Interesting AH ideas that aren't commonly used

Just in general, there's not enough Deep Time PODs used. Deep Time is geologic time. It is stuff like entire environmental things going differently (the Ice Age goes differently, mountain ranges don't form in the same places, meteors don't impact leading to different biological influences on Earth, etc), evolutionary changes, human tribe movements being different to the point where a culture resembling something like the East Asians ended up settling in real world California leaving other tribal influences to develop a culture in the Far East (Slavic China?), and stuff like that, a different formation of Earth or the solar system, and so on. It is the movement of eons rather than relatively limited human changes. And then how those changes impact whatever world there is to focus on. JFK not being shot is relatively minor compared to a different humanoid species evolving or the settling of homosapiens being different and the intermix of their cultural development being different, let alone the changes without the impact of Theia (the theoretical planet that collided with us to make the moon) on early Earth. I think a lot of it is that any timeline will be placed in ASB, and a lot of people who would make that timeline or discussion do not want it in ASB.
Oh, if PODs involving pre-history and alternative human migrations are allowed, then I’d like to propose...

1) What if the “Black Asians” hadn’t gone extinct? Basically, according to one theory, the first human inhabitants of Asia were people of Y-haplogroup D who travel eastward out of Africa along the coast some 50 to 60 thousand years ago. For reference, these people would have looked something like this:

1_Andamanese_Tribe.jpg


Yet for reasons not yet understood, they have gone all but extinct and were replaced by “modern Asians”. One of the few pockets of these early Asians eventually became the Andamanese Islanders (pictured above) and, surprisingly, the Ainu people.

It’s interesting to think about what if a larger group of “Black Asians” had survived as a district ethnic group on the mainland and how they may have influenced (and be intern influenced by) surrounding cultures.

2) Similar to the above, another interesting WI to explore would be “What if the “Negrito peoples” remained the dominant ethnic-cultural group in South East Asia?”
 

Cook

Banned
How about the idea of that jet Engines were never invented.

The problem with this is that, unlike the atomic bomb, the jet engine didn't require any radical scientific breakthroughs; it was just an inevitable extrapolation of existing ideas that became possible once mechanical engineering and the metallurgy made it practicable; that's why it was "invented" almost simultaneously by several different people in different countries almost simultaneously.

You can delay it, but you can't not have it at all.
 

Kaze

Banned
A coin flip.

I actually used this is a story once - where in real life the person needs to either go down the right hand or the left hand path. The former (right handed path - which would be the real history) - the character marries a boring little girl, lives a boring little life, and his descendants for the next hundred years are quite boring until one of his descendants become quite infamous. The later (the left hand path) - the character gets involved in Harry Potter style magical nonsense, his descendants are not as boring, and still become quite infamous. So by flipping a coin, he chooses his fate.
 
I seen a number of Cuban Missile Crisis that turn into full blown Nuclear War.
What I never seen is a timeline were the US invade but no one choses to lunch Nuclear Weapons.
Would the USSR really have been willing to risk full destruction for Cuba?
Remember that The Soviet were the people in charge of the Nukes in Cuba.

An interesting variant could be if the USA invade Cuba, but find it's all been a gigantic Soviet bluff. Military transporters are carrying sewage pipes, clearly marked at ground level, but misleading from the air.

Iv'e always been amazed that the Russians apparently lost so much skill at maskirovka between 1945 and 1962.
 
It could be interesting to see a Civil War in the Soviet Union right after the death of Stalin.

Surviving Non-Sinitic nations in China.

I read once that an American ship almost opened Japan in 1814

Islamic Vikings
 
Here's what I've never seen: Serious extrapolation of the cultural/social side effects of having universal healthcare in the US. Odd, since it comes up as a side effect/butterfly in people's timelines alot.

Specifically, I'm thinking the effects of reducing both the BOOTSTRAPS/mah personal responsibility culture, plus severely weakening one of the 'sticks' to use the old carrot and stick analogy used for enforcing 'middle class' conformism regardless of decade*. The conclusion is obvious: you get a country that'd be significantly more socially liberal than OTL, but not in an OTL sense -- think a combination what we see from OTL western countries that weren't saddled with puritan settlers with Japan's willingness to allow quite alot of stuff that well 4chan posters would approve of but would likely get called 'problematic' if you're respectable enough to have a blue check of verification. The social liberalism of apathy/being ah latitudarian re: people's hedonism rather than the dominant Obama/#MeToo/Silicon valley strain of liberalism. The reduced inequality, if still higher than developed nation levels would have bigtime cultural effects. The reasoning is simple: There'd be more "poor but not quite struggling", solid working class andyes even middle class people and fewer outright poor people than OTL. It'd mean more sensationalist media and less intellectual/faux-intellectual stuff. TV or media in the 2010s OTL is largely aimed towards the upper-middle classes, in TTL this wouldn't apply anywhere near as much due to the differences in consumer base. For a small example of what a more prole/working class-aimed media would look lilke, think of the stuff we saw in the less unequal 80s or 90s vs now. Yeah, more 'edgy' media, more random/pointless sexuality, more gore, more anime and much less self-referential/postmodernism/"relevant" political commentary. That's just the cartoons for kids/teenagers. This would of course apply to other countries too, even ones already having UHC by whenever the US gets it due to sheer influence of Hollywood.

We've seen economic side effect discussion sure, including analogies for other countries with it but not gone deeply enough -- with the choice of keeping the budget deficits well (pre-reagan) normal and medicare* running smoothly or adding to deficits with rent-seeking laws*, it's obviously going to be the popular program kept. Another factor that'd reduce rent-seeking or monopolies would be the fact that business would no longer have to pay twice for health benefits -- buying group plans *plus* being taxed for medicare/medicaid. Going by the the increasing desperation on the part of business to find new revenue streams OTL*, this would mean a visibly different experience for US consumers. There's no shortage of articles out there about how countries with UHC are often more entrepreneurial than the US in some ways, so that'd apply. Actually, it'd be amplified given there being less pressure for 'stable' markets* and government encouragement of oligopolies/monopolies meaning more competition in place.

Lastly, Going by the most likely timeframes during the cold war, the idea that some truly large* expansion of the welfare state wasn't a one-way trip to FULL COMMUNISM and the gulags would do "funny" things to the conservative coalition. It took the Baby Boomers OTL aging to the "Get off your lawn" age and generations X/Y experiencing the side effects of reaganite economics to produce an attempt at a troll candidate with Ron Paul in 2008, to electing Donald John Trump in 2016. Somehow, going by the likely effects on the fusionist coalition it lasting 24+ years after the end of the cold war, and close to 40 after Reagan's election in this TL isn't happening. The possibilities are well.. I could be openly trollish and say "Trump, Earlier but with more support and someone more tactful to implement his ideas" but there's more than that -- Eisenhower-nixonism forever? Nixon's "New Majority", The Pre-reagan GOP aged into place? Up to whoever does this

* From grey flannel suits to plaid shirts and duck dynasty beards, the look changes but the middle class puritanism doesn't.
* Well, why not? NHS wouldn't fit the US, too ah clinical.
* Airline fees, paid online for videogame consoles(Microsoft started it, the others followed), putting energy into finance, being extremely cautious re: bad PR
* Read: no competition, or if competition is allowed it's on gentlemanly terms. Think ISP monopolies as exhibit A of course.
* Medicare/medicaid were smaller than a full-sized UHC program would be
* insert list of quite a few of regulations. I'd expect there to be alot weaker state licensing boards/insurance commissions and copyright law in TTL. Not so much decline but much slower expansions post-adoption of UHC.
 
Italy votes for the monarchy to be maintained in the 1946 referendum.

Flemish nationalists get Flanders to become an independent country.

LBJ is the 1960 Democratic presidential nominee.

Happens in New Deal Coalition Retained
 
Germany and the Soviet Union stick to the original plan so that Germany gets Lithuania in 1939.
Rest of WWII goes pretty much as in OTL.
Lithuania regaines independence in 1944. Under heavy Soviet influence and eventual member of Comecon and the Warsaw Pact, but not the Soviet Union itself.



Betamax defeats VHS.




Wolfgang Schnur or Ibrahim Böhme become PM of the GDR in 1990.
 

Alcsentre Calanice

Gone Fishin'
I actually started gathering ideas for a TL, where Röhm is warned and actually does a successful coup.
Working title was "the Röhm-Strasser Regime"
But than I lost the papers, and nothing ever came of it.

How did you lose this papers?

Also, how far on the road to social revolution would Röhm have gone after defeating the Reichswehr and taking power? Would an alliance between "National Socialism" and "Bolshewism" have been possible? And how strong would the antisemitism of the Röhm-Strasser-Regime have been in your opinion?
 
Germany and the Soviet Union stick to the original plan so that Germany gets Lithuania in 1939.
Rest of WWII goes pretty much as in OTL.
Lithuania regaines independence in 1944. Under heavy Soviet influence and eventual member of Comecon and the Warsaw Pact, but not the Soviet Union itself.
That would make for some disgusting borders.
 
Wjhat about independent titoist Lithuania with Vilnius, Memel and Königsberg?
Lithuania's surrounded from three sides by the Soviet Union and most certainly has a permanent Red Army presence. No chance of that happening.

@Augenis what about a Lithuania that's entirely contained within the borders of Latvia?
I mean

That's basically the same as the UK contained within Northumberland or something

Kinda a screw.
 
Top