Chapter 10 - Old and New
大御神 - Ōmikami - The Great Goddess
For much of Japan’s history, folk religion and Buddhism had mixed together and even largely blurred into one unorganised conception of religion. Shrines (Shinto) and Temples (Buddhist) were built on the same plots of land, sometimes occupying the same buildings, and were indistinguishable to much of the local population. In the late Edo period, the idea of Kokugaku (國學, “National Studies”) emerged as an attempt to make sense of Japanese identity and identify what was Japanese, and what was not.
Attempting to tie nationalism, veneration of the Emperor, and Shintoism together, several scholars and government bureaus pushed to eliminate the influence of Buddhism at the start of the Meiji era. Veneration of the Emperor was a new phenomenon, however, and this movement largely failed. In its place, standardisation of Shinto began. Establishing the Jingikan (神祇官, “Department of Divinity”) in 1867 to manage standardisation and state control of Shinto, the Japanese government divided sects and shrines into two camps: True Shinto and Sect Shinto.
Those who were considered True Shinto would receive financial support, but also undergo standardisation and commit to a unified education for all priests. True Shinto shrines were moved away from Buddhist Kami (spirits/deities) and asked to emphasise Amaterasu, the Sun Goddess ancestor of the Emperor. This followed from earlier attempts to remove Buddhist influence and support veneration of the Emperor. Sect Shinto included “new religions”, or off-shoots of Shinto, which were based on various local Japanese spiritual leaders’ writings.
Japanese Sun Goddess, Amaterasu, emerging from her cave
This pressure on Buddhism remained unpopular, however, and the Jingikan was demoted to a bureau, assigned to the Ministry of Education in 1870. Imperial worship remained unpopular, possibly due to the weak influence of the Imperial household and Emperor Meiji’s young age, and instead focus drifted towards veneration of Amaterasu and past emperors. Various leaders from True Shinto began promoting Shinto as a means to preserve the old traditions of the Japanese state and society, moving the religion into more of a ceremonial and cultural than spiritual role.
In 1873, the Bureau of Shinto Affairs (successor to the Jingikan) again attempted the standardisation of priestly training, but caused significant conflict. Two factions, one led by the Ise sect (of Ise Shrine) and the other by the Izumo sect (of Izumo Shrine). The Ise sect supported further standardisation and focusing veneration on Amaterasu, while the Izumo sect wished to keep Ōkuninushi enshrined as an equal to Amaterasu.
Japanese God of State and Agriculture, Ōkuninushi
The debate was passed off to the Ministry of the Interior in 1875, as the Ministry of Education transferred the Bureau of Shinto Affairs to them. Seeing a deity of state competing with the deity of the Imperial house, the civilian government pushed for equality rather than supremacy of one over the other. The Ministry of the Interior officially ended the debate by making a distinction between the “root” and “branches” of Shinto. The divinity and position of Amaterasu was an inviolable “root” for all sects of Shinto, but their “branches” could recognise and venerate other deities. It is around this time that the association between the Imperial household and Amaterasu weakened.
The new distinction led to the replacement of the True vs Sect Shinto distinction with a further three-tiered distinction: Root, Branch, and Leaf Shinto. Root Shinto was reserved for any sect which venerates Amaterasu as the most high, Branch constituted any sect which followed the “root” teachings of the state, while “Leaf” Shinto was any other religion with a basis in Shinto. State funding was maintained for Root Shinto, while it was reduced for Branch Shinto and withheld from Leaf Shinto.
Meanwhile, the association of Amaterasu with the nation of Japan remained strong. With Root Shinto pushing for veneration of the Sun Goddess as a mother of Japan, the popular rural Agriculture Goddess Inari Ōkami (稲荷大神) began to be conflated with her. This resulted in a feedback loop, as Inari shrines needed to venerate Amaterasu, locals who usually prayed to Inari Ōkami would misidentify Amaterasu at other shrines as Inari Ōkami, and vice versa. The end result was positive, however, since worshippers now saw Amaterasu as a friendly, motherly figure and not an unreachable Imperial deity.
Ise Shrine, the most influential in Root Shinto
日朝一家 - Nitchō Ikka - Japan and Korea are One Family
While religion in Japan was generally peaceful, shrines were occasionally built for war dead. In 1879, Yasukuni Shrine was built for that exact purpose, and received a visit from the Emperor. Japanese nationalists believed Shinto should demonstrate patriotism for the rest of the country, and pressured other shrines to follow the example of Yasukuni. The issue for the state was the overlap between aggressive patriotism and the army, which had been equally hostile to both pacifist Shinto sects and the civilian government. To end the debate and find support for the government from Shintoism, a law was passed permitting war dead to only be enshrined at designated shrines.
The combination of limiting nationalism and accepting of a wide range of positions in Shinto allowed for a unique phenomenon to occur in Korea. Religion in Korea had been split for a long time between Confucianism and Buddhism. Much as Buddhism and Shinto had merged in Japan, religion had also mixed together in Korea. Though there were traces of traditional Korean beliefs in contemporary beliefs and rituals, Koreans did not typically see themselves as practising strictly one thing or another, but as carrying out required religious rituals.
Shortly after the de facto annexation of Korea, several Shinto scholars made their way over. There, they saw what Japan was before religious reforms, and they wanted to institute the same changes. Initial reception to these ideas was poor, however, as all services and administration were conducted in Japanese. In 1897, the Meeting of Busan changed this. Involving the leaders of several local Root Shinto sects, an agreement was made to switch to using Korean language. The move was condemned by many nationalists, but ultimately proved successful.
With Pan-Asian ideology more popular than ever, the Busan Shinto sects adapted and took in more Korean traditions and rituals. While they were demoted to Branch Shinto by the Japanese government, their success was undeniable. They met Korean traditions halfway and helped to foster cooperation between Japanese and Koreans. The success of cross-strait religious accommodations also likely contributed to political concessions later on.
Genzan Shrine in Genzan (Wonsan), built in 1882 and later elevated to Root Shinto status
From 1899 on, Japanese settlement in Korea grew massively. The cause, however, was landlordism and land confiscations. Much of the arable land in Korea had been owned without deeds, using tradition to know who owned which lands. When the Japanese attempted to properly survey the lands and record ownership, they rejected any claims made without deeds and sold the land to buyers, who were usually rich Japanese businessmen. This was noticed by Governor-General Terauchi Masatake, who later became Prime Minister.
Terauchi was a firm believer in assimilation of Koreans into Japanese society, but wanted to do this through cultural means. Responsible for the 1901 Korea Annexation treaty, he supported cultural projects and built schools across the country. This meant nothing for resentful Koreans, however, who had been pushed off their land for Japanese developers. To remedy the situation, Terauchi passed laws to protect Koreans from eviction. Absenteeism became a restricted practice, and some Koreans were given back their land upon verbal testimony from other citizens.
A school in Korea teaching Japanese**
With Korean language accepted among Shinto sects, the views of settlers and the government soon began to soften. In 1911, new Governor-General signed the Chōsen Act, and the 13 circuits (道, dō) of Korea were reorganised into 13 prefectures (県, ken), to match Japan. In addition, the 13 prefectures were bound together in the “Council of Chōsen Affairs” (朝鮮問題評議会, Chōsen mondai hyōgi-kai), an independent body composed of the 13 prefectural governors. The name of Korea would be officially changed to Chōsen, though it would often be referred to as the “Council Territory” (評議会領土, Hyōgi-kai ryōdo) due to its unique pseudo-government.
Furthermore, the 1912 Chōsen Education Act reformed education in the Council Territory to add Korean as an additional subject. The main issue with this decision became how to teach Korean writing. Some proposed Eonmun (諺文, jp: Genbun, “vernacular script”), as that script helped to drive a wedge between Koreans and China, while others proposed using Katakana or Hiragana (Japanese phonetic characters) to bring them closer to Japan.
Initially, a Katakana-based orthography named “New Script” (新文, jp: Shimbun, ko: Sinmun), was devised and enforced. However, the shortcomings of Sinmun became apparent once it entered the school system. Korean students were frequently caught writing notes in Eonmun and later changing them to Sinmun to avoid punishment. After much debate and uproar from both Korean and Japanese writers, Eonmun was accepted as the standard for Korean-language curriculum.
English | All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. |
Japanese | スベテノ人間ハ、生マレナガラニシテ自由デアリ、カツ、尊厳ト権利トニツイテ平等デアル。 |
Sinmun | ムーヅン 人間ン テアナㇽ`デブータ 自由ロウミャ グ 尊厳グィ 権利エ イ`スア 同等ハーダー。 |
Eonmun | 모든 人間은 태어날 때부터 自由로우며 그 尊厳과 権利에 있어 同等하다。 |
Comparison using the first article of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Slowly but surely, Japanese perception of Koreans changed from a domineering fatherly position to that of a sibling. Instead of trying to force Japanese culture on Koreans, it became more popular to search for parallels between the two cultures. Korean religion began to standardise separately from Shinto, but also adopted many customs and structures from it. Eventually, Korean and Japanese language began to share near-equal status. While cities skewed towards using Japanese due to bilateral trade, the countryside began to adopt standardised Korean and writing with Eonmun.
皇姑屯事件 - The Huanggutun Incident
Meanwhile, Manchuria had developed on its own, independent of the Home Islands’ move towards stronger democracy. Having fallen under Japanese influence with the collapse of Russia, the Chinese Eastern Railway was consolidated along with all regional rail under the new Manchuria Railway Company (満州鉄道株式会社, Manshū Tetsudō Kabushikigaisha), also called “Mantetsu” for short.
The Qing Dynasty was also long gone, and in its place in Manchuria, the warlord Zhang Zuolin had consolidated a military state known as the Fengtian Clique. Though formally part of the new Republic of China, Zhang Zuolin wished to see himself on top and thus kept his distance from Beijing (the old capital) and Nanjing (the new capital) until he had enough strength to push his claim. He continually struggled with reforming his private army and eradicating banditry in the countryside, and thus turned to Japan for help.
The Fengtian Clique was supported by Japan, the Guomindang (Chinese Nationalists) were supported by the new SSG and France, while the Zhili Clique was supported by Britain and the United States. After several rounds of fighting between the various warlords, peace finally came in 1922 with the First United Front. Ending warlordism, it instead instituted a kind of legal limbo which recognised that China was united, while at the same time not agreeing who was in charge.
Generalissimo Zhang Zuolin**
In exchange for a free hand in the economy and development of Japanese-owned industrial towns, the Imperial Japanese Army created the Kwantung Army (関東軍, Kantō-gun) as a special security force to protect the railways. While the Japanese government was supportive of this, as it gave them more influence in Manchuria, they soon grew sceptical and suspicious of the Army’s intentions.
The Kwantung Army and Mantetsu began growing closer and closer, and many of the expansionist-minded military officers and thinkers began transferring to Manchuria. A division between peace-minded and expansionist officers began to emerge, as the Kwantung Army was now exclusively expansionist. The navy, which had been a staunch ally of the civilian government since the Sea First doctrine (海主陸従, Kaishu Rikujū) became officially sanctioned, repeatedly tried to thwart the army’s plans to no avail.
In 1919, in an effort to curtail the Kwantung Army’s power, the government split them into a two-level power structure with a civilian administration above the military one. This did not solve the problem, however, as the army held too much power in the region and was able to force their own candidates into the civilian government. This only strengthened the nascent Kōdōha (皇道派, Kōdōha, “Imperial Way Faction”) movement, which wanted to see a “Taishō Restoration”. They saw the civilian government as a mistake, which had only gotten worse since Emperor Meiji’s death in 1912. As such, it needed to be abolished and replaced by a cooperative power structure between the Emperor and the Army.
With members of the Army sitting directly in civilian government, Kōdōha grew stronger and more vocal. This all came to a head in 1923, when the Great Kantō Earthquake devastated central Japan and caused massive economic difficulty. Leading to frustration among the Kwantung leadership, plans for direct intervention in the Fengtian leadership were moved forward when the Northern Expedition succeeded. Jiang Jieshi, leader of the National Revolutionary Army, had defeated the warlords of the Zhili Clique and retaken Beijing (later renamed Beiping).
Kwantung plans were finally revealed in 1925, when an attempt on the life of Zhang Zuolin was made. Departing from Huanggutun Railway Station, Zhang’s train was derailed when an explosion occured near the back. Luckily, the warlord had gone between the first and second carriage to have a smoke with one of his aides, and when the explosion happened he was able to dive from the train and roll. Breaking a few bones but surviving, Zhang was rescued by Fengtian soldiers, who proceeded to fight off the small Kwantung group which had gone to inspect the wreckage.
Fearing a Guomindang or Soyuz takeover of Manchuria, Kwantung intended to assassination Zhang and install a puppet, thus turning the region into a protectorate like Hawaii. Unfortunately, Zhang had survived. To make matters worse, the Japanese government denounced the actions of the Kwantung Army and stripped its leaders of their ranks. Wishing to repair relations and save face, Japan reached out to Zhang and offered to intervene militarily. This worked in some ways, but failed in others.
Leaders of the Kwantung Insurrection
Zhang was more than happy to accept Japanese help, but the Guomindang in Nanjing were less than thrilled. To Chinese President Duan Qirui, this was a violation of Chinese sovereignty. Encouraged by their recent victory in the Northern Expedition, Duan wanted to make a show of force which would elevate China on the international stage, and hopefully attract more foreign investment. Once again dispatching the National Revolutionary Army under Jiang Jieshi, he ordered the complete expulsion of Japanese forces (of any kind) from Manchuria.
This put Zhang in a difficult position: he wanted to remain in the United Front and later assert himself from within, but he did not want to be subjugated completely by the Guomindang. Ultimately, he sided with the Japanese government, and a three-way war began. The Kwantung administration was based in Ryojun (旅順, Lǚshùn, also: Port Arthur), and was immediately challenged by naval attacks from the Imperial Japanese Navy. Land forces marching north from Korea managed to take Changchun and Harbin were met with tough resistance, but the recent adoption of aircraft proved invaluable, as the new technology had been restricted to only the Navy. Meanwhile, Imperial Russian forces marched west across the border towards Aigun, intending to link up with Fengtian forces.
Any hopes Kwantung had of winning were dashed in 1926 with the death of Emperor Taishō and ascension of Hirohito to the throne. Emperor Shōwa stayed true to his father’s wishes and denounced them as traitors to the Imperial House and to the nation. In a last-ditch effort to right their shame, many of the leaders of the insurrection committed seppuku: preferring to disembowel themselves to show repentance rather than face trial and execution. With Kwantung defeated, Japan and Fengtian began preparing to push back Jiang’s forces.
The Chinese had nearly reached Zhang’s de facto capital of Fengtian, since most strength had been diverted towards fighting Kwantung , and since Zhang had hoped to peacefully resolve the conflict. Hastily moving the capital to Changchun, he offered further concessions to Japan in exchange for aid in pushing out the Guomindang: a full transfer of the Korean-claimed Gando/Jiandao region, continued Japanese ownership of the Fengtian Clique’s railways, and additional economic concessions related to mining rights. Though they were strictly promises, Japan was quick to take Zhang up on his offer. Dispatching the Navy to bombard Tianjin and other ports along the Yellow Sea, Japan was able to land marines behind Jiang’s forces and flank the NRA.
With his supply lines cut and his troops tired from continued harassment from bandits and naval aircraft, Jiang decided to pull back. His defeat was not absolute or indisputable, but China had lost its chance to prove itself. The relationship between Guomindang China, the United Front, the Fengtian Clique, and Japan would need to be re-examined and negotiated.
Japanese soldiers during the Manchurian Crisis
The Manchurian Crisis, as it came to be known, was finally resolved with the Treaty of Tanggu in 1928. In it, China recognised the “Northeast Republic” (東北共和國, ch: Dōngběi gònghéguó, jp: Tōhoku kyōwakoku) under Zhang Zuolin’s government, and both agreed to a non-aggression pact lasting at least 10 years. The Chinese-NER border was officially demarcated with West Xing’an and Rehe provinces as part of the Republic of China, while South Xing’an and Jinzhou would be part of the NER. The new Northeast Republic, informally referred to as Manchuria (満國, ch: Mǎnguó, jp: Mankoku), was ambiguous as to whether it should be part of a united China or not. In any case, it did not remain within the Chinese United Front due to recent hostilities.
Manchuria also agreed to give the concessions it previously promised to Japan; The Jiandao province, as well as the area around Mt Baekdu, were to be handed over due to Korean claims on the area. As well, Japan would receive continued control of Manchurian railways and receive exclusive mining rights across the country. No other foreign country could prospect for, or extract, Manchurian minerals.
Administrative divisions of Manchuria, showing lost territory
(West Xing’an and Rehe were claimed, but not totally controlled)
Though he didn’t wish to be a Japanese vassal, Zhang came very close to becoming one. His original plan of building strength and eventually taking the rest of China for himself also no longer seemed possible. Instead, the Generalissimo focused on cementing his position within the new state. The new state faced an identity crisis, as most of the Han population still wanted a unified Chinese state, but was resentful towards the ROC for their recent actions. The NER could also not exactly adopt a Manchu identity, as the near-extinction of the Manchu language and culture prevented that. Instead, they opted for a middle road of promoting separation from the ROC but also the desire for Chinese unification. Manchuria would join the Keijo Accord shortly after peace, in 1931.
Meanwhile, Japan’s relationship with China remained rocky. While many of the Guomindang’s main thinkers had studied in Japan due to Qing oppression, their opinion of Japan had soured from the Manchurian Crisis. It was true that Japan had not taken much land or established a puppet state, and it was also true that Japan had only intervened to protect their Chinese ally, but it was also true that Japan had opposed the Guomindang and challenged the authority of the United Front. The party, which had previously only been split between Left and Right, was now also split into Anti and Pro-Japanese factions.
The new flag of the Northeast Republic: White represents the north and freedom, Gold represents wealth and the land itself, while black represents the Shanhai Pass which connects Manchuria to China.
Edit: Fixed a lore mistake: Japanese ITTL still uses Katakana for most things, not Hiragana. Fixed the language comparison table to match. Japanese language will be touched on in a later update.