AHC: Ex-POTUS other than Jimmy Carter is represented in US Senate by someone born after he left White House

It happened with Jimmy Carter of course: Jon Ossoff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Ossoff was born after Carter left office in January 1981. Indeed, even if Carter had been elected to a second term and left office in January 1985, Ossoff was born later than *that*--though of course a second Carter term would very likely butterfly away Ossoff's election (if not indeed his existence...)

Is there any other POTUS to whom that could have happened? Well, Herbert Hoover died in New York City on October 20, 1964. ("After leaving the White House in 1933, the Hoovers returned to California and later established a second home in an apartment in the Waldorf-Astoria in New York City. When Mrs. Hoover passed away in 1944, Mr. Hoover donated their California home to Stanford University and lived for the last 20 years of his life at the Waldorf." https://hoover.archives.gov/hoovers/homes-hoovers) So theoretically, if Senators Javits or Keating had died between March 1963 and October 1964, Governor Rockefeller could have appointed a *very* young (30 or 31 year old) interim replacement who would then represent Hoover. But it's hard to think who that could be. Rocky could have appointed Charles Goodell several years before he did--but Goodell was born in 1926...

Gerald Ford lived for a little less than 30 years after leaving the White House, so in his case it's not even theoretically possible unless you extend his life a few weeks. No other ex-president lived for more than 25 years and 314 days after leaving the White House (GHW Bush) so you'd have to extend their lives even further.

Of course, with an early enough POD you could have a much younger minimum age for senators, but that might change history too much...
 
Last edited:
George W Bush has the best odds healthwise, followed by Barack Obama, as both are highly health conscious and healthy folks.

Al Gore as POTUS would have also had decent odds given his youth.
 
Is there any other POTUS to whom that could have happened? Well, Herbert Hoover died in New York City on October 20, 1964. ("After leaving the White House in 1933, the Hoovers returned to California and later established a second home in an apartment in the Waldorf-Astoria in New York City. When Mrs. Hoover passed away in 1944, Mr. Hoover donated their California home to Stanford University and lived for the last 20 years of his life at the Waldorf." https://hoover.archives.gov/hoovers/homes-hoovers) So theoretically, if Senators Javits or Keating had died between March 1963 and October 1964, Governor Rockefeller could have appointed a *very* young (30 or 31 year old) interim replacement who would then represent Hoover. But it's hard to think who that could be. Rocky could have appointed Charles Goodell several years before he did--but Goodell was born in 1926...
Have Hoover move to Pennsylvania or Texas, then have a vacancy occur in either of those states.

The youngest Texan US House Rep (Ed Foreman) and the youngest Pennsylvanian US House Rep (William Green) were both born after Hoover left office. The problem is getting them appointed, since they were the opposite parties from each state's Governor at the time.
 
George W Bush has the best odds healthwise, followed by Barack Obama, as both are highly health conscious and healthy folks.

Al Gore as POTUS would have also had decent odds given his youth.
A Senator born after 2001 means they'd come in after 2031 (Clinton 85)
A Senator born after 2009 means they'd come in after 2039 (Bush 93).
A Senator born after 2017 means they'd come in after 2047 (Obama 86)
A Senator born after 2021 means they'd come in after 2051 (Trump 105)
 
George W Bush has the best odds healthwise, followed by Barack Obama, as both are highly health conscious and healthy folks.

Al Gore as POTUS would have also had decent odds given his youth.

The last few ex-Presidents have had to overcome some unhealthy behaviors to get there. Clinton loved his fast food (has since gone vegan,) W was an alcoholic, Obama quit smoking, and don’t get me started on Trump’s weight and COVID battle.

And given Biden’s age, if someone joins the Senate out of Delaware having been born after he leaves office, we may want to make sure he isn’t a Highlander.
 
Somehow have Alf Landon elected in 1937 - if he loses re-election, he could be represented by someone like Mike Hayden, born in 1944 and elected Governor in OTL nine months before Landon's death.
 
Easiest would be JFK isn't assassinated or Teddy Roosevelt lives a full life.
JFK was riddled with Addison's, his back pain was ever-present and debilitating, and the drugs he took to manage the former two issues killed him slowly. JFK would probably never see the 80s if he wasn't assassinated.
 
What does it mean to say that Jon Ossoff represents Jimmy Carter?
Carter is a resident of Georgia, and Ossoff represents Georgia in the Senate.

If Eisenhower dies in office, that makes Richard Nixon president. If Nixon isn't able to get elected in his own right and leaves office in 1961, he's got 33 years of post-presidency to reach his OTL death date.

Oh, another idea: Walter Mondale assumes the presidency to finish Carter's term, and (an equivalently-aged, butterfly-protected counterpart to) Ilhan Omar somehow makes it into the Senate for the 117th Congress.
 
Last edited:
Ford re-elected in 76.
Biden elected in 80.
He suffers a near fatal brain aneurysm in 1984 and decides not to seek a second term, leaving office in 85.
Sean Matthews (D) elected to the US senate in 2020, replacing retiring senator Mike Castle (R).
 
You could have it be an appointment. A Senator dies and a child or grandchild is appointed as the placeholder.

Wouldn't be elected but would still be representing the former President in the Senate.
 
If we look at pre-1900 presidents, although Millard Fillmore (b. 1800) died in 1874, one could plausibly imagine him living until, say, 1890. But it's hard to imagine a really young senator from New York being chosen from 1883 to 1890, though Theodore Rosevelt would be eligible from October 27, 1888 on!
 
Idea 1: Have an amendment that sets the minimal age for every office ( probably excluding the president) to 18, that makes it more likely.

Idea 2: President Dan Quayle if Bush can't finish his term
 
If we look at pre-1900 presidents, although Millard Fillmore (b. 1800) died in 1874, one could plausibly imagine him living until, say, 1890. But it's hard to imagine a really young senator from New York being chosen from 1883 to 1890, though Theodore Rosevelt would be eligible from October 27, 1888 on!
Get Grover Cleveland to 1920 or so, and have a Senator born in 1889-1890?

(I'm guessing focusing on Cleveland's first term does not violate the question).
 
Another idea, if we're interested in doing the alternate president route instead of the alternate senator route:

Reagan serves from 65-69. He lives IOTL until June 2004, if we can just extend that to January 2005 (let's say it's because of four fewer years in the WH), he could see Jimmy Panetta, son of Vice President Leon Panetta, sworn-in to the U.S. Senate.
 
Top