Restored Byzantium 2.0

Status
Not open for further replies.
Section III Healing from the National Schism; 1922-1925

During World War I, the government of Greece had been divided between the pro Central Powers King Constantine I and the Pro Entente and pro Republican Venizelists (led by statesman Eleftherios Venizelos). At the time of Turkish defeat in the 4th Greco Turkish war, the government had been lead by staunchly pro Constantine Prime Minister Dimitrios Gounaris. However, there was widespread support for Venizelism among the peasantry, and despite Greek Victory in the war, the King and his ideals were still unpopular. Following Gounaris’ death in November 1922, new elections were held. Venizelos won the popular vote, but King Constantine refused to recognize the results. The Nation held its breath, waiting to see what would happen.

Great Britain saw this as a once in a lifetime opportunity. British pressure had removed Constantine from the throne once before, in 1917, but Constantine had returned to power in 1920 after his son died from a monkey bite. England saw the benefits of using the Greek Election Crisis to somehow arrange for a proenglish government in Greece. The UK offered to Mr. Venizelos that in return for allowing Great Britain to choose a new ruling dynasty, and along with leasing portions of the port of Constantinople to Great Britain for 99 years, England would remove King Constantine from the throne and give Greece Constantinople.

Mr. Venizelos accepted. Venizelism, as an ideology, called for close relations with the western government and national expansion, both of which far outweighed the republicanism it also had. British warships sailed from Constantinople to Athens harbor, where their threatening presence convinced King Constantine it was in his interest to abdicate. Prince Henry, the third son of British King George V, was offered the position as King of Greece, which he accepted.

To the people of Greece, the new King was not as much news as the sudden gain of Constantinople. Aside from portions of the harbor, which Great Britain leased from Greece for 99 years, the city was once again in Greek hands! Greek troops under General Metaxas arrived in the city on January 1, 1923, and celebrations swept across the nation. On January 5 Prince Henry was coronated Emperor Herrikos I of the Empire of Greece (quickly dubbed the Byzantine Empire in english publications) in the Hagia Sofia. The young monarch, despite his minimal knowledge of Greek, found support among the Greek people, and became the first Emperor of Greece and the first ruler of Greece under the House of Windsor (Greek: Oikos tou Ouindsor). For the first time in 10 years Greece was a stable entity, with the only worry being the news of deadly riots in Turkey.

Let me see. Gounaris was one of the six executed in OTL. There is little to no reason for him to die of physical causes in 1922. Venizelos in in self-exile in Paris. In any election someone is going to return him as candidate in frex Smyrna (where his Liberal party will be winning in a landslide) but he's not coming back on his own. Metaxas, had left the army in 1921 and he was the arch-Constantinist and known pro-German. No chance at all he leads an army in Constantinople after the violent overthrow of Constantine.

Last a British fleet comes to threaten Constantine, in peacetime in order to overthrow him and install one of their own? This begs the questions why the Greeks back down (they won't), why the rest of the world lets such a blatant intervention on the part of Britain go unchallenged and last why Britain is willing to do such a thing in the first place, when the Greek royal family has close family ties to the British one, the crown prince pro-British, the British were not interested in the idea in the first place in 1917 when it was half-heartedly aired for a time during the war and is simply at odds with British modus operandi in Europe. Why Baldwin of all people will want to send a fleet to threaten Athens to install a British monarch on the threat of becoming an international pariah?

One might add that Constantine dies in January 11th 1923 anyway. This brings pro-British George II in the throne and an election is on schedule for 1924 (if Gounaris not that stable coalition survives that long) which the Liberal party has a pretty reasonable chance of winning with the overwhelmingly Venizelist Asia Minor Greeks voting for the first time and the Muslims of Macedonia that had equally overwhelmingly voted for Constantine out of the picture.
 
So sorry for the lack of updates, I've been busy and distracted. I hope to have some new stuff soon, but in the meantime I've revised the last chapter to factor in those inconsistencies and mistakes y'all have been bringing to my attention (thanks for doing so btw, I tend to write stuff without checking plausibility sometimes).

Section III Healing from the National Schism; 1922-1925


During World War I, the government of Greece had been divided between the pro Central Powers King Constantine I and the Pro Entente and pro Republican Venizelists (led by statesman Eleftherios Venizelos). At the time of Turkish defeat in the 4th Greco Turkish war, the government had been lead by staunchly pro Constantine Prime Minister Dimitrios Gounaris. Constantine hoped to sooth the lack of unity in his country, but he died in 1923 and Crown Prince George II became King.


King George II’s rule saw the start of Greece’s recovery from almost a decade of war and political turmoil. Unemployment fell steadily, and people began to trust the government again. King George II viewed restoring his nation as a big priority, and was sometimes questioned for his rightwing tendencies .


In Turkey Mustafa Kemal found himself running into wall after wall as Turks met his attempts to remake their society with increasing hostility. With Turkish defeat in the Fourth Greco Turkish war, much of the support Kemal won in OTL was nonexistent. Reforms such as translating the Qoran into Turkish were fiercely opposed by the religious, and making the nation officially secular was very unpopular. Some reforms, such as moving the capital to Ankara or making education accessible for all, were seen as good, yet in general these were outweighed by reforms like the banning of the fez or the abolition of Sharia Courts. However, the final straw came when Kemal introduced his proposed Turkish Name Law and the use of the Latin Alphabet. These two were seen as an attempt to not only root out Islamic tradition, but to root out the Turkish identity. Riots started in mid 1923 in Ankara, which quickly spread to Qawniyya (Konya), Sivas, Adana, and other major cities.


By November it became apparent that if Kemal stayed in power there would be a rebellion, and in December of that year he stepped down as president. Musa Kâzım Karabekir, a Turkish general who had clashed with Kemal in the past, became president, and reversed many of Kemal’s reforms. Sharia courts were returned as the default court, but one was allowed to opt for a secular court if they chose. The liturgical language was returned to Arabic, and any plans for name reforms were dropped. Universal education was still given, and women retained having equal rights as men.


At the same time this was happening in Turkey, the Ottoman “Empire” was facing changes of their own. The Empire’s population was about 900,000, of which about 850,000 resided in Constantinople. The city had a Turkish majority, with a large minority of Greeks and smaller minorities of Armenians, Jews, Slavs, Aromanians, Circassians, Albanians, Georgians, and others. The European advisors had de facto rule of the country. Despite this, the 1920s was a time of great reform in the empire.


The most profound reform was the Constitutional Reform. Also known as the Third Constitutional Era, it resulted in a relatively functional democracy in the Empire. The new constitution was similar to the old one with a few exceptions. There would still be a bicameral legislature, with the lower house, the Chamber of Deputies, having its representatives elected every 4 years. The upper house, or Senate, would have its representatives appointed by the Sultan, and serve for life. However, given that the empire was now much smaller, the Administrative Councils (equivalent to the USA’s Electoral College) were too be abolished, and the Chamber of Deputies elected directly by the people. The Grand Vizier would be elected by the Chamber of Deputies, and serve for 4 years.


The first elections under the new system were held in 1924. The refounded Freedom and Accord Party won 113 out of 200 seats, followed by the Respect and Rehabilitation Party, with 68 seats. The Freedom and Accord Party’s namesake was a large, liberal party in the Ottoman Chamber of Deputies before WWI. The Party’s new platform called for increasing ties with the west and the importance of the Emperor. The Respect and Rehabilitation Party was founded a few weeks before the election, with a platform of abolishing the nation and joining the Turkish Republic. The party wasn’t trusted by the western Pashas, but were allowed in Parliament due to their minority status. The remaining twenty seats were held by various ethnic parties, and one seat held by the Communist Party.


At this same time the Russian Civil War had all but ended, but with Constantinople again in Christian hands, it was chosen as the place of residence for the House of Romanov-in-exile, led by Kirill Vladimirovich, and was also chosen as the base for the Russian-orthodox-church-outside-Russia.


In 1922 Benito Mussolini came to power in Italy, bringing stable, but repressive government to the nation. Mussolini’s government was the first “fascist” government in Europe, but would not be the last. Mussolini increased the Italian presence in Constantinople, and encouraged poor Italians to settle Lydia. Greece was wary of Italy’s expansionism, but recognized the nation was nowhere near ready for war.


Another country that feared Italian expansion was Albania. Albania was one of the poorest countries in Europe, with a weak government. The Prince of Albania had fled in 1914 due to civil war and WWI, and had not returned at the request of the victorious allies afterwards. By 1921 Albania was being governed by a High Council. The three most powerful men in Albania, who were all vying for control of the country, were Ahmet Muhtar Zogolli, Ymer Pasha Vrioni II, and Theofan Stilian Noli. However, Zogolli, who had over 500 blood feuds against him, was assassinated in a café in Vlorë in May 1923. This shifted the balance of power in the country, and both Vrioni and Noli quickly tried to take control. Vrioni, who had the support of the wealthy landowners and the Muslim majority of the country, won the brief civil war against Noli and his followers, who were primarily part of the Eastern Orthodox Minority.


Vrioni had himself declared Bey of Albania shortly afterwards, as the official Prince, William of Weid, hadn’t been to the country in almost a decade (although he would continue to claim the throne from exile). Vrioni believed in the formation of a greater Albania, which hurt the country’s relations with neighboring Greece and Yugoslavia. Throughout the 1920s Albania would continue to struggle economically.


Greece’s other neighbor, Bulgaria, was facing problems of their own. Tsar Boris III had come to power just in 1918, and faced large discontent among the peasantry. Looking for allies, Bulgaria began to foster relations with Italy during the 1920s.


During all this time, the Weimar Republic in Germany was suffering economically. Hyperinflation had pushed the economy to the brink, and the majority of people were not satisfied with the government. Various radical groups, such as the National Socialist Party, were gaining support. In 1923 the Nazi Party attempted to take over the government in Bavaria. This “Beer Hall Putsch” as it became to be know, was an utter failure. Over a dozen Nazis were killed in the short fight, including the deputy leader of the party, Rudolph Hess. After this, the Weimar Republic stayed in power, but lost even more support.


In 1924, Britain signed a treaty with the Kingdom of Hejaz, making it a British protectorate. Hussein bin Ali, the Sharif of Mecca and King of Hejaz, signed the treaty to protect his country from a feared Saudi attack, and the British signed the treaty to both secure the Red sea and to gain influence over a religion held by millions of people in the British Empire. Mehmed VI, the Emperor of the Ottoman Empire and Caliph, also declared that Hussein bin Ali would be the new caliph after he died. Mehmed did this recognizing that the ruler of an empire the size of a city claiming to be the ruler of a religion of millions was only discrediting the title of Caliph.

While not originally intended to do so, the UK decided to encourage the recognition of the new Caliph, seeing as to how that would help Britain possess influence on the millions of Muslims in the British empire. Britain encouraged the recognition of Hussein bin Ali in their colonial empire, as did France, and over the next few years was recognized by the Muslim world as Caliph.
 
1925-1930

The second half of the 1920s the most stable time the Balkans had seen in decades. Countries traded more, and economies bloomed. A middle class developed, and it looked like war would not happen again. However, storms were brewing on the horizon.

The first cloud was that the Balkans, and the rest of Europe, were developing into two camps. In the Balkans the Little Entente expanded to include Czechoslovakia, Romania, Yugoslavia, and Greece. At the same time Italy and Bulgaria began to grow closer. Turkey’s relations with England, France, Italy, and Greece remained poor. A third alliance between Turkey and Albania began developed. The Ottoman Empire fostered good relations with Greece and the west.

In Greece, shipping and trade grew, despite the less than warm relations with Turkey and the Ottoman Empire. Alexandros Zaimis was Prime Minister, and his moderate position helped unify the country. Unlike some of their neighbors, Greece remained a stable democracy throughout this time.

Yugoslavia was led by King Aleksandar and Prime Minister Ljubomir Davidović during this time, and developed a close relationship with Greece.

In 1926 Ottoman Emperor Mehmed VI died, and his cousin Abdülmecid II became the new emperor while his son, Şehzade, became crown prince. The Title of Caliph shifted to Hussein bin Ali, the King of the Hejaz, as expected.

The Kingdom of the Hejaz was undergoing changes due to the british influence and arab rule for the first time in hundred of years. The British support prevented the Kingdom’s OTL conquest in 1925 at the hand of the Saudis. The Saudi family had founded the Kingdom of the Najd during the waning days of the Ottoman Empire, and had the stated goal of unifying all Arab lands. However, given the Hejaz’s British protection, the Saudis were unable to gain control of Mecca and Medina, the two most important places in the Islamic faith.

It is because of British protection that King Hussein bin Ali continued to let Britain place troops in Jeddah and use the city as a stopover for ships in between the Suez Canal and Aden. Many british goods also entered the Kingdom through Jeddah. At British request, islamic clerics and theologians in the Kingdom refrained from criticizing western imperialism, which stole some of the thunder from islamic nationalist movements, such as the Muslim League in India.

In 1927 a rebellion broke out in Italian Lydia. The rebelling Turkish peasants were opposed to the land reforms Italy was carrying out. These land reforms were expelling thousands of Turkish peasants from their land to make room for Italian settlers. Italy cracked down hard on the rebellion, and accused Turkey of supporting it. Turkey furiously denied this, and no evidence for Italy’s claims was ever found. The rebellion died out after the leaders of the rebellion were executed in 1928. However because of the harsh tactics used by Italy, after the war virtually all Turks in Lydia opposed Italian rule.

The rebellion in Lydia created issues for the Ottoman Empire as well. Since the end of the war, popular sentiments had steadily swung against the empire. Most low and working class Turks wanted the nation to join Turkey, while the businessmen and nobility profited from the legal limbo the country was in. Greeks wanted the Empire to join Greece, and most other minorities favored this too. Since Mussolini came to power in Italy, relations between Italy and England + France had been strained, with neither side wanting the other to control Constantinople. Because of this, the western powers decided to keep the Empire as a neutral territory with all three nations having troops in it. However, the division of the Empire’s citizens manifested itself in the 1928 general elections, where the pro union-with-Turkey Respect and Rehabilitation Party won a majority.

Thus ended the Ottoman Empire’s Third Constitutional Era. Given the R&R Party’s stated goal of immediately unifying the Empire with Turkey, Sultan Abdülmecid II ordered Ottoman troops to arrest the leaders of the party, fearing if he didn’t do so the western powers would do it and remove him from power. The leaders were arrested and the R&R Party was banned from joining the new Parliament. Turks who had voted for the party (about 80% of the Turkish population) realized that the west’s control of the Empire meant no peaceful solution could be used to unite the city with Turkey.

The night of the arrests, the barracks of English, French, and Italian troops were attacked by several unorganized mobs, some attacking physically and others protesting and demanding the withdrawal of troops. The next day the three allied commanders in the city (commonly called the western Pashas), George Milne, Henri Gouraud, and Emilio De Bono met and announced that unless the violence stopped and the perpetrators were apprehended, the Empire would be placed under direct military occupation. Despite their harsh words, western troops continued to be attacked in Constantinople. The rebellion spread to Çanak Kalesi and Hüdavendigar, the two other main cities of the empire. The western powers managed to prevent the rebellion from controlling any actual territory, but much of the Empire was too dangerous for westerners to go to. Guerilla warfare developed, and given the high population of the urban areas, many civilians were hurt in random shootings and attacks. Again Turkey was accused of aiding the rebels, and again they pointed out their was no evidence they did.

After a few months the rebellion subsided as the rebels realized they simply didn’t have the power to evict the world’s two most powerful empires and their sidekick. Hundreds had died, and many Ottoman monuments were damaged. However, afterwards the Ottoman Parliament was never reconvened, and new elections were ever held. The Sultan went back to having absolute power, as long as he did whatever the western Pashas said.

King Ferdinand I of Romania died in 1927. Ferdinand’s son Carol II was barred from becoming king because of marital scandals, so his son Michael I became king at age 6. King Ferdinand’s second oldest son, Prince Nicholas became the head of the regency council ruling the country, along with politician Gheorghe Buzdugan and Patriarch Miron. The three men found themselves in charge of a politically divided country. Romanian society was increasingly being divided between those supporting the fascist Iron Guard and those supporting the mildly populist National Liberal Party. During the regency calls for rightwing Carol II to be allowed to return to the throne were encouraged by the Iron Guard, while at the same time the left of the country was getting acquainted with the idea of a republic.

In 1928 Ymer Pashë Vrioni, the Bej of Albania died and was succeeded by his son, Sami Vrioni. Sami was widely popular within Albania, known for his experience and charisma. However, his support of Ymer’s vision for a greater Albania kept relations distant with Yugoslavia and Greece. Sami also brought Albania closer to Turkey, seeing Turkey as a natural friend, trading partner, and if things got ugly, defender of Albania. Turkey, which had faced isolation by the west since the end of the Turkish War of Independence, liked the idea of having a friend in Europe. In 1929 the Treaty of Albanian-Turkish friendship was signed in Tirana by Sami Vrioni and Ali Fuat Cebesoy, the foreign minister of Turkey. Italy was not happy.

Germany continued to fall economically during this period. The nation struggled to make their debt payments, and an ineffective political apparatus proved to be an issue. The Nazi party gained popularity throughout the nation, despite the failure of the Beer Hall Putsch.

The Start of the Great Depression brought an end to the economic prosperity that was growing in the world. In the 1930s, democracy fell in many countries, and culminated in the Second World War.
 
Two minor nitpicks. Little Entente was directed against Hungary/Habsburg restoration and later tried to be pivoted against German influence. It would be odd for Greece to join it in order to stymy influence of Italy so early, especially since Italy was at some points seen as a potential ally by some of the members. Macedonia will also be an issues between Yugoslavia and Greece. I would recommend you read anything you can by Milan Vanku, but I believe his book on Little Entente has not been translated to English (I may be wrong).

I am not sure if you missed the fact that Yugoslavia got that name in 1929, after the king started the dictatorship. One the one hand this is not an error since it can be assumed author is writing from a perspective Yugoslavia exists. On the other hand, it couldn't have been a peaceful time in Yugoslavia as it would be still called Kingdom of SCS and wrought with internal struggles over federalism/republicanism vs unitarism.
 
Lovely to see that Italy isn't yet bickering with Greece, something I'd like to note however is that Mussulini wasn't entirely against the French just yet, and in fact allied with them against early German attempts under Hitler to claim Austria. He certainly wanted to fight France, but could work with it if it meant keeping Hitler weak.

Mussulini in fact was playing a big game at the time, trying to gain Austria by protecting it from German efforts and also trying to bring Spain into his sphere by backing Franco. Hitler messed this up by taking Austria anyway and also backing Franco which let Franco take power without being indebted to one country.

If anything, I'd imagine the Italians would try to either help Fascists in Greece take over in a move similar to Spain, or offer them protection from the Turkish threat like they did for Austria against Germany. At least until 1933-5, after that the Germans are running the show for the most part.
 
Two minor nitpicks. Little Entente was directed against Hungary/Habsburg restoration and later tried to be pivoted against German influence. It would be odd for Greece to join it in order to stymy influence of Italy so early, especially since Italy was at some points seen as a potential ally by some of the members. Macedonia will also be an issues between Yugoslavia and Greece. I would recommend you read anything you can by Milan Vanku, but I believe his book on Little Entente has not been translated to English (I may be wrong).

I am not sure if you missed the fact that Yugoslavia got that name in 1929, after the king started the dictatorship. One the one hand this is not an error since it can be assumed author is writing from a perspective Yugoslavia exists. On the other hand, it couldn't have been a peaceful time in Yugoslavia as it would be still called Kingdom of SCS and wrought with internal struggles over federalism/republicanism vs unitarism.

Yeah, I've just been using Yugoslavia so people know what I'm talking about. But I'll clarify in the future. Thanks!
 
(1) With the Caliphate not abolished, but Hussein bin Ali as caliph, does that portend serious trouble within Islam with the Shia objecting to being ruled by Sunnis?

(2) See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Sèvres :: What chance of a full Treaty of Sevres Armenia being revived?, likely minus what the USSR had occupied. How much population for it from (a) survivors within Turkey, (b) returners from elsewhere in the Middle East, (c) returners from Europe and the USA etc?

(3) What chance of a Treaty of Sevres Kurdistan?

(4) If the Saudi Wahhabis try to take over the Hijaz as OTL, and Britain tries to stop them, risk of non-Muslim troops entering Mecca?

(5) How much is known about Bulgarian and Greek alternate names for places in eastern Thrace? I know of Kirk Kilisse = (Bulg.) Lozengrad. OTL, Greece renamed Lüleburgaz as Orestias. There is a large-scale Greek map of Eastern Thrace at https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Χάρτα_του_Ρήγα_-_1797_-_Φύλλο_9.pdf , but the writing is hard to read. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ανατολική_Θράκη (Greek Wikipedia page) contains some placename information.
 
Last edited:
(1) With the Caliphate not abolished, but Hussein bin Ali as caliph, does that portend serious trouble within Islam with the Shia objecting to being ruled by Sunnis?

(2) See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Sèvres :: What chance of a full Treaty of Sevres Armenia being revived?, likely minus what the USSR had occupied. How much population for it from (a) survivors within Turkey, (b) returnees from elsewhere in the Middle East, (c) returnees from Europe and the USA etc?

(3) What chance of a Treaty of Sevres Kurdistan?

(4) If the Saudi Wahhabis try to take over the Hijaz as OTL, and Britain tries to stop them, risk of non-Muslim troops entering Mecca?

(5) How much is known about Bulgarian and Greek alternate names for places in eastern Thrace? I know of Kirk Kilisse = (Bulg.) Lozengrad. OTL, Greece renamed Lüleburgaz as Orestias. There is a large-scale Greek map of Eastern Thrace at https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Χάρτα_του_Ρήγα_-_1797_-_Φύλλο_9.pdf , but the writing is hard to read. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ανατολική_Θράκη (Greek Wikipedia page) contains some placename information.
...This story hasn't been updated in over a year... you got my hopes to soar... and then stabbed it right through the heart...
 
...This story hasn't been updated in over a year... you got my hopes to soar... and then stabbed it right through the heart...

Sorry.

In Lascaris's message of Oct 10, 2015, how easy would it be for the greatly reduced Turkish army to defeat the Kurdish rebellion, in mountainous country where a few who knew the area could delay or hold out against many who did not?

If the Greece and Anatolia events do not change the time line elsewhere in Europe too much, what happens when Hitler arises and WWII approaches? Does Turkey stay neutral as in OTL? That stage looks like plenty likely to happen to write about.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top