Chapter 14: Politicide
“I offer my opponents a bargain: if they will stop telling lies about us, I will stop telling the truth about them” - Adlai Stevenson (OTL)
The Election of 1960 remains one of the most controversial and negative elections in American history. It would bring many innovations in campaigning over the tv and radio and would also bring the term “October Surprise” into the political lexicon.
President Bush had come hot off his defeat in the 1958 Midterms with a plan. He saw the Democratic Party beginning to make a pivot to the left, however its leftward moves were being resisted by an increasingly hardline conservative wing. Bush saw a chance to break up a part of the New Deal Coalition and pick off two groups of traditionally Democratic voters, Jews and African-Americans by presenting the Democratic party as too concerned with its own internal conflict rather than preserving the New Deal Coalition. Bush would pivot the Republican Party towards a more pro-Israel stance, repealing the moratorium on weapons sales to Israel in 1959. Bush and Knowland would be renominated easily and the party began to adopt Bush’s strategy of appealing to African-Americans and Jews, putting them into play for the first time since 1932.
The Democratic Party meanwhile, went through a slightly less acrimonious convention in 1960 and nominated a ticket of Happy Chandler for president, in order to cement the Democratic Party’s support of civil rights while also pandering to Southerners chafing under “Yankee Domination”. Massachusetts Senator Jack Kennedy would be selected for vice president with the hopes that his youth and Catholicism would appeal to Northeasterners and liberals. Many voters, however, still saw the Democratic Party as divided, no doubt aided by the mixed messaging and equivocation Southern Democrats gave towards the presidential ticket. Southern voter turnout would be predictably low in this election. Some Southern Democrats debated splitting off and forming their own party, however this would be desired for two reasons.
One was that their legislative influence would be irreparably damaged in such a schism, as they would no longer be part of the Democratic Congressional majority and would lose their powerful committee chairs. Their ability to restrict Republican civil rights legislation would be dampened and such a split would only strengthen the anti-segregation bipartisan faction in the Senate.
The other would be, surprisingly, ideological division. A hypothetical party, despite being united in support of states rights and segregation, would inevitably be divided over issues of whether to be economically left wing or right wing. The growth of unionism in Southern cities had hamstring many Southern Democrats into pandering to their interests, while more rural representatives remained anti-union. Also, near feudal levels of infighting between Southern Democrats for control of a hypothetical party would doom it to failure.
The Chandler/Kennedy ticket seemed, on paper, as a solid ticket to beat Bush. Chandler was a moderate integrationist and moderate to conservaive Democratic popular in the South and Midwest, while Kennedy’s youth and Catholicism could attract minorities and younger, more liberal voters to the ticket. Chandler would campaign hard, blaming Bush for the Recession of 1958 and how little action he took to mitigate it, presumably due to his wealth, according to Chandler. However, Chandlers’ ties to segregationist Senator Harry Byrd and his past tirades against certain aspects of the New Deal would anger many northern liberals. He was also seen as vain and concerned with personal power. Kennedy however, would be the biggest danger to the ticket.
On October 14th, 1960, the New York times released a story stating that Kennedy had been involved in an effort to hide his Addison's Disease from the public, as well as his numerous back problems he had gained from the war. The shocking revelation that the youthful and charismatic Kennedy was lying to the American people ignited a firestorm of condemnation. Mnny in rural areas already mistreated Kennedy due to his Catholicism, with these revelations only adding fuel to the fire. Bush for his part, did not campaign on the matter of Kennedy's health, only stating that the American people deserve the truth about the wellbeing of their civic leaders. Chandler would campaign in the midwest in an attempt to stem the damage, but it was already done.
Election of 1960
Bush/Knowland-56.5%-399EV
Chandler/Kennedy-41.4%-134 EV
Strom Thurmond/Orval Faubus- 3 EV (1 Mississippi, 2 South Carolina)
Richard Russell/ Strom Thurmond-1 EV (Georgia)
House of Representatives:
Rep- 198+19 =217
Dem- 232-13=219
Senate:
Dem- 60-4=56
Rep- 40+4=44
The result was a Democratic blowout. The Democrats almost lost control of the House yet again, with liberal Democratic losses in the North only reigniting the internal conflict of the Democratic Party. John Kennedy’s political career, meanwhile, lay in shambles. He would serve out the rest of his Senate term, before retiring and becoming a semi-accomplished and well known writer of alternate history, before dying in 1987. History, however, would be much kinder to his two brothers, Bobby and Ted, whose political careers were just starting to take off, and had almost been derailed by association with John. Bush, meanwhile, had won himself a second term, just as events both at home, and abroad, threatened to upset the fragile peace that Bush had maintained.