similarly bad term.

Ex-President Gerald Ford (MI) / Representative George Bush (TX)- 287 EV, 41,713,496 (51%)
Senator Henry "Scoop" Jackson (WA) / Ex-Vice President Walter Mondale (MN) - 251 EV, 40,346,264 (49%)
Why does Jackson challenge Carter when he didn't in OTL? And why did Mondale resign?
 
Klobuchar's a Progressive. Why not Andrew Cuomo/Gavin Newsom, if you're emphasising the "moderate" faction?

Also, Utah? For the Party of Trump? lolno.
 
Um, care to explain?:confused:

On the one where blue wins a proper victory, it is all the states poorer than the national average. The top one is similar but the election has been made closer . I'm not sure what election this is set in or what caused the map to be like this, I was hoping somebody could convincingly made an alt history scenario where an election goes like this.
 
Election of 1840 – Difference in Politics: Alternate U.S. Elections (1840–2012):
Following the rather successful two terms of former War of 1812 general and Democrat Lewis Marshall, it was highly expected from both parties that he would seek a third term in the elections of 1840. Instead, he retired from politics shortly after that year's DNC began and endorsed the politically moderate Senator Anthony Knox of Virginia, who ended up successfully winning the nomination after three ballots. The Whigs chose Speaker of the House of Representatives John Braggs Carson and Governor of New Jersey Henry Townshend as his running mate.

Despite even the most war-hardened politician's best estimate for the election's results, it surprisingly ended in a solid Whig victory following multiple accusations of bribery and political scandal that unfortunately beset the Virginia Senator during the end of the campaign trail.

1840 Alt. Election.png
Speaker John B. Carson (W-MA)/Governor Henry Townshend (W-NJ) - 203 EVs
Senator Anthony Knox (D-VA)/Senator Francis Darling (D-PA) - 91 EVs

1840 Alt. Election.png
 
Virginian Governor General election, 1999 (From The New World)

The Governor General election of 1999 was the second election in which the women of Virginia had the franchise (the minimum property or asset requirement remained the same as men). Outgoing Governor General Sidney McCain had overseen a prosperous term as the economy continued to grow on a stead pace. He expanded the size of the Navy, built new fortifications along the Ohio River and signed a treaty of friendship with the Kingdom of Carolina to the south. The Navy's thrashing of Skinny Pete's fleet in the Caribbean was also widely remembered.

The House of Burgesses met in the spring of 1999 to narrow the field of candidates down to two, winding up with former Governor General and Foreign Minister Lorenzo J. Taliaferro of Tappahannock and Delegate Evander Fry of Kanawha. Both candidates represented the primary axes of Virginian politics: Taliaferro the landed gentry and Fry the factory owners and slumlords. The primary issue of the campaign was ongoing crisis in Pennsylvania as Maryland was in the middle of occupying rebelling Philadelphia, while the Virginian economy was rocked by the shockwaves of the New Amsterdam merchant-prince sex trade scandal.

Taliaferro's prior executive experience let him win the day. Male turnout remained out, while female turnout had hardly improved since 1993 (overall, less than a tenth of the total adult population cast a ballot). He performed well in eastern Virginia and the southwest, while Fry did particularly well in the Appalachians. Taliaferro was inaugurated as Governor General at the end of October and he promised to force Maryland, Pennsylvania and the communist rebels to the negotiation table, even if he had to sail the entire Virginian Navy up the Delaware.

6a4hRLs.png
 
Election of 1844 – Difference in Politics: Alternate U.S. Elections (1840–2012):
The first term of John Carson's administration was rather...average, to say the least. The economy that was inherited by Marshall continued to progress in the right direction, and a few semi-protectionist trade policies were passed by Carson in his term of office. The Gag Rule was also rescinded by Congress in 1842, once again allowing the controversial topic of slavery to be discussed in the legislature. However, what is generally referred to by historians as the "absolute breaking point" for Carson's chance at being re-elected was the Panic of 1843, in which a variety of economic failures that was arguably caused by Marshall's free trade policies occurred. By the time the Whig National Conventions came in 1844, Carson was narrowly re-chosen for the nomination over the young, ambitious Senator from Maryland Elias Smith. The Democrats chose the Governor of Tennessee Randolph Langdon, who was a hardline conservative populist.

The election's results were rather unsurprising – the Democrats were able to win a landslide victory over Carson and the Whigs.

1844 Alt. Election.png
Governor Randolph Langdon (D-TN)/Former Senator Frederick Grant (D-MD) - 165 EVs
President John B. Carson (W-MA)/Vice President Henry Townshend (W-NJ) - 110 EVs

1844 Alt. Election.png
 

Thande

Donor
The Governor General election of 1999 was the second election in which the women of Virginia had the franchise (the minimum property or asset requirement remained the same as men).

Very nice! Well...not to live in, but you know what I mean ;) I see the Appalachian point around the Cumberland Gap stands out in TTL as well as it does in OTL.
 
After Bernie Sanders suffered a serious battering on Super Tuesday, it was clear his hopes of winning the nomination were dashed. Despite intense hostility to Clinton from many left-leaning Democratic voters, she easily won the nomination by the time of the DNC.

Meanwhile, the Republican primary was even more of a spectacular mess, with Trump comfortably leading whilst Cruz and Rubio fought for second, neither willing to back down. In the end, Trump won the nomination to the outrage of the Republican establishment.

Ironically, for someone who had worked for Goldwater in 1964, the Clinton campaign was very reminiscent tactically of Johnson's 1964 campaign, portraying Trump as a right-wing extremist and a racist. Whilst Sanders supporters were far from eager, they knew the alternative was Trump, the spectre of which encouraged enough of them to turn out that, along with moderates, Trump was duly slaughtered.

Trump Vs Clinton.png

(Yeah, I know this has absolutely no grounding in reality, but hey, that's what dreams are for.)

Trump Vs Clinton.png
 
I think Clinton v Trump with Clinton winning is actually the most realistic scenario right now. Not sure about the margin though.
 
I think Clinton v Trump with Clinton winning is actually the most realistic scenario right now. Not sure about the margin though.

Same here. The reason I said 'a man can dream' is because I did it as a Johnson/ Goldwater analogue of sorts. IMO what's more probable is she holds onto Nevada and Colorado (or possibly Virginia) and that gives her the election.
 

Asami

Banned
I think Clinton v Trump with Clinton winning is actually the most realistic scenario right now. Not sure about the margin though.

I see Trump beating Clinton when the chips are down, there are almost no polls showing her beating Trump in a 1v1.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top