McPherson
Banned
a. Yorktown class armor schemes would enable a shambles of the superstructure to Vals' bombs but IJN SAPPYs unless of the 550 lb AP "special purpose" variety will utterly fail against the hanger deck armor of a Yorktown as they did at Coral Sea.Generally agree. Her planes would be on Ford Island, I think, and her pilots would be ashore. I don't see damage being much different; the Akagi and Kaga air groups were assigned the battleships, the less-experienced Hiryu and Soryu air groups were assigned to the 'carrier' side of Ford Island. So take the hits on Utah, Raleigh and the one on Helena (the pilot correctly identified Utah, flew over the Ford Island and went for the 'big' cruiser moored at 1010 Dock) and assign them to Enterprise. The second wave dive bombers will have a target for their light bombs if she settles on an even keel, and complete wrecking her if she hasn't capsized. She may be salvaged, but she is out of the war. Her pilots are her real asset, and they will have replacement planes very soon from the States, and will find employment on other carriers as attrition wears them down. After Coral Sea, VT-6 might go to Midway on Yorktown instead of VT-3.
b. USS Saratoga and maybe a time delay. FDR really wanted a publicity stunt. USS Wasp will not change her TROM that much, either. Remember that idiot, Stark, still calls the shots until April 1942. It takes that long to show his incompetence as CNO. So, figure 3 vs. 3 at Coral Sea and this time, the Sara will show what a properly trained pre-war USN CV air-group can do. Only fret is the Buffaloes. It will be an USNAS pilot bloodbath to put down Zuikaku and Shōkaku.As for impact, the US may forego the Doolittle Raid. Hornet was in the right place at the right time to pick up Doolittle, but she needs a veteran carrier escort. Otherwise, I don't think TF 39 will reinforce the Home Fleet, Wilcox will bring them west early and Wasp will take Enterprise's place. Hopefully Wasp will get to participate in the 'makee-learn' raids. Coral Sea could go as historic, or Hornet and/or Wasp could reinforce Fletcher and Fitch. That might mean Yorktown gets away with less damage. I think Lexington will still be lost; the early torpedo hit caused the fuel leak that was eventually set-off by the generator. But that lesson in damage control still gets learned.
c. Have to relieve Ghormley sooner (with Wilson Brown or Aubrey Fitch?) and make sure Miles Browning breaks his neck falling down a ladder. Ship Halsey to Washington to take over Bu-Air and have him sort out the Wildcat and the Buffalo and send Tower to the Aleutians. As for Turner, can the Marines use him for target practice? Then Fletcher or Kincaid has a very good chance at the Santa Cruz. I think Eastern Solomons actually replaces Midway as the Kido Butai death knell in this hypothetical.Eastern Solomons could see Fletcher refuel Wasp closer to the battle-zone, and if she misses her appointment with I-19, she could also participate in Santa Cruz. That might mean her loss.
My thoughts,
Last edited: