The Cuban War (1886- )

My little wargaming scenario, turned into a mini-timeline.

BACKGROUND

The Secession

The northern and southern Democrats split in the 1856 election instead of the 1860 election, and John Fremont was elected President of the United States. The Deep South promptly seceded, and as in OTL, when the President announced that the Union would be preserved by force if necessary, the Upper South seceded.

The handling of what were known as the "border states" in OTL was managed spectacularly badly, with the result that Maryland, Kentucky, and Missouri all declared for the Confederacy, although there were serious battles between pro-Union and pro-Confederacy factions. Fremont was forced to take his oath of office in Philadelphia, where he announced that the South would be forcibly returned to the Union.

Unfortunately, the Civil War was an utter disaster for the North. As in OTL, incompetent Northern generals in the East suffered defeat after defeat in Maryland, and the war in the West, while prosecuted fairly enough, did not result in any major gains.

After a year of this stalemate, President Fremont, a former general himself, took personal command of the Grand Army of the Republic, and marched south. With a little luck, he was able to defeat the Confederate army in two engagements, capturing Baltimore without a fight, and besieging Washington DC.

But the South had fortified Washington well during the previous winter, and slaughtered wave after wave of Federal assaults. Eventually, the Southern army was able to recover its strength to the point where it fought a pitched battle against Fremont. The Confederate troops were victorious, and the battered remains of the Grand Army of the Republic were trapped in Baltimore.

Baltimore could've been held indefinitely, seeing as it was possible to supply it by sea, if a new war machine had not intervened. The Confederate ironclads Maryland and Frederick wreaked havoc on the Federal supply ships, and destroyed the warships sent to try to defeat them. Eventually, President Fremont was forced to capitulate on August 1, 1858.

With the nation's president in the hands of the enemy, Vice-President Dayton vowed to continue to the war. But the North had lost its stomach for the war now, and any further attempt to continue the war was ended when the French Empire recognized the Confederacy on September 15. When it was announced that a French naval squadron had departed Brest to restore trade with the Confederacy and end the Northern blockade by force, Dayton gave in and after a short round of peace talks, the Confederate States of America were recognized as an independent nation by the United States.

Uneasy Peace

The independent Confederacy proceeded to use its newfound independence to spend nearly a decade bickering over what sort of government was truly best for the new nation, before settling into international insignificance.

The French Empire used the United States' defeat and temporary isolation to place Maximilian on the throne of the Mexican Empire, and establish itself in that country.

The United States returned to isolation for a decade, then began to set out on a course to become a Great Power, in great leaps forward, and small steps back. Americans remembered how instrumental the French fleet had been in forcing them to release the South from the Union, and after a confrontation with Chile showed the weakness of the American fleet, the nation embarked on a impressive shipbuilding program beginning in 1879: sixteen protected cruisers and eighteen wooden cruisers as well as two coastal battleships were scheduled to be completed by 1885, with an additional four battleships and eight cruisers to be completed by 1889. The army was modernized, albeit to a lesser extent.

When President Butler was elected in 1884, he promised to reinforce the Monroe Doctrine: almost immediately arms and funds were funnelled to the Mexican resistance against Maximilian, and the "yellow press" began trumpeting the Spanish oppression of the Cubans to the entire country.

War

On May 7, 1886, an American merchantman smuggling arms to Cuban rebels was seized, and its crew summarily tried and executed. This was Butler's excuse to drive the Spanish from the Western Hemisphere.

After giving Spain a ridiculous ultimatum that asked for immense reparations and economic concessions in Cuba to America, and upon its rejection, Butler asked for a declaration of war against Spain, ignoring France's calls for a peaceful solution. The US Congress declared war on Spain in a narrow vote on June 16, 1886.

The Opening Moves

An expeditionary force was loaded aboard transports in New York Harbor, preparing to sail for Cuba as soon as possible. Their escort was the responsibility of the Atlantic Fleet under the command of the newly-promoted Read-Admiral John Irwin. On July 1, the fleet, consisting of twelve protected cruisers, six frigates, three torpedo boat destroyers, several small gunboats, and thirty-five transports carrying 18,000 infantry, 1,500 cavalry, and various supplies set sail for Cuba.

Unbeknownst to the Americans, a hurriedly-scrambled together Spanish force under the command of Admiral Cervera had sailed at best speed across the Atlantic, stopped to recoal in Puerto Rico, and were now heading to engage the American invasion fleet...
 
Last edited:

MrP

Banned
Ooh, I like the fleshing out of the TL. And I'm damned well looking forward to the write-up of the battle! :D
 

The Sandman

Banned
As long as Cuba and Mexico are merely stepping stones to Texas, Florida and DC... revanchism is a must in this world.
 
Note: I took out the bits about the French getting involved, since it seems like the Spanish may just be able to win this one on their own.

But if they lose catastrophically, then I will send the French in, and have another joyous round of mayhem!
 

The Sandman

Banned
If the Spanish look like they're getting beaten, who takes the Philippines? I can see the Japanese, British, and Germans all trying for them, assuming the USA is too preoccupied in the Caribbean and Mexico to be bothered.
 

MrP

Banned
Note: I took out the bits about the French getting involved, since it seems like the Spanish may just be able to win this one on their own.

But if they lose catastrophically, then I will send the French in, and have another joyous round of mayhem!

Ooh, just the Spaniards, eh? Interesting! :cool:
 
If the Spanish look like they're getting beaten, who takes the Philippines? I can see the Japanese, British, and Germans all trying for them, assuming the USA is too preoccupied in the Caribbean and Mexico to be bothered.

Depends... who can tell? Depends if they get beat.

Presumably the American Pacific Fleet (about a total of one wooden cruiser and a couple of Chinese riveboats) is taking the war rather easy.
 
USS Hartford and USS Indianapolis before the Battle of the Florida Straits. Hartford was the flagship of the Second Division, and was commanded by Commodore Alfred Mahan. Note that Hartford has yet to have her "peacetime white" painted over.

pre-battle.PNG
 
what will the CSA do ? they aren`t going to see USA make Cuba a satellite and do do nothing .

Actually, they will. They may not like it, but they have no significant navy.

Timelines which feature a militaristic, powerful CSA bug me because you can't really get a huge military from a state whose overriding priority is states' rights.
 
It was the Bungling of the aftermath of the Dred Scoot decision, [1857] That sent the Abolishinists surging into the Republican party allowing it to become a national Party.

If the Democrats split in 1856, then you have a Whig victory.

Like the TL otherwise.
 
It was the Bungling of the aftermath of the Dred Scoot decision, [1857] That sent the Abolishinists surging into the Republican party allowing it to become a national Party.

If the Democrats split in 1856, then you have a Whig victory.

Like the TL otherwise.

Then why was there a Republican candidate who received 1.3 million votes in the 1856 presidential election? :rolleyes:
 

The Sandman

Banned
Actually, they will. They may not like it, but they have no significant navy.

Timelines which feature a militaristic, powerful CSA bug me because you can't really get a huge military from a state whose overriding priority is states' rights.

Now there's a fair question: just how decentralized is this CSA, and what have they had in the way of secessionist sentiment? Particularly in Texas; it's the only one of the states I can realistically see going its own way.
 
The Battle Begins

It seems incomprehensible that Rear-Admiral Irwin did not know that some sort of Spanish fleet lay in his path, but all reports and notes in the aftermath of the battle seem to suggest exactly this. The American information network was woefully lacking, especially considering the fact the United States had been eyeing Cuba for so long. Even though a message from an American agent in Spain reporting that Cervera had sailed was received by naval intelligence, it did not arrive until July 1, the day the fleet sailed from New York.

As it was, Irwin was shocked and severely consternated when the lookouts aboard his flagship Boston reported smoke in the distance. After weighing his options, and deciding that it was politically impossible to turn around (not to mention devastating for the morale of the crews), he sent back four of his protected cruisers to guard the transports more closely, and proceeded towards the enemy with eight protected cruisers, three wooden frigates, and three of the new torpedo gunboats.

Admiral Cervera had the doubtful honor of commanding one of the ugliest squadrons of warships to ever mar the clear waters of the Carribean with their presence. His flag was in the Numancia, an ancient broadside ironclad that could muster up a maximum of eight knots, but was armed with no fewer than forty eight-inch guns. Following Numancia in the line-ahead formation of the Spanish fleet were two more hideous monsters, the Vitoria and Zaragosa, armed with thirty and twenty eight-inch cannon respectively. These three vessels, though only capable of a snail's pace, were much more heavily armored than any of the American ships, and appeared able to take much damage. The other four ships in Cervera's fleet were cruisers comparable to the American wooden frigates, although with slightly fewer and more modern weapons, and some light armor.

The two fleets headed nearly directly towards each other in line-ahead formation for over an hour, each commander trying to decide what to do while waiting for the enemy to move first. Both admirals wanted a fight: Cervera, to stop the American invasion of Cuba dead in its tracks; Irwin, to keep his precious transports safe. During this time, Irwin ordered his wooden frigates to move 1500 yards off to the west of his squadron, in order to keep them out of danger of heavier vessels in the upcoming action.

Finally, with the range down to 10,000 yards, Irwin ordered battle speed for his line-ahead at 1600 hrs. Following the Boston were the protected cruisers Albany, Chicago, New York, Hartford, Indianapolis, Minneapolis, and Detroit. The three torpedo gunboats brought up the rear of the line.

Cervera ordered his fleet to turn to starboard, so that the imposing broadsides of his ironclads could bear on the oncoming Americans, as well as to make any American attempt to cross his "T" much harder.4

The two fleets moved towards each other and to the east in silence for the next fifteen minutes, as the range between the fleets closed rapidly. The wooden US frigates kept their distance, while working to come up and attack the rear end of the Spanish line when it followed the turn of the bigger ships. At 1611 hrs Irwin signalled the three torpedo boats to begin an attack run on the three large Spanish ironclads.

The silence lasted a few more minutes, before the first shots rang out across the clear Caribbean.

Boston fired at the Spanish flagship first, followed by the entire rest of Irwin's line at a range of 2000 yards. Two shells hit Numancia's ancient armored side, sending shocks through the gun battery that stopped a couple of her guns from firing, but doing no concrete damage. The Spanish line returned fire, hitting the forward 8" mount on Boston that had begun the fight as well as a 6" mount on New York, injuring and killing some of their guncrews. The American wooden frigates exchanged fire ineffectively with the rear of the Spanish line as it made its eastern turn. Both sides' firing remained inaccurate at this point, but as the American torpedo boats continued their run at the Spanish ironclads, and as the much-faster American fleet moved to cross the Spanish "T", the battle was looking to heat up very quickly.
 
Now there's a fair question: just how decentralized is this CSA, and what have they had in the way of secessionist sentiment? Particularly in Texas; it's the only one of the states I can realistically see going its own way.

The CSA isn't particularly the important part of the timeline to me, the naval warfare of it is. After the battle is resolved, I'll take a look at it.
 
Then why was there a Republican candidate who received 1.3 million votes in the 1856 presidential election?
For the same reason that there is a Libertarian or a Green party today.

In 1856 The Republic party was [Mostly] a western Party concerned with things like supporting the Homestead Bill, the transcontinental railroad, , Farmers rights etc. [Lincoln became involved with the Republicans because he was a Railroad Lawyer.]
It was only after the Candidates from the Whigs and the Democrats elected in '58, who had promised to overturn Dred Scott failed to act; That the northern Abolishinists ran as Republicans and made it a true national party.
It was the large number of Republican Abolishinists elected to Congress and to the state governments in the north, that drove home the -Now or Never-, idea to the South.

Like your pictures
 
Top