Foreign Snapshot: El Fénix
------------------
Foreign Snapshot: El Fénix

It is still difficult, to this day, to describe the amount of sheer joy that the people of Mexico felt on December 1, 1988. That day, president Miguel de la Madrid, a member of the hated and seemingly invincible PRI, handed the presidential sash and all of the executive power that belonged to him to his successor, Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas Solórzano, who had somehow performed the impossible and brought an end to 59 years of single-party rule. The mood of the crowd of at least 500.000 people that gathered in the Zócalo to greet the new ruler of the most populous Spanish speaking country on Earth could only be described as completely delirious. Despite their somehow almost simultaneously stopped cheering to listen to every word he said, as if he was a Messiah who would lead them to an era of endless prosperity. And they certainly weren't the only ones in the nation who believed in that.

entrega_baston_de_mando_01118_01.jpg


It was simply too much of a coincidence for that to not happen. The last time Mexico elected an opposition candidate was in... 1910, when none other than Francisco Madero, a hardworking and honest man who gave his life for his country, brought an end to the Porfiriato, a corrupt dictatorship that lasted for 35 years. As if that wasn't enough, it didn't even take an armed insurrection to get PRI out of power: all they needed to do was organize and vote for the right candidate. It was time for a new Revolution, one that manifested itself through laws and rallies, rather than vast armies and bloody battles.

To add to these wild (at the very least) expectations, the new president was the son of Lázaro Cárdenas, who was probably the best leader that the country had in the 20th century, with any attempt to criticize him being seen as a mortal sin. As such, Cuauhtémoc definitely had the "pedigree" to be an excellent ruler, and that was without the executive experience that he earned during the six years as governor of Michoacán, a state that his father also commanded. And since sons are supposed to be better than their fathers, well...

Poor Solórzano didn't meet his people's expectations. No one could.

After he took over, everyone found out the grim reality that PRI wasn't dead at all: they still had all of Mexico's state and local governments under their control, along with a substantial portion of the Chamber of Deputies that was enough to cause quite a headache, even if they didn't have an absolute majority, and worst of all, they had a crushing majority in the Senate, where they controlled 55 seats, while the FDN held 7 seats and PAN just 2 seats (1). The legislature, which for decades served only to rubber stamp decisions made by autocratic presidents, suddenly armed itself to the teeth and stood ready ready stonewall all of Cárdenas' initiatives and turn his life into a living hell.

How was he supposed to get anything done under these conditions?

It is often said that politics make strange bedfellows, and what Solórzano did on January 5, 1989 proved that. Simmering after being effectively forbidden from doing his work thanks to systematic opposition from PRI hardliners (dinosaurios) in Congress and in the states, the president had a meeting with Manuel Clouthier (2), Diego Fernández de Cevallos and Luis H. Álvarez, the highest-ranking panistas in the country. There was just one hurdle, however: their agenda was almost completely opposed to the one Cárdenas defended. While he and FDN were center-left and strongly secularistic, PAN was closely linked with conservative northern industrialists and catholics who opposed the many restrictions imposed on the Church. On any normal situation, these two groups would despise each other.

In spite of all of that, they agreed on one crucial thing that ensured that their alliance became a reality: they loathed PRI infinitely more than each other.

foto.jpg

Left to right: Diego Fernández de Cevallos, Manuel Clouthier, Rosario Ibarra (a former communist and ally of the president), Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas and Luis H. Álvarez. As one can see, none of them are really happy about the recent turn of events.

Right after that alliance was made, president Cárdenas renewed his efforts to get at least one major piece of legislation through the dinosaurios that dominated the Senate. After weeks of negotiations, backroom deals, arm twisting and some honestly humiliating begging to priístas that he would never forget or forgive, he finally got his wish: on January 21 (3), the federal government announced the creation of the National Solidarity Program (PRONASOL) , an ambitious initiative that would later earn international praise and serve as a model for other Latin American countries to follow, particularly those who elected Pink Tide governments. It consisted of the channeling of federal resources to impoverished areas that were lacking in healthcare, education and basic infrastructure, ensuring that the people who lived in these regions experienced an improvement of their standard of living.

On the other hand, Cárdenas had to honor his end of the pact with PAN, whose assistance was critical in the creation of PRONASOL. To do that, he completed the privatization of Telmex, the state telephone company, which had started under Madrid's administration and concluded with it being sold to media mogul Joaquín Vargas Gómez, owner of the radio broadcaster MVS Comunicaciones (4). The banking industry which was nationalized in the last days of the troubled and corrupt presidency of José López Portillo, who preceded Miguel de la Madrid, was returned to the private sector. On the religious front, the Catholic Church was allowed to hold property once more, and priests were allowed to vote and wear their robes in public.

These measures did much to mitigate the concerns of international investors who, despite approving the downfall of a corrupt government (it's bad for business, after all) still had that kneejerk fear that a left-of-center administration would enact extremist policies regarding the economy. The end of the restrictions on the Church was also well received by the Mexican population in general, which was and still is highly religious, and was also seen as an important step towards the full democratization of the country. However, there were also sectors of the left, mostly radical university students, that were disillusioned with them, believing that the president was shifting himself to the right and abandoning his original projects. Some of them even began to call him "Cárdenas the Little", in contrast with his late father, "Cárdenas the Great".

All in all, despite these advancements, Solórzano and his allies still had to face much resistance from PRI to enact anything, since the systematic and absolute opposition led by the dinosaurios would remind an American watcher of the attitude of southern Dixiecrats toward civil rights. There were many things that were left to be done: many crooks who should have been jailed long ago were still loose, an electoral reform to finally end fraud (one of the few things that PAN and FDN agreed on) would never be passed by the current Senate, and, last but absolutely not least, the people who masterminded the Mexican Dirty War, especially former president Luís Echeverría, were still free. It was said one of the only three things that Cárdenas could do was pass funding bills to make sure that important pieces of infrastructure didn't break down from lack of maintenance.

The second thing he could do was dedicate a greater amount of time than usual managing Mexico's foreign policy. Speaking of that, the nation was directly benefited by two world events that were completely out of its control. The first and most distant of them was the Rape of Basra, which occurred in 1987, when Iranian troops finally took over Iraq's second largest city after a four-year siege and massacred its population, totally dismantling the very structures of the Iraqi state and throwing it into a civil war from which it is yet to recover (5). This horrific atrocity ensured that oil prices would remain high throughout the late eighties and early nineties, giving the newborn Mexican democracy a critical source of revenue.

The second and much closer event was the election of California senator Jerry Brown for the presidency of the United States of America. He and his running mate, Pennsylvania governor Allen Ertel (6), were also benefited by the Rape of Basra, since the incumbent Republican president, Ronald Reagan, resigned in disgrace because he and high-ranking members of his administration were involved in a scandal that became known as Irangate. Said scandal consisted of secret arms sales to the Iranian government, with the Reagan administration using the funds acquired from these transactions to support the Contras, a terrorist group in Nicaragua that had lauched itself into a war against the democratically elected government of Daniel Ortega, who first took power in 1979 after unseating dictator Anastasio Somoza Debayle in a revolution (7).

Brown was an ardent opponent of NAFTA (the North American Free Trade Agreement) and immediatly pulled the USA out of the talks focused on its creation, ensuring that it would never materialize. President Cárdenas would no longer have to worry about the possibility of Mexican farmers being outcompeted by American companies within their own country's borders. He was also free to seek closer commercial links with fellow Latin American countries, particularly those that, like Mexico and later Brazil, elected presidents that belonged to the so called "Pink Tide".

Jerry-Brown-1974-Jeff-Robbins-Associated-Press.jpg

The eccentric Edumund Gerald "Jerry" Brown Jr. was one of president Reagan's most vicious critics in the US Senate. After taking power, he immediatly set out on undoing most of his predecessor's measures, such as tax cuts for the rich and a hardline stance against leftist parties and governments in Latin America. Some would later say that he became the Pink Tide's northernmost member.

The third and probably most important thing Solórzano could do was build and strengthen his base. The Frente Democrático Nacional that carried him to victory in 1988 was not an united party, but rather a ragtag coalition between several small leftist parties combined with a group of defectors (the "Democratic Current") from PRI. This group was finally unified under one flag on 1990, with the creation of PRD, the Party of the Democratic Revolution, allowing the allies to from now on now coordinate their actions to ensure maximum political impact. Cárdenas also regularly toured the country and spoke with ordinary people whenever possible, solidifying his image as a popular leader. The most important thing he did on this front, however, was personally overseeing the reconstruction of Mexico City, which, according to him, would rise again "like a phoenix reborn from the ashes"(8).

Cuauhtémoc's future prospects improved significantly after July 2, 1989, when he received what was probably the best news he had heard since his presidential victory last year. That day, an election was held in the little state of Baja California in which the governor's seat was at stake. The victor in that race was the panista Ernesto Ruffo Appel, who was elected by an overwhelming majority of the voters (65%) and became the first non-priísta state governor elected anywhere in Mexico in sixty years. After that stunning victory, many once loyal priístas saw the writing in the wall deserted their party en masse, with the bulk of these defectors going to PAN and the few remaining leftists, such as Francisco Luna Kan, former governor of Yucatán, joining ranks with the president. The dinosaurios now had complete control over PRI's machine, but found it on the verge of completely melting away.

Ernesto%20Ruffo.jpg

Ernesto Ruffo Appel.

The extremely demanding task of running the country became much easier from now on. Even then, not all was birds and roses: as PRI's power declined, the "Democratic Alliance" between PRD and PAN began to show signs of exhaustion, since the two parties had virtually opposed views on how to run Mexico and their common enemy, the one thing that kept them together, was in a state of irreversible decay. Indeed, although he wouldn't ever dare to admit it publicly, president Cárdenas was extremely frustrated with PRONASOL, the world-acclaimed program that became the public face of his administration. Its implementation was only possible thanks to several concessions that he was forced to give to his rightist allies, namely by in the form of the already mentioned privatizations (even if some of them were really necessary) and cuts on other welfare programs.

The Democratic Alliance was finally disbanded after the climatic congressional and gubernatorial elections that took place in 1991 and 1992. In the legislative ones, PRD elected 278 deputies (an absolute majority) and 16 senators, PAN won 153 and 10 seats respectively, and PRI languished in a very distant third, with only 115 deputies and 4 senators, while the rest of the seats were taken over by members of minor parties. On the gubernatorial front, PAN's performance was significantly better, since they captured six governorships (Guanajuato, Chihuahua, Sinaloa, Nuevo León, Durango and Durango) and PRD won two seats (Solórzano's home state of Michoacán and San Luis Potosí) with the remaining states electing priísta governors, the most important of them being Puebla, where the infamous dinosaurio Manuel Bartlett Díaz took over the governorship (9).

With clear majorities in both houses of Congress and governors who wouldn't undermine the enforcement of any meaningful measures, president Cárdenas was at last free to pursue his own projects, and he acted accordingly. Throwing himself into a flurry of activity, presenting bill after bill to the legislature, most of which were approved without too many difficulties, the second half of his six-year term became colloquially known as "El Sexenio de Tres Años" (the three-year sexenio). It was during this period that some of his most celebrated measures were enacted, such as a substantial increase in the aid provided by PRONASOL, the Tierra para Todos program, which consisted of subsidies and low interest loans to small landowners, and an absolutely massive increase of investments towards public education. The thousands of new schools built during this period were called "Cientros de Educación Pública Integral" (Integrated Public Education Centers), best known by the acronym of CEPI, obviously inspired by the Brazilian CIEPs idealized by Darcy Ribeiro and Oscar Niemeyer.

CIDADES-Educa%C3%A7%C3%A3o-remaneja-alunos-da-Creche-Dona-Lili-2.CIEP-489.Divulga%C3%A7%C3%A3o-PMR.jpg.jpg

A CEPI somewhere in Chiapas. What? Imitation is the best form of flattery, after all, and Brizola certainly didn't mind.

The government also stepped up on its anti-corruption rhetoric and, among other things, ordered the arrest of priísta insider and union boss Elba Esther Gordillo, leader of the National Teachers Union (the largest of its kind in Latin America) and famous for her extravagant and luxurious lifestyle, on charges of corruption and embezzlement that were almost certainly true (10). Most importantly, president Cárdenas ensured that Congress approved the creation of a National Truth Commission to thoroughly investigate what had truly happened in the Mexican Dirty War that occurred in the 1970s, when the Perfect Dictatorship's autocratic tendencies reached their peak (11).

Hundreds of former police officers, paramilitary members, politicians and bureaucrats were prosecuted, and many of them were jailed on charges of murder and crimes against humanity. The most prominent person to be jailed was former president Luis Echeverría Álvarez, who was directly responsible for the Tlatelolco Massacre of 1968, back when he was the Secretary of the Interior of the late former president Gustavo Díaz Ordaz, and the Corpus Christi Massacre of 1971, best known as the Halconazo, when he was already Mexico's supreme executive. His trial was highly televised, and his sentencing was celebrated in public parties all over the country, as the relatives of the hundreds of students that were killed under his orders could finally rest assured that justice was done. Echeverría would spend the rest of his life in a prison cell until his death in 2006 at the age of 84 (12).

latest

Echeverría's official portrait as president, when he was at the zenith of his power.

By the time the 1994 presidential election came up, Cárdenas' popularity among the people had reached immense heights, since the measures and achievements mentioned above led to a direct and drastic improvement in their standard of living. He cemented himself as one of his country's greatest leaders, proved to be a worthy successor to his father and someone to be respected and admired even by his detractors thanks to his honesty. As such, it would be very easy to assume that whoever won his endorsement would have a cakewalk ahead of him or her.

Things are rarely so predictable.

The panistas, rallied behind their candidate, deputy Diego Fernández de Cevallos (their 1988 candidate, Manuel Clouthier, had been elected governor of Sinaloa) were emboldened by their numerous gubernatorial victories and ran an energetic campaign, especially in the wealthy northern states, where they were strongest. In the span of only a few years, PAN had grown from an irrelevant opposition party whose sole purpose was to legitimize the Perfect Dictatorship to a force to be reckoned with, one with a very wide support base. Meanwhile, the sinking priístas selected Francisco Labastida Ochoa, a hardliner and former governor of Sinaloa, as their candidate, and they were determined to not die a quiet death, and were poised to take as much of the vote as they could possibly get, something that would obviously throw the potential results into the air.

The candidate chosen by PRD, Secretary of Finance Ifigenia Martínez, had her hands quite full, and as a result campaigned with the president all over the country, especially in the south and the capital. She, along with Cevallos and Labastida, also took part in the first presidential debates in Mexican history, which were basically contests between Martínez and Cevallos over who could hit poor Labastida the hardest.

Mexico 1994.PNG


The result of Mexico's first honest election was highly polarized, and although Cárdenas' popularity eventually assured Martínez's victory, Cevallos' herculean effort allowed him to sweep the northern states and come much closer to the presidency than expected. He quickly conceded, content with the fact that PAN was now a powerful force, and extremely glad that PRI was reduced to a battered hollow shell of its once invincible self.

------------------
Notes:

(1) IOTL, PRI held an absolute majority in the lower house (260 seats) and a crushing 60 seats in the Senate.

(2) IOTL, Manuel Clouthier was killed in a car accident on October 1989. Here, that doesn't happen.

(3) Salinas de Gortari's first act, on November 1988, was to create PRONASOL, which he used not to assist the poor, but rather to bribe voters and prevent them to vote for opposition candidates. ITTL, since Cárdenas faces a determined opposition from PRI, it is enacted almost three months later, but it will also be more focused toward the needy.

(4) IOTL, Telmex was given to Carlos Slim Helú.

(5) I may or may not write an update about the Iran-Iraq War.

(6) Allen Ertel ran for the governorship of Pennsylvania in 1982, but was narrowly defeated by incumbent GOP governor Dick Thornburgh. Here, he barely wins and becomes senator Brown's running mate.

(7) And look at where Ortega is now.

(8) Title Drop!

(9) This guy is a nasty piece of work. If you want to know more, just take a look at Roberto El Rey's excellent timeline.


(10) IOTL, Gordillo was only arrested in 2013.

(11) As far as I know, Mexico never had anything like a truth commission IOTL.

(12) IOTL, Echeverría was briefly put into house arrest in 2006 over his crimes, but was released on bases of ill health. Now he's 97 years old and will certainly die a free man.
 
Some extra things:

First, because of better governance by the Mexican federal government and the fact that NAFTA won't exist, the Zapatista Rebellion was butterflied away. I should have probably put a note on that.

Second, I won't make an update on the United States, seeing as I somehow managed to shoehorn President Moonbeam and the ATL Iran-Contra scandal (Irangate) into the last update.

Third, my next update will be focused on Argentina and Raúl Alfonsín. If there's any poster from that country watching this TL, your advice would be much appreciated.

Fourth, here's a bonus image:

Cuauhtmoc-Crdenas-Partido-de-la-Revolucin-Democrtica-Porfirio-Muoz-Ledo-Ifigenia-Martnez-Poltica.jpeg

President Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas having a chat with Porfirio Muñoz Ledo, one of his closest associates. In 1988, after assuming the presidency, Cárdenas appointed Ledo to the mayoralty of Mexico City, becoming the last municipal executive to take office this way. He was given the difficult task of rebuilding the shattered capital, still full of rubble and scars from the 1985 earthquake.
 

Taimur500

Banned
, it didn't even take an armed insurrection to get PRI out of power: all they needed to do was organize and vote for the right candidate
considering the eighties, i think that's pretty utopian.
but don't get heated over small details, your tl is amazing
 
considering the eighties, i think that's pretty utopian.
but don't get heated over small details, your tl is amazing
When dictatorships, especially long lasting ones like PRI in Mexico, fall apart, everything seems possible. Plus, PRI fell from power not because they were defeated (they lost the 1988 presidential election IOTL, they just managed to rig the result) but because they botched the whole earthquake thing even harder.
 
Foreign Snapshot: Never Again, No Matter What
Special thanks to @juanml82 for advising me on this update. Also, I didn't see any comments complaining about my shitty map, so here's a new one.
------------------

Foreign Snapshot: Never Again, No Matter What

Ah, Argentina.

Brazil's big southern neighbor, once its biggest rival back in the 19th century, underwent many of the processes that it went through in the 20th. However, as every country is obviously unique, it had its own twists. For starters, it suffered no less than six military coups (1930, 1943, 1955, 1962, 1966 and 1976) with no democratically elected government being allowed to finish its term after the first one. The chronic political instability, combined with the presence of the army as a Praetorian Guard and the several dictatorships that spawned thanks to that had profoundly adverse effects on the country's economic development. The last one created a series of juntas that became known as the National Reorganization Process, an exceptionally brutal and corrupt regime that ruled the largest Spanish speaking nation in the world for seven years and led to the deaths of at least thirty thousand people.

Argentina6.jpg

The members of the first junta that took over in 1976. Left to right: Admiral Emilio Massera, Lt. General Jorge Videla, and Brig. General Orlando Agosti.

Their general incompetence and brutality earned them the hatred of the Argentine people, and the only reason they survived for as long as they did was because of their opponents' very strange tendency to disappear whenever they got too uppity. Even that, however, wasn't enough to prevent the dictatorship's decline, as the mothers and grandomethers of these desaparecidos (the disappeared) gathered in the Plaza de Mayo and demanded answers from the government, which was unable to completely supress them (some of them did vanish though) without sparking an international outrage. With a worsening economic crisis and more and more people supporting the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, the government, now led by Leopoldo Galtieri, decided to invade the Falkland Islands, owned by Great Britain, in one final and desperate attempt to unite the population against a foreign adversary.

As we all know, this invasion was crushingly defeated and the military had no other choice but to call an election while desperately trying to save their own skins through an amnesty law, much like the one enacted in Brazil. These plans were quickly dashed by the newly elected president, Raúl Alfonsín, a member of the Radical Civic Union (Argentina's oldest political party) and Argentina's first leader to be democratically elected in ten years, who submitted a law to Congress, where his party had a majority in both houses (1) to overturn this law. The former dictators were defenseless and could now be prosecuted and put on trial.

a26fd3478a81ab01de904bc5bdd891f3.jpg

The triumphant resurrection of Argentine democracy.

Alfonsín, who inherited a country with severe economic and social problems from his predecessors, ordered the creation of a national truth commission to investigate the disappearances and other human rights violations commited by the dictatorship. This commission delivered a report to the president in 1984, and opened the way for the much celebrated Trial of the Juntas, which took place in the following year. This trial became a national and international sensation, not only because of the fact that it was highly televised, but because it was the first time in Latin America that a democratic government put so many members of a dictatorial administration on trial. Sure, there was the trial and imprisonment of Hugo Banzer, former dictator of Bolivia, in 1980, but that country was very small and, besides, many of his associates remained free (2).

Anyway, all members of the juntas that ruled Argentina during those seven awful years, with the exception of the last one (presided by Reynaldo Bignone) were put on the national spotlight once again, and all of their crimes were shown for the nation and the world to see. The five sentences varied from life in prison, in the case of Jorge Rafael Videla and Emilio Eduardo Massera, to as low as just four years in prison, in the case of Orlando Ramón Agosti. However, Agosti and those who were acquitted, such as Leopoldo Galtieri and Omar Graffigna, had very little reason to celebrate, as they would soon find themselves behind bars thanks to trials that were nowhere near as flashy as the one that took place in 1985. A lot of people were forcibly disappeared and had their babies stolen, after all.

Naturally, Alfonsín's approval ratings soared, and his stance on human rights earned much respect and praise from the international community. This was reflected in the midterm legislative election that took place in November of the same year, which saw UCR strengthen its majority in the Chamber of Deputies.


However, this honeymoon period was bound to fade away, if only because of the simple unfortunate reality that trials don't put food onto people's tables. To make matters worse, Argentina's economy was in the gutter, much like the rest of its neighbors' counterparts were throughout the eighties, and the situation was unlikely to improve. To tackle this, the federal government enacted large budget cuts, especially in military spending, which further antagonized the Armed Forces, who were not at all happy with seeing some of their most prestigious members being treated like the criminals they were during the Trial of the Juntas. Soon, there were fears and rumours that some of the more radical sectors within them were plotting a coup against the central government.

Another important group that Alfonsín eventually antagonized were the labour unions, especially the CGT (General Confederation of Labour) which was the largest of them and intimately close to the opposition Justicialist Party, founded by the late Lt. General and former president Juan Perón. This happened not only because of the cutbacks, which often harmed poorer people much like what would later happen in Brazil because of the Plano Cruzado, but because of the approval by the legislatute of what became known as the Ley Mucci (Mucci Law). Named after Minister of Labour Antonio Mucci, one of the few union leaders not in cahoots with the Peronists, it, among other measures, limited the possibility of reelection to elected offices within the unions and facilitated the creation of new labour organizations at the expense of the existing ones. This controversial bill was narrowly approved by the Senate (3), and was rightfully seen by the incumbent union leaders and the Peronist opposition as an attempt to restrict their power among unionized workers, an important part of the electorate.

paro-general.jpg

Workers in what became the first general strike against the Alfonsín administration.

They showed their dissatisfaction with the president in the only way they knew, which was by stagin several strikes that paralyzed important sectors of the Argentine economy and worsened its political instability. With the GDP falling by 5% in 1985, the rumours of an impending coup became stronger and stronger, especially after the arrest of Guillermo Suárez Mason, a hardline officer and former director of the YPF (Argentina's state oil company) who fled to and lived in the United States until September 1986 (4). He was accused of plotting acts of sabotage against the government, directly contributing to the forced disappearance and murder of several people, and of embezzling YPF's funds for his personal benefit.

By December 1986, the situation was critical, and it became clear that unless something was done, there would be an attempt to overthrow the government. Hoping to prevent that, members of Congress hurriedly elaborated a bill that became known as the Full Stop Law, which would greatly limit the prosecutions of Dirty War agents who weren't indicted yet, a massive concession to the military that would hopefully calm them down. There were two major stumbling blocks, though: the first one was the civil society and human rights organizations in general, which were unanimously opposed to the project as soon as it became public and called for mass protest in order to prevent it from becoming law. The second obstacle was the president himself, who was obviously unwilling to let monsters like Alfredo Astiz and so many others go unpunished, and also knew that allowing something like this through would be immensely damaging to his personal image and that of UCR.

810px-No_al_Punto_Final.jpg

A poster calling for a demonstration against the Full Stop Law.

The bill passed both houses of Congress with comfortable majorities after only three weeks of debate, and was submitted to president Alfonsín on December 24, 1986. Under the watchful eyes of the country and enormous pressure, the president, in what he would later deservingly label the single most important decision of his life, defiantly vetoed the bill (5). In the following day, which just so happened to be Christmas, Alfonsín used the traditional televised message broadcast that was transmitted every year since he took office to wish his people a feliz Navidad to outline the reasons for why he took this drastic course of action. In the streets of Buenos Aires, Córdoba, Tucumán and other major cities, ordinary people initally celebrated this unexpected turn of events, but an atmosphere of uneasy anticipation quickly displaced the euphoria.

alfonsín.jpg
The president addressing his people.

When the Senate gathered once more, a few days later, to discuss and vote on whether they should overturn the president's veto, the proponents of the bill wavered and buckled under the pressure of the human rights movements and Alfonsín's firm opposition to the proposal, and they, while obtaining a majority of the votes in the upper house, failed to override the president's veto. The response to these legislative developments occurred on January 3, 1987, when several units in Buenos Aires rose up in revolt and attempted to overthrow the government. However, minutes after the beginning of the uprising, thousands of people rushed to the Plaza de Mayo in support of democracy. This led to clashes between putschist troops and civilian protesters that quickly led to a growing number of dead and wounded.

Meanwhile, politicians from both the government and the opposition alike repudiated the coup attempt, as did all major human rights (obviously...) and civil society organizations. The CGT, still controlled by Peronists and adamant in its opposition to Alfonsín, threatened to spark a general strike that would completely paralyze the country unless the putschists laid down their weapons. This was nothing like the last coups that took place in Argentina, where there was always some important sector of society, whether it was big businesspeople, angry politicians or union leaders who either supported them or simply turned a blind eye to them. After two days of pure chaos in the capital, president Raúl Alfonsín announced to a jubilant crowd of hundreds of thousands of people, which stood before the Casa Rosada, that the putschists surrendered.

42 people were dead, and dozens more were wounded. But democracy was safe at last.

565c2c88a886e.jpg


The president's approval rating shot through the roof. The bravery of Raúl Ricardo Alfonsín made him an international star, and his name became synonymous with the fight for human rights in a Latin America that was just freeing itself from the grip of its military autocrats. Among his people, he was immortalized, not unlike Juan Domingo Perón before him.

However, even with all of that, his job only got harder and harder, as the Argentine economy seemed to perpetually dance around a cliff, to put it mildly. The coup and its aftermath did much to improve political stability, something that would surely give room for the Argentine GDP to grow. However, foreign debt remained a constant concern on the government's mind and now, with stable commodity prices being the only reason the economy grew at all (6). This explains why, despite the president's now virtually unassailable personal popularity, UCR itself made only marginal gains in the 1987 gubernatorial elections. Not that this was a bad result at all, of course, considering that they maintained their control over several important provinces, especially the biggest prize of all, Buenos Aires (7).

Fast forward to 1989, the year of the next presidential election. Much to the despair of the government, the economy entered a recession and ensured that any race would be a tough fight for UCR at best. This didn't mean that the Justicialists' predicament was any better. Still trying to find its own identity after the death of its founder, who gathered people from all over the spectrum behind him, the Peronists also had the problem of having few important provinces under their control, which reduced the quantity of strong candidates that they could select. They had no other choice but to nominate Carlos Menem, governor of the faraway province of La Rioja, as their candidate. Menem was famous for his flamboyant style and enormous, Wolverine-like sideburns that made him a very recognizable and cartoonish figure.

carlos menem.jpg

Legends say those things have magic powers. Certainly explains why he didn't get jailed for corruption until 2005.

Meanwhile, the Radicals nominated a far more conventional politician, the centrist governor of Córdoba Eduardo Angeloz. With Menem initially seen as nothing more than a joke, he quickly took the lead, and it seemed that, for the first time since 1928, an UCR president would be succeeded by a member of his own party. However, the governor of La Rioja proved to be a charismatic and compelling campaigner, who used his ridiculous appearance to earn himself some much needed publicity. He also had the unwavering support of the CGT, which, despite being slightly weakened by the Mucci Law, provided him with millions of activists eager to spread the Peronist message. By October he was locked in a statistical tie with Angeloz (8). As if that weren't enough, one couldn't forget the surprisingly strong campaign of third-party candidate Álvaro Alsogaray, from the Union of the Democratic Centre (UCeDé), a right-winger whose program argued for drastic privatizations that would become a reality not in Argentina, but rather in Peru, thanks to Mario Vargas Llosa. He attracted conservatives who were dissatisfied with both the Justicialists and the Radicals, making the whole race even more of a tossup.

Argentina 1989.PNG

Argentina mapa.png


In the end, Angeloz defeated Menem, and his crushing landslide in Buenos Aires (the city, not the province) gave him the necessary votes to overcome his adversary. However, the biggest surprise of the night was Alsogaray, who got almost 15% of the vote and even won two provinces. With care, UCeDé could later even become a force capable of challenging the bitter Radical-Peronist rivalry that polarized Argentine politics for decades. For now, UCR celebrated its victory, and Raúl Alfonsín became the first democratically elected president since fellow Radical Marcelo Torcuato de Alvear to transfer power to a successor who acquired it not by the force of arms, but through the ballot.

At last, democracy was restored.

------------------
Notes:

(1) IOTL, UCR had a majority in the Chamber of Deputies, but not in the Senate.

(2) Should I write an update about Bolivia sometime? I probably should.

(3) IOTL, the Mucci Law was defeated in the Senate by just two votes. It was Alfonsín's first legislative defeat.

(4) IOTL, Suárez Mason was arrested in 1987 and extradited to Argentina in 1988.

(5) This is a very big difference from OTL, when he instead signed the bill into law and his approval ratings began to drop. Here, he's a bit more confident that he can withstand a military coup, since his administration doesn't have a Peronist controlled Senate acting as a thorn on his side.

(6) IOTL, these commodity prices began to fall and inflation rose. Here, a more severe Iran-Iraq War prevents that from happening. Also, since the government isn't plagued by several carapintada uprisings, but rather by just one big coup, and Argentine politics remain more stable, something that has positive effects on the economy.

(7) IOTL, they were wiped out.

(8) IOTL, the deeply unpopular president Alfonsín called for the elections to be realized five months earlier than they were supposed to, on May, rather than October.
 
Last edited:
I currently have four things to say to you guys right now:

First, I've fixed a broken image of Menem in the last update. Can't let those glorious sideburns not be seen by everyone.

Second, for those that might be curious, Alfonsín never entertained that utterly ridiculous idea of moving the capital to the middle of nowhere. He's too busy making sure he isn't overthrown or murdered.

Third, I ask for any Argentine user (@juanml82 , could you help me out again?) to take a look at this update, just to make sure it's not too wankish. I've got an immense soft spot for Raúl Alfonsín, because of the Trial of the Juntas. We really should have had something like that on Brazil.

Fourth and last, but definitely not leasat, the next update won't be focused on a single large country, but on several smaller ones. My current intention is to write about the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Nicaragua, Uruguay and maybe Chile. Hopefully, I can do that.
 
Last edited:
How did a Brazilian POD affect the Iran-Iraq war?
Butterflies and a bit of handwavium, I guess? The war gets different because Operation Ramadan (which took place in 1982, three years after the POD, and was apparently a close run thing) is a success for Iran and they have a much better position to surround, attack and eventually massacre Basra. Don't expect the Islamic Republic to be anything more than an international pariah after that.

EDIT: Sorry if it's unrealistic.

EDIT NUMBER TWO: Operation Ramadan is more successful because they decide to attack Amarah and disrupt Iraqi supply lines rather than waste their troops assaulting Basra head on.
 
Last edited:
I currently have four things to say to you guys right now:

First, I've fixed a broken image of Menem in the last update. Can't let those glorious sideburns not be seen by everyone.

Second, for those that might be curious, Alfonsín never entertained that utterly ridiculous idea of moving the capital to the middle of nowhere. He's too busy making sure he isn't overthrown or murdered.

Third, I ask for any Argentine user (@juanml82 , could you help me out again?) to take a look at this update, just to make sure it's not too wankish. I've got an immense soft spot for Raúl Alfonsín, because of the Trial of the Juntas. We really should have had something like that on Brazil.

Fourth and last, but definitely not leasat, the next update won't be focused on a single large country, but on several smaller ones. My current intention is to write about the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Nicaragua, Uruguay and maybe Chile. Hopefully, I can do that.
It seems fine. If a better electoral result allows Alfonsin to start the privatizations in the late 1980s he would have had more resources to keep the economy from spiraling down and allow Angeloz to win. Also, Argentina had electoral college at that time. IOTL, the UCeDe turned their college votes to Menem. If you really want to screw things up, you could have a Menem victory, but Angeloz cuts a deal with the UCeDe and ends up winning at the electoral college.
 
It seems fine. If a better electoral result allows Alfonsin to start the privatizations in the late 1980s he would have had more resources to keep the economy from spiraling down and allow Angeloz to win. Also, Argentina had electoral college at that time. IOTL, the UCeDe turned their college votes to Menem. If you really want to screw things up, you could have a Menem victory, but Angeloz cuts a deal with the UCeDe and ends up winning at the electoral college.
Eh, there are enough TLs where Latin America is either forgotten or turned into a hellhole. Someone has to give this lovely continent some love :D
 
Foreign Snapshot: The Pink Tide
Can't forget about the little countries.
------------------

Foreign Snapshot: The Pink Tide

During the late 1980s and throughout the 1990s, Latin America elected several centre-left and leftist governments in a phenomenon that became known as the Pink Tide, something that fascinates historians and political scientists to this day. Some discuss whether or not it could have been prevented, its underlying causes, and if it was truly restricted to just Latin America. After all, several other countries, such as West Germany in 1988 and the United Kingdom in 1990 also elected progressive governments, represented respectively by Oskar Lafontaine and John Smith.

Some even put leaders like the American president Jerry Brown on the list of Pink Tide leaders, thanks to his social liberalism, friendly foreign policy regarding these new governments and the creation of a National Healthcare System. Those who object to this last idea remember that, with the exception of his approach to healthcare, his economic policy was actually quite conservative.

Some even like to put South Korea's Kim Dae-jung (elected in 1987) and the Filipino president Benigno "Ninoy" Aquijo Jr. (elected in 1986 after leading a victorious revolution against dictator Ferdinand Marcos) as members of this wave, something that turns its definition into even more of a clusterfuck.

We'll avoid this entanglement and focus on said phenomenon's more orthodox interpretation, which is restricted to Latin America. It is difficult to overstate its immensity, considering that nearly all countries in South America (Peru, Colombia, Chile, Brazil, Bolivia, Uruguay, Paraguay and so on) and many in Central America, with the most colorful case of that not happening being Guatemala (we'll take a look at what happened there later) elected a leftist government, and it would take an eternity to list and explain all of them thoroughly.

We will take a look at five specific cases: the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Nicaragua, Uruguay and Chile.

------------------

Dominican Republic

A small country that occupies two thirds of the island of Hispaniola, in the middle of the Caribbean, the Dominican Republic is one of the countries that suffered the most from US domination in the twentieth century. It was twice occupied by American troops, first from 1916 to 1924 and later from 1965 to 1966, when they invaded the country to prevent the restoration of Juan Bosch, who was the country's first ever democratically elected president. A prolific writer and educator, Bosch spent more than 25 years in exile thanks to his opposition to the brutal dictatorship of Rafael Trujillo. Returning to his country of origin after the dictator's assassination (or punishment, depending on your point of view) he became president after winning a crushing electoral victory in 1962.

Unfortunately, his administration, which started on February 1963, was short-lived. Accused of Communist sympathies thanks to his bold reformist program, he was overthrown by a military coup after ruling the little island nation for just even months. After a brief civil war two years later, the Dominican Republic fell under the grip of Joaquín Balaguer, an old ally of Trujillo. However, despite his authoritarianism, he was not an absolute dictator, and his rule was definitely nowhere near as brutal as his old benefactor's. Indeed, his twelve years in power were achieved by three successive electoral victories, and he peacefully left power in 1978 after being defeated in his bid for a fourth term by Antonio Guzmán, a member of the center-left Dominican Revolutionary Party (PRD).

lossy-page1-494px-Jimmy_Carter_with_Joaqin_Balaguar_President_of_the_Dominican_Republic_-_NARA_-_176137.tif.jpg

President Balaguer alongside Jimmy Carter.

After this defeat, Balaguer made successive attempts to return to power in 1982 and 1986, losing the latter election to former vice-president Jacobo Majluta Azar by an extremely small margin (1). Four years later, he was ready to make another run for the presidency, confident that, after twelve years of an increasingly fractured and unpopular PRD government, the people were fatigued enough to vote him in. He was right that the ruling party was unpopular after years of corruption scandals and austerity measures, but he was mistaken if he truly thought that his way back to power was guaranteed from the get go. After all, there was another strong candidate that the Dominican people could also vote for: Balaguer's old adversary, the elderly Juan Bosch.

The clash between the two elder statesmen could be rightfully described as epic, and they mobilized considerable portions of Dominican society behind their candidacies. At the same time, the PRD candidate, José Francisco Peña Gómez, was in a distant third, but he refused to just go down without a fight, so he also ran an energetic campaign.

República Dominicana 1990.PNG


In the end, Bosch returned to the presidency 23 years after his overthrow thanks to a surprisingly easy victory against his fellow former president and once powerful opponent. This happened after a particularly embarassing episode where Balaguer -- who was 84 years old and almost completely blind -- tripped and broke his leg in the middle of a rally. The Dominican Republic was one again under a leftist administration, the second one of its history, and this one wouldn't be deposed anytime soon.

------------------

Haiti

The remaining third of Hispaniola that wasn't controlled by Santo Domingo was one of, if not the, poorest country in the Americas. Haiti, the second country to secure its political independence from an European colonial power, was forced to face immense difficulties right from the moment of its foundation. The first of them was the fact that it was an international pariah for a long time, since its liberation was done by a revolt of black slaves (the crushing majority of its population) against their white owners, who were eventually massacred. They were also forced to pay an enormous indemnity to France, its former colonial overlord, which ruined the little country's economy. To top it all off, it was plagued by dictators who were more interested in filling their own pockets rather than build their country and repeated coups that erased any semblance of institutional stability. Oh, and it was also hit by several earthquakes which wrecked what little infrastructure there was.

The 20th century introduced a new problem, which was the almost complete US domination of the Caribbean nations. Haiti was no exception, and it was occupied by American marines for for almost twenty years. After a couple more decades of instability and petty dictators, the little country fell under the incredibly corrupt and totalitarian rule of François "Papa Doc" Duvalier, who stayed on as President for Life until his death in 1971, after which he was suceeded by his 19 year old son Jean-Claude "Baby Doc" Duvalier. An incompetent playboy who was more interested in having lavish parties (while his people lived in complete poverty) rather than matters of state, he maintained his father's repressive regime and had absolutely no interest in reforming it.

Duvalier-hp-slide-ZY2J-videoLarge-v2.jpg

Baby Doc's wedding ceremony cost an astonishing 2 million dollars, a slap on the face of ordinary Haitians.

In the end, his country finally had enough of him, and the dictator was forced to flee Haiti in 1986 thanks to a massive popular rebellion. With the family that controlled Haitian politics with an iron fist for almost thirty years gone, it seemed that the little island nation was ready to follow its Latin neighbors through a path that would eventually lead to democracy. However, this rebirth would take time to happen, since the tiny former French colony was once again overtaken by a wave of instability and, with it, aborted elections and military coups. In the end, they finally held a truly honest vote on 1990, four years after Baby Doc's departure, and the people for the first time ever chose the person who would lead their nation into the modern world.

The unlucky man who had this ginormous task was a Catholic priest named Jean-Bertrand Aristide, a follower of liberation theology who frequently denounced the Duvalier family's brutality and corruption in sermons that were listened by thousands of ordinary people. This did not go unnoticed by the family's followers, who were still active in local politics despite their benefactor's departure, and Aristide, after returning from exile, survived at least four assassination attempts. His bravery made him immensely popular among the people, which explains why he became Haiti's first democratically elected president with almost 70% of the vote.

DuEAExQWoAAYu9G.jpg

President Aristide is sworn into office.

Those who hoped that Aristide's adminstration would be stable were sorely disappointed. The 38 year old leader immediatly embarked on an ambitious and agressive reformist program that quickly earned him the antagonism of Haiti's military and economic elites. For example, he was responsible for the creation of several social programs to aid the poor, and also ordered that many prominent Haitians be forbidden from emigrating until their bank accounts were properly examined. He also attempted to reform the tax system to ensure that the rich paid their fair share, while fiscal burdens on the lower classes were significantly reduced. On the military front, he attempted to assert civilian control over the army and had several prominent members who were accused of committing human rights violations investigated and prosecuted.

As if that weren't enough, he also ordered the arrest and prosecution of the members of the Tonton Macoute (the Duvaliers' personal death squad) who hadn't fled the country. At the same time, his overall political inexperience and hot-headed behavior created many unnecessary with the National Assembly, even though his party, the National Front for Change and Democracy, held very comfortable majorities in both of its houses. The most famous and severe case of them all was the appointment of his close friend and ally René Préval as Prime Minister, which caused severe criticism from many legislators, some of them from the governing party, and almost led to a vote of no confidence against Préval.

As such, it should come as no surprise that, during his five-year term, Aristide made a lot of powerful enemies and suffered at least thirty coup attempts, many of them quite bloody. Indeed, more than a few actually consider the fact that he managed to complete his term without actually being deposed a miracle, and many cartoonists of the time, Haitian and foreign, described him as a political Rasputin: no matter how many attacks he suffered, he just couldn't die (2).

In the end, Jean-Bertrand Aristide completed what would be his first and most chaotic term (he would return to power, with no difficulty at all, later) in 1996, and he handed over the presidency to his democratically elected successor and ally René Préval, which ensured that his reforms and initiatives would be allowed to consolidate and be brought to new heights under Préval's administration. During Aristide's first five years in power, hundreds of new schools, primary and secondary, were built, illiteracy was greatly reduced, and many residential buildings both in the major cities and in the countryside were electrified and gained access to running water and a sewage system. Regarding healthcare, the government sent many doctors to be trained in Cuba so they could better treat their own people and dozens of new hospitals and clinics were built.

201496093675Rene-Preval-Former-President-for-the-Republic-of-Haiti-Elisabeth-Delatour-Preval-Daughter-House-Patricia-2.jpg

President Préval giving an interview.

Make no mistake about it, Haiti was still a very poor country, but from now on its citizens could at least dream of a better future.

As long as they didn't have any particularly nasty earthquakes or hurricanes.

------------------

Nicaragua

You already know what I'm going to type. Small poor country in Central America, plagued by petty dictators and coups. Oh, and US Marines, of course.

On thing that set Nicaragua apart from its fellow banana republics during the early 20th century was the fact that they had this man named Augusto César Sandino, a guerrilla fighter, patriot and certified badass who fought the northern invaders from 1927 to 1933, when they left the country thanks to sheer exhaustion and the Great Depression. Sandino became a hero to countless people and symbol of Latin resistance to US imperialism, and his fame was so great that, for example, the Chinese Kuomintang, led by the then young Chiang Kai-Shek, named one of their brigades after him. Unfortunately, for all of his awesomeness, Sandino was still a human being, and he was assassinated by troops led by a general named Anastasio Somoza García just one year after the Marines' departure.

4-3.jpg

One of Latin America's many ill fated heroes.

Shortly after, Somoza became dictator of Nicaragua through a coup d'état, something that the little nation was no stranger of. The general, nicknamed "Tacho", proved himself to be a corrupt, autocratic ruler, a trait that he passes to his sons, particularly the younger one, Anastasio Somoza Debayle. The country became the private property of the Somoza family for 43 years, during which they did as they pleased with its finances and resources. In 1972 the national capital of Managua was hit by an earthquake that killed thousands of people and left countless more homeless, and the international aid funds that were supposed to help with its reconstruction were instead diverted to the Somozas' personal coffers, something that only worsened the dynasty's popularity and even infurited members of the Nicaraguan upper classes.

In the end, Somoza the Lesser was finally overthrown in a bloody revolution in 1979, and the people behind this regarded themselves as the ideological heirs of Sandino's legacy. These so called Sandinistas were led by a man named Daniel Ortega, who was involved with the group from an early age and became the head of the Junta of National Reconstruction. In 1984, five years after his takeover, Ortega became Nicaragua's first democratically elected president, although not really, since he used every single advantage his incumbency gave to him to secure his inevitable, resounding victory. During these early years the Sandinistas ruled Nicaragua in coalition with several other parties of varying ideological alignments, and the resulting administration was an extremely successful one.

Examples of this success were the halving of child mortality, a massive campaign to combat illiteracy, investments into public health that greatly reduced the occurrence of polio and other diseases, and a land redistribution program that distributed millions of acres of land, many of them belonging to the Somoza family, to thousands of poor families. However, as Ortega's power grew, so did his opposition, and his wide coalition began to break apart, with its more conservative members believing that the Sandinistas' reforms were going too far. Meanwhile, the government's nationalizations incurred the wrath of the United States and its president, Ronald Reagan, who accused Ortega of being a Soviet agent, something that was a bit sketchy since he had friendly relations with other western countries, and of being Fidel Castro sympathizer, something that was obviously true.

19850111-castro_2048526i.jpg

Fidel Castro and Daniel Ortega.

Thus, the US government quickly and, at first, openly funded a group of terrorists known as the Contras, who targeted civilian and military targets alike, as well as important infrastructure works, in an attempts to destabilize the Nicaraguan government. The Sandinistas would spend several years in a bloody stalemate with this group and, as time went on, began to engage in human rights violations, much like the dictatorships that surrounded them, even if they paled in comparison to what the Contras did. Thousands of people would die in this conflict, and it became increasingly clear that the war wouldn't end until Ortega and allies either stepped down or were forced out of power. Not that they wanted that, of course.

All of that changed in 1987, after its was discovered that the Reagan Administration was secretly funding the Contras (such a thing was forbidden by Congress in 1985) through illegal arms sales to Iran. The already mentioned Irangate scandal led to the resignation of president Reagan and the end of American involvement in the war, though Nicaragua was still subjected to an economic embargo that remained under president George H.W. Bush's short administration. Despite the fact that the Contras still had extensive links to drug traffickers, something that gave them plenty of resources, the lack of US funding and their unpopularity among the people (who knew that indiscriminate terrorist attacks could make you unpopular?) meant that they began to lose ground to the Sandinistas little by little.

The election of Jerry Brown to the presidency of the United States decisively brought the war to an end. The new president, obsessed (3) with undoing his predecessor's legacy of an aggressive and clearly corrupt foreign policy and tax cuts for the rich, immediatly lifted the embargo over Nicaragua, giving Ortega that final little push he needed to overpower and defeat the Contras for good. With this great victory, Ortega's reelection was guaranteed, and he easily defeated Violeta Chamorro, an old ally of his (4).

Nicarágua 1990.PNG


Now, he had the tough task of rebuilding a broken country. Still, such a thing would be infinitely easier thanks to the fact that there is no one destroying stuff.

Hell, maybe he could even afford to be a little... creative in the accounting.

------------------

Uruguay

A tiny country stuck between the giants called Argentina and Brazil, Uruguay was plagued by foreign interventions and civil wars, remaining a battleground between the two rival regional powers for much of the 19th Century. After that ugly phase was over, however, it began to quickly grow its economy thanks to lucrative beef exports, and its high standard of living earned it the nickname of "Switzerland of the Americas", a unknown but pleasant place to live in.

Unfortunately, Uruguay was still an oligarchic republic dominated by the conservative Blanco and Colorado parties, with the lower classes and leftist groups marginalized and left to rot under this system. The latter sector, inspired by the Cuban Revolution, founded an armed guerrilla group named the Tupamaros who launched itself into an insurgency against the central government. However, despite their many attacks, ambushes, bombings and executions, all they succeeded in doing was giving the opportunistic Colorado president Juan María Bordaberry an excuse to commit a self-coup in 1973 and turn himself into a dictator. Though he would be ousted by the military three years later, democracy would only return to Uruguay in 1985, with the election of the Colorado Julio María Sanguinetti.

81-06MQwheL._SY445_.jpg

Juan María Bordaberry, Uruguay's civilian dictator.

Sanguinetti's five year term was dominated by the issue of the political thaw. He lifted all of the bans on freedom of press and political parites that were in place. He also passed a controversial law that granted amnesty to all those who were accused of committing human rights violations during the civic-military dicatatorship. The economy was marked by a slow recovery from a depression that had hit it, as well as by an incapability by the government to reduce Uruguay's foreign debt.

In April 1989, seven months before the presidential election was scheduled to take place, the voters showed their desire for justice by voting for the repeal of the amnesty law signed by Sanguinetti three years before by a very narrow margin (5). Then they elected the Blanco Luis Alberto Lacalle as president, and his term was largely uneventful, save for its pro free market policies. No one of importance in the dictatorship was even investigated, most likely out of fear that the military would try to pull off a coup d'état like the one that took place in Argentina. Naturally this made his administration quite unpopular.

Fast forward to 1994, the year of the next presidential election. The Blancos and Colorados were still as strong as ever, but they now had to contend with a new electoral force. This third group, called the Broad Front (Frente Amplio) was a coalition of social democratic and leftist parties that existed since since before the dictatorship, saw its fortunes improve considerably since the return of democracy, at it now seemed that they had a real chance to take the presidency from the bipartisan order that had ruled Uruguay for since its independence.

Promising a multitude of new welfare programs and to put the former dictators and torturers on trial, the Broad Front very narrowly triumphed by an extremely small plurality of just 35% of the vote (6). Its candidate, the jovial mayor of Montevideo Tabaré Vzquez, became the little nation's first ever president who didn't belong to either the Blanco or the Colorado parties.

Tabar%25C3%25A9%2BV%25C3%25A1zquez%2B1898.jpg

Tabaré Vázquez.

Deep down, both Bordaberry and his equally infamous military counterpart, Gregorio Álvarez, knew that their days of freedom were coming to an end, and that it was time for them to share the fate that befell many former dictators in Latin America.

------------------

Chile

The third (or fourth, depending on how one looks at the administrations of Eduardo Angeloz and Adolfo Rodríguez Saá in Argentina) largest country to take part in the Pink Tide, Chile had a strong democratic tradition since the 1930s. This forty-something year long streak of elected governments was ruthlessly shattered in September 11, 1973, when Army commander-in-chief Augusto Pinochet led a bloody coup against his democratically elected predecessor, the socialist Salvador Allende. For seventeen years after this brutal event, Pinochet would rule Chile with an iron fist, becoming one of the most infamous dictators in the Americas. Thousands of political dissidents would be murdered, and an even greater number would be tortured, and even those who fled into exile weren't safe, as proven by the explosive assassination of Orlando Letelier, once one of Allende's most prominent ministers, in the middle of Washington D.C..

7908485716_2da1135b9c_b.jpg

The La Moneda presidential palace during its bombing by putschist forces.

At the same time, the dictator became one of the (if not the) first world leaders to follow the economic recipe of the so called Chicago Boys, which consisted of massive cuts in social spending, privatization of social security and several state-owned companies and lowered tariffs. These policies, combined with the banning of all trade unions, earned him the praise of economists such as Milton Friedman, who later stated that these policies improved Chile's economy to the point of allowing its return to democracy, and political figures such as British PM Margaret Thatcher, who literally stated that the brutal dictator actually "brought democracy to Chile". Naturally, the majority of his people had very different opinions on their ruler, for they saw the massive social inequality that these policies caused.

Presidential elections were scheduled to take place in 1989, but Pinochet was unwilling to leave power, even though he had already worn the presidential sash for seventeen years. In 1988, he set up a plebiscite in which the people would say yes or no to a proposal that, if enacted, would extend his term for eight more years. Unsurprisingly, at least in retrospect, the Chilean people voted for deny him such a thing by a massive margin (60% no -- 40% yes (7)), and his attempt to perpetuate himself in power earned him domestic and international condemnation. The most famous example of them all was when Ricardo Lagos, an important member of the Socialist Party and one of the leaders of the opposition, lambasted Pinochet on national television.


Lagos, already a respected politician, became the undisputed leader of Chile's democratic forces overnight. With no one in the Concertación de Partidos por la Democracia (a wide coalition of parties from all over the spectrum, united in their opposition to Pinochet) daring to challenge his presidential ambitions, he became its candidate with no difficulty at all (8). The dictatorship's candidate, Finance Minister Hernán Büchi, who was credited with masterminding the country's economic recovery after a crisis in 1982, campaigned on continued economic growth and stability. Lagos, according to him, was too radical to rule Chile and would plunge it into the chronic political instability not too different from what happened in 1973, an accusation that was strengthened by the fact that the Concertación candidate made no attempt to hide his desire to become the Chilean Raúl Alfonsín. Still, he had no chance of winning, since the conservative vote was divided thanks to the candidacy of big businessman Francisco Talavera.

Chile 1989.PNG


The reality is that, even if Talavera didn't run, Büchi would have still lost. The people were tired of being ruled by the same man for seventeen years, and the mop-haired minister was unable to disassociate himself from his benefactor. Another important factor was that Lagos promised that the many human rights violations committed by Pinochet's dictatorship, and Büchi, as a regime collaborator, couldn't make such a proposal without being laughed out of the room.

Chile was now under the hands of a disciple of Allende, and it was going to have to buckle up for one hell of a ride.

------------------
Notes:

(1) IOTL, Balaguer defeated Majluta by less than two points, which allowed him to run as an incumbent in 1990 and defeat Bosch in a tight and controversial race.

(2) IOTL, Aristide was overthrown in 1991, after just eight months in power. He returned in 1994 and, two years later, handed the presidency to his democratically elected successor, René Préval. He returned to power in 2000 and was overthrown again four years later.

(3) TTL's cartoonists will have a lot of fun with that.

(4) IOTL, George Bush Sr. was elected President of the USA in 1988, and promised to maintain the embargo on Nicaragua's economy unless Chamorro was elected. She ended up defeating Ortega in an upset. Unfortunately, Ortega remained active in electoral politics, and is now the reincarnation of Somoza.

(5) IOTL, the attempt to overturn the amnesty was defeated in t his referendum. Thanks to some very big butterflies coming in from their giant neighbor, that doesn't happen ITTL. Also, Bordaberry IOTL was sentenced to 30 years in prison for his crimes, but died before he could go to jail. That won't happen here.

(6) IOTL, the Colorados won the presidency with just 32.3% of the vote, and Tabaré Vázquez won 30.6% of the vote.

(7) OTL results: No: 56% / Yes: 44%.

(8) IOTL, Lagos decided to run for the Senate instead of the presidency, and the Concertación candidate was the Christian Democrat Patricio Aylwin. Lagos failed to win the seat he desired, and later became a cabinet minister and finally became president in 2000 by a very narrow margin.
 
Last edited:
Top