Regime Change
Even as late as November 1, Hughes retained hopes that he could carry the election. Never before had the industrial States been lost to the Labor Party, and despite their claims of gains, he was not convinced he would lose. After all, he followed the path laid out by Roosevelt, the path in Reconstructing the once great Union. It would be great again, he assured the voters. As he would soon learn, one required more than patriotic fever to win an election. He made the same mistake made by so many politicians; forgetting that the voter often votes with their wallet.
When the first wave of electoral votes were cast, he knew he was in trouble. Massachusetts was no big surprise, but Pennsylvania going Labor sowed doubts in Hughes’s confidence. The rest of his cabinet, those in his electoral war room, lost all confidence when the next time zone closed its polls. Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin and Ohio all went Labor. It was clear he would not receive one half of the electoral votes. As the night continued, it soon became clear that no candidate would receive the necessary votes to secure the election. By the next day, Hughes retained a plurality with 36% of the electoral votes, followed by Labor candidate Gene Debs who partly ran on a “I told you so” platform with 30%. Trailing them was Democrat Al Smith and Republican Sam McKelvin.
Before 1922, any election going to Congress likely would have seen Hughes victorious. As things stood, no party held a majority in Congress either. The first two votes in Congress again saw no clear cut winner. The candidates and Congressmen saw a potential Constitutional crisis in the making. Perhaps it would have turned out as such, if not for the abrupt dropping out of McKelvin. For the past two years, the Labor and Republican Parties worked together to push their parallel agendas. Again they worked together, with the Republican block of Congress voting in favor of Debs.
Hughes moved quickly to calm his supporters, who upon hearing the news declared that the Labors and Republicans stole the election. It was not the will of the people, more of whom voted for Hughes than Debs for the lesser man to be President. Did millions of Americans bleed and die just so the highest office in the land could be decided by backroom politicking? To prove the protestor’s point, Debs names McKelvin his Secretary of State.
Hughes did not approve of the scheming but the Constitutional process was clear and it was carried out. He conceded the election, publicly congratulating Debs. Privately, Hughes, McCray and other high ranking Progressives began to plan for abolishing the electoral college. It was an idea floating around the halls of the Progressive Party for many years. Some believed it was the perfect time to push for a new Constitutional Amendment, when the peoples’ outrage was highest. Hughes decided to wait on the issue. He did not want to appear to be a poor loser.
The Labor/Republican Alliance introduced, early in the Debs’s Administration a series of protective tarriffs designed to keep out cheaper foreign products. What good were these products to industrial wage earners currently out of work? It was better to have American products on sell, made my American laborers. The action saw Britain, Canada and Brazil issue their own protective tarriffs in response, hurting the export market.
To create more jobs, Debs pushed for a comprehensive public works agenda, one that included transcontinental highways as well as continuing the reconstruction of the South’s destroyed, and in some instanced non-existent infrastructure. His plans would put Americans back to work not in months but in weeks. His plan galvanized hundreds of thousands of unemployed laborers, especially in the South, along with opponents in the Democratic Party, as well as a few Republicans, who believed it was an over extension of Federal power.
There was further criticism of the Labor Party in that Labor governors did little in the way of public works in their respective States. True, the industrial States were well developed by early 20th Century standards so there was little the Labors could do. They could also do nothing about tarriffs at the State level. It did not stop Debs’s enemies from calling the Labor Party a pack of socialists wearing thin veils of red, white and blue. There was some legitimate fears that the Labor Party might take the same route as Socialists in France and try to replace religion and family as the center of peoples’ lives.
Most of the attacks were based on a more tangible fear of Federal power. While the States were subordinate to the Federal Government, the Democratic Platform called for those States to retain their autonomy. As the Tenth Amendment clearly says, any power not granted to Congress or denied to the State was left for the States to decide. Instead of responding directly, Debs sent Labors’s attack dogs after his opponents, reminding the voters that sort of thinking doomed the Confederate States in the long run. For Hughes, now a private citizen, he would wait and see which direction Debs and the Labors would take the nation before deciding whether or not to condemn the man.