One Queen of England After Another, Now For a Third: A Time Line from 1562.

Queen Elizabeth I of England died of smallpox on 30 October 1562. She was twenty-nine years old, and had been queen for two and a half weeks short of four weeks. She was the third consecutive English monarch who had reigned for less than seven years. Elizabeth had not married and given birth to an heir, nor had she named her successor.

The Privy Council met and discussed who would now be king or queen of England. Some members favoured Lady Katherine Grey (born 25 August 1540). She was the great granddaughter of Henry VII, the granddaughter of Mary Tudor the elder, the younger sister of Henry VIII. She was the sister of Lady Jane Grey, and a cousin of Elizabeth.

Other members of the council, including Lord Robert Dudley, were in favour of Henry Hastings, Earl of Huntingdon (born 1535) He was descended on his mother's side from George, Duke of Clarence, the brother of Edward IV. He was also a cousin of Elizabeth, and the brother in law of Dudley. But his Yorkist ancestry was against him. Then there was Mary Queen of Scots, another cousin of Elizabeth, and a great granddaughter of Henry VII. But as a Catholic she was unacceptable to the Protestant council.

In December 1560, Katherine had secretly married Edward Seymour, Earl of Seymour, without Elizabeth's permission. This was forbidden because she was in the line of succession to the throne, and she was imprisoned in the Tower of London. She gave birth to a son there on 24 September 1561, whom she named Edward. The following year, Elizabeth had the Archbishop of Canterbury declare Katherine's marriage invalid, because there were no surviving witnesses to it. The only witness was Lady Jane Seymour, Katherine's friend and the sister of Edward Seymour. But she died on 15 March 1561.

Elizabeth had said that she did not want Katherine to succeed her. But in his will, Henry VIII had named the children of his sister Mary, in the line of succession to the throne, if his son Edward and daughter Mary did not have children. William Cecil, Elizabeth's Principal Secretary, favoured Katherine and she was proclaimed Queen of England on 1 November 1562, as Katherine I. She was pregnant with her second child and still imprisoned in the Tower of London.
 
Last edited:
William Cecil, Elizabeth's Principal Secretary, favoured Katherine and she was proclaimed Queen of England on 1 November 1562, as Katherine I. She was pregnant with her second child and still imprisoned in the Tower of London.
ISTM that as soon as the decision to proclaim was taken, she would immediately be brought from the Tower to Whitehall, before the actual proclamation was made.
 
ISTM that as soon as the decision to proclaim was taken, she would immediately be brought from the Tower to Whitehall, before the actual proclamation was made.
Yes she was, together with her thirteen month old son, Edward, who was in the Tower with her, Her husband, Edward, was also released.
 
The marriage of Queen Katherine and Edward Seymour was declared valid and their son Edward legitimate.

Elizabeth I was buried in a magnificent funeral in early December 1562. Katherine was crowned Queen of England and Ireland in a sumptious ceremony in Westminster Abbey on Sunday 10 January. All the stops were pulled out to make it as magnificent as possible. It was a wonderful piece of pageantry. Katherine did not hide her advanced state of pregnancy. Poems celebrated her youth and fertility. Their was great hope for the new young Queen, who had an heir, and hopefully another on the way. (1) Unlike Elizabeth there was no doubt about her legitimacy.

Katherine's second son, Thomas, was born on 10 February 1563. (2) He was the first child born to an English monarch since Prince Edward in October 1537. He was christened three days later.

Katherine was brought up in the Protestant religion. (3) But during the reign of Queen Mary she outwardly conformed to Catholicism. As far as I know she was not a Calvinist. She continued with the religious policy of Elizabeth I.

(1) There is a portrait of Katherine in the Wikipedia article about her: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lady_Katherine_Grey.

(2) As in OTL.

(3) See http://tudortimes.co.uk/people/lady-katherine-grey.
 
Last edited:
While the (Protestant) English would likely recognize Katherine as Queen, the Catholics in England will probably wind up backing Mary of Scots as the 'rightful Queen' due to her having a 'superior' bloodline and her being a Catholic Monarch and married to the King of France (Francis II). The French could possibly back Mary in a bid to take the English throne, the Spanish under Philip II might be more ambivalent about the idea, after all a France that could potentially tie the whole of the British Isles into a personal union would be a direct threat to him and his relatives in Austria. and the Habsburgs domination of Europe.

Now we know that Francis and Mary will never have children due to Francis likely being sterile (possibly impotent), but the people in that time wouldn't' have that foreknowledge.

Militarily... A Franco-Scottish invasion of England to place Mary on the English throne could work, or it could turn into a giant mess. Depends on how competent the commanders and leaders are, and of course lady luck.
 
If Mary ends up bearing a son anyway (could be a sneaky sneak thing) then Katherine is kind of screwed if this king of Scotland and France ends up wanting the throne of England
 
Francis II of France died on 5 December 1560. Mary Queen of Scots was now a widow, and who she would marry was a matter of international importance. Mary favoured marriage with Don Carlos, the son and heir of Philip II of Spain. The fact that he was totally unsuitable to be her husband did not concern Mary, or any of the marriage brokers.
 
Francis II of France died on 5 December 1560. Mary Queen of Scots was now a widow, and who she would marry was a matter of international importance. Mary favoured marriage with Don Carlos, the son and heir of Philip II of Spain. The fact that he was totally unsuitable to be her husband did not concern Mary, or any of the marriage brokers.
Why would he be totally unsuitable?
The insanity thing?
Well there has been worse I suppose...
 
Why would he be totally unsuitable?
The insanity thing?
Well there has been worse I suppose...
Because Don Carlos had episodes of violent insanity, with a reputation for torturing women and small animals, and the indications were that his mental condition would deteriorate further. There were also rumours that he was impotent. (1)

(1) See Elizabeth and Mary: Cousins, Rivals, Queens by Jane Dunn, London: HarperCollinsPublishers 2003.
 
Because Don Carlos had episodes of violent insanity, with a reputation for torturing women and small animals, and the indications were that his mental condition would deteriorate further. There were also rumours that he was impotent. (1)

(1) See Elizabeth and Mary: Cousins, Rivals, Queens by Jane Dunn, London: HarperCollinsPublishers 2003.
Carlos was insane but he was still heir apparent of all that Philip II had
And of course we do not know if he was fertile or not since he never had the chance to try for children
 
Mary Queen of Scots wrote to Queen Katherine in November 1562. She addressed her as 'my dear sister', and asked after baby Prince Edward. She hoped they would become friends. In her reply to 'my dear sister', Katherine thanked Mary for her letter, and accepted her offer of friendship. Mary wrote again to Katherine in February 1563, congratulating her on the birth of Prince Thomas. In her letters to Katherine, Mary stressed their natural bonds as women.

Mary's position in Scotland was now relatively secure. Her army had won the battle of Corrichie against that of the Earl of Huntly on 28 October 1562 (as in OTL). Mary wanted to get married but made it clear that she would not marry a Protestant, nor one of her own subjects, nor a man of lower status than Francis II.

Only Don Carlos, Prince of Asturias, the son and heir of Philip II of Spain, seemed to meet her strict criteria. He was three years younger than her. Such a marriage would have the political advantage of alliance with Spain, also Elizabeth of Valois, her favourite sister-ln-law, was married to Philip. However in 1562, Don Carlos fell down some stairs. The head surgery he had to save his life brought on attacks of mental illness. He never recovered, and his mental instability was against him. It was said about him that 'he is usually so mad and furious that everyone here pities the lot of the woman who will live with him.' (1). However marriage negotiations continued in 1563, but the following year Philip withdrew his son from them.

Meanwhile Lady Margaret Douglas, Countess of Lennox, promoted of her surviving son, Henry Stewart, Lord Darnley. He was three years less one day younger than Mary. He was born on 7 December 1545, she on 8 December 1542. They were cousins. They were both grandchildren of Margaret Tudor, the elder daughter of Henry VII. Lady Margaret wanted her son to be King of England and Scotland. Though the death of Elizabeth I and the accession of Katherine I, ruled out the English throne.

[1] See Elizabeth and Mary: Cousins, Rivals, Queens by Jane Dunn.
 
Last edited:
In January 1563, Katherine released Lady Margaret and her husband, Matthew Stewart, Earl of Lennox, from prison. Katherine gave birth to a baby girl on 3 May 1564. She and her husband, Edward, named their daughter Jane, after Lady Jane Grey, Katherine's sister. She was their third child and first daughter.

Mary and Darnley met at the castle of the Earl of Wemyss on 17 February 1565. It was not their first meeting. They had met in France six years earlier. He was over six feet tall with youthful good looks. Mary fell in love with him.
 
Mary Queen of Scots created Lord Darnley Earl of Ross in May 1565. On 19 July 1565, they were married in the chapel of Holyroodhouse. Mary became pregnant the following month. This was a month earlier than in otl. Her pregnancy was formally announced on 1 December 1565.

David Rizzio, Mary's secretary, was hated because he was a Catholic and suspected of being a papal spy. He was thought to be a homosexual, but also having to much influence over Mary, and being her lover. Darnley listened to men who told him that Rizzio had betrayed him, and because of his influence Mary had denied him the crown matrimonial. That is the kingship of Scotland with equal status and power with Mary. The Earl of Morton, who was Lord Chancellor, and the Earl of Ruthven wanted Rizzio tried on invented charges and publicly hanged, or killed while he was walking in the garden of Holyrood Palace, or playing tennis. Darnley insisted that Rizzio was murdered in front of Mary to teach her a lesson and make her afraid.

On the night of Saturday 9 March 1566, Mary and a small group of friends, including her half-sister Jean, Countess of Argyll; Jean's mother, Elizabeth Bethune; Mary's half brother, Robert Stewart; her French apothecary, and Rizzio, were eating dinner in the small dining room next to her bedroom in Holyroodhouse. Darnley was downstairs in his apartments with 79 other conspirators.. Then he came in to the room, sat besides Mary and started chatting with her.
 
Last edited:
Top