The Only Winning Move Mk.2

The only winning move Mk.2

Ok i try again to not be a lazy bum:D and put my faulty ideas in print (in a manner of speakin)
___________________________________________________________________


I'm tired of this farce, i probably cannot resist more than some days before hit someone, the negotiations are becoming more and more a kindergarten fight between unruly children than serious diplomatic talks, the Italians want too much and the Austrians don't want give nothing or just some useless scrap, it's seem to talk with two wall, I despair that my mission will be a failure and Germany will pay the price.
Maybe I have still a change, Maria Anna[1] last night has give me an idea, it's a long shot and probably doomed from the start but frankly I cannot think any other move to save the mission and blocking the spread of this madness beyond our control.
Tomorrow I will begin the preliminary contact with Cardinal Gasparri [2] and with the old bastard [3], with God help I will succeed.

Entry of the 18 April 1915 of the personal diary of Bernard von Bulow

225px-Bundesarchiv_Bild_146-2004-0098,_Bernhard_Fürst_von_Bülow.jpg


Prince Von Bulow February 1915 during the Austro-Italian talk

Pope Benedetto XV with his public proposal of a concordat between the Kingdom of Italy and the Catholic Church so to resolve all the problem born from the Unification wars was a sudden storm on the Italian political scene, until this moment dominated by the fight between neutralist and who will want join one the alliance in the European war.
The papal proposal consisted in three parts:

1 - A political treaty recognising the full sovereignty of the Holy See in the State of Vatican City, which was thereby established.
2- A concordat regulating the position of the Catholic Church and the Catholic religion in the Italian state.
3 -A financial convention agreed on as a definitive settlement of the claims of the Holy See following the losses of its territories and property.
The signing of this accord will finally end the prohibition of the catholic to participate to the Italian political life and ease internal and external tension, at the same time giving to the government some need good press and breath from all the economic and social tension bring by the war. What was really important was instead the secret protocol included in the proposal; basically the Pope stated that the condicio sine qua non for the signing of the document was the successful end of the talk with the Austro-Hungarian Empire regarding Italian neutrality. In later years this clerical intrusion on the Italian internal affair had bringed a lot of criticism, especially from the ultra nationalistic crowd, who see the Italian failure to join the conflict as a wasted occasion for completing the work beginned with the Risorgimento and to destroy an old enemy, but at the time this controversial move resulted in a little political coup, because with this provision a 'peculiar' interpretation of the concordat transformed the diplomacy between Vienna and Rome in an Italian internal affair and so outside the king prerogative. The motive of the acceptance by Benedict XV of the Von Bulow proposal was numerous, and the final answer at this question many times simple depend by the political leaning of the interested party. The true is probably a mix of the various theories floating in the cultural and academic circles; the idea of the Prince give at the Pope the occasion to play peacemaker (a role he sincerely pursuit during the entire great war period) and at the same time give him the occasion to normalize the relationship with the Italian state, an objective who the pope tried from his days as cardinal, the fact that all this endeavour in the end will help a staunch catholic power as the Austro-Hungarian Empire was simply the ice in the cake
Noi non ci saremo – La neutralità italiana nella grande guerra (italian neutrality in the great war) – M.Rossi Einaudi editori 1980

Yesterday the ambassador of Great Britain and France were seen enter the house of his Excellency the Prime Minister early in the morning and leave in the evening, reliable source indicated that they were not happy and some strong words were exchanged between the foreign ambassadors and recently appointed for the fifth time Prime Minister Giolitti.
Corriere della Sera 27 April 1915


Italy will stay neutral, all this rumours about secret negotiations, of honourless behind the scene pact between us and other powers are pure nonsense. Simple the usual alarmist rubbish who thrive in period of great strife like this. In all sincerity is not in the best interest of the Kingdom of Italy and his people to enter the war, so his majesty government will maintain his current policy, but the other nations be warned that we are ready to defend our self and protect our interest and the sacred border of Italy from any enemy, from east and west, to guarantee the independence of the country and at the sole goal of the indissoluble good of the king and country. Long live the King, Long live the army.
Original transcript of Prime minister Giovanni Giolitti addressing the Parliament 30 April 1915 - Historical archive of the Chamber of Deputies



Prime minister Giovanni Giolitti in 1916 at the apex of his success walking in the streets of Rome

The immediate consequence of the declaration of neutrality, apart the diminishing of the commerce with France and Britain and the following need to find alternative source of raw material, were a series of riot in all North Italy great cities and some in the South especially in Naples, but luckily for the government the interventionist greatly overestimated the support of the common people for their cause and the carabinieri and the police quickly quell them, even if in Milan at least three days were needed to end the protest and at the cost of 23 deaths and numerous wounded. Naturally the fact the leaders of the movement like Mussolini and D'Annunzio were arrested little before the declaration helped a lot.

History professor and author R. Drago during an interview by Emilio Fede for the documentary 'La storia siamo noi - 150 anni d'Italia'

Giovanni Giolitti know of how terrible the first great war will be, so keep Italy neutral to avoid the other empire fate, using the Prophecy of Nostradamus? We of Voyager believe so.
Roberto Giacobbo - Voyager: ai confini della conoscenza - 24 November 2009 episode (season 4) - Rai tre


[1] Maria Anna Von Bulow, wife of the Prince, born in Naples
[2] Cardinal Pietro Gasparri – Cardinal Secretary of State
[3] Giovanni Giolitti, former Italian prime minister and very influential political


Treaty of Rome of 1 May 1915


I. The Cession to Italy by Austria-Hungary of the Trentino up to Salorno,
II. The correction of Italy's eastern frontier so that they coincide with the west bank of the Isonzo River
III. The transformation of Trieste in a Free Imperial City
IV. The recognition by Austria-Hungary of the importance of Italian culture on Trieste, Istria and Dalmatia and included the establishment of an Italian university in Trieste
V. The recognition by Austria-Hungary of Italy's full sovereignty over Valona and its bay, comprising the isle of Saseno together with such hinterland as might be requisite for their defence.
VI. Austria-Hungary's immediate and complete cessation from interesting itself in Albania as comprised within the frontiers traced by the Conference in London
VII. Italy undertakes to maintain benevolent neutrality towards Germany and Austro-Hungary throughout the war.
VII. The government of Austria-Hungary pledge to give the greatest possible importance at the other Italian request and to resolve the situation to both party satisfactions after the end of the current conflict.
IX. The recognition of Italian sovereignty of the Dodecanese Island.
X. For the delivery of the ceded territories (Articles I and II) from their quota of responsibility in the Austro-Hungarian Public Debt as well as in the debt resulting from pensions to retired Imperial and Royal functionaries, and against the integral and immediate transference to Italy of all domanial property, movable or immovable, with the exception of arms, situated in the said territories, and in compensation for every State right concerned the said territories, in all that may refer to them whether at present or in future, without any exception whatsoever, Italy will pay Austria-Hungary the capital sum in gold of 150,000,000 Italian lire.
XI. Austria-Hungary is to grant a complete amnesty followed by the immediate release of all those prosecuted and convicted upon military and political grounds who are natives of the ceded territories (Articles I. and II)
XII. The Italian government declare to not seek other compensation, territorial or otherwise, from the Austro-Hungarian under the provision of art. 7 of the Treaty of Alliance.
XIII. The official transfer of the territory mentioned in this treaty will be fulfilled after the cessation of the current hostility.
XIV. His majesty Kaiser Wilhelm II Emperor of Germany and King of Prussia pledge to be the guarantee of the terms of treaty

Gabriele D'Annunzio

xp080515102142.jpg


Image of D'Annunzio in his legionary uniform just before his flight over Istanbul


The incarceration of D’Annunzio in 1915 or as he later recalled his ‘Dark days of
May’ were a double-edged sword for the government of Giolitti.
Sure he was now not in the condition of directly committing seditious act or incite people to rebellion, but he was quickly becoming a martyr for the interventionist cause, even worse a martyr with powerful friends who from day one of his detention asked the release of the ‘vate’, first of them General Emanuele Filiberto di Savoia-Aosta duke of Aosta, and cousin of the current King.
The Giolitti solution of the ‘D’Annunzio problem’ in theory was meant to be acceptable to both parts, if the artist was so eager to fight and so fond of war, considered essential to clean the world, well he can participate at the fray enrolling in the ‘Legione Garibaldina’ a volunteers corps who Giuseppe ‘Peppino’ Garibaldi (nephew and named in honour of great patriot Giuseppe Garibaldi and who already commanded a Italian volunteers formation who fight in the French front in the first stage of the war) was forming to fight at the Entente side, and many interventionist was flocking to him so to get a change to fight the hated Austrian but also to escape government persecution.
When in early November 1915 the Legion was sent to the struggling Macedonia Front D’Annunzio was with them with the grade of Lieutenant and, as the entire Legion, distinguished itself in the doomed attempt to save the remnants of the Serbian Army.
Two of the more astonishing and memorable effort of D’Annunzio in this theatre: The slap of Durazzo and the the fly over Istanbul even if of little military value were of great psychological and propagandistic impact especially for internal use of the Entente.
Even after the war this feat were famous and lionized enough (true to be told most is due to D’Annunzio great skill in self-promotion) to be the object of various film and books, one of the most famous is naturally ‘The Flyboys’ the 1963 kolossal directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz.
The greatest achievement of the poet will be obtained not against the hated Hapsburgs but in the desert during the Arab revolt against the Ottoman Empire, when by pure change the now captain D’Annunzio was paired with T.E. Lawrence so beginning one of the greatest friendships of the author.
The so called ‘Odd couple’ was instrumental in establishing and preserves relationship with the Arab tribes fighting the Ottoman and coordinate their effort.
The Italian artist, who put is though and experience during this period in his monumental opera Notturno, demonstrated to be well versed to what now we call guerrilla warfare, Lawrence himself stated in his diary that Gabriel always claim to have a cunning plan.

Extract of the Gabriele D’Annunzio entry from ‘Hollywood – the other side of the golden age’ by Stephen M. Ambrose
 
Caracciolo class battleship

Castellamare di Stabia

Yesterday in a magnificent day and during a moving ceremony, his majesty the King of Italy Vittorio Emanuele III had officially launched the Francesco Caracciolo the newest battleship of our great fleet and the first of the same named class. This prodigy, product of the Italian genius and technical capacity with the extraordinary speed of 28 knots, a state of the art armour and 8 380mm guns is on par with the most modern British battleship of the Revenge Class and clearly superior of the new flagship of the Austro-Hungarian navy the Franz Ferdinand (formerly Ersatz Monarch) launched just a month ago

Il Secolo XIX - 13 May 1917

300px-Italian_battleship_Francesco_Caracciolo_launching.jpg
 
THE VENIZELOS COUP- Greece in the fray

VenizelosConstantineI.jpg


The King and the Prime minister during the war against Bulgaria
The rivalry and animosity between King Constantine I and Prime Minister Eleftherios Venizelos regarding the future of Greece and especially about the role of the nation in the first Great War is stuff of legend both at home and abroad. Both men were wildly popular and with an iron will and an uncompromising character so is naturally that from the first moment they clashed over a multitude of arguments, but the most important was who effectively held power in the kingdom.
The initial clash between the two occurred during the Second Balkan War over the objective of the army but this was not made public to maintain an image of cohesion and national unity during wartime.


200px-Constantineiofgreece.jpg
king Constantine I of Greece in a uniform of a German Field Marshall, a rank awarded by the German Kaiser in 1913




When the Great War started the two find themselves on the opposite political side from the first moment; the King was the brother in law of the German Kaiser and desired to maintain Greece neutrality both for political reason and familial tie but even because it was still not clear who would win and on the other side Venizelos who wanted to enter the war on the side of the Entente (who had make great promise of territorial acquisition in Asia minor and Albania, and has pledged to give Greece a substantial economic aide), even because a victorious Entente would look with hostility a neutral Greece and a victorious Triple Alliance mean simply that the nation would be surrounded by hostile nations with territorial claim over her.
With the recent Italian and Romanian declarations of neutrality the Entente governments decided to put all the pressure that was possible to Greece, so to make her declare war to the Central Powers, for this purpose many republicans and pro-interventionist newspaper and activist were discretely funded and one of the nastiest and violent propaganda campaign of modern times begin, meanwhile at Venizelos was promised even more, as the moment was critical with the Gallipoli campaign dragging and the Serbian army on the verge of total destruction.
During the previous months the conflict between Serbia and Bulgaria deepened and in September the latter declared war on the former, which posed an immediate threat to the newly gained province of Macedonia, including the strategically important port of Thessaloniki. Venizelos ordered an immediate mobilization of the Greek armed forces and asked Constantine for permission to formalize a defense treaty with Serbia in the interests of protecting the Greek border from direct Bulgarian attack. Constantine agreed but only on the condition that Greece was actually attacked. After his inability to sway Constantine to act against Bulgaria, Venizelos took a new route by allowing Entente troops to land in Macedonia in preparation for their attempt to save the remnants of the Serbian army.
The dispute between the Greek Prime Minister and the King reached its height shortly after Constantine I, in a very controversial interpretation of the national constitution, invoked the right that gave the monarch the right to dismiss a government unilaterally. In December 1915 Constantine forced Venizelos to resign for a second time and dissolved the Liberal-dominated parliament, calling a new election. Venizelos seemingly left the capital for his native Crete, but in reality was meeting a cadre of like minded army officers for implementing a plan created just a couple of months ago for exactly this occasion. On 12 December 1915 at the first light of the morning troops loyal to the dismissed first minister and lead by General Panagiotis Danglis take control of the capital, surrounding the royal palace (effectively keeping the King at house arrest) and arrested the pro-central powers high officers in the army. If in Athens the coup was bloodless, the situation in the rest of nation was different as brief but violent clash between factions erupted everywhere. The struggle even if intense was brief, this thanks to the entente intervention at the side of the Venizelos supporter, indeed French and British ships blocked Greeks ports keeping the navy out of this affair and French troops fight against royalist formation in several occasion, but the greatest contribution was the mere presence of the troops and ships who clearly menaced every move of royalist troops, so by the 19 of December the reins of the nation were firmly in the hand of coup leaders. Immediately London and France recognized the new government of Athens who the 1st of January 1916 declared war to all the Central Powers; even if Venizelos finally succeeded in his effort to bring the nation in the war at the Entente side a great price was paid:
- Many see now the prime minister as a French/British puppet and the King as a martyr of Greece independence so general support for war clearly suffered for this as now this was seen as foreign war fought by Greeks blood.
- This act (and the creation in 1917 of the Second Hellenic Republic)only exacerbated the deeply division on the Greece society paved the way for the 1921 civil war and monarchist restoration
- During the initial chaotic period of the coup Italian troops take advantage of the situation and expanded their ‘security zone’ in the Greek occupied North Epirus

venizelos_1_150x231.jpg


Eleftherios Venizelos - first prime minister of the Second Hellenic Republic (1916)

Decades of Darkness - The Balkans in era of nationalism T. H. Andrews Sperling & Kupfer 2010

200px-Constantineiofgreece.jpg
 
Last edited:
THE ENGINEER

Born in Arco, a little town near Trent (and so a citizen of the Austro-Hungarian Empire), the 3 July 1886 from a moderate wealthy family of strong irredentist leaning; very soon he demonstrated a great aptitude and interest in mathematics and engineering so, after attending the Realschul of Rovereto he departed for Monaco so to continue his study at the local university and after having obtained his degree he become so much interested in the new field of aeronautics to choose to build airplane for living, so he departed for France (first Liege and later Paris) to continue the study in this field.

Returned in Arco he started his first project, the CA.1 a biplane who first flow in 1910, unfortunately this project remained a simple private venture as the authorities clearly stated that they were not interested in it.
In 1908, even before finishing the first prototype, Caproni with is brother Federico and the mechanic Ugo Sandri Tabacchi (who later doubled as ‘test pilot’), decided to emigrate in Italy and to establish here their factory, the chosen place was Cascina Malpensa near Varese (who later become the Malpensa airport, the biggest of Italy). At the same time near the factory he created a flight school, so to train others test pilot. From 1911 he concentrated his effort on the developing of monoplanes, from the Ca.8 to the Ca.16, with better sales succes even thanks to results like the first Milan – Rome flight (a biplane piloted by the Russian Hariton Slavorosof) in 1913 and numerous speed record. This achievements had the consequence of making Caproni and a lot of investors very sure to win a very important commission from the Ministry of War, unfortunely both his proposasl (an original project and a licensed Bristol aircraft) were rejected, so the firm was soon on the verge of bankruptcy and Caproni was forced to close the school and sell the society who was later acquired by the Government…as the plane chosen instead of the one proposed by Caproni soon resulted not flight worthy.
So with the factory under administration by the military, Gianni Caproni returned at the drawing table and continued his work, this time without the need to worry regarding administrative and economic problem. This resulted in creation of the ‘206hp’, a very ambitious and advanced project for both dimension and capacity.
It was an enormous biplane with two fuselages and one central body, where behind the two pilots there were three Gnome motors (one 100hp and two 80hp). This futuristic and very costly project was so big that initially the interest was hardly forthcoming, even because none of the little society of the time had enough financial capacity to adopt it. Destiny this time decided to lend an hand, the first time in the guise of Giulio Douhet, at the time commander of the Air corps and considered today one of the fathers of the modern aviation doctrine; from the beginning a great support of aviation, he immediately saw the potentially of Caproni idea and was crucial to secure the necessary money from the Government and to quell the protest from more orthodox officers who preferred the construction of more airships.
With the commission granted soon the ‘207hp’ morphed in the Caproni Ca.30 (who ironically where first built in the factory formed owed by Caproni) one of the iconic bombers of the First Great War and the first of a lineage of aircraft who (in so different form) continue today, it was so good (as the other Caproni creations) who both side flow it.
The first of the Ca.30 were not destined to Italy, but to France who from the beginning demonstrated a great interest for the project.
From the Ca.30 were developed the Ca.31 (a simpler version for easier production), the Ca.32-33, the Ca.44 and the triplane Ca.40; all this planes in various version, usually depending by the owner as every nations use indigenous motor for the craft (Gnome for France, Fiat for Italy, Liberty for the USA and Mercedes for Germany).

Caproni_03.jpg
Ca.30 of the Italian Air Service (a branch of the Royal Italin Army)

fedora


During the war and even much later, Caproni (as all Italy) was seen by many in the world and usually depicted by the journalist, especially the socialist ones, as a ‘Profiteer’ a ‘Death Merchant’ ready to sell anything to anyone if the price is right. This dread image followed Caproni for all his life and is probably the main reason for a brief period of post-war depression, but except for this moment seems that the engineer was uninterested in the opinion of others as his only reason of life was is work. After said that, to better understand the predicatament of the 'Engineer' one must consider the geopolitical and strategic situation of Italy at the time, a neutral country between two warring alliance who traded with both; the pressure from all parties so the Caproni, as a lot of other resources, where sold only to their side were very strong and lasted till the end of the war and this put a great pressure and stress to anyone involved from the top administrators to the lower workers (protest, sometime even violent, were real common in the first year of war as some sporadic act of sabotage, usually done by pacifist/socialist but many believed were in reality the work of foreign agents).

Extract from 'Panorama - Special edition for the 150 years of the Kingdom of Italy'

Caproni_03.jpg
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 1487

Just discovered this! Thanks for posting in my thread. Subscribed.
 
Good update, might want to proof it a bit more, quite a few grammar or spelling issues. I thought there was a subforum where people would volunteer to help with that stuff, especially for non English as first language writers. Or there used to be, I thought. Anyway, let me know if you'd like some help.

All help is greatly appreciated (thanks for the tips i will see around)
 

Deleted member 1487

Too kind, really...the big problem was a realistic last minute reason for Italy to remain neutral, hope i get it.

You could have the A-Hs do better and have that as the reason. So the POD is out of Italian hands, but the perspective of the TL is of one of the butterflies. So its from the periphery of the change.
Of course if you're interested we could do a companion TL situation where you're righting the Italian perspective of my Austro-Hungarian TL; I'll of course fully understand if you want to do you own thing though.
 
You could have the A-Hs do better and have that as the reason. So the POD is out of Italian hands, but the perspective of the TL is of one of the butterflies. So its from the periphery of the change.
Of course if you're interested we could do a companion TL situation where you're righting the Italian perspective of my Austro-Hungarian TL; I'll of course fully understand if you want to do you own thing though.

It will be an honor and a pleasure collaborate with you sir
 
Is this continued in Love TY Neighbour? - if not please continue :D

It seems A-H (the CPs) are doing better TTL - THe Austrians built the Ersatz Monarch TTL :)

OTOH it also seems the Arbas are helping the Brits as OTL, so the OE seems to bleed too.

Greece - interesting - very interesting - If I read correctly (between the lines) the Greek will pay for siding with the Entente (1921 civil war = no Greek Turkish War ?)
 
Is this continued in Love TY Neighbour? - if not please continue :D

Thanks Rich, no is a stand alone thing who i begun before Love Ty Neighbour and ironically bring wiking to ask a collaboration, with poor wiking temporarly out of commission (so to speak) i'm tempted to resume but many of the idea who i thought to use can be used for the TL in collaboration, so i fear to create just a duplicate.

It seems A-H (the CPs) are doing better TTL - THe Austrians built the Ersatz Monarch TTL :)

Without the italian front A-H has more breath plus ITTL the Navy has a more bigger role in the war

OTOH it also seems the Arbas are helping the Brits as OTL, so the OE seems to bleed too.

Greece - interesting - very interesting - If I read correctly (between the lines) the Greek will pay for siding with the Entente (1921 civil war = no Greek Turkish War ?)

Yep, Greece is on for hard times.
 
Top