Map Contest Two: Round Two

First here are the rules again in case you have forgotten them.

You have one week to finish this challenge. Round two maps must be in by 1200 GMT next Thursday. Remember you can post your map at any time but the first map you post is the one we are going to accept (any additional ones will be ignored). New contestants are welcome.

***Remember to use the Map Contest Discussion thread for all comments as we don't want to clutter up this thread with comments.***

The second map challenge:

With a POD post-1500 establish a world that has had a rather different pattern of colonisation. Your map is to be set in the 19th Century.​

Good Luck!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hmm.. if I understand the contest right we have from 1501 to 1899 for a POD and from 1800 to 1899 for a map date? Such broad capablities... might even be too board, just as last round had really narrowing results.

Q: Can we use ASB PODs? I mean in the rules there are no specifing things that say I can't chose giant insects spawning in Africa and having colonies (of a very different type) worldwide.:p

CLARIFICATION to the contest:

Okay just a quick clarification.

Yes you have it right in the sense the PoD is having to do with different colonization patterns taking place sometime between 1501 to 1899 and the map itself should be taken during the 19th century.

However the map challenge was suppose to have you concentrate on a single continent. Either Central/South America, Africa, or Asia (I suppose Australia/Oceania too). This was designed to move mapmakers away from the typical World, Europe, or North America maps.

On further reflection it looks Scarecrow trimmed this challenge down a bit from what I thought it was going to be. (Scarecrow?) :confused: So I'll leave it at that.

As for ASB stuff, um I am going to say no. My policy with map challenges is unless specifically mentioned to be or involving ASBs then it should not involve anything that was not normally there.
 
Updated version.

First here are the rules again in case you have forgotten them.

You have one week to finish this challenge. Round two maps must be in by 1200 GMT next Friday. Remember you can post your map at any time but the first map you post is the one we are going to accept (any additional ones will be ignored). New contestants are welcome.

***Remember to use the Map Contest Discussion thread for all comments as we don't want to clutter up this thread with comments.***

The second map challenge:

With a POD post-1500 establish a world that has had a rather different pattern of colonisation. Your map is to be set in the 19th Century. Your map is to concentrate on a single continent, either Central/South America, Africa, Asia or Australia/Oceania.​

Good Luck!
 

Thande

Donor
For this one I decided to use an "arty" and "African-looking-ish" style that is either really good or really crap and I can't yet tell which ;)

~~

In this timeline, European exploration and colonisation of the Americas was matched by rapid expansion of the Ottoman Empire into Europe. Modernising earlier, and abetted albeit indirectly by a revived Golden Horde laying waste to eastern Europe, by 1750 the Ottomans had brought the entire Mediterranean under their control. With Iberia reduced to petty Christian kingdoms firmly vassalised to the Porte, Spaniards and Portuguese fled in droves to the colonies they had slowly been building up in the Americas over the previous two centuries.

England and France have escaped domination, with an Ottoman invasion of Cornwall* being defeated by the English in 1730 and signalling the end of total Turkish dominance. When England became a republic in 1792 (thanks to the throne being inherited by a Protestant German prince and the Catholic population rising up), her colony Virginia became independent under an elected monarch. The Kingdom of Virginia is now the dominant power in northern Septetrionalia (North America) and has established a colony in Africa to exile freed slaves to and use them as a force to educate and convert the natives. New Spain, popularly known as Mexico, is the other major power in Septrionalia and has established a colony in the Congo.

The Spanish colonies south of Peru, chafing under the limpieza system that favoured the peninsular-exile-heavy Mexico, declared independence with Brazilian support in 1806. The Audiencia de la Plata, as it is known, took the Cape Colony from the English in 1854, who had in turn taken it from the Dutch in 1640.

Brazil, Portugal in exile, has developed the longstanding trading posts in the Congo and the Mozambique coast and has linked them into a large and profitable colony, New Brazil.

The Moghul Empire, having recovered and modernised, now dominates the Indian Ocean arc and has colonies in Somalia and in Madagascar, having driven the Omanis out of all but one of their former colonies.

The age of Ottoman superpowerdom has now come to an end, and Mexico and Brazil are beginning to consider that one day their former mother countries will come under their control after the Turks are finally defeated...


*don't laugh, it nearly happened in OTL.

MC-2-2-3.PNG
 
Well, here's my effort...

PoD: 1521. While leading the siege of Tenochtitlan, Hernan Cortes comes down with a nasty dose of fever. He recovers, and goes on to successfully take the city. However, the feverish dreams he had while confined to his tent make a great impression on him, and he realises that his destiny is not to be Mexico's conqueror, but its Emperor!

It doesn't last of course, but for seven glorious years Hernando I rules his realm with an iron fist, destroying several expeditions sent to defeat him and even gaining recognition from an angry Pope Clement VII in the aftermath of the sack of Rome. The Spanish only have to be successful once though, and eventually in 1528 an expedition led by Álvar Cabeza de Vaca smashes the Mexican army and takes back the country for the King of Spain. The precedent has been set though, and in the 1550s Jiménez de Quesada conquers the Incas and declares himself Emperor. The King is occupied at home, and things snowball; before long, a chain of independent states established by various adventurers stretch from the middle Andes to the Sonoran Desert.

By 1870 (when this map is set), South America is rather different to OTL's. Britain, France, the Netherlands and Portugal have all established colonies on the continent, while the successor states to the original Conquistador Kingdoms remain in the north and east. Spain retains a presence in the New World, but only in her settler colonies along the *Hudson and *Potomac rivers...

On the map, of particular note are:

The Guyranay Commonwealth, which is the spectacularly strange result of combining Puritans, Guarani Indians and something similar to OTLs "Reducciones";

New Zealand
, which retains its name from its period of Dutch rule before the English grabbed it in the early 18th century;

Antarctica (Officially known as "France Antarctique"), a haven for French Hugenouts and a refuge for the Monarchy during the German revolutionary wars of 1812-1846;

Tawantinsuyu, still ruled by a member of the Quesada dynasty four centuries after its inception;

and Klein Wenedig, a cospopolitan state whose long-held status as a haven for scoundrels, refugees and criminals of all nations and creeds has left it with some of the most robust democratic traditions in the world.

SAmerica2.jpg
 
Southern Africa.

The POD is that the Dutch do not settle on the Cape of Good Hope, but the Separatists, and later the Puritans, do. The colony is rather successful, however, British moves to re-assert royal control in the 1700s (as the Cape becomes more and more strategically important) lead to some of the most devout settlers moving inland, founding the Holy Union, a very insular state. However, political differences grow, leading to the colony splitting into the more insular Northern Theocracy, and the more liberal (by Puritan standards) Southern Theocracy in 1832.

Racial factors are less important. In New England, with a much larger white and Indian population, no race has a clear majority. In the Theocracies, religion matters much more than anything else- as long as you're of the proper faith, they don't care what color you are- of course, it's also rather difficult to convert, leaving the majority of Church-goers as the white settlers even with a large black majority. Zululand is almost totally black.

puritansouth.png
 

Diamond

Banned
Okay, I had to save this as a JPEG to get it small enough to load, even on Imageshack, but everything still looks legible... I think.

Anyway, the POD for this is sometime in the late 1550s or early 1560s. Spain's King Philip II is a little more reckless, a bit more of a despot, and suffers some staggering losses when he tries to unite all of Italy under Spanish rule in 1575.

Italy unites alright, but not under Spain - the northern Italian cities band together to form the Italian League and drive Spain completely from the peninsula. In the process they anger the Pope, and several northern Italian leaders are excommunicated, giving Protestantism a huge boost in the north, especially in Genoa, Milan, and Venice, who ironically find common cause after centuries of feuding with each other.

Spain and the Italian League war on and off over the next century. The League builds ties with both England and the Ottoman Empire (oh, there is no Battle of Lepanto here, and the O.E. is still a major threat to Austria and Europe).

By 1800, the Italian League has grown to encompass all of Italy, Corsica, Sardinia, Malta, Crete, and Dalmatia, along with various other bits and pieces around the Mediterranean. They've also built a Suez Canal in conjunction with the Ottoman Empire, and have snatched all of Spain's East Asian colonies, including the Philippines.

The current year is 1848, and tensions are high between the Italian League and the Ottoman Empire ever since the League unilaterally annexed the whole Canal Zone five years ago.

2faritalia3qa0.jpg
 

Susano

Banned
Bababa-BAM :D

So, several things changed in East Asia. The Portuguese were able to recover several holdings from the Dutch, and there is a Ming Exile state on Borneo. The Ottomans, though hardly present in the region, were able to explot conflicts in the region: The Spanish-Ming-Muslim three way struggle on Mindanao, which ended in all sides recognicing the Ottoman protectorate, for example. Likewise, after several Dutch and British attempts to get Aceh in their fold, the Sultan chooses the conviniently far away Ottomans as protetcorate power, but still has to cede its south to the Dutch and British. As there was no Seven

Russia, Amurland: Still large, but internally much, much weaker this TL, they could not muster much resistance against the Prussian-Danish forts in the Amur Region, and eventually sold the land, which with the founding of Germany became German.

Korea: Korea played a major role in the Chinese Ming/Qing Civil War of the 17th century, but faded into global obsucrity afterwards again. After Russia, China, Japan and the UK all had their eyes on the Kingdom, Germany managed to play all sides off each other, and to gain Korea as a protectorate. Even though the Kingdom is not souvereigned, it has a high degree of internal and cultural autonomy, and Koreans also settle in Amurland and Taiwan.

Japan: After a dynastical struggle in the 19th century, into which the European powers were heaviyl involved, of course, the country remains split. Germany protected one faction to establish itself on Hokkaido (and allowed it to also gain Sakhalin) to have a buffer and protection for Amurland. The main Japanese state, with its court and capital at Kyoto, tendentially is more friendly to Great Britain, but goes at great lengths to keep independance. Still, no Mejii restoration this TL.

Quing China: Just as IOTL, Quing China is a weak giant, unable to hold off the European powers. Plagued by constant uorisings and rebellions, it is even weaker than IOTL, and in fact more or less only held together by the European powers, who fear the radicalness of the revolutions. The European powers greatly exploit this weakness, establishing colonies and holdings (permanent and not "for 99 years" or somesuch) at Chinas coasts.

Tibet The Tibetans used the Quing weakness to establish their independance. Over time, they recovered more and more Tibetan settled lands, until most ethnically Tibetan lands were in their hands. This was greatly supported by the Brits, by whom Tibet is greatly influenced.

Formosa: Major battleground of the Chinese Civil War of the 17th century. As result, the Dutchw ere expelled, but neither Ming nor Quing managed to hold the by then devasted island. Hence, Prussia-Denmark invoked the concept of terra nullis, and gained possession of it. Thus it became German when the German Empire was founded. The island is mostly settled by Germans and Koreans, with minorities of Formosian natives and Chinese Min Speakers.

Philippines: Sold by Spain to Germany 1868. Gifted by Germany to Denmark two years after Denmark's independance as part of the deal to part on friendly terms.

Yunnan: Broke away from China in 1844 after a new serie of uprisings and revolutions en par with IOTL Taiping Revolution. Had to eventually submit to Siamese dominance.

Burman States and Tribes: The Brits conquered most of the Burman State, and what remained in the highlands were states and tribes of Burmanese, Karne,S han, Mon and other ethnicities.

Siam: The only remaining independant Indochinese power. Encroached by the Bris in the South in Malaya, and the French in the West in Tenasserim, and later alo by the Italians in the East, Siam had an increasingly uncomfortable situation. German diplomay managed to secure Siam as an ally in this situation, and with German help, Siam gained dominance over Yunnan and the Burmanese territories. In return, it ceded a zone for an isthmus canal to be built to Germany. While Siam is very solidly in the German camp, it still has managed to remain independant of it, unlike Korea.

Tenasserim, Burma: There was no Seven Years War this timeline. India is split between French and British territories, and that spilt over to Burma, too...

Italian Indochina: Italy took Vietnam from China in the Italian-Chinese War of 1873, and Cambodia from Siamese suzeranity in 1877. Ever since 1873, the Italian Indochinese-Siamese border has been redrawn time and time again, but with Siam a German ally now, has now stabilised.

Hainan: Occupied by Great Britain 1875 as a counter to Italy's influence. Not officially ceded by China, Britain has nontheless built up a colonial administration.

Sultanate Aceh: For a long time, the last remaining power in the Eats Indian Archipelago, the only state not conquered by the Ming, the Dutch or the Portuguese. Still, the Dutch and the British had ambitions there. Inspired by the Ottoman protetcorate over Midnanao, the Sultan of Aceh put his state under the protection of the conviniently far away Ottomans. Nontheless, the south of his lands he had to cede to the British and Dutch in order to receive recognition for this step by them.

Malay and South Aceh: A complicated structure holding together the various forms of British holdings in the region - dependencies, colonies, protectorates, vasall states.

Dutch East India: The traditonal dutch holdings in the region.

Portuguese East India: The Portuguese had been the first European power in the region, havinge stablished settlements since the 16th century. However, they lost most their colonies to the Dutch during the Time of the Spanish-Portuguese personal union. However, ITTL, the Portuguese eventually were able tor ecover their most traditional holdings in the East Indian Archipelago, the Spice Islands.

Empire of the Ming in Exile: An outgrowth of the Southern Ming, the remnaints of the Ming Dynasty in the Ming/Quing War after the fall of Beijing. Even afterwards the war went on for decades, allowing the Southrn Ming to establish them on Formosa (though they eventually lost control there again) and Borneo during that time. The Ming capital was officially moved to Borneo 1674.

New Guinea: As the late comers in the colonial business, the Italians had to take what was left over, and in Asia that were the jungles of New Guinea. The southernmost coast is a colony of a colony, to be specific, of Great Britains colony in Australia.

Hm, seems like this time its atcually attacheable. Ah, well, the advantages of gif.

EAsiaedit copy.gif
 
My poor poor map

Okay heres mine. Not very likely to win, but whatever.

POD: Cortez dies trying before reaching shore. The spanish never really get their acvt together, and eventually the franch step in and conuer mexico and the bulf area, but they never conquer the inca, instead just taking mexico's gold home. France is more succesful (I think) but England, Portugal, Denmark, Prussia, and the netherlands, also ammas colonial empires. Poland-lithuania lives on and Muscovy never conquers Novgorod, and they divide russian and the east of sibereia between themselves. The map is set in 1899

Edit Aggggh! dammit! Really sorry. I postd the original map I was working on. Let me repost the actual one. So sorry!

MapContest2II.png
 
Okay guys while I was hoping to get Doctor What's vote (but he is out of town). However Scarecrow and I both came to the same conclusion:

This round's winner is...

<drum roll>








Dutchie


and this round's runners-up is...

Diamond


Lots of good maps guys that made this a hard decision. So keep an eye out for round three in the near future.
 
Top